When in 2007 the Metropolitan Opera/Lincoln Center Theater New Works Program commissioned an opera from Nico Muhly, the announcement caused quite a stir. At age twenty-six, Muhly was the youngest composer the Met had ever commissioned, and much of Two Boys takes place online, two facts that have dominated reception of the opera since its premiere on 21 October 2013. Nonesuch's two-disc CD release—compiled from live recordings of two performances—includes a booklet of liner notes with two introductory essays, the libretto by the playwright Craig Lucas, a cast list, and a plot synopsis.
Based on real events that occurred in Manchester, England, in 2001, Two Boys is about a good-hearted, naïve boy named Brian (Paul Appleby), who becomes ensnared in the lies of a younger, cleverer boy named Jake. Jake poses as various shadowy figures (all sung by different performers) who alternately taunt, goad, or entice Brian in a series of increasingly dramatic chat room encounters. He also presents two versions of himself: Idealized Jake (Christopher Bolduc) and Real Jake (the boy soprano Andrew Pulver). Ultimately, Jake tricks the confused and terrorized Brian into stabbing him at a shopping mall in a strange suicide attempt. It is perfectly believable that Brian—a sheltered teenager in 2001—would not “recognize” Jake underneath his many screen presences. In interviews, Muhly has noted that the early internet, with its unmoderated chat rooms and its sense of limitless possibility, allows for a realistic exploration of one of opera's most time-honored plot devices: disguise.
The opera's plot oscillates between real-life scenes, such as Brian's interrogation by Anne (Alice Coote), a detective who does not own a computer, and flashbacks to Brian's online encounters with Jake's multiple avatars. Muhly, Lucas, and, presumably, the Met are to be lauded for this attempt to represent online life artistically. Although some storytellers escape the difficulty of representing online experience by setting their stories in the 1990s, avoiding cell phones and Google searches, others are seeking ways to adequately represent and explore the internet in traditional narrative forms.Footnote 1 Bartlett Sher's staging of Two Boys was experimental in this respect: the opera's chorus (“Internet Voices”) appeared holding laptops whose glow illuminated their faces as they sang. Additionally, enormous towers were used as screens, on which snippets of chat text, avatars, and surveillance footage were projected. The dual representation of text—sung and projected—made it possible to convey the relentless typos, abbreviations, and emoticons that characterize online speech.
In keeping with the use of typos and emoticons, Lucas's libretto is insistently prosaic. “I love you, bro,” is a repeated lyrical motif, for example. Much of the rest of the text hews closely to real life and is suffused with the kind of off-handed obscenities and vile insults (“You should kill yourself,” “u suck u suck u suck”) that characterize a comments section. Only Anne, the detective, who is explicitly not of the internet era, speaks in what could be considered elevated prose. Disturbed after Brian introduces her to chat rooms, she sings, “Am I struck dumb by the marvel? Could I speak in such tongues?” I find the juxtaposition of Anne's pensive monologues with the incessant blur of chat-speak to be very moving: a reflection of the way technology bears some people into the future while leaving others behind.
Any review of Two Boys would be remiss if it did not address the much-lauded (or loathed) “accessibility” of the opera's contemporary plot, as well as of Muhly's music in general. Much of the journalistic rhetoric concerning Muhly focuses on his appeal to young people and his “reinvention” of classical music, both of which have less to do with his actual compositions than with his career: a twentieth-first century mélange of Björk arrangements, Grizzly Bear and Antony collaborations, film scores, albums of heavily edited vocal and electronic music, operas and chamber works, and his own indie record label (Bedroom Community). Reviews of Two Boys, noting its generationally mixed audiences, sometimes seemed to assume that the Met, in an effort to appeal to young people, had commissioned a hip young composer to write an opera “about the internet.” In his New York Times review, for example, Anthony Tommasini criticized the opera's “topical” plot and noted, “Chat rooms are already kind of passé.”Footnote 2 His criticism overlooks that the plot of Two Boys is not meant to seem timely, exactly. It is a nostalgic rhapsody on a version of the internet that no longer exists, and furthermore, the pseudo “narrator” of the work is Anne, an older woman who finds online life alienating and horrifying (“They’ve killed off beauty,” she sings, of chat room culture). In this sense, the opera itself is less celebratory of the “new” and of “youth” than its critics (and devotees) seem to assume.
Muhly repeatedly insists in interviews and on his blog that characterizations of him as the “savior” of classical music are both boring and rude, and that he has no interest in “changing the face” of music. Nevertheless, a rhetoric of salvation persists, often with a whiff of anti-intellectualism, pitched at the usual straw men (the “accessible” Muhly as antidote to Arnold Schoenberg and Pierre Boulez, whose elitist dissonance drove classical music to the brink of destruction). The two essays in the liner notes, neither written by a music scholar, continue this resistance to critical engagement. Met Live in HD producer Elena Park's notes contextualize Two Boys using Muhly's own statements, providing interesting insight into his intentions but not undertaking significant musical or cultural analysis. New Yorker writer Adam Gopnik takes a subtle dig at musicologists in his essay, saying they will “doubtless one day define with butterfly-species precision” the Muhly style. He then presents the same tired portrait of Muhly as breath of fresh air, marveling over the aforementioned youthful audience at the premiere and portentously proclaiming that his “unashamedly melodic music is a luxuriant growth that can rise only on a ground first cleared away.” Presumably a music scholar might have been able to engage with the music while avoiding clichés about the heroism of writing melodies.
Gopnik's characterization, although facile, does identify the most obvious stylistic referent for Two Boys, which is minimalist repetition. The orchestra presents a collage of repetitive motives that often evolve into rhythmically propulsive, cyclical figures, very much akin to some of Philip Glass's music, particularly Glassworks (1982). Where Muhly differs most powerfully from Gopnik's loosely defined “minimalism” is in his fine ear for melodrama. The music in Two Boys rises and falls, swells with emotion, climactically explodes, and falls silent in shock, accompanying and punctuating the narrative in a more or less traditional way.
Vocal music makes up a significant portion of Muhly's oeuvre. Next to Glass, the most common referent in his work is the Anglican choral tradition (indeed, there is an Anglican church service in Two Boys), and yet with one exception I found myself primarily captured by orchestral material, for example the gorgeously pensive repeating harp line that underscores the testimony of Brian's parents in Act I. The most exciting vocal writing in the opera, and also its musical centerpiece, is undoubtedly the representation of the internet itself, which Muhly effects with an experimental use of the chorus. He wisely avoided anything too literal in this depiction, saying he “didn't want it to look or sound like TRON.”Footnote 3 There are no electronics in the orchestra; rather, the chorus vocally represents the feel of the internet by deploying a shimmering fabric of overlapping texts and motives. Snippets of conversations periodically rise above the sea of unintelligible sibilants only to fade away, replaced by other snippets. Sometimes the sound builds up into a Ligeti-like, dissonant trembling; at other times it is heard distantly, a gentle rumble underneath “real-life.” Muhly has worked with this kind of unintelligible vocal shimmer before—primarily on his 2009 album Mothertongue—but here it is used as a metaphor: the way the individuals sing their own unrelated texts, yet are also unified by their joint harmonic movement, is like the internet, which simultaneously isolates us and brings us together. It serves a powerful dramatic function as well: as the plot thickens and Brian's online experiences slowly change from innocently fun to baffling and scary, so does the sound of the internet. At first the overlapping voices seem largely benign—chanting “when can i c u?” or “u coming over?”—and their underlying harmonies are peaceable. However, as Brian is sucked further into Jake's web of deception, the chorus begins voicing the darker side of the internet, muttering lines like “Looking for a well built 18–30 year old 2 b slaughtered then consumed,” and interrupted by jarringly dissonant orchestral blasts à la Bernard Herrmann's score for Vertigo (another tale of a man driven mad by disguised identities).
The vocal performances on this CD are, as a rule, excellent. I found the juxtaposition of the two vocal types playing Jake to be quite poignant—the vigorous, adult tenor of Idealized Jake giving way to the fragile soprano of the doomed Real Jake. Alice Coote, with her rich, nuanced mezzo-soprano, however, is the standout.
