Mexico's Partido Revolucionario Institucional used to sponsor the publication of big, glossy collections of historical photographs. They all told the story of how Mexicans joined together to make a revolution which toppled a dictator and brought peace and social justice to the country, and usually portrayed Agustín Víctor Casasola as the defining photographer of the era. John Mraz's book is also a big, glossy collection of 197 photographs from the years 1910–20, originating in a 2010 exhibition commemorating the revolution's centenary. However, that is where similarities with the old historia gráfica end. In place of a comforting narrative of national liberation, this collection asks some simple but important questions: who created these images, how did they create them, and why? The book aims to debunk myths about the Mexican Revolution and those who photographed it, and to illuminate how those myths were made. It succeeds admirably, and makes an important contribution to the history of the revolution and of photography in Latin America.
The chapters focus on key periods, themes and revolutionary groups. The introduction describes the main arguments and also the methodology, which involved a great deal of cross-referencing of photographs reproduced in different places. Chapter 1 covers the Porfiriato, comparing illustrated magazines with images made by foreign visitors. The interpretation of the Porfiriato is conventional (and convincing): a racist, corrupt, modernising regime that kept the masses out of politics and the photographer's lens. A short chapter then describes how those photographing the revolution initially clung to mannered pictorial styles, and how revolutionary leaders quickly developed an awareness of the political value of photography. Chapter 3 tackles the myth of Casasola: contrary to his posthumous reputation he did not take most photographs of the revolution, and usually he did not stray far from the Federal District. However, he created a news photo agency in 1912, bought photographs, contracted with freelancers and pirated images from magazines. Later, he systematically erased signatures and claimed credit for others’ images. These practices were not unusual at the time, but few could match Casasola's organisational abilities and entrepreneurial vision, and he eventually founded an archive of half a million images. This chapter effectively sets the scene for the remaining five, which look at who really took the photographs of the main contending factions: Maderismo, Zapatismo, Huertismo, Villismo and Constitucionalismo. The epilogue discusses five photographs that would become iconic in later years.
Each chapter blends an analysis of how the photos were made – what Mraz calls the history of photography – with a discussion of what the images tell us about everyday life in Mexico – what he calls ‘photohistory’. This makes sense, since each perspective clearly informs the other; particularly useful is Mraz's discussion of what appear to be images of revolutionary soldaderas, which sometimes turn out to be nothing of the kind. Uniting the chapters is a gradual trend towards increased realism and spontaneity in photography, enabled by new lightweight equipment. By 1914, we find scenes of warfare ‘of a modernity so radical that it would not be seen again until the Spanish Civil War’ (p. 170).
Mraz debunks myths but also puts forward some original arguments. He explains why it is so difficult to identify photographers and their motives, and warns us against facile psychological readings of subjects’ expressions. Nevertheless, he identifies the key photographers and agencies associated with each group. Predictably, men dominate, although Mraz also recounts the activities of rare female photographers such as Sara Castrejón. Drawing on the important research of Samuel Villela and Blanca Jiménez, Mraz shows that the supposedly parochial Zapatistas were just as eager to use photography as other groups. Some photographers were driven by political commitments; in 1910 a Sonoran photographer, Jesús Abitia, even helped Francisco Madero escape assassination in Hermosillo. Overall, pragmatic considerations were probably more important: Constitucionalismo produced the most photographs largely because it had the most money. In the epilogue, Mraz also offers some interpretations of historical memory, arguing that most iconic images ‘arose through a (more or less) popular consensus’, although he only scratches the surface of the issue here (p. 255).
This book is not a research monograph, and Mraz seems somewhat apologetic about this in his introduction, although he need not be. The project's origins in an exhibition may have limited what could be done, but Mraz succeeds in synthesising recent research, including several unpublished manuscripts and papers, with his own analysis of many well-known and obscure images. He also suggests new directions for research on themes from child pornography to amateur photography. Mraz is an affable guide, communicating his enthusiasm for certain powerful images and explaining how his own ideas have changed over time.
There are, however, a few stylistic infelicities. Mraz often places phrases which are not direct quotations in quotation marks. This is irritating and sometimes obscures the meaning. We read that the Casasolas were often seen as representing objectivity, but only later do we find out that it was the Casasolas themselves who used this descriptor. Sometimes the text meanders a little too far from the images – a photograph of a 1914 land survey leads to a vague assessment of postrevolutionary land reform and ecology. When Mraz notes that many revolutionary leaders were ‘equally corrupt and not much more revolutionary’ than Victoriano Huerta, readers may wish for a bit more explanation (p. 256).
Historians of Mexican politics and society will benefit from this book's synthesis of the latest research and original analysis. The style is suitable for the general reader and undergraduate classroom. I suspect that these images accompany many a lecture on Mexican history. Teachers in search of ways to encourage their students to use photographic evidence critically will find much useful information here, and historians of photography may also find the analysis and occasional comparisons with other revolutions suggestive. Of the glut of books to emerge from the centennial celebrations, this is surely one of the very best.
