More than 100 years have elapsed since the magnum opus of Vincent and Abel – Jérusalem nouvelle (Reference Vincent and Abel1914–26) – first appeared in print, and the history and archaeology of ancient Jerusalem continue to inspire scholars, presenting new finds and observations. Numerous articles are published each year, and three books have appeared recently dealing with the Hellenistic and Roman city: Avni and Stiebel Reference Avni and Stiebel2017, Weksler-Bdolah Reference Weksler-Bdolah2020, and Gafni et al. Reference Gafni, Reich and Schwartz2020 (the last in Hebrew; in spite of its title, the subject of the second volume is archaeology).
D.-M. Cabaret's book is an augmented product emerging from his PhD dissertation (Cabaret Reference Cabaret2019), written under the supervision of Prof. François Villeneuve. The present book also deals with the southern part of the city. It comprises nine chapters, a rich bibliography (331–59), and an index of personal names: ancient authors, historical figures, and modern authors (361–63). It is lavishly illustrated with photos and maps. For the benefit of non-French readers, there are also a “General introduction” and “General conclusions” in English (10–18 and 325–30, respectively). The early chapters deal with the fortifications and urban development of the northern part of Hellenistic and Roman Jerusalem: the Second Wall (Chap. 1, 19–32), and the areas included within (Chap. 2, 33–64), to its east – the “Bezetha Quarter” – and to its west (Chap. 3, 65–104); and the impact of the enlargement of the Temple Mount on the urban layout to its north (Chap. 4, 105–16). The long Chapter 5 (117–82) is devoted to a detailed architectural analysis and reconstruction of the Ecce Homo Arch, which is attributed to Herod. Chapters 6 (183–220) and 7 (221–42) are additions to the PhD dissertation. The topic of Chapter 6 is the Third Wall and the parcellation of the areas on both its inside and outside; Chapter 7, the only chapter that addresses the area to the south of the Decumanus Maximus of Aelia Capitolina, deals with the Camp of the Tenth Legion. The subjects of the last two chapters concern the post-Herodian city: the new layout of Aelia Capitolina in the northern part of the city (Chap. 8, 243–68), and the city Forum and Hadrian's Platform on the former site of the Temple and its courts (Chap. 9, 269–310). Altogether, it is an excellent piece of research, full of innovations. It is well written and magnificently illustrated. The arguments are clearly presented, but some of the conclusions, though suggestive, are too theoretical and not substantiated by archaeological evidence.
Adhering to the “Law of persistence of a city plan,” the author has succeeded in tracing, in a majestic and most convincing manner, four or five different systems of ancient parcellation (arpentage) in the plan of the Old City and to its north, according to different grids of centuriation given in feet, cubits, or actus, attributed to different periods (see his Carte 7): two radial parcellations, à la patte d'oie, and the others orthogonal (323). His study reflects a deep acquaintance with the streets and lanes of the Old City, combined with a thorough analysis of all relevant literary sources pertaining to the 2nd c. BCE–2nd c. CE and beyond, and the archaeological finds, with which he is well updated.
Many of C.'s suggestion and conclusions are very suggestive and thought-provoking. In addition to the different systems of arpentage (about which see farther below), the innovations are numerous. Space precludes mentioning them all, but they include:
— Tracing the line of the Second Wall (attributed to the Hasmoneans), to meet the northwest tower of Fortress Antonia, not the northeast tower, as was the prevailing opinion; locating the Strouthion Pool against the course of this wall, near its southeast end; and setting the Hasmonean Baris there.
— The Second Wall encircled a new Hasmonean quarter, laid out à la patte d'oie arpentage.
— Two phases in the evolution of the extramural Bezetha Quarter, attributed to Herod: the first, on an orthogonal layout, with a theater and a quadriporticus in its center resembling the theater complex of Pompey in Rome; and the second with a street in line with the Via Dolorosa of the present, adorned with the Ecce Homo Arch – a city gate flank by two towers – with a bridge of wood or stone in front, across the Strouthion Pool. C.'s architectural analysis and reconstruction of this gate and its doors, based on in situ remains and scattered architectural fragments he has managed to trace in local museums, is an exemplary study. He should be applauded for that.
— A second extramural Herodian quarter of orthogonal arpentage to the west of the Second Wall.
— A second arpentage, à la patte d'oie, to the north of the present Damascus Gate, with its central axis crossing the opus sectile monument, which served, according to the author, as a commemoration for Herod himself, to the north of the city. C. envisages the outer circle of this round monument as an elevated round structure, rather than merely a podium for an inner circular structure (196–98, 203–7).
— An orthogonal arpentage on either side of the Third Wall, attributed to King Agrippa I. The principal north–south axis of this arpentage skirted the Tombs of the Kings on its east. C. attributes the first stage of this burial complex to the king himself, but its burial chamber was not completed, owing to Agrippa's sudden death. Later it became the mausoleum of the royal house of Helene, queen of Adiabene. Agrippa I might have been buried at the Nicephoria tomb, which was adorned by three pyramids, according to the author.
— Locating Titus's siege camp against and on the inside of the northeast corner of the Third Wall, beyond the reach of ballistae set on the Second Wall, still held by the Jewish rebels, and tracing the circumvallation wall beyond the reach of ballistae set on the First Wall (fig. 6.18), after the Second Wall fell.
— Unlike several Israeli scholars (Avi-Yonah Reference Avi-Yonah1966; Bahat Reference Bahat2000; Tsafrir Reference Tsafrir, Grabar and Kedar2009), who maintained that the camp of the Tenth Roman legion occupied only the Armenian and the western part of the Jewish Quarters, C. argues that it extended over the entire Upper City. In this he follows Wilson (Reference Wilson1905), Vincent and Abel (Reference Vincent and Abel1914–26), Geva (Reference Geva1984), and Weksler-Bdolah (Reference Weksler-Bdolah2020). But the camp's plan he reconstructs is much more detailed than any other, depicting not only its north–south Via Principalis, but all other components of a legionary camp, including a praetorium, a forum, and barracks of various sorts. It was a Flavian combination between the square, Late Republican Polybian military camp, and the rectangular Imperial camp of Pseudo-Hyginus (3rd c. CE), with rounded corners like a playing card (en carte à jouer). It had an arpentage of its own, determined by Titus. On the west it was delineated by the earlier First Wall of the city, while, strangely, on the north it had a new wall, just to accord with the proposed arpentage.
— Innovations, pertaining to Aelia Capitolina, are the proposal that a part of the present upper platform of Haram al Sharif, trapezoidal in shape, served as the podium of the Hadrianic Aedes; a detailed layout of the “Eastern Forum” – the Ecce Homo piazza – (accessed by three monumental staircases leading down to its northern part from the east, west, and north), and a minute analysis of the distribution of the shallow drainage channels of its paving, the lithostratos; and the layout of the main Forum, on the intersection of the Cardo Maximus and the Decumanus Maximus, with the Capitoline Temple on its northern edge. C. maintains that in other parts of the Northern Sector, the earlier arpentages were respected by Hadrian; only colonnaded streets replaced the earlier, narrower and simpler, main thoroughfares.
However, several reservations should be presented about the proposed chronological evolution of the city plan and the dates ascribed to various arpentages.
The elliptical piazza, la patte d'oie, and dating the three main arpentages in the northern part of the Old City
Tracing different systems of arpentages following the “law of persistence of city plan” is in itself an extraordinary achievement. The problem is the dates assigned to them: Hasmonean and Herodian.
The central street à la patte d'oie, following the course of the Tyropoeon Valley and leading to the Temple and the Lower City of David, was always a natural trail. The absence of archaeological finds to corroborate the date of the Oval Piazza and of the Western and Eastern streets as Hellenistic is a severe deficiency, of which the author is aware. However, oval or circular piazzas and radiating streets are known in Greco-Roman urbanism in the orient only from Roman times, not earlier. Gerasa, Scythopolis, Bostra, and Palmyra are such examples. Theoretical acquaintance with the oval shape in Hellenistic Alexandria cannot prove its implementation in urban arpentage so early in Hasmonean Jerusalem. Finds unearthed underneath the Damascus Gate have already led some scholars to suggest that a Hellenistic gate might have existed there, and that the Second Wall might have been built by John Hyrcanus. But attributing to him such a sophisticated arpentage within the wall, without providing contemporary parallels from anywhere in the Hellenistic world, is problematic. Different arpentages could be applied in different zones of a city due to topographical constraints and other considerations, but a semi-oval piazza and radiating streets are exceptional. The fact that this quarter was laid out according to the royal cubit, rather than the Roman foot or actus, certainly deserves consideration, but in itself it cannot serve as an ultimate proof in favor of the Hellenistic origin of this arpentage. Herod applied both the royal cubit and the Roman foot in the Temple Mount.
Point B of the geometrical analysis (figs. 2.12, 2.15, and more)
According to C., Point B, placed on top of the future Muslim Rock, is a major point for arpentages, which are set by him a century or more apart. It is perpendicular to the Hasmonean street DE (the Western Street of the patte d'oie), and it lies on axis with the Cardo Maximus of the Herodian Quarter of Bezetha (fig. 3.3). On page 89 the author says that the Rock was the Altar of Sacrifice of the Jewish Temple;Footnote 1 elsewhere he is less determinative about this point. This identification is impossible for several reasons. First, according to the literary sources (Rabbinic and Flavius Josephus), the altar was located in front of the Temple to its east, not to its north. Second, following the Jewish Law, the Altar of Sacrifice was built of separate unhewn stones; it was not a rocky monolith. Third, as early as the 19th c. scholars were aware that the level of the Jewish Temple (porch, sanctuary, and Holy of Holies) was roughly 3 m higher than the top elevation of the present Rock. The Rock is therefore irrelevant for locating any component of the Jewish temple.Footnote 2
Hence, Point B could not be relevant for either the Hasmonean or the Herodian arpentages. But it could be relevant for the Roman Hadrianic arpentage since it lies on the median axis of the Hadrianic Forum (fig. 9.6), and it also marks the possible location of the altar of the Hadrianic Aedes. Respecting earlier arpentages by Hadrian is one thing. Reusing the same point as a point of reference for all three arpentages, remote in time from each other, is dubious, and actually impossible since Point B had no significance in the court of the Jewish temple; it is irrelevant for the arpentages assigned by C. to pre-Roman times. This leads one to conclude that the “Hasmonean” Western Street (DE) that became the Cardo Maximus of Aelia Capitolina (and the entire Hasmonean arpentage), and the “Herodian” orthogonal layout of the Bezetha Quarter, including its theater and qudroporticus, are to be attributed to Hadrian as well. After all, according to the Chronicon Paschale, Hadrian built a theater in Aelia Capitolina. In addition, one should bear in mind that the Herodian Quarter uncovered in the large-scale archaeological excavations in the Upper City was not laid out orthogonally!Footnote 3 Orthogonal arpentage was not applied by Herod in Jerusalem. Given the fact that no archaeological remains have so far been found to corroborate the attribution to Herod of the orthogonal layout of the Bezetha Quarter, this layout should rather be conceived as Hadrianic as well. Likewise, the arpentages on either side of the Third Wall can be conceived as Roman Imperial, associated with extramural centuriation outside Aelia Capitolina.
Point A of the geometrical analysis (figs. 2.12, 2.16)
This point, on the Mount of Olives, is a virtual point; it has no particular topographical characteristic. Its elevation is about 800 masl, perhaps less,Footnote 4 as the peak of the Mount of Olives is at 810 masl (289). It could not serve as a point of emergence of any arpentage, and certainly not the “Hasmonean” one. One should rather choose Point D, near the Genath Gate, a physical feature in the urban landscape. Likewise, the meeting point of the two yellow lines in fig. 9.23 (ca. 804 masl) has no particular topographical characteristics. But these facts should not detract from the brilliant geometrical analysis of the arpentage within the Second Wall.
The Hasmonean city wall to the north of the Temple Mount
From the time of Nehemiah, the Lower City of David and the Temple Hill were surrounded by a single city wall. Under the Hasmoneans the Western Hill was added and surrounded by another wall, the First Wall of Flavius Josephus. On the north, the Temple Mount was surrounded by the early city wall up to Herod's time, when it became redundant owing to the expansion of the Temple Mount to the north and to the west beyond it. This fact is clearly indicated in the description of the siege and conquest of the Temple Mount by Herod in 37 BCE.Footnote 5 The description in Josephus's Antiquitates 14 speaks about three defensive walls on the north: the city wall, the wall of the Outer Court, and that of the Inner Court of the Temple.Footnote 6 C. ignores the existence of a city wall that was separate from the northern wall of the Temple Mount (see, e.g., figs. 2.12, 2.15, 2.21, and 317–18, Cartes 1 and 2).
Altogether, as indicated above, the book is an excellent piece of research, full of innovations. It represents a brilliant analysis of various ancient arpentages that underlie the present streets and alleys of the Old City of Jerusalem and beyond.Footnote 7
