The eugenics movement in early twentieth-century America stood, like the debates over evolution, at the intersection of science, popular belief, and social policy. Most of us think of eugenics as a fringe movement, the product of pseudoscience and a racial conservatism intensified by the influx of immigrants. As Tamsen Wolff points out in her fascinating and important study Mendel's Theatre: Heredity, Eugenics, and Early Twentieth-Century American Drama, though, eugenics was a mainstream social ideology during the first third of the twentieth century. Its principles were taught in public schools and universities—science departments at Harvard, Columbia, and other leading institutions offered courses on the subject—and its ideas and vocabulary were widely disseminated through films, magazines, newspapers, books, and lectures. Theodore Roosevelt, W. E. B. DuBois, and Helen Keller were among its supporters. As Wolff shows, the eugenics movement also lent itself to performance, from fieldworker training plays to fairground demonstrations and exhibits. Mendel's Theatre explores the roots of this theatrical interest in heredity and eugenics, its manifestations in the culture at large, and the surprisingly vigorous role it played in the emergence of twentieth-century American drama.
The book's first chapter (“Predecessors”) considers the earlier treatment of heredity by Henrik Ibsen, August Strindberg, George Bernard Shaw, and Eugène Brieux. (Given the centrality of hereditary impairment to Vor Sonnenaufgang [Before Dawn], Gerhart Hauptmann would have made a useful addition to this list.) Heredity formed a natural subject for drama during this period because, Wolff argues, both deal with “visibility and spectatorship, the place of the past in the embodied present, and autonomous identity and agency” (6). Wolff's analysis of these playwrights is especially revealing when she examines their reception by American audiences who viewed their plays through eugenic lenses. Ibsen, for instance, whose Ghosts was deplored by critics when it first played in the United States, was subsequently celebrated, in the publicity language of one American production company, as “our foremost eugenic reformer” (51).
Chapter 2 (“From Peas to People”) examines the American eugenics movement and its many uses of the stage. Wolff's overview of the movement is a rich account of the personalities—historical and fictional—that shaped the campaign for race betterment. These include Charles Benedict Davenport, a figurehead of the eugenics movement who created a display model called “Mendel's Theatre” to demonstrate the inheritance of such traits as hair and skin color; the Kallikaks, a pseudonymous family whose generations of mental defectives were the subject of an influential 1912 study by Henry H. Goddard; and Eugenie Traveller, the protagonist of a “eugenical comedy in four acts” (68) performed for eugenics fieldworkers-in-training in Cold Spring Harbor, New York. Wolff's performance analysis of such phenomena as the Living Demonstrations that displayed good and bad homes at exhibitions and public fairs and the Fitter Family and Better Baby contests that took place across the country is similarly informative and insightful. In surveying this cultural terrain, Wolff synthesizes the considerable scholarly literature on the American eugenics movement while also drawing on her own extensive research in archives and other special collections. She has a keen eye for the contradictions, ironies, and rhetorical sleight of hand that characterized eugenics doctrine and advocacy, and she is attentive to the ways in which the eugenics movement theorized, employed, and sought to regulate women as part of its broader agenda of race betterment.
The book's remaining chapters examine the impact of popular eugenics on plays by Eugene O'Neill, Susan Glaspell, and Angelina Weld Grimké and on the Oscar Hammerstein–Jerome Kern musical Show Boat. Chapter 3 reads The Verge against Glaspell's broader interest in “inheritance, transmission, mutation, and descent” (116). The botanical prodigy of the opening act signals the play's celebration of experimentation and the emergence of new forms, while Claire Archer's antagonism toward inherited conventions challenges the notion of fixed identities and model relationships that hard-line eugenics sought to consolidate. Chapter 4 (an earlier version of which appeared in Theatre Journal) explores the eugenic elements of O'Neill's Strange Interlude—chiefly, the congenital insanity of Sam Evans's family and Nina's decision to father a healthy child with Ned Darrell—against the eugenic argument for breeding healthy offspring. As with The Verge, formal experimentation is linked to hereditarian content: O'Neill's technique of dramatizing unspoken thoughts mirrors the eugenic drive to read interiority through surface traits. Although space does not permit a fuller presentation of this chapter's nuanced and revealing analysis, Wolff's reading of Strange Interlude's wild (and otherwise bewildering) popularity is so convincing that it should stand as a definitive account of this challenging play for years to come.
Chapter 5 introduces the category of race to the eugenics equation. The effort to do so has its challenges, since (as Wolff points out) African Americans played a minor role in the predominantly white literature on race betterment; immigrants and those of “defective” stock among the country's established white population were more prevalent targets. Wolff makes this absence the focus of her chapter, which analyzes the visibility–invisibility of the black body in Rachel and Show Boat. Grimké's play, which was accused of promoting “race-suicide” through its central character's decision to forgo motherhood (172), works with and against eugenic ideas idealizing motherhood, whereas Show Boat suggests that progress (something eugenicists championed through race betterment) was tied to the disappearance of the black body.
While the readings of Rachel and Show Boat are skillfully negotiated, it is something of a stretch to claim, as Wolff does, that the complex racial explorations of these two theatrical works “reflect directly and ideologically [their] eugenic moment” (199). Visibility, representation, motherhood, and the black body antedated the eugenics movement as themes in American society, literature, and performance. In a similar vein, the critique of motherhood that Wolff rightly identifies in The Verge is directed at least as strongly to the cult of womanhood that the nineteenth century bequeathed to the early twentieth as it is to eugenic ideas. But this tendency to overattribute eugenic meanings in certain instances does not negate the overall power of Wolff's readings of earlier twentieth-century drama, nor does it undermine her insistence that we understand the climate of popular and educated thinking on questions of heredity, family structure, and normality when approaching these plays. Learned, insightful, and engaging, Mendel's Theatre is an impressive and groundbreaking study. Its critical voice is assured, and it establishes a new way of thinking about the relationships among drama, theatre, and social theory during the early twentieth century.
