This important work dealing with the impact of British Indian colonialism on early 19th-century Afghanistan (1809–42) is divided into two three-chapter parts. The book begins with an examination of the intellectual foundations of British knowledge about the country established by the 1809 Elphinstone mission and a discussion of how that template structured colonial action culminating with the debacle of the first Anglo–Afghan war (1839–42). Attention to the discursive construction of Afghanistan flows into a critique of the standard “Great Game” narrative that largely denies local agency in the imperial contest between Great Britain and Russia. A chapter focusing on the role of Ranjit Singh and the Sikh empire in mediating Anglo–Afghan relations that is designed to fill a local gap in Great Game historiography concludes the first part of the book. The second part starts with a discussion of Afghan politics and Pashtun culture. This is followed by a consideration of the social organization of the transit trade through Afghanistan and colonially inspired changes in the North Indian economy that are positioned against transformations in the global economic order. The final substantive chapter of the book develops a typology of cities comprising the Afghan trade corridor.
The introduction and conclusion perform their tasks well, and the six body chapters are effectively organized and proportional. Readers benefit from a useful collection of historic maps, but the short glossary is of limited value. The great worth of this book is its use of a wide array of British colonial archival sources housed in the United Kingdom (India Office Records, British Library, Public Records Office, Royal Asiatic Society, and Royal Library of Scotland), India (National Archives of India), and Pakistan (Punjab Provincial Archives). The author engages a substantial volume of primary-source materials and draws on secondary literature dealing with modern Afghanistan, colonial India, and global imperialism to build a series of arguments about this important period in local, regional, and world history.
The most significant argument of the book, presented in Chapter 1, is that the archival and published records resulting from the first British delegation to Shah Shuja led by Mountstuart Elphinstone established a colonial framework of knowing Afghanistan that shaped political action through the first war and in fact well beyond that conflict through to the present. What is termed the Elphinstonian episteme produced a limited understanding of Afghanistan that has remained largely in place and unassailable until the present, effecting local cultural transformations in the long run. The argument posits the following causal relationship between the nature of colonial knowledge and the failure of imperial action in the country. Elphinstone's mission provided an understanding of Afghanistan based upon the cultural and political dominance of Pashtuns who act in accordance with the Pashtunwali tribal code and exclusive genealogies that serve to define their segmented world relationally. The British political agenda for Afghanistan intended to replace a polity based on competing, mobile suzerainties and genealogical space with one organized around a single, grounded sovereign power ruling over a discrete territorial place. The failure of the first colonial project in Afghanistan resulted from British Indian inability to transcend the limitations of its conceptions of Afghan society on the one hand and to temper the expectations of its transformative aspirations for Afghanistan on the other. Subsidiary claims about colonial knowledge leading to local cultural transformation and changes in Afghan self-perception over the longer historical term after the failure of the first war are underdeveloped.
Chapter 2 offers a fresh reading of the Great Game. Here readers find the British strategic preoccupation with the Russian imperial threat to be a minor component of the Great Game. Much more significant were the ground-level activities and interactions generated by an ideology of free trade and an attempt to articulate the bifurcated political and territorial frontier at the core of the Forward Policy that evaporated with the demise of the occupation Army of the Indus. Approaching the Great Game from below the geostrategic tier highlights deficiencies in the intelligence networks of the East India Company (EIC) insofar as Afghanistan is concerned. The third chapter returns to the grave failure of the company's information order to explain the decimation of the Indus Army, however the primary foci here are a trifurcated set of Anglo–Sikh–Afghan relations that were constructed around new modes of war. The new modes of war, marketed by European and North American mercenary contractors, eroded the traditional market for Afghan cavalry and the land grants that supported them in kind and introduced new fiscal regimes to underwrite the expensive imported rifle and artillery technologies and the associated, increasingly ubiquitous sepoy infantry soldieries who were paid in cash.
Discussion of the normative ordering of the Afghan political community in Chapter 4 draws attention to the important role of cities and the influence of Persian language and culture more broadly in this tribal environment. There is a heavy reliance on secondary sources, and among the body chapters of this book this one makes the least use of archival data. The thrust of this chapter echoes a popular but problematic ascription of moral incoherence to Pashtuns, who are caricatured as unable to transcend the incompatibilities and divisions of tribe, Islam, and the state. There is scant attention to the cultural substances, or lack thereof, to buttress this limiting view of Pashtuns. Perhaps of most significance, readers are regularly exposed to invocations of and references to Pashtunwali as a normative index, but they do not benefit from descriptions and analyses of the values informing Pashtunwali, or how Pashtunwali is expressed, or the operation of sanctions for deviance from its expected behavioral patterns. This cultural hollowness is especially conspicuous when treatments of politics are hinged on the practice of Pashto or not (note that Pashtuns distinguish doing Pashto [Pashto kawul] from speaking Pashto [Pashto wayel] and having Pashto [Pashto laral]). This chapter may raise more questions than it answers about the Pashtun identity of Afghan politics.
Chapter 5 offers a composite view of the Afghan transit economy that was marginalized by British Indian colonialism. Hindki, Shikarpuri, and financiers from other Indian backgrounds organized in widespread networks of family firms were primary handlers of credit that involved the use of hundis or bills of exchange (known as hawalas in Afghanistan). These merchant groups also handled cash-currency transactions that were becoming increasingly defined by the EIC's silver-based rupee. Afghan merchants in urban settings, both Pashtuns and non-Pashtuns, and nomadic communities, particularly Ghilzai and Lohani Pashtuns (it should be noted that most genealogies identify Lohanis as Ghilzais) involved in the export of fruit, horses, and military labor lost the sustenance traditionally provided by North Indian markets to the EIC. The latter's rise to power involved transformations in both consumption patterns across the subcontinent and global silver flows to the detriment of the Afghan political economy. Hopkins finds the Afghan transit economy to be representative of other frontiers on the periphery of global capitalism. The Afghan economy can be modeled as a case study of larger global processes occurring elsewhere on the margins of colonialism and imperialism such as in the Balkans, Levant, and Sudan. Chapter 6 is designed to do just that and is organized around descriptions of a set of cities that are addressed as ideal types, highlighting certain functions such as production, consumption, transit, or exchange. The routes between these cities could and did change, but mobile commercial resources nevertheless continued to be a vital source of revenue for urbanized political authorities who remained vulnerable to the elusiveness of the commercial caravans animating the rural zone.
Although the book speaks to local, regional, and global levels, the regional level receives the most robust and effective consideration. Attention to global processes and a comparative inclination effectively complement the dominant regional narrative while some local cultural features, including language use and the social organization of kinship, are treated without substantial rigor. The shortcomings of this book are clearly surmounted by the strengths of the work as a whole. It is a must read for all those interested in modern Afghanistan, but students of Iran, South Asia, colonialism, and imperialism will also find considerable value in it. This provocative volume establishes Afghanistan as a product of British colonialism, which marginalized yet remained influenced by its own untenable creation during the formative 1809–42 period. Brief forays beyond that time frame into the late 19th century and the present succeed in prompting readers to apply the historical and analytical lessons learned from the temporal focus of this book to subsequent colonial encounters in the country. Readers will have ample material to weigh as they consider the predicates behind the prospect that if Afghanistan is unable to wrest its tribal self back from a colonial constitution, it will continue to appear as an entity granted political life only to avenge its past by undoing its maker.
