Kate Dossett's Radical Black Theatre in the New Deal offers a new approach to race in the Federal Theatre Project. In five chapters, she takes readers through new and revelatory interpretations of the seventeen Negro theatre units and how they challenged the white structures of the FTP. Performing works by white and Black playwrights, these theatre units rebelled against productions that ignored the experiences of Black people. Even as Black theatre makers remained dependent on the FTP for employment during the Depression, they negotiated with the FTP and the larger Works Progress Administration for the creation of a theatre that reflected their values and attempts at consciousness raising.
Dossett relies on the FTP collections held at the Library of Congress, George Mason University, and the WPA Records at the National Archives to make bold claims in her readings, not only about these plays but also the communities that shaped them. She recasts white benevolence as contrary to the desires of Black theatre makers, who saw the theatre as a form of pedagogy. The FTP-led theatre projects offered an integrated space for white, Black, and ethnic Americans to witness Black drama. Spectatorship functioned differently for Negro theatre units, which added a sense that events could be for and by Black communities only. Yet as Dossett warns, “what was embraced by black communities could be alienating and even shocking for whites: white critics and audience members who traveled uptown were fascinated, and often troubled, by the vocal manner in which African American audiences asserted their ownership of a production” (10).
Dossett's archive shows how many of these productions changed from their earliest drafts to their stage production runs. In so doing, the reader understands how different communities of government officials, theatre makers, and activists affected the contours of many theatre works of the era. As she states, these manuscripts “offer an alternative history of how radical ideas and ambitions were developed in spite of, and perhaps even because of, the racial hierarchies that governed federal agencies and American theatre” (16). Focusing only on staged productions, she argues, marginalizes the creative endeavors and ambitions of Black performance communities in shaping the theatre. Importantly, Dossett also uncovers several plays that were never produced and explores the failure of Black and white theatre makers to negotiate representations of race on the stage. By bringing to light the impact of Negro theatre units and their communities, we move beyond our understanding of a Black canon approved by white theatre producers and publishers.
The first chapter covers the performance history of George Sklar and Paul Peters's Stevedore. This play focuses on Black dockworkers who, in a climactic battle, drive off a white lynch mob after receiving reinforcements from a white union. Here, Dossett brings attention to the ways that a Black theatre community used a white-created drama to address the politics of Black Americans. Where Sklar and Peters imagined a work of interracial class solidarity, Black Americans saw their own independent liberation brought to the stage. This point is made evident by the story of Bill “Bojangles” Robinson leaving his seat to join Black actors onstage to build the barricades against the approaching white mob, an act that blurred the borders of theatre and reality. As Dossett notes, “Robinson's act took on heightened significance before an integrated audience that was accustomed to black Americans being confined to the stage as performers or segregated in the gallery” (53). Such displays troubled the play's attempts at class solidarity by emphasizing a narrative of Black struggle that demarcated a difference in understanding for audiences. For the Black community, the conflict against a white lynch mob outshone the climactic introduction of the white union members and changed the perception of the play's politics along racial lines.
The next chapter expands into the popularity of the Living Newspaper, a genre transplanted from revolutionary Russian theatre to the FTP. Living newspapers produced by Black playwrights, such as Stars and Bars and Liberty Deferred, for Dossett, “unmask performative devices used within white Living Newspapers that consolidate, even as they critique, the racial discourses that enforce black subordination” (81). Both productions used the narrative structure of the Living Newspaper to critique white narratives of Black life, where metanarrative devices put the gaze on white audience members for their facile responses to American racism.
Chapters 3 and 4 explore differing perceptions of masculinity, first in conceptions of heroism in the folkloric John Henry and the Bigger Thomas of the theatrical version of Richard Wright's Native Son, and second in political ideologies of American capitalism, Garveyism, and communism in Theodore Ward's Big White Fog. With John Henry and Bigger Thomas, Dossett draws our attention to how Black playwrights did not want their heroic ideals to redeem whiteness but instead to expose the system that creates them. And where Big White Fog has often been seen for its acceptance of communism as a solution to white supremacy, Dossett sees the play dealing with the failure of any ideology to help recover Black masculinity.
The final chapter looks to the successes of the Harlem Negro unit and productions that countered Orson Welles's Voodoo Macbeth with historical depictions of the Haitian Revolution, and the Conclusion reminds us of the importance of theatre under the FTP for providing Black theatre makers a larger audience to appeal to and mainstream white theatre makers to contend against. Black theatre communities “found ways to use the very dramatic conventions and theatrical forms that had helped to construct what it meant to be a black person in America, to first tear down, and then rebuild, those images” (251).
Dossett connects the work of the FTP to the postwar Black theatre of Lorraine Hansberry and Amiri Baraka. More important, what makes Dossett's work unique is her ability to connect script drafts to performance and theatre makers to audience. In the manuscripts, “black communities also created and debated roles that foregrounded black experiences, black history, and black heroes” (252). And Dossett's book provides a necessary resurfacing of Black theatre beyond the stage to the community engagements that reveal the give-and-take of theatre making.
