1914 saw the publication of G. L. Cheesman's The Auxilia of the Roman Imperial Army, frequently held up as the foundational study of the auxilia (the first monographic synthesis, which built on the fundamental work of Cichorius, Domaszewski and Mommsen). The organisers of the regular Lyon conference on the Roman army (the seventh, in 2018, was dedicated to ‘corps du chef et gardes du corps dans l'armée romaine’) chose to mark the centenary by dedicating the conference to this theme. Some 28 scholars participated, and 27 contributions (some absent, some additional) are presented in this substantial volume. The organisers are to be commended for managing to bring such an event to publication (never an easy task), and doubly so for making the effort to equip it with detailed indexes of primary sources and of military units (although the focus implied by such indexes is a point to which I return below).
In his brief introduction, Patrice Faure rapidly sketches the historiography of auxiliary studies, and sets out the organisers’ aims. Several tensions emerge, which form the basis for this review. The first is the laudable aim to extend discussion of the auxilia beyond the traditional confines (established by Cheesman) of the period between Augustus and the early third century a.d. However, in pushing the study of the subject back into the republican period and on into Late Antiquity, the very serious question is raised of what auxiliaries actually are, and hence what the subject of study might be. This is rather easy, if all one means is the alae and cohortes of the army of the Principate, so lovingly catalogued by Cichorius, Spaul and others (the organisers regretfully recognised that revision of this work was beyond the conference's scope) — even if the growing recognition of the presence of citizens within these units has steadily complicated matters, alongside the long-running debate about coherence of ethnicity in units and sources of recruitment over time. When considering the republican army, there is much uncertainty as to where to draw the line between mercenaries, non-Italian allies and auxiliaries, or the Italian socii; and once one moves into the later Empire, the proliferation of overlapping new categories (numeri, limitanei, foederati, etc.), universal citizenship and the gradual transformation of military structures make comparison almost impossible. On this fundamental question of definitions, Faure simply refers the reader to the rich discussion of Jean-Michel Carrié (447–89), which confronts the late antique problems head-on (Michael A. Speidel's thoughtful questioning of the consensus on Augustan military reform is the other exception, especially 82). Otherwise, the challenge is largely ignored, and for most contributions all that is meant are the traditional alae and cohortes. Be that as it may, the most coherent, substantive and potentially valuable section of this whole volume lies in the three major papers by Jean-Michel Carrié, Maxime Petitjean and Guillaume Sartor in the final section (occupying 130 pages). Between them, they trace the nature of auxiliaries, cavalry and foederati in the Roman army from the late third century onwards (arbitrarily, I single out the attempt by Carrié on 468–70 to survey the overall patterns of non-legionary units in this period, east and west).
A second tension is the inevitable one to which almost all conference volumes are prone — that between organisers’ aims and contributors’ interests. Faure notes that few of the contributors obliged with syntheses (Le Bohec's brief introduction retreads ground covered by Faure, but less effectively), and these are not always worthwhile (Giovanni Brizzi on the Republic is tradition personified, referencing standard pre-1980 scholarship). Patrick Le Roux missed the conference and here contributes a paper that has nothing to say about auxiliaries at all, but offers thoughts on the emperor's relationship to warfare. Besides the late antique section already noted, Werner Eck's summary of the contribution of the constantly increasing evidence of military diplomata is perhaps most useful. In general contributions are of remarkably varied length and focus, ranging from Pierre Cosme's thoughtful 7-page consideration of what was archive-worthy in the administration of auxiliary cavalry, to Everett Wheeler's self-indulgent, digression-laden 52-page discussion of Parthian auxiliaries, which ends abruptly and is only the first half of a study that continues in HiMA 5 (2017) (did the editors lose patience?). As Petitjean notes (492), preconceptions on the Roman army are very long-lived (think Marius) — the most stimulating among several revisionist pieces is François Cadiou's persuasive attempt to argue against the long-held assumption that citizen cavalry ceased to exist after 91 b.c., with obvious implications for several current readings of late republican society and politics (Cadiou and Petitjean's papers on republican and late antique cavalry form a valuable pair). If there is one thematic as a whole to be drawn from the volume, it is the repeated recognition that continuities of practice are more prevalent than have often been assumed, often concealed by changes in terminology or excessive emphasis upon traditional moments of rupture in imperial history. The majority of contributions are, however, traditional studies of units, regions or categories (I single out François Bérard's careful study of the units serving as garrisons in provinces without legions), and this brings me to a final point of tension.
The preceding year saw the publication of Ian Haynes’ Blood of the Provinces: The Roman Auxilia and the Making of Provincial Society from Augustus to the Severans (2013). A comparison between the volumes is instructive, especially given the organisers’ desire to open an ‘aperçu de la varieté et du dynamisme des recherches en cours’ (disclaimer: both Haynes and I myself participated at the — excellent — conference, although both of us, for different reasons, were ultimately unable to contribute to the volume). In his introduction Faure notes the rise in the 1980s of new historiographical approaches, as a prelude to marking the significant contribution of Haynes’ book, which engaged with a wide range of material culture and social history in an attempt to write a rather different account of auxiliaries within the Empire. Faure, in line with the reviews by several contributors to this volume (Petitjean and Wheeler) expresses caution regarding ‘les “nouvelles” approaches’ (17: the scare quotes are curious). That caution is reflected in the fact that archaeology, material culture and social history are almost totally absent from this volume (a couple of iconographic studies aside), and beyond the extension of chronological range, any novelty here primarily lies in the accrual of new epigraphic evidence, or the challenging of old assumptions. Dare one note that out of 27 contributions, only 4.5 are by women (including both the iconographic studies) and none of them are over 13 pages? To judge by this volume, which by its chronological range, bibliography and indexes, will occupy a significant place in future work, traditional auxiliary studies are thriving; but this is surely only half the story, and it is apparent that in this sphere at least, the traditional disconnect between literary/epigraphic scholarship and archaeology remains as strong as ever, as do certain stereotypes about military history.
