Through the study of the “Ladies' Commissions” of Turkey's Refah Party, the main Islamist political party of the 1990s, Arat examines the ways in which the role and status of Islam in the secular, liberal-democratic system in Turkey is negotiated and transformed. She argues that, despite the polarization and antagonism between Islamists and secularist circles, there is nevertheless a tight interconnection that serves as the potential basis upon which a mutual accommodation of differences and a possibility for reconciliation may emerge. According to Arat, the Islamist women activists of the Refah Party are transforming secularism as well as Islam in Turkey by successfully merging liberalism and Islamism.
Even though several books have appeared on the issue of Islam, its public visibility, and its relation to women in Turkey—including those by Nilufer Gole, Meyda Yegenoglu, Alev Cinar, and partially by Yael Navaro-Yashin—this book is unique in that it provides an insight into the discourse and self-conceptualizations of a unique group of Islamist political activists gathered around the Ladies' Commissions of the Refah Party. Based on interviews and case studies, Arat provides a firsthand account of the lives, thoughts, and views of these women that goes far beyond the superficial and quite biased image that is attributed to them popularly by the secular media.
After providing a brief account of the significance of women in public life and politics in Turkey, Arat outlines the terms of the debate that erupted over the Islamic headcovering in Turkey in the 1980s, particularly from the perspective of women. She illustrates that, while secularist circles, especially feminists, accused Islamist women of upholding traditionalist, patriarchal values that serve to subordinate women, Islamist women in turn accused secularist feminists of being elitist, alienated toward women's actual conditions and lives in Turkey. Islamist women seem to have a point when we consider that no secular–feminist group has been nearly as successful as these Islamist activists in mobilizing women at the grassroots level in such mass numbers.
As Arat demonstrates later in the book, the success of the activist women of the Refah Party in rallying votes from among women in large cities, particularly during the 1994 local elections—a success that was acknowledged equally by secularist and Islamist circles—was to a large extent due to their ability to reach and communicate with a large group of women in lower income sections of cities at the grassroots level. Arat illustrates that the success of the Ladies' Commissions in mobilizing women was due to their visiting a large number of women in their homes; listening to their needs and problems, which were mostly material and economic; communicating these concerns to the party; and conveying to the women that the Refah Party was willing and prepared to meet these demands. Arat argues that the women activists of the Refah Party became the intermediaries for women at the grassroots level who otherwise had no way of having their concerns heard in the public and political spheres.
In support of her argument that these Islamist women activists are successfully merging Islam with liberalism, Arat shows how they consistently upheld and appealed to a discourse of liberalism and individualism in defending their position as Islamist women and in justifying their activity among the ranks of the Refah Party, rather than appealing to Islamic justifications and Qurءanic stipulations. In another example that Arat gives, however, it is possible to see how Islam still maintains its presence in this quite liberal discourse of the women of the Refah Party. She notes that, in the meetings of the Ladies' Commissions, guidelines, policies, and plans are read in a messianic tone and that their meetings have a rather ritualistic quality, suggesting that, even though the content of their discourse does not make any Islamic references, the unique ways it is presented and articulated convey a sense of a holy mission, as if serving Allah and serving the party's interests converge. Unfortunately, Arat does not elaborate on the significance of these observations in relation to the ways in which Islam is reinserted in quite subtle ways into public discourse and political activity embedded within a seemingly liberalist discourse.
Arat concludes that “in the context of Turkish secularism, liberalism infiltrated Islam” and Islam in turn “expanded the reach of liberalism and deepened its practice” (pp. 113–14). In other words, according to Arat, this unique presence of Islamist women in the public sphere is changing (liberalizing) Islam from within, thereby serving to negotiate a space wherein a possibility for reconciliation between Islamism and secularism may emerge, thus contributing to the expansion of liberal democracy. However, such an important argument deserves further elaboration and clarification, which Arat does not provide to show exactly how the Islamist discourse is liberalized and the secularist discourse transformed.
As Arat herself mentions, the demands of these women activists of the Refah Party for active positions in the administrative ranks of the party were rejected. Indeed, none of these activists was given a post in the administrative body of the party, even though the party recruited several women from among secular circles who did not wear headcoverings. This finding suggests that the party has resisted the change that these women activists might have brought about in party ideology and programs. Arat's work would have been more complete (and presented in a lengthier book) had she offered a more thorough observation and analysis of the ways in which the party's ideology has indeed been transformed by the activities of the Ladies' Commissions. In addition, Arat's claim that secularism is also transformed by such activities remains insufficiently developed as well. Even though I have no doubt that this claim is correct, it would have been much better founded had Arat illustrated the exact ways in which the secularist discourse of liberal democracy in Turkey has been transformed to make it possible for an Islam-based political party to function effectively in politics, as in the case of the Justice and Development Party (Adalet ve Kalkinma Partisi), which came to power in 2002 as a majority government.
