Alessandro Roncaglia is Professor of Economics at the University of Rome La Sapienza and a member of the Italian Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei. He is a distinguished exponent of the modern Classical approach to the theory of value and distribution, based on the standpoint adopted by the old Classical economists, long “submerged and forgotten since the advent of the marginal method” (Sraffa Reference Sraffa1960, p. v) and eventually rescued from oblivion by Piero Sraffa’s Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities (1960). This collection of essays provides a fitting tribute to the man and the scholar on his turning seventy.
Besides a preface by the three editors, the book has sixteen chapters and is rounded off by a bibliography detailing Roncaglia’s scientific production updated to June 2017, a list of contributors, and a name and subject index. The various essays are written by leading experts of the field and witness the scope and breadth of Roncaglia’s scientific interests, ranging from economic theory and policy to the history of economic analysis and political thought.
The opening chapter by Salvatore Biasco briefly recalls the main analytical and methodological features of an approach to economic theorizing alternative to the so-called mainstream and akin to that adopted by Roncaglia in his lifelong scientific career. At the cost of some simplification, the remaining fifteen chapters may be arranged into five groups. Accordingly, we have three ‘Sraffian’ chapters, by Geoffrey Harcourt, Heinz Kurz and Neri Salvadori, and Nerio Naldi; six chapters devoted to various theoretical and historical items, mainly but not exclusively focusing on Classical economists, by Marcella Corsi and Carlo D’Ippoliti, Peter Groenewegen, Gianni Vaggi, Cosimo Perrotta, Bertram Schefold, and Alfonso Sánchez Hormigo; four chapters related to economic policy and broad policy issues, by Jan Kregel, Mario Tonveronachi, Michele Salvati, and Davide Antonioli and Paolo Pini; and two chapters concerning the oil market and the economics of natural resources, by Maria Cristina Marcuzzo and Annalisa Rosselli, and Sergio Parrinello. Some chapters consist of a summing up of the author’s previous contributions on the issue under scrutiny while others provide fresh material.
In the Sraffian chapters a common feature of Kurz and Salvadori’s and Naldi’s contributions is their meticulous examination of textual evidence coming from Sraffa’s unpublished manuscripts kept at the Wren Library of the Trinity College, Cambridge, UK. Naldi focuses on the development of Sraffa’s efforts in writing down the equations of his 1960 book and evaluates Pierangelo Garegnani’s views on the evolution of Sraffa’s interpretation of Classical economists in the 1920s. Kurz and Salvadori discuss the famous “snapshot” metaphor employed by Roncaglia (Reference Roncaglia1978) to characterize Sraffa’s price systems, verify on which occasions Sraffa used it himself, and compare it with another metaphor that Sraffa actually employed: “man from the moon.” According to Kurz and Salvadori, the two metaphors are part and parcel of the same research project Sraffa was keen to develop since the late 1920s: an objectivistic approach to the theory of value and distribution. The two metaphors help elucidate a few methodological issues concerning the threefold relationship among “economic reality,” “the economist/observer,” and “economic theory.” Within Sraffa’s objectivistic approach, in fact, the economist/photographer is an active agent who deliberately chooses both the perspective from which to shoot the photo and the time when the trigger button is to be pushed; this implies that “the photographer already has an idea of the object to be caught and seeks to catch it when it materializes” (p. 115). Moreover, the photographer has the responsibility to decide when, according to the specific object to be analyzed, a single snapshot must be replaced by a sequence of pictures. Similarly, the man fallen from the moon on the earth is not a passive spectator of flows of commodities consumed and commodities produced: he performs a series of mental operations to calculate the exact prices at which the various commodities must be sold if production is to start anew and a uniform rate of profit is to obtain.
The third Sraffian chapter is by Harcourt. Harcourt recalls Roncaglia’s threefold classification of Sraffian scholars into Smithian, Ricardian, and Marxian (see Roncaglia Reference Roncaglia2000). Paolo Sylos Labini, Roncaglia’s mentor and maestro, and Roncaglia himself are taken to belong to the first school; Kurz and Salvadori are considered neo-Ricardians; while Garegnani is the leading exponent of the Marxian current. Harcourt sides with the Marxist interpretation that, in his view, is potentially able to provide a bridge between Sraffa’s price theory and Richard Goodwin’s and Michal Kalecki’s cyclical growth models. Yet, Harcourt does not miss to criticize the proponents of the long-period method, Garegnani as well as Kurz and Salvadori, since all of them “have never been able to incorporate the two most characteristic sustained and persistent forces—an inescapable environment of fundamental uncertainty and continuous technical change—into their formal analytical structures” (p. 91). The issue of the theoretical limits of the long-period method is a fascinating one that, for obvious reasons, can’t be tackled here. It suffices to recall that Sraffa, in his 1932 review of Friedrich Hayek’s Prices and Production, clarified that the issue of agent’s expectations can’t be avoided in the analysis of disequilibrium situations (more on this issue in Signorino Reference Signorino2001). It is to be hoped that an in-depth scrutiny of Sraffa’s unpublished manuscripts will provide scholars with fruitful insights on how to model agents’ expectations along Sraffian lines. In the meantime, the proponents of the long-period method appear to be on firm analytical grounds when they choose to put the analysis of the issues of fundamental uncertainty and continuous technical change outside what, according to Garegnani (Reference Garegnani1984), constitutes the ‘core’ of the surplus approach to the theory of value and distribution.
In the historical chapters, Corsi and D’Ippoliti focus on John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty in order to compensate, so to speak, Roncaglia’s neglect in his 2005 book on the history of economic ideas. They show how Mill’s ideas may still be valuable within a liberal socialist world view that can be set against present-day triumphant conservative liberalism. Groenewegen fills a lacuna in Anne-Robert-Jacques Turgot’s scholarship concerning the latter’s analysis of the division and specialization of labor. Perrotta proposes a reassessment of the underconsumption thesis within Classical economics; Sanchez Hormigo describes the troubled diffusion of Smith’s ideas in early nineteenth-century Spain; Vaggi starts from the contribution of one of Roncaglia’s favorite Classical authors, Sir William Petty (see Roncaglia Reference Roncaglia1985a), to sketch the history of the notion of agricultural surplus and the theory of wealth up to Adam Smith and shows its relevance for contemporary development economics. Schefold’s highly technical chapter reconsiders the Walras–Morishima model in the perspective of the Cambridge controversy in the theory of capital.
In the ‘economic policy and polity’ chapters, both Kregel and Tonveronachi focus on the ongoing financial crisis and investigate its remote and proximate causes and its likely outcomes. Kregel points to the theoretical foundations of what he calls “market fundamentalism” and its internal contradictions that, in his view, render it useless, or even misleading, as a basis for sound economic policy. Kregel reconstructs the history of the economic theory of market and market prices in terms of “homogeneity” and “diversity.” In this perspective, financial markets are considered as ideal types of perfectly competitive markets because of their capacity to supply homogeneous and standardized products to individual agents characterized by different risk/return preferences and different price expectations. For Kregel, the present-day financial crisis is the result of the failed attempt by contemporary financial engineers to create a homogeneous mortgage asset, notwithstanding the huge diversity and idiosyncratic nature of the underlining mortgages.
Tonveronachi claims that post-crisis reforms of the financial regulatory framework have mainly tended to mend and not to change drastically the previous situation. Since the structural weakness of the latter are, for Tonveronachi, among the triggers of the financial crisis started in 2007 with the US subprime meltdown, prospects for the future of financial stability are anything but bright. For Tonveronachi, the financial regulatory framework is deeply influenced by the economic model that mainstream economists consider relevant for the explanation of the ‘normal’ functioning of real-world economies and their dynamics. Put briefly, financial laissez-faire is the natural consequence of an economic theory based on the dogma of free-market efficiency.
Democracy and its crisis is the subject of Salvati’s chapter. He claims that the history of democratic states shows that democracies have always been, more or less, in a state of crisis, since their ideal of equality—equal political weight for each and every citizen—has always proved unattainable. Yet, the present-day crisis of democracy, particularly in European countries, has some specific and alarming features due to low growth, persistently high unemployment, increasing wealth inequality, disappointed hopes of steady social progress, and waves of apparently endless and unregulated immigration. Hence, populistic-demagogic and even extreme right political parties are presently gaining electoral consensus in various European countries, thus jeopardizing the way to a full-blown federal European state endowed with a genuine parliament and a sense of “fraternity” among all European citizens.
The final chapter on economic policy issues is by Antonioli and Pini. The two authors discuss the impact of the European fiscal architecture on European countries at the periphery in the wake of the present-day financial crisis. Their main contention is that fiscal austerity has not delivered the expected outcomes in terms of GDP growth and debt-to-GDP ratio: European crisis-hit countries have not significantly reduced the latter, while their growth performance is disappointing. Moreover, the two authors show that labor market flexibility may be detrimental to labor productivity dynamics and advocate a 180-degree turn in European economic policy, particularly as regards industrial, innovation, and labor market policies.
Two chapters are devoted to natural resources economics. Starting from Roncaglia’s analysis of the oil market (Roncaglia Reference Roncaglia1985b), Parrinello argues that Sraffa’s equations in chapter 11 of Production of Commodities (“Land”) may be used as the basis of an original analysis of the prices of production and the rent/royalty paid for the use of oil. The chapter by Marcuzzo and Rosselli provides readers with a vivid reconstruction of a fascinating and still little-known aspect of John Maynard Keynes’s intellectual history and personality: Keynes’s dealings in the tin market. Keynes was at one and the same time an economist, a speculator, and an investor. Marcuzzo and Rosselli show how Keynes’s approach to trading in tin and tin-related assets in the interwar period may be assessed as if he consciously made use of the analytical categories developed by him in his Treatise on Probability (1921). In particular, “Keynes’s approach to trading was based on evaluation of the amount of information available for each individual commodity and the degree of uncertainty about the future course of the main factors underlying it. Collection of the ‘relevant information’ available was the premise to evaluating the ‘weight’ of any argument that could be inferred from it” (p. 181).
To conclude, the book is worth reading by two distinct but possibly overlapping types of readers: those interested in the history of economic analysis and political ideas, and those dissatisfied with mainstream economics and willing to give a chance to the modern revival of Classical economics.
