As we enter the post-farm-to-table era, many Americans consider themselves well versed in the particulars of the national food supply chain. However, despite the popularity of farmers’ markets and grow-your-own options, most Americans still rely on grocery stores and supermarkets for the bulk of their food needs. So where do supermarkets fit into this supply chain? In Movable Markets, Helen Tangires unpacks the evolution of the American wholesale marketplace from centralized produce district to its current existence within industrial food parks located outside the city and beyond public access.
Tangires splits the history of wholesaling into three parts – “Open Entry,” “Consolidation,” and “New Frontiers” – and uses a selection of cities, including Baltimore, Chicago, Boston, and New York, to talk about the evolution of the American urban food supply. In an effort to encourage direct sales between producers and consumers, nineteenth-century laws forbade intermediaries, or middlemen, from “forestalling” or reselling goods within the city. But these regulations failed to keep up with the rate of city expansion, agricultural production, and improved food transportation networks created by the railroad industry. Wholesalers became functional necessities for the growing supply and distribution of perishable food within the urban landscape.
After the turn of the century, Progressive Era reforms aimed to standardize urban food markets and regulate the recently legalized practice of wholesaling. Reformers capitalized on American anxieties about social order and sought to consolidate wholesale markets under a central authority. From 1921 to 1930, the United States Department of Agriculture operated Center Market, an open public market near the National Mall and the only market “subject to federal oversight” (106). Other American planners turned to Europe for functioning models of suburban terminal food markets. Infrastructural concerns – including traffic jams, public sanitation, and the high cost of living – eventually forced city planners to reconsider the geographic location of their food supply.
By the 1930s, municipal authorities governed urban food markets aided by several federal Acts, including the Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act of 1930, which enforced licensing of the fruit and vegetable trade; the Motor Carrier Act of 1935, which deregulated agricultural trucking practices; and the Agricultural Research and Marketing Act of 1946. Over the next few decades, additional improvements in air travel, the creation of the Interstate Highway System, and new streamlined methods of shipping drastically evolved wholesale food practices.
As markets shifted to the periphery, federal art and photography campaigns aimed to bolster their reputation, and that of the middleman, within society. A long-held negative perception of middlemen and a “lack of consensus on terminology” on what to call wholesale markets (terminal markets? free-trade markets?), made the public unclear of how these variables fit into the national food supply chain. Tangires, who also authored Public Markets and Civic Culture in Nineteenth-Century America (2003) and serves as the administrator of the Center for the Advanced Study in the Visual Arts at the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC, relies on her background in visual arts to help navigate the material-cultural objects used to help reshape public sentiment regarding wholesale food markets. To help promote the benefits of these disparaged food spaces, the Farm Security Administration and the Office of War Information helped document American life in wholesale markets between 1935 and 1944. A poster produced by the Federal Art Project explained that “this is the market where the storekeeper buys the food and brings it to his store near your house,” demonstrating the necessity, albeit indirect, of the wholesale market to the American consumer (173).
Combining an archival treasure trove of federal documents, popular literature, economic reports, and visual materials, Tangires weaves a compelling story about a lesser-known aspect of American food history. Within this story, she details the evolution of the middleman within the public imaginary, which frequently maligned wholesalers as “hucksters” and often associated their problematic practices with their “foreign birth” (33). Despite this perception, Tangires demonstrates how the wholesale market became the foundation of the urban food system and the wholesaler “was the keystone” (215).
While Movable Markets is well documented and cleverly illuminates a new aspect of American history, Tangires's arguments rarely circle back to the food itself. How did wholesale markets influence the foods Americans ate? What trends in restaurants, cookbooks, and consumer habits can we glean from the wholesale-market shift to the urban periphery? In thinking through these larger issues, Tangires's book fits perfectly alongside other food studies publications that help fill in these historical and cultural gaps to create a whole picture of the importance of the American wholesale marketplace.
