Decades before President Dwight Eisenhower signed the legislation that would fund and build the long-simmering Interstate Highway system, and even before the Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1921 created the first federally funded interstate highways, there were a handful of experimental and pioneering efforts to build long-distance interregional highways. The two best-known and most successful of these proto-highways were the Lincoln Highway, which stretched from New York to San Francisco; and the Dixie Highway, a loop that extended from Miami to Michigan and back again. This latter project, built over more than a decade after being initially proposed in 1915, is the focus of Tammy Ingram's fine new book, Dixie Highway: Road Building and the Making of the Modern South, 1900–1930.
A growing body of scholarship has tied the American road-building movement to the broad national contexts of economic development, political change, corporate lobbying tactics, mass migration to the suburbs and the sunbelt, urban decline, and environmental degradation. In this increasingly robust historical narrative of highways, automobiles, politics, and human resettlement across the continent, the story of the Dixie Highway has often been an aside, but never the topic of an in-depth treatment. Tammy Ingram has stepped into this breach, unearthing and retelling the details of this important story—and in so doing she gives readers an up-close look at the particular brand of progressive reform politics that emerged in the modernizing South, and its opponents. At its core, this is a book about state and local politics in the South.
The Dixie Highway was not a single road-building project. Rather, driven by a fluid roster of boosters—local politicians, businessmen, real estate developers, hotel operators, auto industry entrepreneurs, and road-building contractors—it was a stitched-together set of county, state, and local roads that shared signage and marketing, ultimately linking emerging tourist destinations in Florida with parts of the Deep South, the Eastern Mississippi valley, the industrial Midwest, and the Great Lakes region. The main mechanism for this coalition was the Dixie Highway Association, which—in addition to providing support for lobbying efforts at county governments, town halls, and state houses all along the route—circulated its own magazine, organized its own advertising and marketing campaign, and even published its own theme song. Behind closed doors, this was also the group that massaged local political deals and haggled over routing decisions, whenever possible wending their way past cooperative businesses and detouring around unhelpful political jurisdictions and freeloaders who wouldn't contribute to the effort. The central figure, throughout, is Carl Fisher, an auto-parts maker who had also been involved in the earlier effort to build the Lincoln Highway, learning from the successes and challenges faced by that project.
Ingram's book is readable, accessible, and clearly organized around a chronological narrative, divided into five digestible chapters, plus an introduction and conclusion. Geographically, even though the highway spanned the nation from the southern tip of Florida almost all the way to the Canadian border, Ingram has emphasized the portions in the South, especially Georgia. It is here, in these local Georgia cases, that the author most clearly tells the story of how the Good Roads Movement played a central role in the creation of modern Southern retail politics, becoming a partisan flashpoint. What began as a populist and agrarian groundswell of progressive reform, government-funded road building was artfully recast by Southern Republicans as a high-tax overreach by big government. The initial targets of their invectives were license and registration fees (“tag fees”), but soon gas taxes fell under the same umbrella condemnation. The surprise here, for some readers, will be that Southern-Republican rhetorical opposition to publicly funded infrastructure projects began well before the New Deal. This mismatch, between the high popular desire (and economic imperative) for new infrastructure and the low willingness to pay for it, is a recurrent feature of modern American politics. Dixie Highway offers a valuable addition to our understanding of the historical roots of this dynamic, and its place in local political debate, especially in the South.
The author argues that the story of the Dixie Highway is also at the center of the story of the Interstate Highway System, that Carl Fisher's project should be seen as the first aborted attempt at an Interstate Highway system that was finally carried out by Eisenhower. In this regard, this book is somewhat at odds with much of the recent scholarly literature on the topic. The prevailing argument has been that the model used by Fisher to build the Dixie Highway was one of two competing models that had emerged in the years before World War II. The other, which also harnessed powerful private-sector partners, but was more formally structured, officially anchored by federally funded technocrats in the Bureau of Public Roads and State Highway Departments, funded by big corporations, and formally sustained by legislated federal mandates, was the model that prevailed and later culminated in Eisenhower's Interstate Highway System. In contrast, as Ingram's own analysis shows, the Dixie Highway Association ultimately died under the weight of insurmountable conflict, dependent as it was on the informal and wholly voluntary cooperation of state, county, and local governments. The great contribution of this book is not that it shows us the early roots of the modern highway system, but rather gives us an eye-opening understanding of the path not taken.
Dixie Highway is a fine addition to the growing body of scholarship shedding light on Americans’ relationship to the automobile, a relationship that is often mistakenly cloaked in obscuring marketing slogans and cultural mythology of “the Freedom of the Open Road” and “The American Love Affair with the Car.” These constructs persist in popular American culture, even as a more complex and complete story emerges through books like this one and its predecessors. Tammy Ingram has done a great service, adding more depth and detail to an important chapter of the big story. Scholars of early twentieth-century American history in general should take note, especially those interested in the local and Southern roots of the new partisan divides that would subsequently tear apart the national political scene.
