The Questionnaire de sociologie et d'ethnographie published by the société d'anthropologie following its meeting on 21 June 1883 contains a section devoted to the vie sensitive. The questionnaire was intended to provide travellers and explorers with a field guide to facilitate the compilation of a complete ethnographic record of questions considered common to all human activity. In the section on the senses, the questionnaire recorded the response given by ‘primitive peoples’ regarding stimulation of the five senses: touch, taste, smell, hearing and sight. The aim was to collect ‘objective’ data to demonstrate that cultural differences in sensory perception were due to different levels of development in the areas of the brain that govern the five senses. The anthropometric results were thus used to create a hierarchical racial and social classification in which primitive peoples, peasants and hysterical women were attributed various kinds of deficiency in sensory perception. In line with this trend towards an evolutionary interpretation of history, ancient civilisations were also thought to have presented deficiencies in sensory perception, to the point of claiming that the ancient Greeks only distinguished between light and dark colours, as argued in studies by Gladstone (1858) and Schultz (1904).
More than a hundred years later, the senses are receiving renewed research attention. However, far from considering that those in the ancient world suffered a kind of chronic colour blindness, new studies have revealed a sophisticated sensory world that surpassed the limitations of the five senses. Senses of the Empire forms part of this new trend. As Betts explains in the introduction (1–12), the title of the book takes its inspiration from one of the foundational works in sensory studies, D. Howes (ed.), Empire of the Senses (2005). B. also highlights the impact on Classical studies of Yannis Hamilakis’ theories about an archaeology of the senses. In line with Howes’ concept of sensory emplacement and the postulates of sensory archaeologies, B. establishes an equation between the body as recipient of sensory stimuli, objects as emitters of sensory information and places, whose physiognomies also generate sensory stimuli that are perceived and processed differently according to the type of individual frequenting them. In addition, consideration is given to each individual's distinctive capacity to perceive, interpret or process sensory experiences according to his or her physiology, age, sex and social condition; the utility of activating the senses to create collective and individual memories; and the different emotional, social or intellectual responses that can be aroused by sensory stimuli. In one form or another, most of the contributions explore these premises.
A first group of chapters (chs 1, 4 and 5) aims at reconstructing different aspects of the Roman sensory ecosystem. Jeffrey Veitch (ch. 4) proposes a methodology for applying the postulates of ‘aural architecture’ to Roman archaeology. Thus, he analyses the acoustic properties of several buildings on the Portico di Pio IX in Ostia, considering the type of construction materials used and the size or decor of the rooms, which would determine the manner in which sound was reflected and propagated. He also includes other parameters, such as an estimate of mean population density in the street or noise variations according to types of activity throughout the day, and suggests that passers-by may have used ‘echolocation’ to orientate themselves in the city. Thomas J. Derrick (ch. 5) maps the olfactory landscape at Vindolanda based on the type of activities carried out in the vicus and the weather there (in particular, the prevailing winds, which would have exerted a strong influence on the spread of smells inside and outside the vicus), distinguishing between ‘macro smell environments’ (e.g. industrial areas, stables and barracks) and ‘micro smell environments’ (e.g. the interior of temples, baths, barracks and the praetorium). According to his reconstruction of Vindolanda's olfactory landscape, buildings used for administrative purposes and, in general, places frequented by high-ranking men were located in areas unaffected by the smells emanating from industrial areas and stables. He concludes that it is at the microenvironmental level where an individual's capacity to influence the surrounding olfactory landscape can best be analysed.
A second group of chapters (chs 2, 9 and 12) focuses on sensory stimulation. Jo Day (ch. 12) examines the sparsiones and missilia scattered in theatres and amphitheatres as an example of the tactical use of artefacts to heighten the audience's emotional response to the spectacle's patrons, who spared no expense to impress the crowd. Eleanor Betts (ch. 2) analyses literary and epigraphic testimonials which serve as descriptors of sensory experiences, examines the capacity of objects to stimulate each individual's senses differently depending on variables such as age, social status, emotional state or sex, and explores aspects such as the artefact's location or the moment when an individual interacts with it. Of particular interest is her use of the concept of ‘sense loci’, defined as ‘an object (or objects) and its (or their) sensory properties, bounded in space but usually habituated so as not to dominate the consciousness of the perceiver’ (28).
A third and final group of papers (chs 3, 6–8 and 10–11) addresses sensory perception. Miko Flohr (ch. 3) questions the widespread idea that the fullonicae were foul-smelling places. Whereas traditional historiography has described these workshops in exclusively olfactory terms, Flohr offers a more nuanced interpretation that also includes sight, sound and touch. His main contribution, however, is to differentiate between the sensory perception of sporadic passers-by and that of individuals regularly involved in the daily life of the workshop, and to assess the impact of the fullonicae according to their size and location in the city. From this perspective, in comparison with other workshops or businesses, the fullonicae did not have such a negative image as has been assumed. Alexandre Vincent (ch. 10) advocates a methodology that combines literary description of the senses (providing an idea of how these were perceived) with the objective information that can be extracted from the archaeological evidence. To illustrate his proposal, he combines a lexicographical study of the term tuba (which yields an emic perception of the sound the instrument emits) with the archaeological information obtained from sound emission studies conducted with a tuba discovered in 1861 in Neuvy-en-Sullias (Loiret, France). Helen Slaney (ch. 11) analyses dance (orchēsis) in Rome from the perspective of the actors. This enables her to include kinaesthesia and proprioception (movement, orientation, balance, effort) among her analytical tools. Slaney describes the social pressure to which mimics would have been subjected, suggests that the terms used to describe them would have affected their postural control and stresses the mimics’ capacity to adapt their bodies to the different roles represented, including imitation of elements such as fire and water or of the character of an animal.
Senses of the Empire is undoubtedly destined to become an essential work of reference in the new trend of Sense Studies in Ancient History. However, the quality of the essays is uneven. Ray Laurence's chapter (ch. 1) on sound in the city of Rome is excessively general, and he fails to consider relevant studies by Maurizio Bettini, Christophe Vendries, Sylvie Pittie and Maria Teresa Schettino. Given the breadth and problematic nature of the question, Candace Weddle's chapter (ch. 7) on the role of touch and taste in Greco-Roman sacrifice is also unsatisfactorily reductionist. The authors could have made more explicit use of the heuristic categories proposed in Howes’ Empire of the Senses, such as the concepts of hyperaesthesia (exploitation of the senses for mercantile ends) or dystoposthesia (‘a descriptor of the sensory experience of those who suffer the effects of environmental sensitivities’ (380)). Nevertheless, these reservations in no way detract from the success of the book in paving the way for future research in the field of sensory studies in the Classical world.
