Intangible cultural heritage (ICH), its recognition and preservation have become buzzwords of cultural policy in much of the world over the last twenty years, in particular since UNESCO’s designations in 2001, 2003, and 2005 of “Masterpieces of the Oral and Intangible Heritage of Humanity.” As a result, analysis and critique of preservation policies and practices have generated a plethora of scholarly publications. This volume, which succeeds in moving beyond simply revisiting well-worn themes, arose in part from a symposium held in London in 2014 with Japanese and British support. All authors trained and/or work in British or Japanese institutions (p. x); most are ethnomusicologists, but three historical musicologists and one composer/musicologist add disciplinary variety.
Following the editors’ introduction, the volume is divided into three sections: “Representing Music Heritage,” “Safeguarding Music Heritage,” and “Repositioning Music Heritage,” each containing four essays. The first chapter, by musicologist Anthony Pryer, covers basic historical and theoretical contexts for the concept of “musical heritage” and international efforts at “safeguarding,” with particular reference in the latter case to UNESCO. The exposition grounds the following eleven case studies. A magisterial “Afterword” by Keith Howard embeds the phenomenon of heritage preservation in international political, economic, and social developments of the last seventy years.
Unsurprisingly, given East Asia’s pioneering role in ICH preservation since 1950, the region provides four of the book’s case studies. Simon Mills (Chapter 5) analyses the fortunes of four Korean shamanic ritual traditions designated as cultural properties by the country’s long-running ICH system; Min Yan Ong (Chapter 6) describes the de facto exclusion of amateur performers from official preservation strategies for China’s UNESCO-listed Kunqu opera; David Hughes (Chapter 7) compares seven Japanese folk songs in various states of health, some officially recognised by national or lower-level governmental organs, some not; and Hwee-San Tan (Chapter 10) investigates the efforts of local officials in two areas of southeast China to implement government ICH directives. All four essays are extremely well written, drawing on years of research and emphasising the views of tradition-bearers and on-the-ground officials. One gets a vivid sense of being there and witnessing the stories unfold.
Two more essays address traditional musical genres; as with the East Asian examples, both feature in-depth field research. Lara Pearson (Chapter 11) convincingly explains why, amidst the thriving South Indian classical music scene, two iconic instruments, the plucked lute vina and double-reed nagasvaram, are declining. Caroline Bithell (Chapter 9) sets out the lively world of polyphonic folksong (another UNESCO-anointed “Masterpiece”) in post-Soviet Georgia, where top-down and grassroots initiatives co-exist and interact, while foreign enthusiasts have helped make the songs a transnational phenomenon. Maybe because I have witnessed this in Georgia first-hand, I found Bithell’s chapter especially compelling.
An unusual feature of this volume is that three case studies revolve around facets of Western art music: discarded improvisatory traditions in early romantic piano concertos, with the suggestion that their resurrection could enliven modern performances (Rohan Stewart-MacDonald, Chapter 8); the “reciprocity between gagaku and modernist music” (275) (Rica Narimoto, Chapter 12); and, intriguingly, a comparison of the 2001 UNESCO “Masterpiece” l’opera dei pupi, a Sicilian puppet theatre, with early opera, which nobody would think of proposing for such a programme, despite their similarities (Naomi Matsumoto, Chapter 2). All three subjects invite productive questions about genre and conceptual boundaries.
Most pathbreaking for this reader was the inclusion of two essays on the role of film in documenting heritage and assisting transmission of traditional performing arts. Publications on ethnographic film are legion, but focused discussion of its place in these contexts is rare. Barley Norton (Chapter 4) analyses the role of audiovisual documentation in UNESCO’s ICH designation system, describing in detail a filming trip he witnessed in Vietnam to document two folksong genres for inscription in the Representative List, together with the cultural politics that influenced the final product. Terada Yoshitaka (Chapter 3) vividly outlines two film projects he and colleagues from the National Museum of Ethnology in Osaka undertook, one over 1999–2000 on endangered Cambodian shadow puppet theatre, the other in 2008 on kulintang music in Mindanao. Terada emphasises the role audiovisual media can play in both transmitting performance skills and cultivating audiences. He highlights the efforts his team made to render the films useful to the originating communities by working with native scholars, producing native-language editions, organising screenings, and conceiving of filmmaking as a collaborative process.
This edited volume has many strengths. It includes novel material alongside more familiar topics, and case-studies are thoroughly researched and well written. Numerous quite well-reproduced photos are an asset, as are the links authors provide to online audiovisual examples. Some essays could have done with more attentive proofreading (e.g., at the top of p.6). The geocultural ground covered—essentially Asia, plus Western art music, plus Georgia—is perhaps somewhat quirky, though hardly a problem. The book will be most accessible to scholars and graduate students in ethnomusicology, anthropology, and Asian studies.
