I arrived home from Australia at the start of the summer recess. I was told that the Prime Minister could not see me until the House sat again in the autumn but that the only qualification that Churchill insisted on for his junior Ministers was that they had served at some time during the war in the Armed Forces. I was fortunately able to satisfy this requirement by my short period of service in the R.A.M.C and the Intelligence Corps.
I finally met with Churchill on 1 November 1944, when I arrived at 10 Downing Street, I had to wait for an agonizing 15 minutes in the waiting room. The decor was heavily utilitarian and topical with four pictures by war artists, a stuffed platypus from the Australian Government,Footnote 354 and a bronze bust of Churchill himself. I was summoned by a Secretary to the Cabinet Room, and found the Prime Minister sitting alone in the middle of the long Cabinet table reading some papers. He seemed to expect me to start the conversation, so I congratulated him on how well he was standing up to his long journeys. He said he did not mind travel, and intended to go out to Australia as soon as the war with Germany was over.Footnote 355 He then told me that he would like me to go to the India Office as Under-Secretary; Lord Munster,Footnote 356 the present junior Minister at the India Office, would move to the Home Office, a very busy Department. My freedom from departmental business would give me plenty of time to assist Lord SalisburyFootnote 357 as Deputy Leader in debates in the House of Lords.Footnote 358
I started to thank him but he pulled me up quickly with ‘There is no need to kiss anybody's hand.’Footnote 359 A rhetorical note crept into his voice when he wanted to emphasise the need to keep the Coalition alive until the end of the German war, and the educational value to the Labour Party of its experience in the wartime Coalition. ‘The Country would benefit in time to come’, he said, ‘because the Labour Party, essential to our party system of Government, will have learnt an invaluable lesson from its wartime partnership’.
I could not have been more fortunate to find a Secretary of State as my boss who was no ordinary run-of-the mill politician. Leo AmeryFootnote 360 had long experience as a Cabinet Minister, after a brilliant academic career culminating in a fellowship at All Souls College at Oxford. As a firm believer in the value of the Commonwealth, he had an unrivalled knowledge of its leaders and their policies. The first question he asked me was whether there had been any political content in a message of greetings I had sent to Nehru,Footnote 361 when in prison, on his birthday. If my answer had been ‘yes’, I have little doubt that my life as an Under-Secretary would have ended there and then.Footnote 362 He then asked me to lunch with him at his home in Eaton Square where he told me that the average life of an Under-Secretary at the India Office was about 12 months, and expressed the hope, in which I heartily concurred, that I might be lucky enough to survive for a slightly longer period.
Leo's main contribution to my education was by allowing me to attend the meetings of the India Committee of the Cabinet, as an observer not as a full member, although I was allowed to ask questions. This Committee had been set up by Churchill in 1942, under pressure from Cripps after his return from Russia,Footnote 363 but I did not come upon the scene myself until January 1945. The India and Burma Committee, as it was officially known, was the powerhouse of Indian policy. Its members were chosen for their knowledge of India or their departmental responsibility for its affairs, and they had time for consideration and long discussion of matters of policy which was not possible at meetings of the whole Cabinet. Simon, Anderson,Footnote 364 Grigg,Footnote 365 Butler,Footnote 366 Amery, Cripps, with Attlee in the chair as Deputy Prime Minister, were all figures that had played a part in the history of India. They were a galaxy of talent such as seldom if ever before, since the time of the East-India Company, had sat around a table to decide the future of the sub-continent. I also obtained a liberal education in world politics, as my boss was one of the Ministers who received the Foreign Office Telegrams, reports to that Department from British diplomatic missions all over the world. Luckily for me, he always underlined the important telegrams with a red pencil, which lightened an otherwise extremely time-consuming task.
My duties in the Lords involved me in a lot of public speaking on subjects I knew very little about. As there are many fewer Ministers in the Lords than in the Commons, even the junior Ministers have often to speak for several Government Departments. I found myself the spokesman for the Ministry of Health and the Board of Trade as well as speaking on matters concerning the India Office. This was no mean task, as the Ministry of Health in those days included housing and local government among its responsibilities, and the planning of a post-war housing drive was a matter of burning public interest. Indeed, the rapid building of flats and houses at low rents, which had been halted by the war, and rendered even more urgent by the air raid damage to our great cities, was at that time the most pressing of our domestic problems. Lord Woolton,Footnote 367 at that time Minister of Reconstruction, put the case for the Government's housing proposals, and I on several occasions replied to his critics on the Opposition benches, having been an observer at the Cabinet Committee on Post-war Reconstruction. I also deputised quite often for my Leader, Lord Salisbury, when he was away on Government business. Some useful social legislation was passed in spite of Parliament's primary concern with the war effort, and I was proud to play a small part in the raising of the school leaving age, the introduction of family allowances, and the start of the mainly post-war housing drive.
A curious situation arose towards the end of my time as Deputy Leader. Lord Salisbury was chosen as one of the ministerial team to represent the U.K. at the drafting of the Charter of the United Nations at San Francisco. In anticipation of a fairly long absence from the House, he wanted to prepare me to take over while he was away. He had prepared for me an amusing and penetrating character sketch of each of his senior ministerial colleagues. Would that I had kept it! This was accompanied by much sound advice about the management of the House. But my temporary elevation was not to be. When this proposed arrangement for dealing with business during his absence reached the ears of Churchill, it was instantly vetoed. After all, Lord Woolton was a member of the War Cabinet, and a staunch Conservative in an almost completely Conservative Chamber, which made him obviously the best man for the job. There can be little doubt that Churchill was right. So I remained Deputy Leader, while Lord Woolton became Acting Leader of the House. This little episode illustrates the truth of the old saying that there is no love lost at the top in politics.Footnote 368
Early in 1945, after the end of the war with Germany, the Coalition Government broke up, and Churchill formed a Conservative caretaker Government, to tide the country over until the first post-war General Election. I tidied up my own office at the India Office, and bumped into my successor, Lord Scarbrough,Footnote 369 who had had some useful experience as Governor of Bombay, on the way out of the building. There was no need for a formal handover, so I just wished him good luck.
When the Coalition broke up, it was typical of Churchill's magnanimous personality to present each of his retiring Ministers from the various shades of the political spectrum with a bronze plaque: inscribed on one side with the words ‘Salute to the Great Coalition’ framed in a laurel wreath, and on the other, in my case, ‘Listowel from Winston Churchill’. The word ‘Great’ is not I think an exaggeration, when one considers what the Government did for us and for the rest of the free world.
When I look back on the wartime Coalition Government, I suppose it was one of the most gifted, remarkable, and successful Governments in our history. It was indeed a ministry of all the talents. The struggle for our national survival had united the parties, and brought the best men from every walk of life into the Government service. The outstanding personalities in all three political parties – Conservative, Liberal, and Labour – were in the Cabinet, which also included two of the most successful figures in the business world, Lord Woolton and Lord LeathersFootnote 370 who respectively had fed the Nation and organised the shipping which carried the food and other wartime necessities. The unity between the parties and the classes reflected the determination of public opinion in our mature democracy to present a united front to the forces of aggression that threatened our national survival.
I would like to include at this point a charming letter I received from Lord Salisbury after the general election in 1945, in reply to a letter I had written to thank him for his kindness to me as Deputy Leader in the Coalition.
Personal
My dear Billy (may I?),
How very nice of you to write me such a charming letter. It has given me immense pleasure. I have always been extremely conscious of my deficiencies as Leader of the House, so, though I am well aware that I do not deserve the kind things you say about me, it was none the less delightful to read them.
May I, in return, say how much I have enjoyed working with you. I feel sure that you have a big future in the House of Lords. Everyone likes you, which is half the battle, and if it is not impertinent for me to say so, your speeches as Deputy Leader have been quite admirable.
It will certainly be a large job for me to lead the Opposition. But you can be quite sure that, so far as I am concerned, there will be no fractious Opposition to the Government, and my impression is that that will be the view of the vast majority of their Lordships. Whether you have got the cure for all our ills I am not so certain; but at any rate the country has decided that they wish you to try your policy out, and if, for instance, you can find a solution to the housing problem, I should imagine that everyone, whatever their party, will breathe a sigh of relief.
At any rate I hope and believe that their Lordships’ criticisms – if they do criticise – will always be constructive, and we shall avoid any small wrangling.
Yours ever,
BobbetyFootnote 371
