There is no denying the growing significance of China in the world today. Since the global financial crisis, it has become the second-largest economy in terms of both GDP and exports. It is also playing a greater role in global governance with its pivotal position in the G20 and the emergence of the BRIC countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China) as important global actors.
The (re-)emergence of China is having a major impact on the rest of the world, including the developing world. While the impacts of China on Africa have attracted a great deal of attention recently – not least because of the growing involvement of China in countries such as the Sudan, Angola, Zimbabwe and the Democratic Republic of Congo, which have been sites of major conflicts and human rights abuses – its impacts on Latin America have received less coverage. There is now, however, a growing literature on relations between China and Latin America, to which this book makes a useful contribution.
After a brief introductory chapter, Ellis examines in turn the key interests of China in Latin America and what Latin America hopes to gain from its relationship with China. The chapter on the interests of China in the region highlights four issues. Firstly, China sees Latin America as a source of primary products, both raw materials for its growing industrial sector and agricultural products. Secondly, it seeks markets for its industrial exports in the region. Thirdly, since half the countries in the world that continue to recognise Taiwan rather than the government of the People's Republic are in Latin America and the Caribbean, a major strategic objective has been to woo these countries in order to further isolate Taiwan. This is particularly important in Central America and the Caribbean, where China has little direct economic interest. Finally, Ellis argues that China sees Latin America in geopolitical terms as part of its strategy of promoting a multi-polar world in opposition to US hegemony.
Latin American interest in China is primarily as a market for the region's exports, which have increased rapidly since the start of the millennium. There are also great hopes of Chinese investment coming to Latin America, particularly to develop the region's infrastructure, although so far the actual investments that have been made are quite limited. Ellis argues that relations with China are seen in Latin America as a way of reducing the political, economic and institutional dominance of the United States, thus providing an opportunity for greater autonomy. This seems particularly the case for governments such as those of Chávez in Venezuela, Morales in Bolivia and Correa in Ecuador, which have been characterised as populist left-wing regimes.
The book then provides more detailed case studies of individual countries, divided into three regional chapters on the Southern Cone, the Andean countries, and Mexico, Central America and the Caribbean. The discussion of each country follows a similar structure, looking at the historical context of its relations with China, the ethnic Chinese population, exports to China, imports from China, infrastructure projects, technical cooperation, government and business infrastructures, intellectual infrastructure, and political and military relations. The final chapter looks to the future.
This volume provides a wealth of information from the author's own interviews and numerous media reports, as well as some academic studies, to give an up-to-date picture of Chinese–Latin American relations. This is also the weakness of the book, however. Such has been the spectacular growth of China that any account will inevitably get overtaken by events within a relatively short period of time, so China in Latin America is likely to date very quickly. This problem might have been avoided had the book developed a theoretical framework for analysing China's impact on Latin America, but its focus is mainly descriptive rather than analytical.
A second problem is the book's heavy reliance on media reports that may not always be reliable or accurate, especially in relation to economic data. For example, it is claimed that Argentina has significant exports of sunflower products (p. 62), but trade data show that these account for less than 1 per cent of Argentina's total exports to China. This is an even more acute problem when it comes to discussing foreign investment, where media reports are often exaggerated because they refer to planned investment that may never materialise. A case in point is the proposed joint venture between Baosteel and the Brazilian iron ore mining company Vale. Ellis quotes reports of a US$ 1.4 billion investment in the state of Maranhão in 2006 and of a further planned steel plant in the state of Espírito Santo in 2007 (p. 51). In fact, this was merely a change in the planned location of the plant, which has now been cancelled. The scale of Chinese foreign direct investment in Latin America is also often exaggerated in media reports by the inclusion of flows to tax havens such as the Cayman Islands and British Virgin Islands.
The book also reflects its provenance in the emphasis that it puts on the implications of the growing Chinese involvement in Latin America for the United States' relations with the region. This has been a major concern for the Right in the United States, which has argued that the Chinese presence represents a threat to US interests and to free markets and democracy in the region. Although not going as far as some political figures such as Congressman Dan Burton, Ellis does appear to share some of these worries.
Despite these criticisms this book provides a very useful summary of the current state of economic and political relations between China and the individual Latin American countries, which will make it essential reading for anyone wanting an up-to-date picture.
