In On the Road, the seminal work of literature celebrating the ideals of the American open road, Jack Kerouac exults, “the road is life.” It is at once both a timeless metaphor that permeates all of human history and also a thoroughly modern celebration of the American experience. In the late 1940s when Kerouac undertook his American odyssey, he assumed (not with complete justification) that the roads existed for him to travel at will. As Tammy Ingram shows in her fine study of road building in the American South from 1900 to 1930, such confidence was a luxury. The ambitions of travelers in the first half of the century were always mediated by the lack of good roads. The tenuous process of rectifying that dismal situation is detailed in this study so that readers can better appreciate the arduous, maddening political process of road building that was forever on the edge of crisis in the early part of the American century.
Road building is messy, in every sense of the word. In this compelling and well-informed book, Ingram seeks to place the complex history of the “Dixie Highway” at the center of the political, social, and economic struggles to move the American South into the twentieth century, an era that would be defined by the automobile. This particular road project is an apt topic for such an exploration, and Ingram makes a convincing case for its centrality in any consideration of the development of all facets of automotive culture in the first three decades of the twentieth century. Ingram demonstrates how a mostly forgotten road dream serves as a microcosm for the tumultuous struggle to transition the nation's transportation network from the railroads to the highways, from steam to oil. The story of the Dixie Highway is thus not only about the South but also about the nation as a whole as varying constituencies fought to embrace a dramatically changing world. Of course, any such complex and vast investment in developing and transformative technology would bring out highly motivated participants, so the story of the creation of a modern infrastructure is perhaps the most provocative and productive way to examine how the United States became a modern nation poised to dominate the latter half of the twentieth century.
Dixie Highway is well conceived and offers a logical exploration of a complicated subject. The five chapters follow a chronological sequence: “Building a Good Roads Movement, 1900–1913,” “The Road to Dixie, 1914–1916,” “Roads at War, 1917–1919,” “Modern Highways and Chain Gang Labor, 1919–1924,” and “Paved with Politics: Business and Bureaucracy in Georgia, 1924–1927.” Throughout the text, Ingram draws from a wealth of primary and secondary sources to weave a narrative that shows the contentious interplay between various stakeholders. The first two chapters provide strong context for the “good-roads” movement – on a national scale in the first chapter, and as applied to regional issues in the second. Taken together these chapters provide the grounding for the importance of the Dixie Highway as both case study and symbol of the broader political struggles prior to World War I in direct relation to Progressive Era tensions. The next two chapters take on the impact of the global crisis of the war and then the regional problems tied to the convict lease system and the use of chain gangs. The final chapter focusses on the particular issues informing road building in Georgia. The push and pull between constituencies in the battle for control – local, state, and federal – of the Georgia system typifies the fight for roads nationwide. Ingram's discussion demonstrates the cultural clashes made explicit by the ever-tenuous transition to modernism that affected the South and the nation.
In the end, the dream of the Dixie Highway, despite the tireless efforts of its boosters, was never realized as envisioned. To see that result as a failure, however, ignores the deep impact of the road-building efforts as reflective of the battles between key ideological debates that still inform our political structure. Dixie Highway is an informed and consistently readable study. It will appeal to a wide range of readers and should be essential reading for anyone interested in political and social history in the early twentieth century.
