Modern Western religious sensibilities tend to draw a fairly sharp boundary between the spiritual and the sensual. At first glance, this seems to be the case in Islam as well. By examining the effects of human sexuality on ritual purity, Zeءev Maghen convincingly demonstrates that this was not the case in early Islam. His study is divided into two major sections. The first examines early Muslim attitudes toward sexual activity and desire as evidenced by the Qurءan, hadiths, and legal literature and how later scholars have reinterpreted this material. The second focuses more specifically on mulāmasa and ṭahāra (cross-gender physical contact and ritual purity, respectively).
In chapter 1, Maghen demonstrates that early Muslims were not inhibited in their discussions of human sexuality. Sex is a blessing (Qurءan 5:87 and 7:32) both here and in the hereafter. According to several hadiths, Muhammad prohibited celibacy (or at least monasticism) and—as long as the sex is licit—encouraged his followers to enjoy this blessing. Maghen argues that, although sexual activity negates ṭahāra and, therefore, requires ghusl or wuḍūء (major or minor ablution) before prayer, sexual activity is not inherently impure or defiling. The neutral nomenclature suggests that, like urination, defecation, regurgitation, bleeding, and sleeping, sex is merely “prayer precluding.”
The remaining chapters in part I show how the early harmony between piety and carnality in Islam has been upset. Abdelwahab Bouhdiba in his La Sexualité en Islam (1975) had argued that ṭahāra is indicative of Islam's strong division between the spiritual and the sexual, suggesting that the latter was considered impure and close to evil. Maghen takes issue with these conclusions in chapter 2, showing that Bouhdiba had used sources that were unrepresentative of Islam and poor in quality and quantity. Chapter 3 discusses the infamous story of Zayd and Zaynab, which has been used to attack Muhammad and Islam. Zayd was Muhammad's adopted son, and he divorced his wife Zaynab, whom Muhammad subsequently married. Maghen deftly traces how the story, which initially depicts a very human Muhammad, evolved into one in which he is utterly devoid of romantic and erotic attraction; this asexual depiction is still promulgated by modern Muslim apologists, whether in scholarly works or on the Web. Chapter 4 argues that Rosenthal's use of adab literature is not the best source, at least in the case of Muslims, to attempt to construct social realities. The Qurءan, hadith, tafsīr, and fiqh together provide a better insight into popular attitudes toward sexuality.
Part II delves into one specific issue, mulāmasa (literally, “touching another”), a term derived from Qurءan 4:43 and 5:6, both of which enjoin Muslim men who have “touched” women and cannot find water to use clean dirt before prayer (tayammum). The fiqh arguments revolve around the meaning of “touch.” For the Hanafis, “touch” is a euphemism for sexual intercourse, and so requires ghusl. Merely touching has no effect on ṭahāra. For the Malikis, Shafiעis, and Hanbalis, “touch” is read literally and so requires wuḍūء to regain ṭahāra. Having introduced the legal issues in chapter 5, Maghen turns in chapter 6 to arguments used by both sides based on the Qurءan, including the philological and syntactical arguments from the Hanafis and the counterarguments from al-Shafiעi. Chapter 7 outlines the arguments that draw on materials from the Sunna. The Hanafis try to show instances of Muhammad having touched women before or during prayer without performing wuḍūء, whereas the other schools attempt the opposite. The inventiveness of the jurists is remarkable as they argue about the differences between active and passive touching and the role of intention, as they invoke abrogation or an exception for Muhammad, and in one case as they suggest he was wearing socks when his feet were touched by עAءisha. Chapter 8 explores Hanafis' use of raءy on this issue.
Chapter 9 returns to the issue of the importance of the laws of ṭahāra and what they can tell us about actual Muslim practice. Maghen states, “Purity practices are woven into the fabric of Muslim existence: they are integral and indispensable element[s] in the rhythm of daily life” (p. 218). His evidence that fiqh al-ṭahāra does in fact reflect social history comes from historical texts, literature, and the Internet. This is clearly the weakest link in Maghen's argument, and to his credit, he realizes that his study can be seen as an essentialist analysis, and he is careful to use words such as “assume” and “speculation.”
Chapter 10 explores the source of the impurity or preclusion from prayer that mulāmasa causes, an issue particularly salient given the Maliki, Shafiעi, and Hanbali position. That women must also perform ghusl or wuḍūע and so achieve ṭahāra suggests that they cannot be inherently impure. Maghen argues that the preclusion is caused by shahwa (passion or erotic desire). This is an explicit position of the Malikis, but is implicit with many Shafiעis too. Maghen further illustrates his arguments by briefly discussing the legal arguments about homosexual contact; direct contact versus contact through various types of clothing; the touching of hair, teeth, and nails; and the touching of the dead. Maghen may be understating the role of bodily fluids and gases in causing the preclusion. Urination, defecation, flatulation, regurgitation, and bleeding all involve substances that cause impurity. Therefore, just as sleeping negates ṭahāra, because one cannot be certain that gas was not passed, so shahwa may negate ṭahāra, because one cannot be certain that pre-ejaculatory fluids were not present. Maghen cites several jurists who make this very point.
Maghen provides a fascinating look into the close connections between Islamic sexuality and spirituality. Given modern prejudices, contemporary scholars (Muslim and non-Muslim alike) might be taken aback by his conclusions. However, he has argued his case thoroughly and forcefully. That he accepts hadiths at face value (with only passing references to issues of authenticity) does not ultimately detract from his depiction of early Muslim jurists' openness to discuss sexual matters and to portray their prophet as a sexual being. Virtues of the Flesh is a refreshing look into early Islamic law, both for its subject matter and its approach.
