The intersection of art and politics has intrigued philosophers ever since Socrates described his beautiful city, the kallipolis. Modern political philosophers have been especially drawn to aesthetics, in which they see a potential solution to two problems endemic to modern politics: alienation and the limits of rationalism. In the first case, these philosophers recognize that modern liberal democracies, characterized by bureaucratic legalism and economic calculation, fail to capture our imagination or focus wayward longing. The result is a citizenry increasingly disenchanted with and distant from a political order they perceive to be both corrupt and recalcitrant. Modern aesthetic theorists like Friedrich Schiller argue that a shared culture of artwork could provide the kind of social cohesion necessary yet often lacking in modern polities. In the second case, modern liberal democracies, rooted in the hopeful project of modern Enlightenment rationalism, depend on universal norms of human conduct, yet are unable to establish or justify the necessity or universality of these norms. Modern philosophers like Nietzsche turned to aesthetics to circumscribe or replace Enlightenment rationalism as the foundation for these norms. Thus Nietzsche calls for an “aesthetic justification of existence,” in which the shared experience of beauty, not pure reason, grounds a culture's beliefs and values.
Diego A. von Vacano's book, The Art of Power, largely addresses this second issue, that is, the limitations of Machiavelli's rationalism. Much of his book consists of extensive explication of Machiavelli's and Nietzsche's texts, with the largely negative aim of undermining Enlightenment rationalism. Von Vacano argues that both Machiavelli and Nietzsche reveal that the world is neither intelligible nor controllable by reason alone. Nature is harsh and indifferent to its human inhabitants, and, because everything is in flux, reason cannot establish universally binding and stable principles. At best, humans can attain only partial glimpses of this constantly shifting world.
Yet while little of von Vacano's critical project could thus be said to break new ground, underlying it is a second, more constructive project, one that is far more unusual and exciting. The author does not focus on the role of art and beauty in making human life endurable in an indifferent world. Rather, he recaptures the more comprehensive meaning of “aesthetics” as the study of “worldly, corporeal basis of our understanding,” with vision as the most important worldly sense (2). The author thus offers a unique aesthetic political theory, one intended to address the very different reality of our modern age. Von Vacano observes that the increasing prevalence of visual phenomena, like twenty-four-hour cable television coverage, has profoundly transformed the way modern citizens understand politics. Our political judgments are increasingly based on visual stimulus, on spectacle or appearance.
Yet rather than representing an outright break with the political aesthetics of the past, von Vacano argues that the contemporary obsession with spectacle is only a more exaggerated version of a phenomenon Machiavelli and Nietzsche identified in their writing. Von Vacano notes that both these thinkers reveal the subtle ways statesmen employ the art of appearance to deceive, misrepresent, and appeal to emotion (147ff). For von Vacano, such manipulation is the only means individuals possess to cope with the tragic limitations of human effort. In such harsh conditions, heroic individuals arise who strive with all their effort to give sense to an apparently senseless world. Since the world resists rationalist moralizing, these individuals must act in “amoral” and even “immoral” ways (49) by employing dazzling appearance and spectacle.
Von Vacano's book deserves praise for a few reasons. First, the author succeeds in bringing out this visual aspect of aesthetic political theory. This aspect is especially illuminating of our political life as images such as the Abu Ghraib photographs are becoming ever more central to our self-understanding. Second, von Vacano's chapter 3, “Nietzsche's Machiavellianism,” is useful for its analysis of nearly all of Nietzsche's explicit references to Machiavelli.
At the same time, the book faces a number of problems. First, although aesthetic political theory can help explain our contemporary visual world, von Vacano does not clearly or rigorously develop such an explanation. It is not enough to say, as he does, that statesmen use the art of appearance in order to navigate their people through uncertain times. We know this already. What von Vacano owes us—and what he does not deliver on, despite the rich resources in Nietzsche in particular—is an account of why human beings respond so deeply and profoundly to spectacle. For Nietzsche, as for Machiavelli, spectacle enthralls us because we are deeply moved by deeds of human excellence that stretch the limit of human ability. A presumptive aesthetic political theorist would have to probe deeper into what the standard of this human excellence—the noble or the beautiful in Nietzsche's term—consists in, what distinguishes this standard from the moral “good and evil,” and what qualities of human psychology justify its claims.
Von Vacano, however, fails to ground the standard of the noble or beautiful largely because the view he attributes to Machiavelli and Nietzsche—a reductivist, existentialist view in which little more than mere survival means anything—prevents him from distinguishing qualitatively between nobility and baseness. In particular, the author relies on an interpretation of Nietzsche's “perspectivism” as a kind of egalitarian “relativism” (172). Yet such relativism must ignore Nietzsche's incessant claims of a “rank ordering” of human beings based on excellence of soul. A clear instance of this problem is von Vacano's discussion of “taste,” which he understands in terms of “pleasure and enjoyment” (155), not “sophistication” (154), again, overlooking Nietzsche's own explicit distinguishing of democratic from aristocratic forms of taste. In the case of Machiavelli, von Vacano is unable to account for his clear preference of Cesare Borgia over the excessively cruel Agathocles (51), a preference that Machiavelli grounds in Borgia's noble use of cruelty.
Second, many of von Vacano's interpretations of Machiavelli's and Nietzsche's texts are too often insufficiently supported and sometimes in tension with one another. For example, he argues that Zarathustra embraces the religion of the Ass Festival in book four of Zarathustra, but provides little evidence for his claim. Rather, Nietzsche seems clearly to be satirizing the “higher men's” insurmountable need for a religious idol, here, a bleating Ass. Von Vacano bases his interpretation in part on the argument that the religion of the Ass is supposed to “displace” the “valuation of one's will” (125), the last vestige of Christianity. Yet von Vacano also argues elsewhere that “Nietzsche exalts subjective experience” (94). How can Nietzsche simultaneously exalt and displace the subjective will?
A final problem has to do with von Vacano's prescriptive philosophical claims. It is not clear how his aesthetic political theory can help guide contemporary politics, as he wants it to do. A reasonable interpretation of the consequences of his aesthetic political theory is one he cites, that it may “dangerously foment immorality” (183). I find little indication that an aesthetic political theory will be quite as “humble” as von Vacano claims (183), especially given his focus on the heroically immoral individuals Machiavelli and Nietzsche praise. His answer to this charge is that aesthetic political theory can find an “affinity with consequentialist ethics” (183). The author unfortunately does not elaborate on how this marriage would work. Ultimately, if von Vacano would have spent more time analyzing the ways that we come to appreciate artistic beauty in common—rather than focusing on irreconcilable “perspectival” differences of private taste—then perhaps we could see more clearly how an aesthetic political theory can help us live together in an incompletely rational world.
