The wonderful Theatre& series aims to put innovative scholarship on a wide variety of subjects into the hands of students, an admirable goal assisted by low costs and short lengths. Harvey Young's Theatre & Race is another worthy volume, a clearly written book that engages with recent theories of race and performance studies. As Young states in the introduction, “Theatre & Race actively encourages the consideration of topics—race and racism—that most people would prefer not to address and applies them to a medium—theatre—that many incorrectly view as being escapist” (3). A key contribution of this volume is to help make a conversation about race and racism possible in the classroom. Young realizes that, even in a college setting, students shy away from open discussions of race for fear of speaking in error or voicing an unnuanced opinion. The book provides readers with basic terminology for use in research and in critical conversations with others.
At the outset of the book, Young offers a concise definition of race and performance. For Young, race is a construction that changes and shifts over time; however, it also dictates social interactions and imposes limitations upon bodies and identities. Race's “broad acceptance, seeming materiality, and staying power are anchored in its ability to provide a narrative that unifies a collective social history with the variances in individuated social perspectives” (6). Utilizing Michael Omi and Howard Winant, E. Patrick Johnson, Louis Althusser, and Pierre Bourdieu, Young goes on to theorize the simultaneous embodiment and performance of race as involving “three interrelated activities: racial interpellation . . . racial socialization . . . and racial habitus” (10). The three activities are then examined in different eras and locations of performance.
The book is broken down into chapters of ten easily digestible pages each; these are organized chronologically and focus on commonly defined eras of Western theatre history: classical Greek and Roman, Elizabethan England, nineteenth-century United States, and present-day United States. The examples in each chapter range from playtexts and performances to popular theatre forms and film. Despite the many merits of the book, its title is slightly misleading in that the examples, theories, and scholarship focus on blackness and African American identity; other forms of racial performance are given less attention.
The two chapters that follow the introduction discuss race in the classical period and Elizabethan age, respectively. The chapter on classical theatre hops from Greek to Roman times, and Young uses it to help define community formation within the theatrical space/event as a counterpart for cultural articulations of race: “These stories affirm a sense of communal wholeness by spotlighting foreigners whose unchecked passions and (occasionally) mixed blood make them ‘other’ to Athenians” (20). Communal “othering” is examined throughout Theatre & Race. In his chapter on the Elizabethan period, Young compares anti-Semitism to other racial constructs, noting that “unlike Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice (1596) or Christopher Marlowe's The Jew of Malta (1589), [Othello] is not centrally concerned with cultural or racial difference” (26). As a transition into the rest of the book, he notes, “Although always an ‘other,’ Othello did not become consistently ‘black,’ from a contemporary perspective, until the early twentieth century” (27). Othello's mutable racial status highlights theatre's ability to track such social changes.
The following two chapters of Theatre & Race center on the use of racial makeup for the purpose of denigration in nineteenth-century US theatre: blackface in one chapter; red-, yellow-, and whiteface in the next. Young describes the rise of the minstrel show as “arguably the most spectacular theatrical genre involving the staging of race and racial difference” (36). He then discusses African American blackface performers of the late nineteenth century by noting “they still had to imagine and then perform another person's assumptions of blackness” (43). In my experience, students resist the very idea of black minstrel performers, but Young renders this historical necessity with sensitivity. In discussing the other “faces,” he finds commonalities between stereotyped performances: “Like redface and blackface performers, yellowface actors spoke broken, nonstandard English with an invented dialect that distorted the speech patterns of actual immigrants” (53). This time period and these examples are central to Young's volume because they so perfectly encapsulate the activities of interpolation, socialization, and habitus.
Each of the final two chapters examines a present-day controversy around theatre and race: the debate around color-blind casting and the idea of postrace performance. Both are illustrated using examples drawn from African American theatre. The chapter “Colorblind and Color-Conscious Casting” deftly summarizes a complicated and multifaceted issue, and I can imagine using it as the basis for in-class discussion. “Colorblind casting assumes,” Young writes, echoing the concerns of August Wilson, “that color is the least consequential or least significant element when evaluated alongside age, physical ability, and gender and that, as a result, it can be ignored or overlooked” (57). Young advocates for color-conscious casting practices to create both new opportunities for actors of color and new interpretations of canonical texts. Postrace theatre, he argues, is “rooted in discussions of ‘post-black’ culture” (64), a claim that allows him to end the volume with discussion of two contemporary African American playwrights, Thomas Bradshaw and Branden Jacobs-Jenkins, who present black identity through cultural products unmoored from essentializing, racist metrics. “The utility of the post-black concept,” Young writes, “is that it redefines race not as something that is biologically based or an essentialized state of being but rather as a production, a becoming, that is always in process” (67). I love this quote; Young distills the idea of postrace while advocating for the centrality of performance in our cultural moment.
Like the rest of the Theatre& series, Theatre & Race is a worthwhile text for classroom use, especially given the price, length, and clarity of writing. Though most directly applicable to courses in black studies or African American performance, I'm sure the volume will find a place on many different syllabi at the undergraduate, and even graduate, level.
