The saga of “Old Town Road” has emerged as one of the largest popular music stories of 2019. Before sparking conversations on race and genre within commercial music, “Old Town Road” was born from a uniquely internet-based set of circumstances. The song's backing track, produced sometime in 2017 by Netherlands-based Kiowa Roukema (known professionally as YoungKio and referred to as Kio in this review), samples track “34 Ghosts IV” from Nine Inch Nails’ ambient album Ghosts I-IV (2008). After being posted online to YouTube and beat-selling website BeatStars, Atlanta-based Montero Lamar Hill (known professionally as Lil Nas X and referred to as X in this review) found Kio's beat on October 31, 2018. X purchased the beat from BeatStars and added his vocals, releasing “Old Town Road” on SoundCloud on December 3, 2018 as “Old Town Road (I Got the Horses in the Back).”Footnote 1
What followed over the next few months was a well-planned, meteoric rise of the song to cultural preeminence. Born and raised in internet culture, X tweeted various memes of the song and posted the opening lyrics (“take my horse to the old town road”) and the lyrics from the initial drop (“I got the horses in the back”) in a song-finding Reddit community in a ploy for more exposure. In mid-February, these seeds sprouted. Nicemichael, a major user on the short-video lip-synch/dancing app TikTok, posted a video of himself dancing to “Old Town Road,” with a sudden outfit change into western wear at the initial drop. This video sparked the hashtag #YeehawChallenge, wherein users would post a video with the same gag as Nicemichael; some videos relied on a mythical “yee yee juice” to instigate the conversion to western wear, others simply aligned a jump cut with the drop.Footnote 2 The #YeehawChallenge spread across the internet, and, because TikTok provides a link in all videos back to the original audio, so too did X's song. On March 16, 2019, “Old Town Road” entered the Billboard Hot Country Songs Chart at #19 and the Billboard Hot 100 at #83.
By the following week, however, the song was nowhere to be found on the Hot Country Songs chart, despite climbing to #51 on the Hot 100. According to a statement that Billboard released to Rolling Stone, although the song “incorporates references to country and cowboy imagery, it does not embrace enough elements of today's country music to chart in its current version.”Footnote 3 Questions of racial motivation for the exclusion of “Old Town Road” from the Hot Country Songs chart sprung up almost immediately, alongside allegations that X was choosing the country label in order to sit higher on the charts. Had the song been made with a record label and subject to industry scrutiny during the genre-labeling decision, a verdict for the country genre may have been more accepted; however, the homemade nature of the song's creation and the individual decision to tag it as country complicate the assignment of genre. X maintained that the song is “country-trap, but I feel like if I had to choose—which I had to—I thought it would lean more on the country side,” and his initial tagging of the song as country on SoundCloud, months before it went viral, repels the argument that the genre choice was intentionally meant to manipulate the charts.Footnote 4
Questions of race and genre are fundamental to the commercial music industry, which from its very beginning segregated the music of southern white and black artists into “hillbilly” and “race” records, respectively.Footnote 5 The effects of this separation continue to the present day, coming to the forefront of popular culture whenever a black artist attempts to reclaim the music of a genre that was reserved for whites.Footnote 6 Artists are still generally seen as participating in the creation of music within one genre only, and with commercial genres initially drawn along color lines, artists of color can struggle to be included in genres outside of the one assigned to their racial or ethnic origin. For example, before “Old Town Road,” Beyoncé’s 2016 “Daddy Lessons”—a song with markedly more elements of country music—was kept out of consideration in the country categories of the Grammys.Footnote 7
Reliance on the Billboard charts to determine genre is also potentially problematic for other reasons. Billboard relies solely on airplay for many charts, leading to results that sometimes appear questionable; for example, five of country-pop artist Taylor Swift's songs charted on Latin Pop Songs from 2009 to 2015.Footnote 8 Certainly, airplay on genre-specific stations can inform our discussion of genre: if a song is seen as “country enough” to be played on country stations, along with having some country elements and being described by the artist as country, can we consider it to be “officially” country? “Old Town Road” remained on the Country Airplay chart after being excluded from Hot Country Songs, peaking at #50 on June 8 before falling off. Although the virality of “Old Town Road” allows the possibility that the airplay on country stations is due to popularity rather than identification within the genre (like Swift's presence on the Latin charts), the presence of country elements and the original designation as country provide for the argument that the song is country after all.
While news and social media exploded with discussions of whether “Old Town Road” could be considered country, X and “Old Town Road” continued to rise in popularity. X signed to Columbia Records on March 22 and teamed up with Billy Ray Cyrus for a remix that was released on April 5. By the following week, “Old Town Road” was #1 on the Billboard Hot 100. “Old Town Road” stayed solidly at the top of the pop culture zeitgeist, even being mashed up with another pop culture phenomenon, HBO's Game of Thrones, in a meme following the penultimate episode of the series.Footnote 9 On May 17, the official music video (referred to as “official movie” in the YouTube title and directed by Calmatic) was released.
Like the song itself, the music video for “Old Town Road” is unique in the circumstances surrounding its creation. Because it was filmed after the viral #YeehawChallenge and the Billboard genre controversy, the music video was able to directly reference the circumstances surrounding the rise of the song and the debate of race and genre that it sparked. Unlike other music videos to approach issues of race and racism in the United States, such as Beyoncé’s “Formation” (2016) and Childish Gambino's “This is America” (2018), the music video for “Old Town Road” maintains a narrow focus on the specific reception of the song and the way issues of race in music have directly affected it.
After starting in 1889, the music video primarily occurs in the present day, juxtaposing the reactions of both black and white communities to people that initially don't appear to belong. The opening scene in 1889 introduces the characters played by X and Cyrus, who are shown in a horse chase that concludes with the arrival at a lone country house. Inside the house, a young white woman spots the arriving criminals and calls for her “daddy.” Referencing the Billboard controversy and setting up the main premise of the video, X states, “last time I was here they weren't too welcoming to outsiders,” just before escaping the young woman's gun-toting white father by diving down a mine entrance and, surprisingly, being transported into 2019.
Landing in his 1889 western wear, X looks up at a young black child who, paralleling the white woman, calls for his “mama.” As the song starts, the video cuts to a sequence of 2019 locals of various ages turning, bewildered, to look at X, who is riding on a horse in his full western wear. This contrast between a black community in 2019 and X as a black cowboy continues throughout this section of the video, with dance-off and street-racing scenes. A short section of spoken dialogue closes this section of the music video, with the interaction between X and rapper Vince Staples (whom X beat in the street race) showing that X has been welcomed into and has gained the respect of the black community.
The final section of the video is set in a community center called “Old Town Hall,” in which X and Cyrus interrupt a bingo game (to looks of skepticism similar to the initial shots in the black neighborhood) and lead a group of older white bingo players in a line dance to the song. The video concludes with a photo shoot–like sequence of various people in front of a piece of fabric that says “Old Town” and includes western imagery of a desert scene with cacti and wolves. One clip shows X drinking Snapple-branded “Yee Yee Juice,” referencing the #YeehawChallenge. Other clips include a cameo by Jocelyn Donald, the singer/songwriter who wrote Cyrus's verse, decked out in western wear; Cyrus and X posing together; four of the women from the bingo hall dressed in matching cow-print vests; and, finally, one white woman, dressed in a red dress, white shirt, denim vest, and cowboy hat, posing with X and looking up admiringly at him.
An entire article could be dedicated to the controversy surrounding the genre designation of “Old Town Road” and the song's place in the narrative of black Americans reclaiming their history in the Wild West. In addition to its musical presence, this reclamation has taken root in fashion through the “YeeHaw Agenda.” Bri Malandro, a black Texan pop culture archivist, coined the term, using it to describe the trend of black artists, including Beyoncé, Solange, Cardi B, and Megan Thee Stallion, wearing western clothes.Footnote 10 The music video for “Old Town Road” internalizes the genre controversy and the black cowboy reclamation narrative, showing X as a black cowboy finding a way to fit in with both a present-day black community and a present-day community of white people connected to western heritage. Rather than making an outwardly political statement like Kendrick Lamar's To Pimp a Butterfly or the aforementioned works by Beyoncé and Childish Gambino, “Old Town Road” and the YeeHaw Agenda are political because they disrupt racialized popular music categories, as demonstrated in the music video through X's positive interactions with the two separate black and white communities.
Although the tacitly political nature of “Old Town Road” might not have the same immediate impact as the outwardly political statements seen from other black artists, the genre designation controversy and the music video's self-reflexive commentary remind us that racial justice is about combating small acts of racism and racial exclusion as well as large acts of racist violence and other violations of civil rights. Racial justice agendas rightly include ending mass incarceration, police brutality, and voter suppression, but there are more subtle ways racial discrimination manifests itself in all facets of society. The music video for “Old Town Road” shows us not only the ideal world for the song, one in which it can be part of both the hip hop/trap realm and the country realm, but also the ideal world for black artists, one in which they can participate in all genres of music without discrimination or exclusion.
Although internet-based social media platforms like YouTube have been used harmfully to exoticize black culture and to sexualize black bodies, the origin of “Old Town Road” in the “do-it-yourself” internet meme culture suggests alternative possibilities that might further cultural discussions of race and racism.Footnote 11 “Old Town Road” is notable for drawing on aspects of two cultural realms that have been racially segregated and bringing attention to the discussion of race and genre in music, in addition to its meteoric rise from internet-based origins to the top of the Billboard Hot 100. Although other songs and multimedia productions created on the internet may not experience the same commercial and popular success as “Old Town Road,” the popularity of the song and the conversations it has sparked have shown the impact that grassroots new media can have on the course of racial justice.
