The political prominence of Muslim organizations and activists across so much of the world has forced social scientists to deal increasingly bluntly with the question of the relationship between Islam and democracy. Ostensibly, this is the very charge behind Masatoshi Kisaichi's edited volume, Popular Movements and Democratization in the Islamic World. Unfortunately, that focus is not carried throughout the volume.
The brief preface by editor Masatoshi Kisaichi presents the volume as the product of an October 2001 symposium entitled “The Dynamism of Muslim Societies: Toward New Horizons in Islamic Area Studies,” part of a multiyear, Japan-based Islamic area studies project. As Kisaichi explains, the premise of the book is that the idea that Islam is not compatible with democracy is “naive reasoning” (p. x). This presumption of compatibility, however, is refuted to a greater or lesser extent in several chapters. Moreover, the editor offers no introductory or concluding synthesis—and indeed, I do not think one could be written. The chapters have in common a very useful concern for history (not surprising, because most of the authors are historians) and a more descriptive than analytical bent but little else.
The first four chapters deal with saints and Sufism, beginning with Morocco and the extension of sultan authority through the 19th century (Mohamed El Mansour), moving on to Sufi networks and religious revival in Albania from the Ottoman Empire through the post-Communist period (Nathalie Clayer), then to varieties of Sufism in pre- and post-Soviet Uzbekhistan (Thierry Zarcone), and finally (the editor's own chapter) to the role of Sufi orders in Egypt from the 19th century through the present day. These chapters do deal with popular movements in the Islamic world (although at times with more emphasis on elite than “popular” dimensions) but engage little with democratization. Still, the elaborate detail of these accounts will no doubt be helpful to students of these topics and periods.
The volume shifts gears at the fifth chapter, in which Midori Kawashima tells of a populist but violent Muslim bandit in the southern Philippines in the 1930s. Next is an elite-centered overview of why Malaysia is more democratic than Indonesia. This chapter, unfortunately, appears to have been written in 1999 and not revised since—problematic for a 2006 volume, especially because a major thrust of the chapter is evaluating the results of political changes since 1997. Although lack of updating as well as the oddly narrow focus of author Syed Farid Alatas limits its utility, it is this chapter that introduces “democratization” into the volume. The next chapter homes in further on Indonesia, with an unfortunately disjointed account of its past and present array of Islamic movements. The author, Ken Miichi, though, at least is the first in the volume really to broach the linkages between popular movements and democratization in his discussion of the Islamist Partai Keadilan (Justice Party).
The final two chapters are most germane to the volume's stated premise. Yoshiko Kurita addresses the clash between secularism or nonsectarianism and Islamism amidst democratization and other political changes in several Middle Eastern countries. The chapter could carry the analysis further—for instance, of whether nonsectarians remain the primary democrats in the cases surveyed or of how much of a “popular movement,” as opposed to an elite strategy, nonsectarianism has been. Still, it represents an intriguing, comparative foray into a critical topic. Rounding out the volume is Yasushi Hazama, who details contests between secular-nationalist and Islamist forces in republican Turkey. Although arguably the strongest chapter in the book, even this piece could extend later (the narrative ends around 2002) and probe more deeply into, for example, the many ways Hazama suggests Islamism may gain precedence, from party competition to state efforts at legitimation and societal stabilization.
Beyond these chapter-specific substantive concerns, technical problems weaken the volume. The chapters do not cohere well as a book and, for papers initially presented at a symposium, are frustratingly devoid of cross-referencing. As just three examples, the set of chapters on Sufi movements could usefully draw out connections, the two chapters dealing with Indonesia could reconcile their treatments of the concept of masyarakat madani (an alternative framing of civil society), and the final two chapters, discussing secularism and nonsectarianism in the Middle East and Turkey, respectively, could benefit from even implicit or cursory comparison. Moreover, certain authors either spend too much time restating others' evidence and arguments or neglect key works on their topics, both of which failings limit the “value added” of this volume.
Although a promising initiative—especially for its laudable inclusion of a wider swath of the “Islamic world” than in many other such ventures—this book could have accomplished more. Certain readers will find individual chapters useful, but the volume lacks an overall argument or even theme and is pitched at widely divergent levels and disciplines.
