Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-wxvwp Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T12:08:20.542Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Diversity and Inclusion in the American Legal Profession: Discrimination and Bias Reported by Lawyers with Disabilities and Lawyers Who Identify as LGBTQ+

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  12 July 2021

Peter Blanck
Affiliation:
University Professor & Chairman, Burton Blatt Institute (“BBI”) at Syracuse University
Fitore Hyseni
Affiliation:
Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs, Syracuse University
Fatma Altunkol Wise
Affiliation:
Syracuse University
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Purpose

This article is part of an ongoing body of investigation examining the experiences of lawyers with diverse and multiple minority identities, with particular focus on lawyers with disabilities; lawyers who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (“LGBTQ+” as an overarching term); and lawyers with minority identities associated with race and ethnicity, gender, and age. The focus of this article is on discrimination and bias in their workplaces as reported by the lawyers experiencing it.

Methods

We employ survey data from the first phase of this investigation, gathered from the survey responses of 3590 lawyers located across all states in the United States and working in most types and sizes of legal venues. The data were collected between 2018 and 2019, before the 2020 pandemic. We estimate differences across three categories of discrimination reported—subtle-only discrimination, overt-only discrimination, and both subtle and overt discrimination. We estimate the nature and magnitude of associations among individual and organizational variables, and we use multinomial logistic regression to illustrate relative risks of reports of discrimination for intersecting identities.

Results

As compared to non-disabled lawyers, lawyers with disabilities show a higher likelihood of reporting both subtle and overt discrimination versus no discrimination. Similarly, lawyers who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, and queer (“LGBQ”) show a higher likelihood of reporting both subtle and overtdiscrimination, and subtle-only discrimination, as compared to lawyers who identify as straight/heterosexual. Women lawyers and lawyers of color are more likely to report all three types of discrimination. In general, younger lawyers are more likely to report subtle-only discrimination when compared to older lawyers. Lawyers working at a private firm are less likely to report all types of discrimination, while working for a larger organization is associated with a higher relative risk of reporting subtle-only discrimination versus no discrimination.

Conclusions

The current study represents a next, incremental step for better understanding non-monochromatic and intersectional aspects of individual identity in the legal profession. The findings illustrate that primary individual and multiple minority identities, as identified by disability, sexual orientation, gender, race/ethnicity, and age, are associated with reports of discrimination and bias in the legal workplace.

Information

Type
Special Issue Article
Copyright
© 2021 The Author(s)
Figure 0

Table 1.Descriptive Statistics

Figure 1

Table 2.Correlation Between Discrimination Types and Relevant Individual Characteristics

Figure 2

Table 3.Distribution of Discrimination Type by Individual Characteristics (Column Percentages)

Figure 3

Table 4.Determinants of Reporting Discrimination in the Workplace Among Lawyers (Multinomial Logistic Regression)

Figure 4

Figure 1.Predicted Probability of Reporting DiscriminationNotes: We use Average Adjusted Predictions (AAP) to calculate the expected probability of reporting discrimination. These numbers represent the average predicted probabilities that would be observed for a specific variable, all else remaining as it is in the data.

Figure 5

Figure 2.Predicted probability of reporting discrimination for all combinations of disability, sexual orientation, and gender (only men and women)Notes: We use Average Adjusted Predictions at Representative values (APR) to calculate the expected probability of reporting discrimination. Specifically, we compute the average predicted probabilities at representative values of disability, sexual orientation, and gender, all else remaining as it is in the data.

Figure 6

Figure 3.Predicted probability of reporting discrimination for all combinations of disability, sexual orientation, and race/ethnicityNotes: We use Average Adjusted Predictions at Representative values (APR) to calculate the expected probability of reporting discrimination. Specifically, we compute the average predicted probabilities at representative values of disability, sexual orientation, and race, all else remaining as it is in the data.

Figure 7

Figure 4.Predicted probability of reporting discrimination for all combinations of disability, gender (women and men only), and race/ethnicityNotes: We use Average Adjusted Predictions at Representative values (APR) to calculate the expected probability of reporting discrimination. Specifically, we compute the average predicted probabilities at representative values of disability, sexual orientation, and race, all else remaining as it is in the data.

Figure 8

Table 1A.Determinants of Reporting Discrimination in the Workplace (Multinomial Logistic Regression with Subtle Discrimination as Base Outcome)

Figure 9

Figure 1A.Predicted Probability of Reporting Both Types of Discrimination by AgeNotes: We use Average Adjusted Predictions at Representative values (APR) to calculate the expected probability of reporting discrimination. Specifically, we compute the average predicted probabilities at representative values of age (from 24 to 89), all else remaining as it is in the data.

Figure 10

Figure 1B.Predicted Probability of Reporting Subtle Discrimination by AgeNotes: We use Average Adjusted Predictions at Representative values (APR) to calculate the expected probability of reporting discrimination. Specifically, we compute the average predicted probabilities at representative values of age (from 24 to 89), all else remaining as it is in the data.

Figure 11

Figure 1C.Predicted Probability of Reporting Overt Discrimination by AgeNotes: We use Average Adjusted Predictions at Representative values (APR) to calculate the expected probability of reporting discrimination. Specifically, we compute the average predicted probabilities at representative values of age (from 24 to 89), all else remaining as it is in the data.

Figure 12

Figure 1D.Predicted Probability of Reporting no Discrimination by AgeNotes: We use Average Adjusted Predictions at Repsresentative values (APR) to calculate the expected probability of reporting no discrimination. Specifically, we compute the average predicted probabilities at representative values of age (from 24 to 89), all else remaining as it is in the data.