Between November 1827 and October 1828, William Burke and William Hare murdered sixteen people in order to sell their bodies to the Edinburgh anatomy schools. The killings, as Ruth Richardson has observed, were ‘a crime waiting to happen’ (Social History of Medicine (1995) 8, p. 136). Demand for anatomical subjects was growing rapidly, and the unregulated market in cadavers was at its height. The cadavers came mainly from illicit raids on graveyards and dodgy deals with mortuary porters, and anatomists knew not to enquire too closely about where their suppliers sourced their goods. Under such circumstances, it is hardly surprising that some unscrupulous individuals should have hit on murder as a way of turning poor acquaintances into valuable commodities. Burke and Hare were not the only ones to do so. In London, we know that John Bishop and Thomas Williams killed at least three people, and Edward Cook dispatched a fourth, for sale to the metropolitan anatomy schools. It is quite possible that other anatomy murders occurred but went undetected.
If Burke and Hare did not have a monopoly on ‘burking’, as the practice became known, they certainly remain its most notorious practitioners. In part, this is attributable to the sheer scale of their killing spree. But it is also helped by the fact that they left such rich documentary accounts of their crimes. Finding himself charged with murder, Hare turned king's witness, securing his own freedom by offering a fulsome if self-serving confession that sufficed to convict Burke. Burke in turn sought to put his own side of the story, dictating not one but several accounts of the murders from his condemned cell, the first to the legal authorities, the rest – directly or indirectly – to the press. Ever since, the tale of Burke and Hare has remained in circulation, in versions more or less faithful to the original confessions. Given this popular fascination, it is surprising how little attention has been paid to the anatomy murders by historians of science and medicine. The only sustained scholarly account of the West Port murders, as they were known at the time, has for a long time been Owen Dudley Edwards's Burke and Hare (1981), which is concerned principally with the light they throw on the plight of the Irish in Scotland (Burke and Hare were both Irish, as were several of their victims). Among medical historians, Ruth Richardson, in Death, Dissection and the Destitute (1987), has considered the murders in the context of the developing market for cadavers, arguing convincingly that, despite the publicity they attracted, they were only one among a number of factors that led to the passage of the Anatomy Act of 1832. Other than Richardson, however, historians of science and medicine have tended to mention the West Port murders only in passing, allowing them to stand as reminders of the dark underside of early nineteenth-century medical science, but neglecting to enquire more deeply into what they might tell us about how that underside related to the medical and scientific world as a whole.
Lisa Rosner's splendid new book The Anatomy Murders goes a long way to correct that neglect. Rosner is eminently well qualified to place Burke and Hare in their historical setting, having written what is still the best account of medical education in late eighteenth- and early nineteenth-century Edinburgh, as well as a celebrated study of the seedy life of the Edinburgh doctor Alexander Lesassier. In The Anatomy Murders, Rosner combines her historical expertise with a gift for storytelling that makes for compelling reading. Nine beautifully crafted chapters detail the tragic stories of Burke and Hare's victims, starting with an old man known only as Donald, whose death from natural causes in Hare's lodging house provided their first introduction to the anatomy trade, and ending with Margaret Docherty, the discovery of whose body in Hare's rooms initiated the investigation that led to Hare's confession and Burke's execution. Two further chapters describe the denouement, including Burke's trial and Hare's flight. Around this narrative, Rosner skilfully hangs a rich analysis of the historical circumstances that made the whole sorry saga not just possible but almost inevitable. The lives and conditions of the Edinburgh poor; the competitive world of the city's thriving anatomy schools; contemporary ideas about the causes and control of criminality; the means of criminal investigation, trial and punishment: all are examined in a way that illuminates and helps to make sense of this dark episode in the history of the city of Enlightenment.
Among the rich cast of characters who stagger or strut through Rosner's narrative, one of the most vivid is the anatomist Robert Knox, proprietor of the school to which Burke and Hare sold their victims' corpses. As perhaps the most accomplished and flamboyant teacher in the Edinburgh medical school of the 1820s and 1830s, Knox made important contributions to the domestication of French transcendental anatomy in Britain, and he became widely known, particularly after his removal to London in 1846, for his lectures and writings on the formation of species and the origins of human races. His work as one of the leading anatomical theorists of the first half of the nineteenth century has accordingly been examined in some detail by a number of historians, most notably Evelleen Richards. Up until now, however, we have had no scholarly account of Knox's life and career as a whole. Alan W. Bates is therefore to be thanked for his thoroughly researched and admirably readable biography of the man who, in the words of a contemporary song, ‘bought the beef’ from Burke and Hare.
Even without his involvement in the West Port murders, Knox's life would have been a remarkable one. As a young army surgeon posted to South Africa, Knox's disputatious personality first got him into serious trouble when he became entangled in a disagreement between officers that ended with him being horsewhipped, censured by a court of enquiry and shipped home on half pay. Bates makes a convincing case that it was the same personality flaw, rather than his association with Burke and Hare, that eventually led to the collapse of his Edinburgh teaching career and his removal to London. Indeed, Knox continued to teach in Edinburgh for ten years after the murders were exposed, and if anything his popularity with medical students seems to have been boosted by his notoriety. Rather, it was his obduracy in refusing to comply with the restrictions of the new Anatomy Act that led to the decline in his classes, while his penchant for voicing contrarian opinions and antagonizing the leaders of the local medical establishment was to blame for his failure to secure a chair in the university medical school. Following his removal to London, he continued to make an adequate, if not always comfortable, living as a lecturer, author and, latterly, pathologist to the Cancer Hospital at Brompton. Fired by an obvious sympathy for this difficult man, Bates tells Knox's story with skill and flair, making eminent sense of his sometimes obscure anatomical philosophizing, and ultimately vindicating his claim to be considered one of the most provocative biological thinkers of his time.
