This book uses a cultural lens to examine the ways diplomacy and propaganda were structured, received, and finally rendered incomplete by the “full-fledged myth of America and of Wilson,” which, according to Daniela Rossini, was more powerfully felt in Italy than elsewhere in Europe (1). This myth drew deeply from the image of the United States as a “promised land” for immigrants and was transformed by Wilson's propaganda and knack for modern mass politics. Rossini traces this myth and its impact on what she defines as a paradoxical relationship between the two countries rooted in cultural differences, which helped to lead to equally paradoxical diplomatic settlements. Eventually, conflict crested after the dispute over the Adriatic question in 1919 with an “avalanche of hatred” pouring over the once-popular Wilson. Thereafter “Figlio di Wilson” or “Son of Wilson” “became a common insult in Italy” (190).
Rossini teaches contemporary history at Università di Roma Tre. Rather than focus on personalities of leaders and diplomatic discussions, she directs her attention to the meshing of cultures between the two nations. A particular focus is the way misunderstandings, prejudices, and politics prevented connection and coherence in their relationship. Rossini emphasizes U.S. propaganda in Italy, which she characterizes as both vast and successful, as well as the genesis of a “drive for a new cosmopolitanism” catalyzed by Wilson and later fulfilled by Americans (3).
Rossini starts the book with a retrospective of the role of Italy in the mind of American sojourners stretching back to the nineteenth century and in the experiences produced by massive migration. Images of Italy and Italians were in a great deal of flux and conflict, usually errant and ill-formed. Rossini uses this space to detail American ignorance, “indifference and even hostility” and the emergence of a pattern of “idealization, rejection, and ignorance,” which she later uses to characterize U.S.-Italian relations during the war (17). Rossini covers the wide-ranging early Italian views of the United States with special emphasis on the attitudes after 1898 when the “myth of America” fully developed. She draws from an array of Italian sources on immigration, which will likely be new to American historians.
The second chapter provides a discussion of the background and general flow of the First World War that centers on Italian and American experiences. This section does not add especially new material on the war, though it does allow Rossini space to explore the concept that the Italian-Austrian conflict and the United States-Germany conflict can be seen as “two parallel wars” with different rhetoric, emotions, battlefield realities, and post-war visions (49).
Wilson is introduced in a chapter that considers progressivism in some detail before turning to the emergence of wartime Wilsonianism and the “unprecedented propaganda campaign that he organized,” particularly through the Committee on Public Information (CPI) (68). Rossini deftly describes the CPI's actions and argues that “what emerged forcefully from these undertakings is the vitality and modernity of American society at the turn of the [twentieth] century” (79).
The second half of this book grapples with the impact of Wilsonian propaganda in Italy through the peace talks. It is here that Rossini makes a contribution to understanding the interstate relations of this period. She argues that the American propaganda from groups like the YMCA, the U.S. Army, and ultimately the CPI, was highly efficient and was aided by the myth of America that had developed in the previous decades. This is a truly intriguing idea that deserves a longer and more detailed study, as Rossini's definition of the “myth of America” remains somewhat indistinct throughout the book. Although she discusses American films and speakers and some aspects of public opinion regarding Wilson, what would have greatly aided the argument would have been a granular discussion of the reception of U.S. propaganda with evidence drawn from available Italian sources in addition to CPI and U.S. diplomatic reports.
There are a few small quibbles with this book and some larger questions of context and interpretation. On the relatively insignificant end, there is some repetition (Ernest Hemingway and John Dos Passos are mentioned driving ambulances twice within the first seventeen pages), and the extensive background seems unnecessary in this short volume. In 192 pages of text, Wilson does not really appear until page 61. It may be that in terms of Italian historiography this emphasis on background stretching back to the nineteenth century is necessary, but it defers attention from the vital task of observing the U.S.-Italian relationship during and after the war.
The abbreviations list in Rossini's thorough notes functions as a list of the archival collections she utilized (about a third of which were in Italy). Nevertheless, a full bibliography would have been useful. Specialists in particular would have benefited from a comprehensive list of her Italian sources. The English language secondary works cited are standard older works from before 2000, the year this book was published in Italian.
Though this work presents the interstate relationship in a transnational and multi-archival vein, because it is essentially a work of the 1990s it does not fully engage the new, theoretically rich “international history” emphasis in the study of American foreign relations. It does not present either a de-centered or global reading of this diplomatic relationship between the two countries. Rooted as it is in older works, Rossini's reading of Wilson is also fairly flat, especially given the range of scholarship detailing his myriad motivations and the broader global and systemic ambitions of American foreign relations of the era, which are not engaged here. Woodrow Wilson and the American Myth in Italy misses an opportunity to thoroughly contextualize this story within the broader critical frame of American foreign relations. As a cultural study, this book is effective in the ways it brings this key emphasis to bear on issues in a vital diplomatic wrangle.
