In Who Cares? sociologist Katherine Newman and policy analyst Elisabeth Jacobs argue that public attitudes toward government assistance to the poor and disadvantaged have been remarkably consistent since the 1930s, despite the shifting ideological balance in American politics. Using analysis of public opinion polls from the 1930s through the 2000s, letters written by members of the public to the president and administration officials during the presidencies of Franklin D. Roosevelt, Lyndon Johnson, and Richard Nixon, and various secondary sources, the authors document the public's enduring reservations and qualified support for government efforts to help the less fortunate. In doing so, Newman and Jacobs seek to dispel several myths promoted by popular commentators, if not widely held by scholars. The first is the belief that the New Deal and Great Society were a response to the public's embrace of an expansive welfare state—a belief that they suggest has been fostered by the nostalgia of present-day progressives for a golden age of generosity to the poor and faith in government that never existed. The second is the belief that the conservative electoral victories from Ronald Reagan to George W. Bush reflected the public's desire to roll back the welfare state. The authors argue that conservatives were not responding to public opinion, but trying “to create an ardor for dismantling government” (p. 9).
The book's chapters are organized around three eras—the New Deal, the Great Society plus Nixon's subsequent efforts to pass a guaranteed minimum income, and the “new gilded age” of rising inequality over the last three decades. Newman and Jacobs find that throughout these periods, a significant percentage of Americans has been concerned that antipoverty programs fed dependence and undermined the work ethic. However, public opinion has also consistently reflected support for assistance to the deserving poor and for programs emphasizing work over cash relief. In their discussion of the New Deal period, they document the sizable portion of poll respondents who supported cuts in relief over the course of the Great Depression, but also supported assistance to the elderly and provision of public jobs, though with lower wages and fewer protections than private-sector employment. They show that during the Great Society period, support for medical care for the aged and for education was considerably higher than support for War on Poverty programs, which declined in popularity as they came to be viewed as rewarding the undeserving, particularly among minorities, in a climate of heightened racial tension. Nixon's failed Family Assistance Plan of income subsidies was unpopular from the start. In their analysis of public opinion in the new gilded age, Newman and Jacobs emphasize data reflecting public support for equal opportunity over equal outcomes, but also a growing public unease with rising levels of inequality and increasing support for a government safety net.
Newman and Jacobs are not primarily scholars of public opinion and most of their observations in this area echo the work of others. For example, they reconcile conflicting findings of the erosion of support for the welfare state over the course of the twentieth century and of the stability of attitudes toward a government safety net by noting that the public tends to oppose specific welfare programs, primarily Aid to Families with Dependent Children, but to value a “social compact between American citizens and the government” (p. 141). This analysis is fairly widely accepted in the literature on public opinion. However, Who Cares? makes a contribution by providing a concise history of the interplay between the development of antipoverty policy initiatives and public opinion since the New Deal and by demonstrating consistent themes in attitudes toward the welfare state. A 1935 letter from a Pennsylvanian to FDR observed that “‘The forgotten man … is NOT the shiftless, indifferent individual, who believes the world owe him a living (and is now getting it). The forgotten man in your administration is the thrifty middle class who have striven to make this country worth living in—whom you are striving to wipe out of existence’” (pp. 18–19). It might well have been addressed to President Barack Obama from a Tea Party supporter.
The book does not explicitly engage much of the political science scholarship on the amount of influence that public sentiment has or should have on politicians' decisions, but it contributes to the debate by providing considerable evidence that presidents have pursued policies dealing with poverty and inequality in the face of public indifference or outright opposition. Newman and Jacobs argue that the “essence of leadership is not registering the popular will and transforming it into policy but setting a course and sticking to one's guns in the face of growing resistance. This … is the real story of the New Deal, the Great Society, and the conservative triumph in the age of inequality” (p. 10). They note that support for programs like Medicare actually declined as Congress came closer to passing them. It would be useful if the authors used such shifts to explore the malleability of public opinion and the difficulty of using polls to gauge complex attitudes. Does public support for policy options decline because underlying attitudes actually change? Because opponents' efforts to discredit these policies increase in intensity as these policies gain legislative support? Or because the public is turned off by the sausage making of the legislative process? And why does the public eventually come to support these programs after they are established? In any case, Newman and Jacobs provide a useful reminder that polls once reflected tentative and qualified support for policies that subsequently became widely accepted.
Who Cares? was released just as congressional consideration of President Obama's health-care reform initiative was coming to a close in 2010 and it was largely written before most of that struggle unfolded. The authors conclude the book by urging President Obama “to move quickly and decisively to enact his most ambitious plans as early in his tenure as possible” and by emphasizing that Presidents Roosevelt, Johnson, and even Nixon “paid little political price” for proposing bold policies “well beyond what the public felt comfortable with” (p. 166). As with Medicare, public support for health-care reform declined as the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) neared passage. Should it survive a Supreme Court challenge, PPACA may also become a popular and accepted component of the welfare state with the passage of time. We will know much sooner whether President Obama will pay a political price at the polls.
