This ethnographic book analyzes the Gülen movement, drawing on the latter's self-given name, Hizmet (service), for the title. It is not an easy text to review due to its paradoxical aspects. On the one hand, those with limited information on Hizmet and Turkey would appreciate the book's detailed background information on Ottoman and modern Turkish history, but they may be disappointed that the book does not provide a comprehensive analysis of the movement's various aspects, particularly its recently increasing political engagements. On the other hand, those already knowledgeable about the movement and Turkey will find the book's narrow focus on specific items refreshing; however, they may regard the historical background tedious—readers must wait until page seventy for discussion of the movement.
Tittensor argues that such a long historical background is needed to contextualize the Gülen movement. While exploring the movement's recent public influence, for example, he notes that Islamic actors played important public roles throughout late Ottoman and modern Turkish history. The author also points to the Turkish state's historical persecution of Islamic actors, which contextualizes his criticism of the Gülen movement's lack of sufficient transparency.
The book poses two main questions that relate to how to define the Gülen movement: First, is it a Muslim missionary or merely an education-based movement? Second, does it depend on secret sources of funding or simply donations? According to the book, the ideological polarization between the critics and proponents of the movement has led to confusion over how to answer these questions. The main critics—assertive secularists in Turkey and Islamophobes in the West—perceive it as Islamist and therefore untrustworthy. For them, the movement hides its missionary identity and has mysterious financial resources. The proponents, on the other hand, have reacted to these criticisms with hyperbolic claims that the movement has nothing to do with proselytizing and is exclusively funded by donations. Tittensor tries to offer a middle ground between these two depictions. He emphasizes that the movement does not try to convert non-Muslims through tebliğ (proselyting); it only conducts temsil (representation through behaviors). Nonetheless, to Muslims, the author adds, the Gülen movement preaches a particular understanding of Islam. Tittensor also provides a balanced picture of the movement's finances by stressing that though it does collect donations, it also has profit-making institutions such as elite schools. Similarly, when discussing its structure, the author emphasizes both the moral hierarchy of elderly brothers and sisters, and the voluntary nature of its participants.
The most original aspect of the book is its in-depth interviews conducted in Turkey with those who taught at and attended the movement's schools in various parts of the world, especially Central Asia. Through these interviews, the author is able to stress the importance of the personal relations and trust that link members together. He also reveals the views of various teachers and students, and thus goes beyond previous publications that mostly examined Fethullah Gülen's views.
Although the title of the book refers to “Islam's third way,” the book's content hardly touches on this issue. The author includes only a few lines on how the Gülen movement's interpretation of Islam is neither literal formalism nor Sufi mysticism. This crucial issue would require further elaboration. I also have reservations about the book's portrayal of the movement's human and financial resources. To argue that “between 8 to 10 million people in Turkey are associated with the Movement” (p. 73) and it is “worth … $25 billion” (p. 149) is speculative. Recent elections in Turkey have revealed that the number of the movement's followers is much smaller. Additionally, the author's insightful comparative data about major Christian movements’ budgets (p. 149) unintentionally shows that the financial claims about the Gülen movement are likely exaggerated.
Overall, this timely and scholarly book presents an objective analysis of the influential Gülen movement, which is generally described in controversial terms.
