There has been an impressive proliferation of scholarly work recently on Arab and other Middle East and North African cinemas, much of which reflects an increasing degree of depth and sophistication. Robert Lang's New Tunisian Cinema: Allegories of Resistance is an example of this trend, exploring as it does newer cinematic works from Tunisia in a manner that links sociohistorical trends to insightful readings of a number of key cinematic works.
Lang's study is comprised of nine chapters, beginning with an introductory overview that historically situates the developments in Tunisian cinema during the period of President Zin al-ʿAbidin bin ʿAli's rule (r. 1987–2011). The next seven chapters are each dedicated to an in-depth study of a single work produced roughly during this period. The films chosen for analysis include Nouri Bouzid's Rih al-Sad (Man of Ashes, 1986) and Bezness (Business, 1992), Ferid Boughedir's ʿAsfur al-Sath (Halfaouine, Boy of the Terraces, 1990), Moufida Talatli's Samt al-Qusur (The Silences of the Palace, 1994), Mohamed Zran's Essaida (Essaïda, 1996), Nadia El Fani's Bedwin Hacker (Bedouin Hacker, 2003), and Moncef Dhouib's La Télé arrive (The TV Is Coming, 2006). The final chapter addresses links between Tunisian filmmaking and the Tunisian revolution of 2011. The scope of the study is impressive and Lang engages deeply with Tunisian history and the nation's political dynamics. An excellent bibliography offers a comprehensive set of resources (although unfortunately limited to French and English texts) on the subject of Tunisian cinema.
As the book's subtitle suggests, Lang's monograph focuses primarily on the allegorical dimensions of these films, locating within each of them a critique of state power and authoritarianism that constitutes a form of resistance to the Bin ʿAli regime and to broader forms of social repression. In particular, Lang is interested in national allegory. Identifying his conceptual framing as being inspired by Frederic Jameson's influential essay, “Third-World Literature in the Era of Multinational Capitalism” (Social Text no. 15 [1986]: 65–88), he adopts Jameson's argument for the “primacy of national allegory in third-world culture” (p. 84). Lang's selection of films is therefore based not only on their canonical status during the period he discusses, but also on the extent to which each can be read as a form of national allegory. To this end, his study leaves out works that do not offer compelling national-allegorical readings—a choice that arguably does result in the passing over of some important films of this period.
Lang explains his choice to exclude the films of the prolific Tunisian filmmaker Nacer Khemir by remarking that, “[m]ore obviously than most, [Khemir’s] films are allegories. But what are they allegories of? And there is the related question: How ‘Tunisian’ are they?” (p. 13). Lang's decision to exclude them does bear a certain logic; Khemir aspires to a trans-Islamic spiritualism in his works that pushes against the national cinema model within which Lang has chosen to work. But Lang's own question, “How ‘Tunisian’ are they?” arguably haunts his other selections, and the entirety of New Tunisian Cinema. This is because most (if not all) of the filmmakers under discussion make significant use of European production assistance and generally have had more success reaching audiences outside of Tunisia—specifically in Europe—than inside Tunisia. The reasons for this are complex, and there is no merit to branding such works as inauthentic as a result of these realities. Nevertheless, it is difficult to argue that Tunisia's film industry fulfills some essential requirements of a national cinema in the way that Egypt’s, Turkey’s, or Iran's would. Lang does acknowledge this point, but at times he arguably overarticulates what is “national” in these films to allow them to do the work of illustrating social and historical trends in Tunisia. Equally interesting to their possible status as national allegories, one may argue, is their status as products of a transnational neocolonial order, and many of the same films could be explored as examples of globalization or as neocolonial cultural artifacts.
The focus on allegorical readings leads to a narratological approach in Lang's discussions of the films. In each chapter, Lang sets out the sociopolitical backdrop to the film's narrative and follows this with a fairly detailed plot summary supplying the framework for the discussion. This aspect of Lang's methodology will be of particular use to those readers who may be less familiar with the nuances of Tunisian social and historical dynamics, as he very effectively leads the reader through complex historical and political issues. While this approach does much to offer a solid grounding for understanding the context for the film, the reliance on context and the focus on allegory at times results in a discussion that is centered too greatly on narrative. As a result, Lang only occasionally addresses the specifically cinematic qualities of these works, and in particular their aesthetics, whether visual or otherwise. Nonetheless, each chapter-length discussion works well as a comprehensive study of the film under discussion, and may be used very effectively in teaching as a standalone assigned reading. While films such as Rih al-Sad and Samt al-Qusur have been the subject of other studies, the chapters on Nadia El Fani's Bedwin Hacker and Moncif Dhouib's La Télé arrive are very original and offer welcome readings of unfortunately still underappreciated works.
Lang's use of the term “New Tunisian Cinema” draws from Nouri Bouzid's appellation of his own generation as “bearers of a social, cinematic and political project” by having “decided to make films that were all like [them]selves” (pp. 32–33). What these “new Tunisian” filmmakers broke from is a prior legacy of derivative, formula-based filmmaking modeled on the successes of the classic Egyptian film and its melodramatic form. The reader is to be cautioned that this formulation of “new” cinema does therefore end before the most recent generation of young Tunisian filmmakers, including Raja Amari (Satin Rouge [Red Satin], 2002), Nejib Belkadhi (Bastardo [The Bastard], 2013), and perhaps the most successful Tunisian director in history, Abdellatif Kechiche (La Graine et le mulet [The Secret of the Grain], 2007), whose works are largely centered on French and French-Arab themes.
While each film analysis stands alone, Lang does offer an effective framework for his study that threads together all of the chapters. This framework leads to a broader evaluation of the films as offering an alternative history to political developments in Tunisia since the 1980s. Lang summarizes this by saying,
it is, however, the Tunisian national cinema as an institution speaking to both local and global audiences that has most consistently and effectively articulated for the Tunisian people an image of themselves—an image of who they are and aspire to be—giving them a coherent sense of not only what they were protesting against … but of what kind of Tunisia they feel they deserve and are willing to fight for. (p. 291)
This mode of evaluation folds in neatly with the historical bookends of the study—beginning with the coup that brought Bin ʿAli to power, and ending with the 2011 “Arab Spring” revolts that overthrew him. In this sense, the films discussed come to offer a sort of roadmap for social and political developments that culminate in the 2011 revolution. Overall, the study is extremely valuable as a guide to the aims of a particular generation of Tunisian filmmakers and for its many insights into modern Tunisian history. Even if one may argue that the omission of works by Khemir or works by more recent filmmakers leaves the scope of the work somewhat incomplete, these omissions are not overly significant. Lang's study is erudite, well written, and compelling, and offers students of Arab cinemas a welcome set of inquiries to inspire further studies of the works and themes he addresses.
