This is an unusual and important book. It sets out to “ground”, in the author's term, a vast range of textual sources in the archaeological evidence provided mainly by Udayagiri as it was refashioned by Candragupta II but also makes comprehensive references to the epigraphic and archaeological insights afforded by other Gupta, or Gupta-subordinate, sites. The volume consists of three long parts each of between 70 and 80 pages and each made accessible to the reader by frequent sub-divisions. They treat: 1. The Archaeology and Politics of Time at Udayagiri; 2. The Establishment of the Gods and 3. Ritual Action and Ritual Actors. These overarching themes are three pillars supporting the edifice of the book: identical in function, they sometimes draw on the same sources and develop the same or similar arguments but always for well-differentiated purposes. This confers logical continuity, strength and transparency on the book. Thus Part 1 is concerned with a major new reading of the archaeological landscape of Udayagiri, particularly the central ridge and passage, the hilltop and remains of water features. It constructs from the three main sculptural reliefs and in situ epigraphs a narrative of the cosmic power of Viṣṇu, and creates a sustained argument that it is an allegory of the royal power of Candragupta II who celebrated a rājāsūya at this site. Willis’ new reading of the Udayagiri central passage extends to locating its east-west orientation in the solar and lunar calendar of the period of his reign, from the late fourth to the early fifth century (Part 1.2, 1.3 and Appendix 1), and in particular to calculating the times of the year when the sun's rays would fall on the recumbent figure of Viṣṇu-Nārāyaṇa slumbering on the coils of the cosmic serpent Ananta-Śeṣa. Similarly, the huge sculpture of Viṣṇu as Varāha (Udayagiri Cave 5, one of the major depictions of this form in India) is accorded a very detailed reading in relation to the inscription close by as well as the Nārāyaṇa and Narasiṃha sculptures. The votive figures kneeling at the foot of the Varāha and Nārāyaṇa sculptures receive extended study and are identified as Candragupta II in a subtle set of arguments. Uniting the specific sculptures with the site as a whole, the author takes them out of the isolation imposed by current site-barriers and creates a mental reconstruction of its water features (a high level tank, stepped cascade and low level tank) that may have accompanied the major rituals performed here at the most significant points of the religio-political year, such as putting Viṣṇu-Nārāyaṇa to sleep for four months and awakening him to rescue the earth (pp. 75–78, Appendix 2). It is also argued here that these integrated water features may have operated as a water clock.
In Parts 1 and 2, Willis has additional and very significant aims, namely to reveal the central aspects of what he sees as a time of crucial change under the Guptas with enduring consequences for Hinduism. This change is from a culture dominated by Vedic rituals and actors (which he presents as anti-iconic and anti-monumental) to the monumental projects of temples, shrines, sculptures and inscriptions initiated by a king aspiring to be a universal monarch, and on lesser scales by queens, ministers and subordinate kings. Part 2 therefore discusses in great detail how the gods inhering in the consecrated statues and their dwelling places in the shrines and temples became legal entities during this period and thus could be the recipients of benefactions intended to endure. The small number of in situ inscriptions at Udayagiri is supplemented by stone inscriptions from other sources, mostly Gupta or Vākāṭaka sites, copper-plate land grants and an erudite array of textual sources always carefully chosen for their relevance to the main themes. His discussion of the Mānavadharmaśāstra, the Arthaśāstra, the Allahābād and Taḷaguṇḍa inscriptions among others are exceptionally interesting and offer many original insights. Inter alia, Willis has a gift for restoring vitality and novelty to ideas that have become obscured by the weight of linguistic criticism. He argues that the lesser kings who were conquered by Candragupta II (under whose reign the empire reached its greatest extent) replicated in their kingdoms the ritual projects of the king-of-kings himself. This concept permits him to draw on a larger body of evidence to support his analysis of change embodied at Udayagiri. Part 3 is devoted to the agents of this change, in particular the royal preceptor, the ācārya, other priests who received land grants to maintain the service of images and temples, together with the continuing but reduced role of the Vedic priests at court. Here he traces a separation among the brāhmaṇa-s, (and notes a possible conflict between them): some remaining Vedic priests while others pursued the evolving status and activities of temple priests. Among the significant elements of change, he points to temple-building, sculpture, the increasing use, and increasingly correct use, of Sanskrit as the sacred language of ritual, law and endowment. Willis concludes that the enactment of Gupta royal rituals, endowments and their monumental expression were instruments in the propagation of Gupta power, rather than the other way around. By choosing Udayagiri as his centrepiece, he is able to locate his study in the works of the greatest of the Gupta rulers in the one site of Gupta royal-religious activity where a significant set of monumental art has survived in situ.
In view of the great resonance of Gupta and immediately post-Gupta culture in South East Asia, let us consider the wider relevance of this book. The term hindouisation of South East Asia (usually translated into English as indianisation), was coined in the 1920s by the distinguished French epigrapher and historian, Georges Coedès. Coedès had in mind a counterpart to the prevailing colonial model of the romanisation of Europe, but conceded in his introduction to Les Etats Hindouisés d'Indochine et d'Indonésie, that the colonisation in Asia was cultural not military. Nonetheless, from the 1920s to the 1970s, many European and Indian scholars referred to the imposition of Indian culture on South East Asian societies by ‘colonists’ in the first and early second millenium. Though the imposition model is rejected by contemporary scholars of South East Asia, the term ‘indianisation’ is still used: there is an urgent need for a redefinition of what it means – just as the concept of romanisation has been redefined and refined many times. The deepest aim of Willis’ book is to delineate the profound changes in rituals and endowments, art and architecture under Candragupta's reign which were to launch a new phase of Hinduism and himself as a cakravartin. Among the many achievements of this book, it offers a logical basis for a more precise discussion of what that new phase of Hinduism involved, the agents through whom it was achieved, and its implications for models of indianisation (or indianisations?) over wider regions.
This is an elegantly written book, unusual in the way it combines the archaeological perceptions of extensive field-walking in Central India, an art historian's eye for eloquent iconographic and stylistic detail, with a comprehensive knowledge of relevant inscriptions and many (but never burdensome) quotations from Sanskrit texts, followed by beautiful English translations. Inevitably, since there are many controversies surrounding textual issues, of which the authentication and dating of all parts of the Arthaśāstra and the Laws of Manu are but two examples, there will be critics of one passage or another in this book. But all would agree that it offers a coherent set of richly documented, transparently framed arguments, which together comprise a well-considered, new interpretation of religio-political change in the reign of Candragupta II. Cambridge University Press is to be praised for the excellent standard of production: an attractive typeface, and high-quality paper which permit sharp reproductions of the illustrations complementing the points made in the text and always placed adjacent to them.
