No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 22 November 2005
Between the early sixteenth century and the late nineteenth century there were two major waves of European penetration in Southeast and North East Asia. The first encroachment was a byproduct of the European oceanic exploration that ultimately brought the Americas under Spanish, Portuguese, French, British, and Dutch colonization. Between the early 1500s and the mid-1600s the Portuguese explored the Moluccas and seized Malacca, the Spanish took the Philippines, and the Dutch staked out an empire in the Spice Islands. In the wake of this assertion of military and commercial prowess, the great powers of East Asia—China and Japan—pulled in, limiting their contact with the Europeans and with each other, insulating themselves in cocoons of near autarky. The second encroachment followed on the heels of the Industrial Revolution, which vastly increased the firepower Europeans could muster in Asian waters. Great Britain spearheaded the second penetration, taking Hong Kong in 1842 on the heels of the first Opium War and negotiating the treaty port system on the coastline of China and its immediate hinterland. This forced China to open up to trade, in the process allowing Westerners the privileges of extra-territoriality in the designated treaty ports and constraining the country's capacity to impose tariffs on imports.
The volume edited by Kaoru Sugihara deals with the consequences of the second wave of European intrusion for Northeast and Southeast Asia. Its basic thesis is simple. In contrast to the Asian disintegration that followed upon the European penetration of the 1500s, Asian lands became increasingly integrated with one another following the establishment of the treaty port system in China and its spread to Japan after Commodore Matthew Perry opened Japan up in the early 1850s.
Why did the second European wave set off centripetal motion, the economic and political destinies of the Asian lands increasingly intertwining with one another, whereas the first wave fomented centrifugal motion? The authors of the chapters in the Sugihara volume provide four compelling answers: the use of steam power in transportation unleashed powerful migration streams, Chinese emigrants from Southwestern China moving in Southeast Asia in droves; Chinese merchants mainly based in Shanghai became especially adept at exploiting commercial opportunities in the treaty ports, both in China and in Japan, thereby creating a commercial network that transcended national boundaries; the successful harnessing of steam power in cotton textile manufacturing in Japan paved the way for the development of heavy industry in that country, thereby bolstering Japan's national income and its military muscle; Japan, emboldened by its military successes in wars with China and Russia, and thirsty for export markets for its rapidly expanding textile sector, secured a formal empire in Korea and Taiwan and an informal empire in coastal China, thereby paving the way for its war of aggression against China.
Part 1 of the volume—containing chapters by K. Furuta and N. Kagotani on the activities of the Chinese merchant community in Kobe and a chapter by T. Abe on the Chinese market for Japanese textiles—focuses on the role of the nascent steam-powered cotton textile industry in integrating the Chinese and Japanese economies between the 1880s and the late 1930s. Major themes developed in this section include documenting the acumen of Chinese merchants in exploiting the treaty port system, highlighting the importance of yen depreciation in the early 1930s in sustaining Japanese textile export capacity in the face of general depression in world trade, and discussing the push to substitute domestic textiles for imports that took hold in China during World War I and gained momentum during the 1920s and 1930s.
Part 2 of the volume picks up the theme of Chinese import substitution and economic nationalism introduced in Part 1. A chapter penned by A. Kuroda discusses the difficulties that Chinese entrepreneurs faced due to the collapse of the Chinese Imperial monetary system and the proliferation of regional currencies. A chapter by H. Goto-Shibata looks at the Chinese Nationalist government's campaign to boycott both Japanese imports to China and the products of Japanese factories situated in China, highlighting the economic drive to substitute domestic products for imports as well as the political drive to limit Japanese military and political meddling on the Chinese mainland. And a chapter by T. Kubo analyzes the impact the Nationalist Chinese government's renegotiation of tariff policy with the Western powers and Japan had on the success of import substitution in China. What emerges from this section is a sense that internal Chinese regionalism—centrifugal political and commercial disintegration—limited China's capacity to meet the growing military and commercial prowess of Japan.
Part 3 of the volume develops the theme of internal Chinese disintegration further. In a chapter on Chinese geographic dualism, Man-houng Lin argues that the treaty port system, coupled with relatively poor transportation linking the interior of China to its coastline, created two Chinas: a core that carried on extensive trade with Japan, Great Britain, and the United States, and a periphery that remained relatively poor and lacking in manufacturing prior to 1937, when Chinese industrialists moved their production sites out of the core that was quickly falling under Japanese military domination. A second chapter, by H. Kose, uses the scheme of Chinese regions developed by W. Skinner, that divides China into “macro-regions,” to discuss how foreign trade impacted different regions of China in profoundly different ways. Key to Kose's argument is the thesis that Shanghai lost some of its entrepot functions as foreign trade expanded, China becoming less internally integrated as a result of its surge in international commerce.
Finally, Part 4 of the volume deals with Chinese integration with Taiwan, under Japan's control from the late 1890s until 1945, and with Southeast Asia. The chapter penned by Man-houng Lin on Taiwan mainly deals with commercial and capital market integration between Taiwan and China, both when the Japanese ruled Taiwan and when they did not, while a chapter by K. Sugihara (the volume's editor) deals with Chinese emigration to Southeast Asia between 1869 and 1939.
In grappling with two of the great themes in late-nineteenth- and twentieth-century history—cooperation and conflict between China and Japan, regional integration and disintegration within China—this volume moves forward our understanding of the modern interaction of politics and economics. For this reason I recommend it to the readers of the Journal with enthusiasm and without reservation.