The past fifteen years have seen the emergence of the field of “Indian Ocean studies”—based on the realization that peoples inhabiting the Indian Ocean shores have been linked through continuous commercial and cultural contact over millennia. In the same period, several studies have emerged that have brought an “Indian Ocean” perspective to the cultural study of regions that previously tended to be studied separately, tied to their respective continents rather than to their ocean frontier.
A common theme in these studies has been the underlying assumption that the Indian Ocean over a very long period has been a field of intense cultural exchange among the coastal regions of East Africa, South Arabia, and India and the archipelagos of Southeast Asia. The Hadramis of southern Yemen were one group who traveled within this world from an early time. Particularly mobile were the ʿAlawi sāda—a distinct Hadrami social stratum claiming descent from the Prophet. The ʿAlawi sāda are also the main focus in Engseng Ho's thorough study.
The Graves of Tarim addresses issues that have marked the study of the Indian Ocean—many of which are also central themes in the ongoing discourse on cosmopolitanism, globalization, translocality, and transregional identity.
The Graves of Tarim is first and foremost an important contribution to the study of diaspora in general, emphasizing the longue durée perspective. Diaspora, as presented by Ho, is generated over time, and its chief byproduct is absence, repeated and represented over generations. The study demonstrates that mobility is not necessarily connected to the rise of the West or to modernity as defined by Western criteria. Furthermore, the interrelation between genealogy and place is brought out with admirable clarity. Kinship replaces place as the ʿAlawi diaspora is formed, although place nonetheless remains the loci of diaspora as represented in ʿAlawi literature. The homeland is conceived as a place of return, notions of homeland versus diaspora are maintained over generations—interpreted in terms whereby genealogy and place are inextricably linked and come from the soil of the homeland, its graves.
The real strength of the study lies in the use of textual sources that are interpreted with reference to the present-day diasporic world of the Hadramis, researched through ethnographic field work. In the study of diaspora, the researcher inevitably must face the fact that he or she (like his or her object of study) encounters several national, regional, linguistic, and historiographic traditions. The textual production of the ʿAlawi sāda of East Africa, for example, feature prominently in the local historiography of that region, now recounted in Kiswahili. The perspective adopted by Engseng Ho brings out the explicit interconnectedness of texts (and thereby cultural products in general) produced in various parts of the ʿAlawi diaspora—in this case focusing mainly on Southeast Asia and Hadramawt itself. By juxtaposing texts from different eras and regions and by analyzing them in a present-day context, Ho brings out clearly the recurring topos of the texts, translocality, as interpreted by the migrants themselves over centuries. Furthermore, his analysis clearly elucidates the relationship between bloodlines and textlines, genealogy and its representation. Finally, the analysis highlights the intertextual relationship between texts that may otherwise not have been connected.
Here, The Graves of Tarim paves the way for further studies of comparable diasporas, both in the Indian Ocean and elsewhere. In the same vein, Ho's work also contributes to the study of hybrid, or multicultural, texts in general, offering insights that are valid also for the study of literature.
Finally, as the texts under scrutiny are mainly Islamic texts and the society studied overwhelmingly Muslim, The Graves of Tarim is also a study of Islam in the Indian Ocean—as spread (and transmitted back to Tarim) by the ʿAlawi sāda. Its main strength here lies in focus on the close connection between descent lines and textlines, genealogy and Sufism, forefathers and religion.
The structure of the book is elegant and complementary to the themes raised by its author, beginning with the establishment of place through the funeral site, via the outbound journey to the various forms of return to the site of the ancestors. The language, too, deserves special mention. A gravestone is “a sign whose silent presence marks an absence” (p. 1), thus incorporating the idea of the absent as an inherent component of mobility. The ʿAlawis are like a “strong current” in a “restless ocean” (p. 102), evoking both the movement of the ʿAlawi way and its confluence with the turbulence of Indian Ocean history. This fluency of style, combined with the previously mentioned analysis of textual sources, is what extends this book beyond specialized reading and makes it a general discussion of transregional mobility. It will be of interest to students of social anthropology, history, Islamic studies, and literature.
As a general criticism, the book suffers slightly from somewhat dated fieldwork (in some cases more than a decade)—and is not very specific as to where and when fieldwork was conducted. One must assume that both Hadramawt and the diasporic world have changed since the early 1990s, especially in terms of employment opportunities—a never-ending topic among the Hadramis, be they migrant, settled, or stranded. On the whole, however, this does not detract from an otherwise very thorough study that deserves a wide readership.
