A historian of humanitarianism must unravel many knots.
The history of global humanitarianism – the organised, institutionalised expression of caring for distant others across borders, guided by principles of humanity, impartiality and neutrality – is an entangled history par excellence.Footnote 1 Humanitarian work mediated connections between people across the world, linking the histories of disparate populations. Historians must grapple with the blend of stimuli – altruistic, pragmatic and cynical – that motivated humanitarian work, which was both deeply idealistic and grounded in the imperfections of its time and place. They must evaluate how relief organisations aspired to neutrality and impartiality in a world of empires and nation-states and how the practices of global humanitarianism were shaped by, and in turn shaped, processes like imperialism, decolonisation, war and state-building. Unsurprisingly, these entanglements present certain methodological challenges. Perhaps most notably, the voices of those the humanitarians served rarely surface in institutional archives, creating deep lacunae. These problems are of course not unique. Reading against the grain to recover agency of specific groups is a common practice, disentangling complex motivations a key task of the historian and finding oneself caught in snarled threads a common occupational hazard.
Nevertheless, the relative youth of humanitarian history as a field allows its practitioners to experiment with novel ways of negotiating these conceptual and methodological challenges. They do so within a generally agreed-upon chronology of global humanitarianism that begins in the eighteenth century, when developments such as Enlightenment thought, the growth of capitalism and renewed religious feelings fostered a ‘revolution in moral sentiments and the emergence of a culture of compassion’.Footnote 2 The slave trade was an obvious target for those who wished to mobilise their compassion to affect change, as was violence in the Ottoman Empire later in the nineteenth century.Footnote 3 The carnage following the First World War, with its shattered empires and massive population displacements, catalysed both an explosion of humanitarian activity and the development of modern humanitarianism, defined in part by increasing professionalisation, secularisation, scientisation and Americanisation. These trends continued and intensified following the Second World War, when the expanding non-governmental organisation sector emerged to play a significant role in international governance.
The five works under review align with this periodisation and identify the inter-war period as an important one for the development of both the organisations they discuss and the aid sector more broadly. As Czechoslovakian president Tomáś G. Masaryk famously proclaimed, Europe following the First World War was a ‘a laboratory atop a mass graveyard’ and therefore an ideal site for both humanitarian experiments and historians’ attempts to understand them.Footnote 4 They reveal the elusiveness and fluidity of neutrality as a concept and illuminate how deeply seemingly neutral aid organisations were implicated in the ambitions of their national governments. This latter point allows us to appreciate how relief organisations served as mediators between different peoples and nations, a move that opens new ways of understanding international relations and connections between peoples. Methodologically, they grapple with new ways of making visible those who have previously been invisible or objectified in humanitarian archives, such as women, children and communities served by aid groups. Lastly, these books illustrate the extent to which history of humanitarianism provides, as per Daniel Maul, ‘an indicator and entry point for broader developments within twentieth-century history’.Footnote 5 That history, and the histories told by these books, were deeply entangled ones; through the lens of humanitarianism history, we can see how disparate forces – nationalism and internationalism; altruism and empire; American ambition and universal values – intertwined tightly during this important moment of destruction and rebuilding.
Emily Baughan’s monograph fully embraces the entangled nature of its subject, the venerable British aid organisation Save the Children (or Save the Children Fund; SCF) and traces the group’s evolution from a protest movement against the Allied blockade of Germany during the First World War to a humanitarian giant. The SCF quickly lost its radical edge as it institutionalised, professionalised and increasingly and intentionally aligned with the interests of the British government. This last process drives much of Baughan’s analysis: as it became part of the British establishment, SCF oriented its programming to create conditions favourable to British imperial and post-imperial rule, which, she argues, fundamentally compromised the moral thrust and transformational potential of the organisation’s work. Saving the Children thus uses an institutional history to chronicle the larger processes in which the organisation was implicated, specifically Britain’s changing role in the world and the construction of a particular strain of inter-war liberal internationalism.
Via its work directly with children and through its leadership of the Save the Children International Union (SCIU), Save the Children, Baughan argues, propagated a style of humanitarianism shaped by and advancing imperial biopolitics. Even actions seemingly grounded in discourses of individual rights, such as the Geneva Declaration on the Rights of the Child, which was drafted by SCF founder Eglantyne Jebb and adopted by the League of Nations in 1924, rested on biopolitical concerns about the future economic productivity of the children in question. Much of SCF’s programming pursued these goals with little regard for the wishes of the children or their family structures. For example, one of its favourite strategies for providing services was to separate children from their families in orphanages or other institutions. Baughan argues that this was a pragmatic decision that quickly became an ideological preference. Here, and at a few other points, the book’s arguments would have been strengthened by a bit more elaboration on the analysis and evidence that supports this claim; practical, altruistic and cynical motivations were tightly braided in humanitarian decision-making, and seeing Baughan’s reasoning as she unravelled these motives would have been instructive.
For Baughan, humanitarianism was a ‘set of practices that expose political visions’, and her book advances this understanding as it explores multiple episodes in the SCF’s work across the British empire.Footnote 6 In the inter-war period, when European colonialism attracted new scrutiny, the SCF became more tightly aligned with Britain’s domestic and foreign policy interests. The Great Depression marked an important moment in this relationship; during the Slump, SCF grew closer to the government to secure funding and advance its vision of the emerging welfare state. This orientation with a government vigorously pursuing its policy of appeasement, alongside its hesitancy to upset its SCIU allies in Germany, kept the organisation from criticising the Third Reich during the 1930s and therefore from participating in pre-war rescue schemes for Jewish children, such as the Kindertransport. After the Second World War, the SCF responded to the decline of the British Empire as well as the new American dominance of aid by focusing more narrowly on the empire’s decolonising nations. Rather than uphold formal empire, SCF transitioned into preserving informal forms of British dominance through its programming. The book’s most interesting chapters discuss the group’s post-war work in Kenya, Malaya and Somaliland, where its new focus on juvenile delinquency targeted local youths, many of whom had engaged in anti-colonial activity. The most compromised moment of the SCF’s work in this era was undoubtedly its camps for Kenyan youths during the Mau Mau rebellion, which straddled the line between reformatories and internment camps. In these camps, SCF replicated colonial discipline in the most literal sense.
As befits the nature of her arguments, Baughan acknowledges the silences within the SCF’s archives, especially in terms of the voices of those it served as well as the local staff it employed. To overcome these gaps, she incorporates acts of resistance by the local populations who interacted with the SCF, both against the organisation itself as well as the British hegemony it represented. The book most successfully foregrounds the frequently overlooked experiences of local humanitarian collaborators by exploring the work of a Caribbean social worker and a Nigerian nurse affiliated with Save the Children. After studying at British universities, both women returned home to work with and advocate for the populations they served in ways that the frequently white and male humanitarian officials could not. Overall, Saving the Children demonstrates how humanitarianism can provide an entry point to larger discussions about empire and decolonisation; by following the stories of these two women, among other local collaborators or recipients of humanitarian relief, it also demonstrates one pathway to incorporating voices frequently muffled in humanitarian archives.
Saving the Children takes a generally dim view of the nature and meaning of its titular organisation’s work; for Baughan, the degree to which the organisation was imbricated in Britain’s imperial and biopolitical ambitions overshadows the moral and ethical good it undoubtedly has accomplished over its long life. This more critical approach allows her to make her insightful claims about the intersection of humanitarian imperialism and liberal internationalism, and unrelenting praise rarely makes for a compelling or important academic monograph. At the same time, she is clearly invested in the organisation’s work and its potential to do good in the world. Her conclusion stirringly calls for the organisation and the aid sector in general to decolonise their work by, among other reforms, involving local communities in decision-making and challenging rather than upholding inequitable global structures. Similarly, she calls on practitioners of the still-Eurocentric humanitarianism history to adopt a more expansive view of humanitarianism that incorporates practices and perspectives from other regions and peoples. Saving the Children therefore suggests that writing a more well-balanced and ethical account of humanitarian activity involves deeper entanglement with non-European histories and modes of caretaking. Despite the wisdom of Baughan’s recommendations and the power of her driving central argument, Saving the Children would have been even stronger if it had engaged more with the life-saving and life-improving, if often ephemeral and flawed, work accomplished by the group. Doing so would not have dulled the sharpness of her critiques; rather, it would have enhanced them by further demonstrating the moral compromise at the heart of so much humanitarian work and the entanglement of altruism, cynicism and ambition that defines it.
Like Saving the Children, Daniel Maul’s The Politics of Neutrality traces the history of a single relief organisation, the American Friends Service Committee (AFSC), although it focuses tightly on the group’s first twenty-five years in order to problematise the value of neutrality. According to Maul, two central tensions drove the organisation’s early development. Inspired by its religious heritage, the AFSC maintained a universalist vision for its work; at the same time, as the group grew more closely aligned with their American context and the American government, it grew in prominence, which facilitated its work abroad. Similarly, the group sought to determine how to best provide aid according to increasingly professionalised standards while still maintaining a distinct profile grounded in their religious values. The AFSC was, perhaps, an unlikely organisation to emerge as an aid giant. The Quakers, or Society of Friends, totalled approximately 250,000 members worldwide at the beginning of the twentieth century.Footnote 7 Despite their small number, they had played an outsized role in American history; befitting their origins as a Dissenting sect, the Quakers were perennial pacificists and reformers, often with a radical edge, especially around slavery. Suspicious of American imperialism and active in the broader peace movement, they did not join other American Protestants in the missionary-driven humanitarian activity that complemented formal American imperial expansion in the latter quarter of the nineteenth century.
Whereas Save the Children began as a radical affront to British conduct in the First World War, the AFSC emerged as a means to reconcile American Quakers with the war effort and, in a context of theological fracturing, with each other. Founded by a small group of leading Quakers upon America’s entry into the war, the AFSC provided a means for pacifist young men to demonstrate their patriotism and various Quaker communities to coalesce around a shared venture. From its inception, the committee debated to what extent it viewed itself as representing the United States abroad. At home, it clearly marketed itself as patriotic and representative of American values, broadly defined; an AFSC pamphlet instructed Quaker women, when sewing clothes for French civilians during the First World War, to ask of each garment, ‘Is it worthy of America?’Footnote 8 During the 1930s and 1940s, organisation leadership collaborated with Eleanor Roosevelt on several domestic projects and enjoyed access to her husband’s White House. In addition, during the Spanish Civil War, the AFSC emerged as the unofficial representative of the United States in the conflict. Maul’s book, like Baughan’s but more dispassionately, demonstrates how humanitarian organisations, including those that espoused universalist values, could become entangled with the interests of their national governments. Unlike Baughan, Maul does not view the alignment of the AFSC with its national government as inherently compromising, instead acknowledging that such a relationship enabled the group’s work.
From the very moment of its inception, the group walked the first of many tightropes, as it attempted to sell the service of conscientious objectors as patriotic to a sceptical and bellicose American public. It developed a sophisticated public relations operation that marketed its work to different stakeholders across different registers, and in doing so helped craft a particularly Quaker vision of neutrality that contained contradictions without being constrained by them. Via its 1917–18 work in France, an Allied country, the committee could demonstrate that its pacifism did not mean that it was opposed to the American war effort.Footnote 9 Within Quaker circles, the organisation emphasised its spiritual roots and its goal of reconciling warring nations – it also worked in vanquished Germany and revolutionary Russia – and among themselves AFSC members pondered the nature and meaning of their work. All these contradictory elements were subsumed by a bespoke definition of neutrality, which emphasised its technical expertise, apolitical neutrality and desire to help, regardless of the identity of the recipient. In Quaker hands, neutrality – that lodestar of humanitarianism – was a strategic and elastic notion, as well as a genuinely held one.
This form of neutrality raised the organisation’s international profile and allowed it access to the most politically sensitive and volatile spaces in inter-war Europe. It was the most in flux in the group’s work during the Spanish Civil War, during which it provided relief in both the Nationalist and Republican zones. As the course of the war changed and domestic sentiment in the United States shifted, the AFSC negotiated and renegotiated its concept of neutrality and used it as a tool with Spanish and American stakeholders. The book’s final chapter rushes through the group’s work during the Second World War, which ranged from southern France to China. Maul’s decision to treat the conflict as a bookend makes sense given his emphasis on the importance of the inter-war as a crucible of humanitarian development; nevertheless, the AFSC was quite active abroad and at home during the war, and a more robust elaboration of the book’s themes via an exploration of the group’s wartime work could fill several more fascinating chapters.
Maul makes a convincing case for both the utility and flexibility of the concept of neutrality, even if – or perhaps because – it feels a bit more amorphous at times. The organisation prided itself on distributing aid without regard for the recipient’s nationality or creed. Still, as he recounts, the AFSC exhibited a certain ambivalence in its relationships with its Jewish recipients. In its operations in inter-war Soviet Belarus, it hesitated to focus its efforts on the country’s large Jewish populations, and when it agreed to distribute resources on behalf of the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee (JDC, or the Joint), it only did so under the agreement that it would distribute aid to Jews and non-Jews alike. During the refugee crisis of the 1930s, the AFSC concentrated its efforts on ‘non-Aryan’ Christians instead of practicing Jews to avoiding duplicating the efforts of Jewish groups.Footnote 10 While these practical explanations for why the AFSC declined to target Jewish populations ring true, further exploring the attitude of the AFSC towards Jews perhaps would have deepened the study’s argument about the fluid nature of neutrality, and its twin, impartiality, as well as how easily different motivations could entangle in humanitarian action. Were the leaders of the AFSC, who tended to be New Dealers who abhorred Jim Crow racism, blinded by the faults in their liberal imagination to the extent that they were hesitant to engage with the particularity of specific groups?Footnote 11 Were they, at times, swayed by some form of antisemitism? Or, as is more likely, were these seemingly contradictory impulses entwined?
Grounded in Quaker archival holdings, The Politics of Service is a straightforward institutional history. While it acknowledges the usefulness of humanitarian history as an ‘entry point for broader developments within the twentieth century’, its focus is more inward, on elaborating how the group perceived itself and developed its identity.Footnote 12 Likewise, it does not strain to innovate methodologically or to excavate the voices of those the Quakers helped. Nevertheless, it is an excellent, well-researched contribution to the history of this aid organisation, and it is a reminder of the utility of problematising the categories, such as neutrality, on which the field of humanitarian history rests.
The AFSC and Save the Children established themselves as enduring relief organisations. Other groups that emerged or gained prominence during and after the First World War were more ephemeral but, as Emmanuel Destenay illustrates, no less important for our understanding of inter-war humanitarianism. His book America’s French Orphans traces the work of several Franco-American humanitarian organisations that cared for needy children in France during and after the First World War. It also reveals the extensive and active roles women and children on both sides of the Atlantic played in constructing Franco-American relations and new modes of humanitarianism, inviting us to reflect on how humanitarian history offers news way of understanding how ordinary people performed international relations.
Founded by a small group of long-time American residents of Paris during the early days of the war, the Committee Franco-American for the Protection of the Children of the Frontier (CFAPCF) housed 1,557 children in twenty-nine colonies.Footnote 13 Often operating in conjunction with various religious orders in borrowed or leased buildings across the country, the CFAPCF colonies cared for children from occupied France and Belgium orphaned, traumatised or injured by the war. American donors contributed $72 a year for each child’s upkeep, which included food, shelter, education, medical care and nurturance designed to bind emotional wounds of war.Footnote 14 A constellation of women on both sides of the Atlantic collaborated to ensure the children’s care. After the war, several other organisations, such as the American Committee of Devastated France and the American and French Children’s League, emerged to undertake various rebuilding and rehabilitative activities directed towards children in parts of France that had been occupied by Germany during the war.
Arguably the most important organisation in Destenay’s monograph, and certainly the most interesting, was the Fatherless Children of France Society (FCFS). The FCFS operated on a very different model than that of the CFAPCF: whereas the latter offered intensive, residential care for a necessarily small number of war-affected children, the former provided cash aid to the widowed mothers of French children affected by the war. At only $36.50 a year per child, the FCFS model of child sponsorship was less expensive than the residential care offered by the CFAPCF, and it offered more personal connections between the French children and their American benefactors. Sponsors could specify the gender, age and location of the child or children they wished to sponsor. The American sponsors and French sponsored, or their mothers, could correspond, thus creating a network of transatlantic goodwill and affective bonds that acquired multiple meanings. This phenomenon was brief but not insubstantial; between 1915 and 1922, the group facilitated American support of more than 300,000 French children.
The adoption model utilised by the FCFS permitted more than just the exchange of pleasantries; instead, as Destenay argues, it contributed to a new form of American humanitarianism that extensively mobilised both women and children and decoupled humanitarian relief from political neutrality. During the war, the FCFS collaborated with over 200 local chapters across the United States to fundraise and assign needy children to adopters.Footnote 15 While the organisation had elite leadership, its cause appealed to donors of all classes. Women performed much of the yeoman’s work necessary to run such a massive enterprise, and children also actively participated: American children publicised the cause and donated from their piggy banks, and French children advocated for themselves and their families in their letters to their American benefactors. Destenay argues that the FCFS was the first humanitarian organisation to appeal to the middle and working classes as well as the wealthy.Footnote 16 While Baughan may dispute this characterisation – Save the Children appealed to a wide range of Britons, despite its elite origins and orientation – the diverse and wide-ranging engagement with FCFS’s mission reveals a democratisation of global humanitarianism. Here perhaps Destenay undersells the interpretative implications of the story he tells; while the FCFS’s child sponsorship model was not novel, every time a woman or child sat down to write a letter that would be sent over the Atlantic, they were, in a sense, doing foreign policy – or at least international relations – at home.Footnote 17
More than goodwill or sentiment inspired so many Americans to care for these faraway children; American altruism was intertwined with biopolitical and nationalist concerns. Many of the children had mothers and sometimes fathers who were still alive; nevertheless, these children were often referred to as ‘orphans’ or ‘fatherless’. Both appellations suggested the threat of poverty and degeneracy and the need for paternal or paternalistic intervention. Adopting French children allowed Americans to symbolically assume responsibility for the future of France. While the FCFS operated independently of either government, it was hardly politically neutral. Prior to America’s entry into the war in 1917, the FCFS allowed Americans an opportunity to circumvent their government’s neutrality by supporting France; after America’s entry into the war, it reinforced the country’s commitment to its beleaguered ally.Footnote 18 Nationalism, biopolitical anxieties and shifting political values were the threads with which FCFS permanently knit together wartime histories of America and France, as ‘children’s fate in wartime directly moved the hearts of foreign populations’ – and moved into their hands.Footnote 19
Destenay’s monograph also poses important questions about the nature of humanitarian work and the methods of performing research on humanitarian history. The surviving letters, as well as other relevant records, were scattered across the United States, largely in private papers eventually donated to local archives. Most of the temporary organisations he discusses did not leave extant archives, necessitating an impressive feat of archival athleticism; for this book he drew on 100 archives across America and France. The ephemerality of his sources and the disparate, often amorphous source base reflect the difficulties in grasping the contours, extent and long-term effects of humanitarian work. Daniel Laqua likens humanitarianism to a cloud whose contours shift rapidly and can obscure the objectives, objects, motives and values contained therein.Footnote 20 Davide Rodogno uses a night-time fleet of taxis, each on a different itinerary, as his metaphor for humanitarianism, an analogy that suggests transience and movement and emphasises the often fleeting nature of humanitarian encounters.Footnote 21 Regardless of the metaphor deployed, ephemerality characterised relief work, and when discussing humanitarian activity it remains much easier to identify a starting point than an end point. Destenay’s story – of a meaningful and democratic mode of humanitarianism that impacted hundreds of thousands of lives and then disappeared into scraps in scores of local archives across the world – illustrates this.
All the works under review discuss organisations that were, to varying degrees, guided by universalist or internationalist values yet firmly embedded within their national context. In their books, which explore post-war state-building in Hungary and Romania, respectively, Friederike Kind-Kovács and Doina Anca Cretu most explicitly explore this seeming paradox, and both argue that, when viewed through the lens of the history of humanitarianism, these seemingly contradictory forces not only coexisted but also reinforced one another. There is a certain irony to Hungary and Romania being linked in this way; they fought on opposite sides of the First World War, and the post-war treaties awarded the latter huge swathes of the former’s territory. Both emerged from the war economically devastated, dependent on humanitarian relief and engaged in state-building processes: Hungary greatly diminished and Romanian greatly enlarged, each using foreign aid for their own purposes. Thus, when viewed in conjunction, both Kind-Kovács and Cretu’s books demonstrate how humanitarianism allows us to perceive the entanglement of internationalism and nationalism in new and edifying ways.
Each also explores the agency of aid recipients, although they take different approaches. Often the scholarly focus on humanitarian work centres on the humanitarians – their actions, their ideologies, their plans and dilemmas – and not on those the humanitarians helped. This latter group typically did not leave neat archives, and their interactions with and perspectives on the humanitarians are difficult to trace in humanitarian records. Despite these legitimate methodological challenges, an undue focus on the actions of the humanitarians threatens to flatten a historical rendering of their work, their milieu and the relationships between them and those they helped. Cretu’s book on American humanitarians in inter-war Romania, which she asserts is an ‘experiment in writing histories of foreign aid’, attempts to avoid this methodological trap by emphasising the extent to which inter-war Romanian state-builders actively and intentionally pursued and utilised American relief for their own ends.Footnote 22
At the end of the war, Romania annexed territories from the crumbling neighbouring empires, thus fulfilling the nationalist dream of a Greater Romania. At the same time, the war had wrought enormous destruction within Romania, with some estimating that the Old Kingdom has lost 14 per cent of its pre-war population.Footnote 23 Despite this devastation, Cretu forcefully asserts that Romania was not a blank slate for American humanitarians. She argues that the Romanians negotiated inherently asymmetrical relationships with agency and that examining how they did so reveals ‘the symbiotic relationship between nationalist visions of the state building and internationalist ambitions of foreign aid organisations’.Footnote 24 These entanglements – of nationalism and internationalism; of Romanian state-builders’ ambitions and American anxieties and aspirations; of the triumphalism of the new Romanian state and the reality of its desperate poverty – both shaped and reflected the conditions of American aid.
A range of American organisations, such as the American Red Cross, the JDC, and the American Relief Administration (ARA) participated in post-war reconstruction of Romania. Rather than attempting to comprehensively account for all the activities of these donors, the book proceeds thematically, with each of the four chapters discussing a different facet of the interface between American aid and Romanian state-building. The first chapter concerns how a variety of Romanian actors actively pursued American aid to advance their state-building agendas. The Americans’ initial foray into Romania during the war was brief and largely involved emergency food aid, but it foreshadowed the deluge of American aid to come after the war, as donors realised the potency of food aid to quell anxieties about the spread of Bolshevism and Romanian officials recognised that easing civilian suffering could advance their post-war state-building plans.Footnote 25
The second chapter discusses some of the aid targeted at children, which spanned a variety of forms, such as education and orphan care. Once again, Cretu emphasises Romanian agency around this aid by discussing how certain Romanian groups instrumentalised and essentially nationalised some of that aid for its own ends. The third chapter concerns the work of the JDC, which provided relief to Romania’s substantial Jewish population. Non-Jewish Romanians viewed this aid as especially suspicious. On the one hand, helping the Jews could, antisemites feared, increase the Bolshevist threat to the new country. On the other, by relieving the suffering of a large population, it could demonstrate the strength of the new state. The Joint’s aid efforts therefore had the potential to be both stabilising and destabilising; despite their antisemitic misgivings, the Romanian authorities permitted it because, on balance, they felt it stregnthened the nascent state. The premier expression of American Jewish internationalism ironically helped construct and lend legitimacy to an antiliberal government whose antisemitism would be almost unmatched in Europe over the next several decades.
The final chapter delves into ‘constructive aid’, or attempts to move beyond emergency aid and into proto-development activities. Much of this work centred around the production of scientific knowledge about health, statistics and sociology, which formed the core of the American vision of state-building and allowed the state to comprehend and therefore tailor its ‘social and ethnic fabric’.Footnote 26 Surprisingly, apart from the work of the Joint, which many in Romania interpreted in an antisemitic light, it does not appear that the Romanian state-builders engaged deeply with the American motivations – a desire to stem Bolshevik expansion, secure Romania as a trading partner and civilise East-Central Europe, all shot through with genuine benevolence – that spurred such help. Similarly, if the American humanitarian organisations had qualms with their aid contributing to the construction of a fundamentally illiberal state, they did not meaningfully impede it. Investigating more thoroughly how all the actors involved viewed each other’s intentions would have added another fascinating layer to this story without distracting from its emphasis on the primacy of Romanian agency.
Foreign Aid and State Building in Interwar Romania bursts with language – ‘symbiosis’, ‘embedded’, ‘transfer’ and so on – that implies partnerships of relative equality, a shared goal between donors and recipients and the entanglement of global aid with local processes. Cretu supports her approach with convincing examples of on-the-ground interactions between Romanian actors and their foreign benefactors that demonstrate how the former instrumentalised the largesse of the latter. Cretu’s study would have been even stronger if it had been more thoroughly situated in the broader context of relief work in Romania or perhaps the broader region to more fully understand the extent to which these interactions were representative or if they were extraordinary – and if the latter, why the Romanian case was so distinct. Regardless, Cretu’s methodological approach – of intentionally excavating and foregrounding the agency that Romanians exercised in their interactions with American humanitarians – is bold and refreshing. Still, many of those who interacted with and pursued American aid were from the middle and upper classes and were largely the facilitators of aid rather than its recipients, as Cretu acknowledges. The stories of the Romanian poor who most directly benefited from foreign relief remain submerged beneath the surface of the historical record. Still, Cretu’s study plants a marker regarding the possibility of foregrounding aid recipient agency in histories of humanitarianism and invites other scholars to consider how in their interactions with humanitarians, local communities exercised agency and advanced their own goals.
In her new study about international relief for children in post-war Budapest, Friederike Kind-Kovács is less laser-focused than Cretu on advancing a claim about recipient agency; instead, she takes a more holistic approach and describes the work of foreign humanitarian work in post-war Budapest in remarkably rich detail. Immediately after the First World War, Budapest, like Romania, was a humanitarian catastrophe; post-war treaties had dismembered the pre-war Kingdom of Hungary, and hundreds of thousands of ethnic Hungarians found themselves outside the country’s new borders. Many of them made their way to its capital city, which had already been buckling under the strains of war. In response, a deluge of western aid, spearheaded by the usual suspects of post–World War One international humanitarianism, such as the ARA, among others, poured into Budapest, which Kind-Kovács charts thematically over the course of an impressive nine chapters.
At the centre of this humanitarian hubbub were the children, who Kind-Kovács portrays as both the subjects and objects of historical change. Many of the biopolitical and class-based dynamics that characterised humanitarian work elsewhere after the war shaped their efforts in Budapest: many relief organisations focused their efforts on restoring middle-class children who had fallen into poverty, and many of the Hungarian institutions with whom they collaborated were led or otherwise spearheaded by upper- and middle-class women. Much of their relief was directed at the bodies of the children in what Kind-Kovács deems a ‘form of transnational biopolitical intervention’.Footnote 27 A great deal of energy and resources went into examining, measuring, managing, surveilling and altering the children’s physical forms, interventions that inevitably diminished parental authority and expanded the role of the state.
Publicity efforts on the part of the humanitarians, who circulated photographs of the physical degradation of the children, permitted their work to continue even if doing so raised a host of ethical issues. It publicised the terrible poverty in which the children lived as well as the efforts of the relief groups to ameliorate it. In her discussion of SCF relief during the Russian Civil War, Baughan criticises such publicity efforts for utilising a visual language that transformed children into objects, depoliticised the conditions that caused their suffering and visually stripped them of their familial relations.Footnote 28 Kind-Kovács does not disagree that photographing the suffering bodies of children or touring the slums in which many of them lived inherently objectified individual children. However, she argues that, in the hands of Hungarian nationalists and irredentists, depictions of child poverty served as evidence of the unfairness of the Treaty of Trianon and had the potential to inspire relief from abroad as well as perhaps international reconsideration of Hungary’s plight. Objectification therefore lent the children a sort of highly nationalistic agency, as, when mediated though the publicity documents of the relief organisations, they could potentially play an important role in advancing their country’s irredentist goals. This is an intriguing point, as it problematises what being an agentic actor of historical change can look like.
Per Kind-Kovács, this entanglement – of humanitarian relief for Hungarian children knotted with Hungary’s revanchist claims – formed one central interface between internationalism and nationalism in post-war Budapest. Another was the intersection between Hungarian nationalism, which attempted to portray the country as a victim, and American ambitions, which hoped to advance the country’s international standing through its relief work. The book’s most tightly organised and argued chapter explores this relationship in the context of material aid contributed by Americans, who intentionally associated their relief with the United States and its values. This was commonplace in inter-war humanitarianism, especially when the ARA was involved. Led by Herbert Hoover and marshalling both government and private funds, the ARA coordinated the activities of American relief organisations in post-war Europe; its work was both altruistic and political, as it hoped that, by alleviating suffering in Central-Eastern Europe, it could exercise American soft power and halt the advance of Bolshevism. As both Cretu and Kind-Kovács point out, Romanian and Hungarian recipients utilised this aid to stabilise and strengthen their illiberal governments. The medium of humanitarian action therefore absorbed and refracted disparate motivations, practices and politics, from the poverty of the slums of Budapest to the geopolitical calculations of an emerging superpower.
Kind-Kovács’s study is deeply researched and impressively detailed; its many striking and well-chosen images further enhance the text’s richness and illustrate both the pathos of post-war Budapest and the many attempts of international aid agencies to ameliorate the plight of the city’s children. An overreliance on direct quotes weighs down Budapest’s Children, as does, at times, the inclusion of so much historical detail. Unfortunately, some of this extraneous verbiage obscures the truly excellent connections that the book makes between the local and the global and between countries. A more thorough line edit would have cut through some of the brush, tightened the book’s argument and allowed its ideas to shine unimpeded.
Collectively, these five books suggest several intriguing paths forward for researchers of humanitarian history. They bring nuance to our understanding of women and children as actors in the story of inter-war international relations. Save the Children was founded and initially led by women, and Baughan argues that tracing the history’s organisation therefore allows us to ‘recover women’s political visions for the international order’.Footnote 29 The organisations discussed by Destenay – and the democratisation of international relations they spearheaded – were almost exclusively staffed by women and permitted women and children to exercise their own agency in their correspondence with each other. In Budapest and Romania, upper- and middle-class women worked alongside men to utilise foreign aid for humanitarian and nationalist purposes. As Kind-Kovács demonstrates, both American and Hungarian humanitarians transformed the suffering of the city’s children into a political force. Even organisations where women did not play a leadership role, such as the AFSC, reveal the importance of gender in understanding the history of humanitarianism. For the AFSC, the masculinisation of relief efforts was part of its process of professionalisation during and after the First World War; nevertheless, women played important, if not leadership, roles in AFSC work at home and abroad.Footnote 30 While the roles of women in humanitarian enterprises have already attracted scholarly attention, placing these books in conversation encourages scholars to broaden the analytical possibilities of engaging with issues of gender and humanitarianism and to focus their efforts on excavating the agency of child recipients of relief.Footnote 31
Lastly, even if not all the books under review directly problematise the concept of neutrality like Maul, they all engage with the inherently political nature of humanitarian aid, both during the inter-war period and after. Intentionally or not, and often in contradiction to their universalist beliefs, humanitarians upheld or contributed to political structures, such as Britain’s colonial control or the illiberal governments in Romania or Hungary, that restricted or denied individual rights. Often their work preserved pre-existing class structures by targeting formerly middle-class children brought low by the vicissitudes of war. Most significantly, when read together these five books demonstrate the extent to which humanitarian organisations were embedded in their national political contexts, and vice versa, and contribute to a blurring of the line between state and private aid, especially in the American context. While previous scholarly work has explored international relief as an instrument of American foreign policy, reading these five books together encourages a return to the ARA as an important moment in the histories of American foreign policy, American humanitarianism and humanitarianism more broadly.Footnote 32 The ARA was a remarkable humanitarian undertaking; an important instrument of American soft and political power in the inter-war period; and a precursor to the United States’ enormous post–Second World War relief apparatus, which would combine private and state organisations to shape the post-war order and uphold the country’s global hegemony. At a moment when a pillar of that relief apparatus, the United States Agency for International Development, was gleefully destroyed for specious, partisan reasons, further exploring the relationship between America’s foreign policy interests and its state and private humanitarian endeavours feels especially relevant.
Lastly, when juxtaposed, the books under review demonstrate the importance of humanitarian history as both an entry point into larger trends of twentieth-century history and a lens that makes the entanglement of seemingly disparate processes more apparent. Just as global relief work mediated connections between distant peoples, treating ‘humanitarianism as history’, per Daniel Maul, permits us to more fully appreciate the connections between the local, the national and the international.Footnote 33 Imperialism, state-building, American ambition, altruism, nationalism, internationalism – all converge and intertwist in humanitarian action, as do the pragmatic and idealistic motivations with which individual humanitarians approached their work. Untangling such knots requires patience and dexterity but offers fresh perspectives from which historians can assess otherwise familiar events as well as a set of methodologies that can be deployed to recover the voices, experiences and agency of those frequently silenced in the archive.
Acknowledgements
The author thanks Lauren K. Stokes and Stephanie Wright for their helpful feedback and kind patience.
