This two-volume set is part of the Intellectual Legacies in Modern Economics series. It contains articles which are about the economics of Michał Kalecki or which extend the Kaleckian approach. It also contains selections from Kalecki's own writings that are relevant to each of the sections into which the volumes are subdivided. After an opening section devoted to pieces that present some of the key distinguishing aspects of Kalecki's economics, the volumes then offer sections on the following topics: Effective Demand, Investment, Profits, and National Income; Pricing and the Degree of Monopoly; Cycles and Growth; Political Economy of Full Employment; Money and Finance; Taxation; Socialism; and Development.
Readers familiar with Kaleckian economics will see the appropriateness of these categories. Those who are less familiar with Kalecki should note that the first topic in the list depicts the key concerns in Kalecki's approach to macroeconomics, while the second topic offers Kalecki's “microfoundations” of macroeconomics, which have to do with imperfect competition. The remaining categories should be rather self-explanatory, other than the idea of “political aspects of full employment,” which refers to Kalecki's political economic arguments about why “Keynesian” policies should not be used to establish a state of continuous full employment.
If one wanted to present a coherent picture of Kalecki's work and its importance, of course one would want to write a book, as Malcolm Sawyer, the editor of this collection, has already done (Sawyer, Reference Sawyer1985). If one wanted to appreciate Kalecki's work by looking at the most important articles in the Kaleckian tradition, one could do that by reading this book. Those not already familiar with Kalecki would I believe find these two volumes valuable. They are of course worthwhile for those of us who are working within the Kaleckian approach or on issues to which the Kaleckian approach speaks. Indeed, in reading the book to do this review, I myself discovered a couple of articles of which I hadn't been aware that have been very helpful to some of my work. The collection can also aid in advising grad students who are interested in becoming more familiar with or working in the areas covered.
For the most part, I believe that Sawyer's choices of what to include in the volumes was very good. (I have to acknowledge that one of these was written by Steve Fazzari and myself.) Including selections from Kalecki himself assists in making each specific section complete. That is, a reader can see in each section Kalecki's original ideas and conclusions and then the work done to extend those results or to pursue questions raised there or to debate different perspectives relevant to the issues.
In Volume I, Part I the reader gets an overview of Kalecki's approach and a picture of the differences between his approach to macroeconomics and that of John Maynard Keynes, such as Kalecki's insistence on a dynamic treatment of investment and his emphasis on the importance of distribution between and differential spending out of wages and profits. Differences and controversies between the Kaleckian approach and that of the neo-Ricardians and neo-Marxians are also presented there but occur again in many of the articles in the rest of Volume I. The discussions of the determinants of investment, the significance of income distribution between wages and profits in Kalecki's macro framework, Kalecki's pricing theory, and Kalecki's cycle and growth theory in the rest of Volume I contain very valuable and useful articles, including pieces by A. K. Dutt, Marc Lavoie, and Peter Kriesler, who are well known for their contributions on these topics.
The section in Volume II, Part I on money and finance is underdeveloped, mainly because Kalecki's ideas on these topics were never offered as a unified theory. In a later article Sawyer (Reference Sawyer2001) has collected and organized Kalecki's thoughts on money and finance. The most valuable work so far that might be seen as extending Kalecki in the area of finance is probably contained in Jan Toporowski (Reference Toporowski1993, Reference Toporowski2000), though this goes well beyond Kalecki's own work. (If I may also plug my own work in this area, see Mott, Reference Mott, Mántey and Levy2007.) Toporowski (Reference Toporowski2005) has some valuable chapters on Kalecki on finance, which came out too late to be included in this collection.
Volume II, Part II on taxation gives the basic thrust of Kalecki's insights through the inclusion of Kalecki's original taxation paper and A. Asimakopulos and J. B. Burbridge's classic extension of this. I find, however, that the papers by Anthony Laramie and/or Douglas Mair, with other authors at times, are often presented in a somewhat confusing framework that can make the conclusions drawn misleading. Maybe I am prejudiced here, but I like my article with Ed Slattery (Mott and Slattery, Reference Mott and Slattery1994) on this topic better. In any event, Kalecki's arguments that support taxing capital income rather than labor income should be of interest in today's economic climate where we often hear the opposite advocated.
The section on “political aspects of full employment” (Vol. I, Part V) contains pieces that raise particularly interesting issues. Many economists working in post-Keynesian or neo-Marxist traditions are familiar with Kalecki's original 1943 paper, but not enough I think are familiar with the other three articles offered in this section, which are able not only to bring in a deeper discussion than that of the 1943 paper but, in the last two articles in the section, to examine matters from the perspective of 30 to 45 years later.
I found the sections of the book on Kalecki's work on the socialist economy and on economic development the most interesting, probably because I previously knew the least about them. The articles in Volume II, Part III on socialism seem to me to present what I had heard about Kalecki's major propositions in this area and to clarify my brief understanding of them. Though these ideas are implicit or explicit in the articles which precede it in this book, Wlodzimierz Brus's article notes that Kalecki's battle with established dogma in the Soviet and Eastern European conceptions of socialism was on two fronts—(1) against the doctrine favoring the production of investment goods over consumption goods and (2) against the reaction to central planning that arose that called for the widespread use of markets in these economies. That is, Kalecki believed that planning could lead to economic performance that avoided the macroeconomic problems he identified in capitalism without creating the problems that the emphasis on producing capital goods to make capital goods that had arisen in the 1930s Soviet Union had led to in postwar Eastern Europe. Rather than embracing enterprise autonomy as a counterweight to excessive centralization, which he thought would re-create the problems of capitalism or create distributional problems incompatible with socialism, Kalecki advocated the use of workers’ councils as ways to improve efficiency on the plant level and to increase democracy in the workplace, and this book contains an article of his own on this topic. After we have a longer time perspective, we may well find that Kalecki's ideas are rather valuable for our understanding of the Soviet and Eastern European model of socialism.
The final section, on development economics, begins with an article “The Problem of Financing Economic Development” by Kalecki, which is a summary of his 1953 lectures in Mexico City and presents many of Kalecki's main propositions concerning economic development. Later the book contains two articles by E. V. K. Fitzgerald which present Kalecki's ideas on financing development, formalize them, and extend and critique them to some extent. The second article in the section is by Kalecki on what he called “intermediate regimes,” underdeveloped countries ruled by the lower middle class and rich peasantry in the era of the Cold War, and later there are two papers by others on this type of economy.
Kalecki's main concern regarding economic development, which is also seen in his work on the socialist economy, was how to transfer labor and capital into productive investment without unduly squeezing the real incomes of peasants and workers. An emphasis on distributional concerns and their relevance to macroeconomic performance is also the hallmark of Kalecki's work on the developed capitalist economy. There are others who have worked in this vein, but Kalecki is almost certainly the most significant. I recommend readers not familiar with Kalecki's economics to read this book so they might see economics done from such a perspective, which is largely absent from mainstream economics today.
