This is the second edition of a book first published by Ashgate in 2000. Since the reviewer has not read the first edition, the current discussion is solely based on the new version and will not address the changes between editions. In essence, Khun Eng Kuah-Pearce's book is a nuanced study of a group of Singaporean Chinese whose ancestors or who themselves emigrated from Anxi County, Fujian Province, in China's southeast coast and settled in the island state. The relationships and interactions between these expatriates in Singapore and their kinfolks in Anxi—chiefly through remittances from Singapore to Anxi, occasional home visits, and participation in ancestral worship rituals and lineage activities—have gone through many ups and downs and eventually evolved into a new type of multilayered identity that is reflective of the globalization era. Based on this observation, the author proposes a cultural network model to illustrate the new identities acquired by all through the crafty manipulation, negotiation, and reinterpretation of the traditional lineage institution and the accompanying moral economy that served to connect the spiritual source (the ancestral village in Anxi) with the overseas nodes and dispersed individuals.
As a member of the Anxi Ke lineage in Singapore, Kuah-Pearce was able to take advantage of the insider's position to carry out longitudinal studies from both ends of the international exchange flows. She conducted empirical fieldwork in Singapore among the Ke lineage members through participation in ritual activities, in-depth interviews with individuals belonging to diverse age cohorts, and survey questionnaires for quantitative data. She then followed the Ke lineage members when they visited their ancestral homes in Anxi to observe how they interacted with local kin, fellow villagers, and officials. This painstaking research unraveled the contorted process of cultural preservation and identity formation on both ends of the spectrum summarized below.
The most immediate factor affecting the Anxi Chinese identity in Singapore is the changing policy of Singapore's nation-state building project. Established as a multi-ethnic state composed of a majority Chinese (although divided into several “dialect” groups), plus significant minorities of Malays and Hindus, Singapore in the post-independence decades (i.e., 1960s through 90s) has purposefully promoted a Singaporean identity and systematically discouraged other ethnic markers to avoid internal divisions and conflict. It was not until Singapore reached a high level of economic development in the 1990s that the state began to encourage the revival of ethnic customs and identities as part of the cultural preservation project. Anxi expatriates took advantage of this change and began to expand contacts with their kin in both Singapore and China.
Singapore's softening policy toward internal ethnic identity coincided with China's changing state-engineered modernization projects. In the first thirty years of communist rule (c. 1949–79), contacts with overseas Chinese, especially those in capitalist societies, were considered politically incorrect. Information exchange through mails or remittance from abroad could jeopardize a person's socio-political standing in society. Hence little effort was made to promote contacts between Anxi rural folks and their kin abroad. But the “Reform and Opening” policy since the 1980s changed all that. To encourage overseas Chinese investments to speed up China's economic development, Anxi officials began to urge those with overseas connections to invite them back for home visits. The Singapore expatriates, taking advantage of the official initiatives, began to press for permission to rebuild ancestral halls and graves and to revive related ritual festivals. Tensions and conflicts between the Singaporean Anxi expatriates, their local kin, and the Chinese officials, as well as intergenerational conflicts among them—based on what they perceived to be the most urgent needs of individual kinsmen, the lineage groups, or the local communities, and how to allocate the precious capital the expatriates brought back to Anxi's poverty-stricken hill hometown—constituted the major flash points in the ensuring decades.
Two new developments seem to have alleviated some of the conflicts. The first is the creation of new symbolic foci to cement the spatial and temporal distances between the Singaporean and their village kin. The building of a zuzhai (ancestral house) as the new focal point of all lineage members seems to have fostered good will among the distant kin. The second development is the new interpretation of the lineage institution from a localized, territorial bound kin group in Anxi's remote hills to a loosely connected transnational network. The recompilation of the Ke lineage genealogy in 1996 seems to have accomplished this goal. In short, Kuah-Pearce's book is an insightful ethnography for China experts who are interested in the globalization process of the Chinese overseas and its impact on their home communities in China.
