These three scholarly works, each a major intellectual contribution in its own right, also fit together well for a book review because all address global systems of order, either colonialism or the creation and maintenance of empire. They contrast with much of modern political science, which is more oriented toward the contemporary world and studies of the nation-state. Across these three books we review three of the major empires of history: Spanish colonial control of Latin America; the creation, sustenance, and decline of the Ottoman Empire; and British colonialism, particularly in Africa but also in parts of Asia and the Americas. These empires no longer exist but have left important legacies, including multiple nations that were once controlled by a center and a trajectory of more or less successful development. These books cause us to think back to a time when huge portions of the world were controlled or governed from a central base. That time has left a stamp upon our own era. The books also fit together methodologically because all three use comparative historical analysis for understanding differences in style of colonial or imperial control, and all look toward hundreds of years of history in explaining differences.
The argument of Karen Barkey's Empire of Difference is that the Islamic Ottoman Empire of 1300–1918 distinguished itself by its tolerance of difference and its acceptance of diversity, particularly religious diversity. This fact is remarkable given that the empire was governed with reference to Islamic law, existed during centuries when religious differences were defining human identities, and included large numbers of Christians and Jews as well as Moslems. Tolerance explains why the empire survived for so long and incorporated such vast territories. Barkey's position is both comparative and qualified. She compares the Ottoman Empire both to previous (the Roman and Byzantine) and to contemporary (the Russian and Western) empires and finds that the Ottomans were more tolerant of diversity and more adept at handling religious difference than any of the others. She also suggests that the height of this tolerance came in the early centuries of the empire while the Ottomans were building and then sustaining their vast territory of control. But in the final centuries, particularly the eighteenth and nineteenth, the Ottomans lost much of their capacity to incorporate diverse populations. As the empire declined and felt threatened both by the Russians and by Christianity from the west, the Ottomans lapsed into increasingly authoritarian patterns of behavior, including the Armenian genocide.
Chapters 1 to 4 discuss the early centuries of Ottoman rule and show how the Ottomans dealt successfully with difference. Chapters 5 to 8 then discuss the rise of problems, including political dissent (Chapter 5), growing financial problems and alternative bases of financial power (Chapter 6), and general economic decline (Chapter 7). Chapter 8 discusses the final years but avoids commentary on the creation of modern Turkey.
Barkey leaves us with a haunting question: Is it possible to govern so vast a territory from a single center of political control? Her answer is that possibly it was not or that, at least, it became impossible by the end of the empire. But that answer in and of itself raises questions for the modern era, including those for contemporary systems of cooperation like the European Union and the Mercosur. In the end, the Ottoman Empire proved ungovernable because it was too vast and too diverse to be administered successfully into the modern industrial era from a distant center. But the skill the Ottomans showed in managing so diverse an empire for so long has been lost with their demise and theirs was a skill the modern world could well use today.
The author's argument could use more explicit discussion of the other empires, as well as examples showing why she finds them less tolerant of difference than the Ottomans. We know of the murderous tension between Catholics and Protestants in Europe, as well as of the mistreatment of Jews. The Crusades were also examples of religious intolerance and violent efforts to convert others. More specific discussion of these differences in a thorough comparative chapter would have been helpful. Additionally, it would have been useful to find some discussion about why the Ottomans were so pragmatic and willing to create and use social and political alliances while other empires were less so. And finally, anticipating the Lange and Mahoney works in the following discussion, Barkey gives us no basis for understanding why the former territory of the Ottoman Empire has witnessed so much violence and includes so many nations that would today be considered underdeveloped. Did the Ottoman Empire have any role in this outcome? No book can do everything, and the best works finish by raising more questions and curiosity in our minds. Barkey succeeds in this way as well for she leaves us wondering about the relationship between Ottoman control and the modern era. This last question points toward another book entirely.
The books by Matthew Lange and James Mahoney fit together even more closely because they are both studies of colonialism that attempt to discover differences in the style of colonialism and the level of colonial control used by European powers. Unlike Barkey's work, Lange's and Mahoney's make specific reference to the modern era in an effort to explain why some former colonies are development success stories and others are not. These authors define development as the ability of citizens to live enhancing lives.
Lineages of Despotism and Development is a study of British colonialism. It focuses upon a territory even more vast than that of the Ottoman Empire, and one that reached literally around the globe. Yet the British Empire was shorter-lived than the Ottoman Empire, and Lange points us toward one possible reason why: Some parts of that empire were not governed well and British rule left very diverse legacies for the modern era. Lange breaks ground by attempting to discover differences in the mode of British colonial rule and whether those differences have had any long-lasting effect today. I find this effort quite illuminating because much previous work on colonialism has relied primarily upon differences by modern nation-states, for example, differences between British colonialism and Portuguese colonialism. Instead, Lange looks only at former British colonies. He finds that they had very different colonial experiences, and those differences help explain levels of development and contemporary political outcomes today.
Using an elegant quantitative analysis of colonialism and development, Lange builds a new variable that measures the level of colonialism. His measure suggests two basic kinds of colonial control: “direct” and “indirect” colonial rule. The first of these was used in territories where the indigenous population was sparse and indigenous institutions of governance were either absent or did not concentrate around a strong center of power. In these territories, the British colonized by importing wholesale the institutions of Britain herself. But in territories that had large indigenous populations and complex systems of governance already in place locally, the British style of colonial rule was indirect, and the Brits imposed their control through the use of local power holders. The two categories are not fully mutually exclusive, but Lange's measure of colonialism shows that most former British colonies fall more fully into one category or the other. An important exception is India where the British tried to establish direct rule but found the nation too vast and too highly populated for that approach to work. Instead, they moved toward a kind of hybrid colonial rule in India where parts of the nation experienced indirect British colonial rule.
These differences matter because nations that experienced direct British rule have developed more successfully than those that experienced indirect British rule. To explore this finding, Lange produces four single-chapter case studies and a series of abbreviated cases studies to see whether details about single nations fit his theory. Among his four chapter studies, two fit his theory while two do not. He uses the discussion to show where the cases follow the trajectory predicted by his theory and why his exceptions are different. His book is important because it helps take the shine off of British rule. British colonialism has often been compared positively to both Spanish and Portuguese rule. But Lange shows that the British also did damage, and the examples of their indirectly ruled colonies show how.
One key problem with Lange's work is his exclusive reliance upon African examples for all of his four case study chapters. Many scholars of Africa think that the continent is exceptional. If that is true, then one wonders how generalizable the findings are to the rest of the world. The theory purports to apply to all British colonies and the quantitative analysis is more global in its reach. But the superficiality of the statistics is not buttressed by limiting case study analysis only to Africa. The argument would be greatly strengthened by an in-depth study of several British colonies outside of Africa. But again, that may be too much to ask in one volume and may be a different book entirely.
James Mahoney's book on Spanish colonialism in Latin America falls within the same genre as Lange's: an effort to discern and understand long-term effects of different colonial styles. But the reach of Colonialism and Postcolonial Development is much more extensive than Lange's book and offers much greater depth of understanding of individual cases. Mahoney uses extensive study of Brazil to explore Portuguese colonialism and reference to British colonies worldwide to understand British colonialism. He is able to use British and Portuguese colonialism as examples that support his theory. As a result, his theory applies far beyond the Spanish colonial efforts alone, and the book successfully offers a way of comparing colonial legacies at the global level.
Like Lange, Mahoney suggests that there were fundamental differences in styles of colonialism, but he does not divide these by countries. Mahoney's work is a major departure from previous studies of colonialism because instead of looking primarily at the colonial territory, the author looks at the political and economic institutions inside the colonizing power at the time of colonization. This scrutiny of the colonizer allows him to clarify ways that European colonial powers differed in their styles of colonialism. Those differences emerged not only across European nations but also across time within one nation. He argues that depending upon which kinds of institutions were predominant inside the mother country, European nations engaged in either mercantilist colonialism or liberal colonialism. Accordingly, early Spanish colonialism (under the Hapsburgs) in Latin America was primarily mercantilist, while later Spanish colonialism (under the Bourbons) was more liberal. British colonialism, by contrast, was primarily liberal, while Portuguese colonialism was primarily mercantilist. Mercantilist colonialism aimed mostly at the extraction of wealth and the importation of institutions that would support that effort. Liberal colonialism, by contrast, was oriented primarily toward importing the rule of law, with liberal capitalism being an aftereffect of such colonialism.
Mahoney then looks at the conditions inside the territory being colonized, and here his work is similar to Lange's. Where territories had sparse indigenous populations and lacked either centralized or regional power centers, liberal European colonizers invested heavily by importing large European populations and many European political institutions. These territories were colonized essentially by implanting a neo-Europe in the newly colonized territory. These (the United States, Australia) became the strongest developmental success stories. But where sparsely populated territories only attracted the attention of mercantilist colonial powers, that attention was minimal. The investment of European populations and institutions was low or absent, and these territories are less likely to have become developmental success stories today. Territories that primarily experienced mercantilist colonialism are likewise not success stories today.
The strength of both Mahoney's and Lange's work is also their key weakness. Their understanding of history has produced an excessive reliance upon a path-dependent explanation for contemporary circumstances. As with any method, when done well, path analysis may overdetermine outcomes, leaving no room for, and no hope that, modern actors and humans alive today can intervene in developmental trajectories to improve things now or change the trajectories imposed by colonialism. One would certainly hope that this is an overly pessimistic conclusion. Modern political science analyzes differences between individual contemporary countries, including their ability to develop themselves successfully. Surely there is room inside modern nations for citizens and political leaders to help determine their own fate. Lange's work, with its study of exceptional cases, leaves more room for human agency today in explaining political outcomes, but Mahoney's theory is so thorough that one is left with a feeling of hopelessness: Heavily populated nations colonized by mercantilist powers appear forever doomed to underdevelopment. Of course, reality is not that dark. The detailed study of specific nations can show how and why individual countries can depart from the trajectories left to them by the colonial experience. But that task is left to other authors and other studies.
Nonetheless, much of modern political science is ahistorical, moving too far in the opposite direction. Therefore, we gain much of value by the understanding of history that these three books provide. They allow us to see that there were distinctive differences in the way that empires were governed and in the impact empires had on their colonized territories. As we try to understand contemporary differences between modern nation-states, a thorough understanding of comparative historical background is an invaluable foundation for our work.
