Introduction
On September 23, 2002, the Belgian law on euthanasia came into force. This makes Belgium the second country in the world (after the Netherlands) to have an act on euthanasia. Even though there is currently a legal regulation of euthanasia in Belgium, very little is known about how this legal regulation could be translated into care for patients who request euthanasia. Although euthanasia-related mortality rates in Belgium are low, ranging from 0.30% to 1.20%, it can be expected that caregivers will increasingly be confronted with euthanasia requests and will, therefore, be more involved in the care for these patients.Footnote 1
In this paper, we present a relational personalist approach, based on a Roman-Catholic view of mankind, to the care of patients who request euthanasia.Footnote 2 Crucially important is the palliative filter procedure. The aim of the palliative filter is to assure that all pertinent caregivers (physicians, nurses, palliative care experts) inform one another about the euthanasia request and about all palliative care alternatives: The care for a patient requesting euthanasia should include a consultation with a specialized palliative care team in order to consider the real needs of the patient. The palliative filter makes explicit how medical and nursing expertise could effectively be employed in the interdisciplinary care context, so that the competent, terminally ill patient who requests euthanasia receives the best human care available. Requests for euthanasia from incompetent persons (advance directive) or from persons who are not terminally ill—which are also regulated by law—fall outside the scope of this paper. Restricting the palliative filter procedure to requests for euthanasia from competent, terminally ill patients permits us to develop a more focused procedure. Before sketching the palliative filter procedure and its integration in a personalist ethics, some relevant aspects of the Belgian euthanasia Act must first be clarified.
Belgian Euthanasia Act
According to Article 2 of the Belgian Act, euthanasia is defined as intentionally terminating life by someone other than the person concerned at the latter's request. The Act determines that the physician who performs euthanasia commits no criminal offence when he has reassured himself that all conditions are fulfilled and when he has respected the conditions and procedures as provided in this Act (Article 3, Section 1):
- The patient has attained the age of majority or is an emancipated minor and is legally competent and conscious at the moment of making the request.
- The request is voluntary, well considered, and repeated and not the result of any external pressure.
- The patient is in a medically futile condition of constant and unbearable physical or mental suffering that cannot be alleviated, resulting from a serious and incurable disorder caused by illness or accident.
Article 3, Section 2, contains a very detailed description of the requirements that have to be respected by the physician who performs euthanasia:
- Inform the patient about his or her condition of health and life expectancy; discuss with the patient his or her request for euthanasia and the possible therapeutic and palliative courses of action and their consequences.
- Be certain of the patient's constant physical or mental suffering and of the durable character of his or her request.
- Consult another physician about the serious and incurable character of the disorder and inform him or her about the reasons for this consultation; inform the patient about the results of this consultation.
- Discuss the request with the nursing team or its members.
- Discuss the patient's request, if the patient so desires, with relatives designated by the patient.
The physician who has performed euthanasia is requested to fill in a registration form and to deliver it within 4 working days to the Federal Control and Evaluation Committee (Article 5). No physician may be compelled to perform euthanasia. No other person may be compelled to assist in performing euthanasia (Article 14). The Euthanasia Act contains some sections concerning requests for euthanasia from incompetent persons (advance directives; Article 4, Sections 1–2) and from persons who are not terminally ill (Article 3, Section 3). These sections fall outside the scope of this article.
A Relational Christian Anthropology as Background
Roman Catholics in the context of modern pluralist societies have to confront the major challenge of modern pluralism. One of the probable reasons for the unique position of the Netherlands and Belgium in the context of euthanasia may be the unfortunate translation of “respect for autonomy” as “self-disposal” (zelfbeschikking). This implies the suggestion that the human person may decide freely about life, body, and death and consequently also request euthanasia as an exercise of his or her basic rights. A Christian-inspired anthropology questions this one-sided interpretation of respect for autonomy, which limits the understanding of freedom in terms of pure self-disposal concerning life and death. For a Christian, humanity as well as the exercise of human freedom is much richer, and human autonomy implies the full realization of a human person's relational and social character.Footnote 3
A Christian-inspired anthropology avoids the one-sidedness of the absolutized autonomy approach. It considers the human person as essentially decentralized without being alienated. We opt for a conception of autonomy in which an integral role is ascribed to the relation between people in terms of solidarity and responsibility. In this way, one can do justice to the fact that, in the final phase of their lives, people often go through an entire process in which they must constantly make hundreds of small and large decisions designed to make the end of their lives more dignified. To a significant extent, this process is based on a balance between autonomy and mutual dependence, not only on individual self-determination. Vulnerable dependence and self-assured autonomy must be recognized as equal and mutually interwoven aspects of human existence. This interpretation of autonomy as a value that can only develop fully in a relational context takes account of the fact that there are always degrees of autonomy (no one is fully autonomous) and that people make choices in consultation with others.
We fully endorse the Roman Catholic teaching against euthanasia. The major argument that also must be accessible for a pluralist society is, in our view, the affirmation of the relational and caregiving dimension of human existence. As also indicated by Jewish philosophers such as Martin Buber and Emmanuel Levinas and by the Protestant ethicist Paul Ricoeur, one's responsibility to the other binds us to accompany the other fully in the process of his dying. Admitting the helplessness of human beings before death, we can only give our caring presence to the dying one. This relational interpretation of responsibility for the dying patient and the dignity of the dying process has inspired the palliative care movement and other caring initiatives for dying patients.
One issue still remains to be clarified: Even in the best palliative care, it may be possible to be challenged by tragic situations, the so-called casus perplexus or, more legally, the “state of necessity,” where, despite a careful implementation of palliative measures, the physician is faced with a conflict of conscience when the patient's suffering (and the euthanasia request deriving from it) does not diminish. In these dramatic situations, euthanasia may be the lesser of two evils.
Palliative Filter Procedure for Euthanasia Requests from Competent, Terminally Ill Patients
The starting point of the palliative filter procedure is the principle that everything possible should be done to provide support to the competent, terminally ill person who requests euthanasia and his or her relatives. It is, therefore, recommended that every dying person should have the right to expert medical and nursing care in the framework of dignified care (bodily, mental, social, and existential). The recognition of this basic right can best be ensured by setting up a structure and a culture of palliative care.
We support the general opinion that good palliative care is considered to be a sine qua non of euthanasia, for the problem of the control of suffering still remains.Footnote 4 What then has to be done? The first thing to do is to try to present the occurrence of those situations for which euthanasia has been suggested by anticipating their onset and forestalling their development.Footnote 5 The second thing is to make available to terminal patients all the methods of relief and control of distressing symptoms that are now available.Footnote 6 Finally, it must be recognized that the care of the patient and the relief of his or her suffering are never purely medical concerns, and we must thus provide for his or her physical, mental, and spiritual well-being by involving all the caring professions in an effective and sensitive approach to the patient and his or her family in order to support them in their situation of need.Footnote 7 For this reason, the consulting physician needs to appeal, at an early stage, to the expertise of a specialized palliative support team in order to discuss the palliative possibilities and to apply them in a way that alleviates the patient's suffering as much as possible.Footnote 8
When it becomes clear that a terminal patient's pain and distress cannot be adequately combated using “normal” palliative methods, the technique of palliative sedation could be taken into consideration.Footnote 9 In the context of palliative care, palliative sedation refers to “the intentional administration of sedative drugs in dosages and combinations required to reduce the consciousness of a terminal patient as much as necessary to adequately relieve one or more refractory symptoms.”Footnote 10 Palliative sedation is only considered when one is confronted with a refractory symptom that causes the patient enormous suffering and prevents a dignified death. A symptom can be considered refractory to treatment when it cannot be adequately controlled in spite of every tolerable effort to provide relief within an acceptable time period without compromising consciousness.Footnote 11 The most frequent reasons for inducing sedation are delirium, dyspnea, and pain,Footnote 12 but also psychological symptoms can be considered as refractory.Footnote 13 Recently, a nationwide study on the evolution of end-of-life practices in the Netherlands made it clear that physicians consider palliative sedation as an alternative to euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide.Footnote 14
When Termination of Life Is Requested
Attentively Listening to a Request for Euthanasia
A request for euthanasia is, in the first place, a signal that the patient gives to elucidate his or her views toward being ill, the physical pain, the possible deterioration that can come, and the hopeless character of the situation. Each euthanasia request must, therefore, be open to discussion even if, medically speaking, the actual dying is still far away. It is essential that caregivers show their willingness to listen to the patient who requests euthanasia while, at the same time, ensuring that the euthanasia decision of the patient is based on an autonomous, free, and informed choice. To this end, the following questions should be posed:Footnote 15
• What motivation lies at the ground of the request for euthanasia? Is this really a request to put actively an end to his or her life, or is the patient asking for caring guidance in the last days or weeks of his or her life?
• Does the patient have sufficient information (e.g., diagnosis and prognosis) on the grounds on which he or she makes the request?
• Is the patient mentally competent at the moment when making the request?
• Has the patient discussed the euthanasia request with other people?
• Does the patient make the request voluntarily? Is there no question of any form of coercion or pressure?
Listening to a Request for Euthanasia by Means of the Palliative Filter Procedure
It would be contrary to the guidelines concerning care for a dignified end of life if a request for euthanasia were to be ignored by the physician when medical decisionmaking takes place. On the other hand, however, the patient's request is, by itself, a necessary but not sufficient condition for initiating euthanasia. We emphasize—even more than the Belgian legislation does—the importance of adequately implementing palliative possibilities. What is aimed at by the palliative filter procedure is that palliative possibilities are investigated and that all involved thoroughly consult each other on the euthanasia request as well as the remaining palliative possibilities. The palliative filter procedure contains the following steps:
1) The concrete possibilities of palliative care are thoroughly discussed by the attending physician with the healthcare institution's palliative support team:Footnote 16
• What diagnosis and prognosis can one give of the illness?
• What suggestions can one make in relation to the treatment of the symptoms?
• What treatment alternatives can one still offer the patient?
2) The patient is completely informed by the attending physician about all aspects of his or her health situation and about the existing possibilities for palliative care. In these cases, the patient will be provided with the palliative support team's recommendations and the patient will explicitly be given an opportunity to consult the palliative support team. In every case, it must be communicated:Footnote 17
• To whom the patient can go with questions.
• What sort of care the patient can expect.
• What happens if the patient can no longer make his or her own decisions.
3) If the patient so desires, the physician will discuss the euthanasia request with friends and family as the patient designates. Hereby the following questions can be addressed:Footnote 18
• How do the relatives view the situation of the patient?
• What information about the illness and about the prognosis is known to the relatives?
• What knowledge do they have about the palliative possibilities?
• What position do the relatives take when they hear about the request for euthanasia?
• How can the relatives of the patient be supported?
4) The attending physician will thoroughly discuss the euthanasia request and the patient's situation with the nursing team:Footnote 19
• The nurses must know that eventual involvement with euthanasia can never go further than nursing tasks.
• The nurses must know where they can cope with the emotions that a euthanasia request can bring along with it.
• The nurses must know that they have the right to follow their conscience with regard to the request for euthanasia and eventually to make a conscientious objection.
The procedure just described shall guarantee that all terminal patients will be offered good palliative care. The aim is that the palliative filter procedure function as a preventive measure with respect to euthanasia requests.
If the Euthanasia Request Persists
The experience of palliative support teams shows that such an active and integral approach (palliative care including palliative sedation) can, in many cases, displace the euthanasia request and allow the patient to die in a dignified manner without euthanasia. The palliative filter procedure functions as an adequate preventive measure regarding euthanasia; it offers the best guarantees for adequate protection of the human person, as it reduces the number of persistent euthanasia requests to a strict minimum (the so-called states of necessity or casus perplexus). After the introduction of the palliative filter procedure, palliative sedation seems to function as an extremely valuable alternative to euthanasia, reducing states of necessity to an absolute minimum. If, in rare and exceptional cases, such states of necessity occur, the physician may be faced with a dramatic conflict of conscience. In these extremely dramatic situations, we respect the decision made in good conscience by the physician.
Discussion and Conclusion
The debate on euthanasia in Belgium leads us to believe that caregivers will increasingly be confronted with euthanasia requests and will, therefore, be more involved in the care for these patients. With this palliative filter procedure, we try to contribute to greater transparency and clarity of policy regarding clinical practice. This initiative could be considered within the increasing need for written policies and practice guidelines about medical decisions concerning the end of life, which is in line with the general tendency toward developing guidelines in modern medicine. Some of the reasons mentioned for the usefulness of written guidelines are that they may be helpful as a practical guide in work, define the responsibilities of caregivers, and serve as a cornerstone for quality.Footnote 20 It is only recently that the need for practice guidelines on handling requests from patients for euthanasia has gradually received international recognition.Footnote 21 A recent study revealed that 63% of Flemish hospitals had a written ethics policy on euthanasia.Footnote 22
Although this procedure is in the first place practice oriented, the clinical application of this procedure makes clear that the fields of medicine, ethics, and law are intertwined. Caregivers will use this procedure to improve the quality of the care for patients who request euthanasia. But the decisions caregivers make at the end of life are not purely “medical” but also “ethical” decisions. Questions of human dignity, meaningfulness, and quality of life transcend the clinical discourse and require an ethical judgment. As the act of killing remains for Christians a transgression of the norm “Thou shall not kill,” we presented in this paper the palliative filter procedure as an adequate preventive measure regarding euthanasia. We have described the ethical justification of the palliative filter procedure elsewhere.Footnote 23 Finally, concrete clinical practice, and the accompanying ethical decisionmaking process, will be influenced by the legal perspective, which focuses on what one has to do in order not to be prosecuted. Most of the points that have been taken up in the palliative filter procedure are also present in the euthanasia law. The importance of the procedure, in terms of clinical practice, lies in the way that an effort has been made to integrate the purely legal testing of the euthanasia request in a wider ethical framework concerned with death with dignity. In this way, the decisionmaking process gets less of a bureaucratic character and is instead seen in terms of a clinical–ethical dialogue. In such a process of clinical–ethical decisionmaking, the three perspectives—clinical, ethical, and legal—cannot be separated from one another. To the contrary, clinical competence, ethical awareness, and legal regulation permit caregivers to be “skilled companions” for patients who request euthanasia, a companion who is willing to encounter the patient as a person, to ascertain his or her needs, and, together with the patient, to seek the most dignified answer in an interdisciplinary context.
The style of ethical argumentation that is used in this procedure is referred to as “clinical ethics.” In clinical ethics, the focus is on the ethical aspects of the factual clinical situation with attention to the patient's expectations, experiences, and so forth, as well as the professional and personal experiences of the caregivers. To make this procedure relevant for clinical practice, where possible, experiences of experts are integrated. More concretely, the palliative filter procedure is based on the expertise of the Flemish Palliative Care Federation (a pluralistic organization that unites all Flemish palliative care services).Footnote 24 This organization has been involved proactively in the debate on the contents of the euthanasia law in Belgium, highlighting that if euthanasia can ever be justified, it is necessary to provide good palliative care for all and to include in the euthanasia law a palliative filter, that is, a compulsory prior consultation with a specialized palliative care team. Besides this contribution of the Flemish Palliative Care Federation in the development of this procedure, we were confronted with a lack of empirical studies that describe the experiences of caregivers concerning their involvement in the care for patients who request euthanasia. More specifically, apart from the Netherlands,Footnote 25 studies regarding caregivers’ experiences with clinical practice guidelines in terminal care were nonexistent. Caregivers who speak based on their own experience can focus attention on important aspects of the contents and the functions of guidelines in end-of-life care. Further research into the use of the palliative filter procedure and its contribution to the care for patients who request euthanasia is, therefore, needed. Research in the Netherlands found that compliance with the guidelines on euthanasia or assisted suicide, if present, is quite high.Footnote 26 The reported high rate of compliance with the euthanasia guidelines is possibly explained by the fact that euthanasia involves a practice with considerable implications, and the guidelines can actually offer support to the physician.
The starting point of this palliative filter procedure is the principle that everything possible should be done to provide support and assistance to the competent, terminally ill person who asks for euthanasia and that person's relatives. The aim is that such an active and integral palliative care approach can displace, in many cases, the euthanasia request and allow the patient to die in a dignified manner without euthanasia. This means that healthcare institutions should conceive of palliative care as an active and integral approach employed in the case of every terminally ill patient. To interpret this argument in the right way, we have to refer to the developments in the field of palliative care in Belgium. The plea for the palliative filter procedure is only credible if a sufficiently strongly developed and accessible palliative care structure exists. In Belgium, the development of palliative care preceded the euthanasia debate.Footnote 27 As a result, Belgian palliative care (e.g., Flemish Palliative Care Federation) played a very active role in the Belgian euthanasia debate. The Belgian euthanasia debate itself functioned as a lever that facilitated the further development of palliative care, as is illustrated by the new law on palliative care that was approved at the same time as the euthanasia law. Because of a very fruitful cooperation between palliative care and the Belgian authorities, a unique, comprehensive, legal and organizational palliative care framework (palliative care at home, support teams in hospitals and nursing homes, palliative care units) was set up nationwide. This specific situation of palliative care in Belgium makes the main argument of this palliative filter procedure (prioritization of palliative care over euthanasia) a more realistic and plausible one. Because of the close interactions between the development of palliative care in Belgium and the Belgian euthanasia debate, one can conclude that theoretical arguments pro or contra (legalization of) euthanasia always have to be understood against the background of the development of palliative care in any particular country. In terms of Belgium and the Netherlands, the only two countries in the world with a euthanasia law, one could investigate to what degree national differences concerning the place of palliative care have had an influence on the content of the euthanasia debate.
Although the Belgian Euthanasia Act does not contain the palliative filter procedure as a due care criterion, our experiences since 2002 reveal that the palliative filter procedure has highly influenced both Catholic and non-Catholic institutions in dealing with euthanasia requests. The majority of hospitals restrictively applied the euthanasia law by introducing palliative procedures in addition to legal due care criteria.Footnote 28 However, it also became clear that the palliative filter procedure cannot provide an adequate answer to all clinical problems. A major problem remains with patients requesting euthanasia combined with a strong refusal of all kinds of palliative measures. In these cases, there is a willingness to provide palliative care, but the care is not received by the patient. As a consequence, the care process cannot be fulfilled. Another weak point of the palliative filter procedure is that it cannot be applied to euthanasia requests of non-terminally ill patients, although euthanasia, in this patient group, is regulated by law in Belgium.
