Graham Fuller's recent book offers a contemporary primer on the dynamics of Turkish foreign policy. Fuller focuses both on the changing nature of Turkish diplomacy throughout the 20th and early 21st centuries and on the increasing independence of Turkish foreign policy from American influence. This change within Turkish foreign policy reflects transitions within Turkey's domestic politics as well as within Turkey's geostrategic interests. Fuller's central claim is that although this more independent foreign policy may not sit well with policymakers in Washington (and here Fuller's focus is on the Bush administration), it may “nonetheless serve the best interests of Turkey, the Middle East, and even the West” (p. 5).
Underpinning Fuller's text is the question of the relationship between Turkey and the United States. As Fuller notes, this relationship has evolved from America's desire to use the alliance with Turkey for containing Soviet influence in southeast Europe and the Middle East to contemporary concerns over the spread of Islamic radicalism and the global war on terrorism. Yet, as the Turkish refusal to allow the Bush administration to use Turkey as a northern front for the 2003 invasion of Iraq illustrates, Turkey has increasingly acted in ways that defy American expectations. Fuller suggests three main reasons for this decline in American–Turkish relations: first, the collapse of the Soviet Union removed Russia as a threat to Turkey; second, Ankara's interests within the Middle East diverge from the U.S. agenda; and third, Turkey is seeking to increase its political and economic agenda through new relationships with Russia, China, and the Muslim world.
Fuller develops this analysis in three parts. In the first part he offers an explanation for the changing nature of Turkish foreign policy. The trajectory of Turkish foreign policy, he argues, results from efforts to address exclusionary aspects of the Kemalist project of modernity. In fact, as Fuller's overview of Islamist political and social mobilization in Turkey illustrates, realignment in Turkish foreign policy has been ongoing since the 1970s. Unlike many studies of Islamic politics in Turkey, Fuller focuses not only on the importance of Islamist political parties (from the Welfare Party to the Justice and Development Party) but also on the rise of Islamic civil society—in particular the Gülenist movement. The success of Islamic politics at the domestic level, Fuller argues, serves as a model for the rest of the Muslim world. Moreover, these changes within the domestic politics of Turkey, Fuller rightly suggests, are good for Turkey and Turkish democracy despite the fact that they are the source of the country's increasing independence from U.S. influence.
In the second part of his analysis, Fuller examines how these domestic changes contribute to recalibrations in Turkey's foreign relations. Although the text never delves too deeply into any single case, Fuller provides an overview of the changing nature of Turkey's relationships with Syria, Iraq, Iran, Israel and Palestine, Egypt, the Gulf states, Afghanistan, Europe, several Eurasian states, and, of course, the United States. The weight of the evidence suggests the emergence of a far more independent Turkish foreign policy; it is a foreign policy enabled by Turkey's military dominance and economic advantages within the Middle East and characterized by active diplomacy unprecedented in Republican history. Yet, throughout this section, Fuller justifiably warns that the Kurdish question remains a serious impediment to Turkey's foreign-policy aspirations.
The final part of his analysis briefly considers paths Turkish foreign policy may take in the future. Fuller is careful not to rule out the possibility of Turkish foreign policy once again realigning with Washington's interests, or turning mainly toward Europe. However, Fuller lays out several reasons why these paths seem unlikely at the present moment. Rather, Fuller concludes, “On balance, the trend toward an increasingly independent Turkish foreign policy is the most powerful force in Turkey today and is increasingly supported by domestic, regional, and global events” (p. 174).
If there is one line of argument within the text that I found provocative, but not necessarily compelling, it would be Fuller's argument that Turkey can fulfill the Muslim world's search for a strong leader (p. 23). I find this language a bit jarring. What, after all, is the Muslim world, and why does it need a leader? In fact, much of Fuller's text focuses more on Turkey's influence within the Middle East, not necessarily the broader Muslim world. Although Turkey may be able to, or may want to, play a greater role in the Middle East, the reason for Turkey's influence will likely involve more than a shared religious identity; it will involve precisely those elements Fuller's text so efficiently outlines—military superiority, control of water resources, access to European markets, a commitment to democracy, and so on.
This text provides a useful and succinct introduction into Turkish foreign policy; its argument is clearly presented and logical. Key points in the text are often isolated with bulleted passages. The text addresses a range of issues influencing Turkish foreign policy and considers Turkish relations with a number of critical neighboring states in addition to major world powers. This text would prove eminently useful to individuals unfamiliar with Turkish foreign policy. It would make a great addition to undergraduate library collections or prove useful in undergraduate courses either on Turkey, the Middle East, or international relations. The text also seeks to persuade an audience of American public policymakers that a more independent Turkish voice in the Middle East may do more to foster a Western agenda than a Turkey that is perceived to be doing the bidding of the West. More knowledgeable scholars may find Fuller's case studies to be too brief; whole texts could be written on some of the relationships between Turkey and its neighbors, which Fuller addresses in a few pages.
