For relatively privileged university students in the Global North, slow internet, dropped Zoom calls, and trouble logging in are the extent of their digital-access challenges. This article describes creating an opportunity for experiential learning to teach students in a privileged institution about “epistemic marginalization”—that is, the ways that people’s knowledge can be reduced to opinion or dismissed altogether. The course texts give students a grasp on the theoretical language that feminists of color have used to reveal and explicate these concepts (e.g., Dotson Reference Dotson2014). However, by incorporating experiential learning into the course through Wikipedia “edit-a-thons,” we provide students the opportunity to see, experience, and—in some cases—mitigate certain manifestations of epistemic privilege.
Through the same partnership that we brought to the classroom, we—Anasuya Sengupta, the co-leader of Whose Knowledge? (a campaign devoted to centering the knowledge of marginalized communities online, including on Wikipedia), and Brooke Ackerly, a professor of political science—describe the politics of knowledge (1) in the choice of Wikipedia, (2) in the system of editorial rules and practices of Wikipedia, and (3) in the development of edit-a-thons for pedagogy. The goal was an assignment that brought undergraduate and graduate students together outside of the classroom to learn how to identify, understand, and challenge the politics of knowledge, and—as a result of their efforts—experience the politics of knowledge when some of their edits were approved and others were rejected. The key pieces of the assignment were as follows:
-
1. Select a person or topic about which Wikipedia coverage is incomplete or biased.
-
2. Conduct additional research outside of the course material to be able to complete the three dimensions of the editing assignment (i.e., Nos. 3, 4, and 5)
-
3. Write a unique page or significantly edit an existing page.
-
4. Create links within the created page to existing pages.
-
5. Create “red-links” to other content that should have pages.Footnote 1
-
6. Attend at least one of two edit-a-thons to work with one other person on ideas for Nos. 4 and 5.
The goal was an assignment that brought undergraduate and graduate students together outside of the classroom to learn how to identify, understand, and challenge the politics of knowledge, and—as a result of their efforts—experience the politics of knowledge when some of their edits were approved and others were rejected.
This article explains the ways in which these pieces of the assignment together shaped a learning experience both about and within the politics of knowledge—a core concept of the courses involved.
Generally, Wikipedia edit-a-thons are organized events in which people interested in a set of related pages and topics edit together.Footnote 2 There are other ways to use the editing of Wikipedia in teachingFootnote 3 (see the contributions by Wilfahrt and Michelitch Reference Wilfahrt and Kristin2022 and by Norell Reference Norell2022 in this symposium). The article is organized in three sections. The first section, designed for use in a feminist class, is a theoretically informed understanding of the broader context of how historical and current structures of power and privilege play out in the design, editing norms, use, and experience of Wikipedia. We set this up in the theoretical work of the first part of the course. Using Causevic and Sengupta’s (Reference Causevic and Sengupta2020) work with marginalized communities, we list content problems in Wikipedia and then illustrate that the encyclopedia that “anyone can edit” is not actually experienced equitably by its editors. Finally, we show how the “nuts and bolts” of the assignment gave students the opportunity to experience epistemic inequity.
WIKIPEDIA CONTENT: ABSENCES, GAPS, ELLIPSES, AND MISREPRESENTATIONS
Epistemic marginalization was a central idea of the course (Ackerly Reference Ackerly2018; Duran Reference Duran2001; Haas Reference Haas1992; Lorde 1984/Reference Lorde2007; Medina Reference Medina2013; Spivak Reference Spivak, Nelson and Grossberg1988; Yanow Reference Yanow, Yanow and Schwartz-Shea2006; see also the online appendix). To inspire students to look for content politics on Wikipedia, Sengupta described the types of absences, gaps, ellipses, and misrepresentations experienced in Wikipedia using the example of Native Americans and the California Gold Rush.Footnote 4
Michael Connolly Miskwish, a scholar from the Kumeyaay Nation from Southern California and Northern Mexico (Causevic and Sengupta Reference Causevic and Sengupta2020; Sengupta, Bouterse, and Allmann Reference Sengupta, Bouterse and Allmann2018), asked Wikipedians to prioritize editing the California Gold Rush article. This is a frequently accessed article that, at the time, was written entirely from the perspective of white settler colonialism without any details about the genocide of Native Americans that the Gold Rush caused.Footnote 5 Sengupta then used this example to illustrate key features of epistemic authority on Wikipedia, including the following:
-
• the policies of notability, neutrality, and reliable sources, which establish what can be included, how, and which references might support each substantive claim of a Wikipedia article
-
• the “view history” tab,Footnote 6 which archives the edit history of an article
-
• the “talk” page,Footnote 7 where editors can discuss substantive content issues
By reviewing the history of the Gold Rush page, students could see how revisions to a particular page, using credible references, can address exclusions with political implications without triggering considerations of political bias on the part of the editor making those changes.
The first part of the assignment was for students to identify (1) authors from their courses who did not have Wikipedia pages (e.g., Patricia Mohammed, Jewel Amoah, Emma Perez, Darlene Pagano, and Gita Sen); (2) cross-language differences in the articles on an author (e.g., the Spanish and English versions of the Silvia Rivera Cusicanqui articles); and (3) as with the Gold Rush pages, articles whose references were concentrated in one view of the topic or field.
WIKIPEDIA PRACTICES: REFERENCES, CREDIBILITY, AND EDITORIAL AUTHORITY
Identifying content gaps and distortions was the crux of the assignment and is at the heart of the efforts of most course-based contributions to Wikipedia. The challenge, as Baltz (Reference Baltz2022) and Norell (Reference Norell2022) discuss in this symposium, is that biases in the coverage and content of Wikipedia are only part of the editing politics constructed by Wikipedia’s editing rules and definitions of notability. Certain Wikipedia pages conceal (and, to those who know, reveal) another politics of knowledge within Wikipedia. Experience of the latter is the heart of the experiential learning about epistemic oppression.
Wikipedia editing practices are supposed to be democratic, neutral, and transparent; however, superimposed on a world in which global politics do not reflect these principles, Wikipedia practices do not either. To prepare students for the politics of the editing process, Sengupta offered two illustrations: Dalits and women.
The Dalit are a community of more than 250 million people from South Asia and the diaspora who were formerly and pejoratively called “untouchable.” In the oppressive social structure of the caste system, they were (and often continue to be) relegated to manual scavenging and the handling of corpses. Their inclusion in content and as editors would seem to be part of Wikipedia’s democratic aspirations.
Historically, however, Dalits have been systematically denied access to spaces and tools of education and knowledge. Thus, bringing their history and knowledge onto Wikipedia immediately conflicts with the key Wikipedia editorial norms: notability and reliable sources. “Notability” is defined as being mentioned in “secondary sources” such as published books, peer-reviewed journal articles, well-known and credible media and academic references, and other Wikipedia articles or “links.”Footnote 8 This means that any community—such as the Dalits—whose history and knowledge have been systematically destroyed, undermined, made invisible, or not given the opportunity to be published are systematically not notable despite the seemingly apolitical terms of “notability.”
Dalit feminist scholars and activists have been marking Dalit history and knowledge through the radical community project, Dalit History Month.Footnote 9 In edit-a-thons organized with the Dalit community and in partnership with experienced Wikipedians, they created new and modified content (Kauntia Reference Kauntia2020).Footnote 10 Yet, this effort was challenged and questioned, and a number of those edits were reverted by questioning the notability of certain articles and the credibility of certain references. This is an ongoing struggle: even the biographical article about the Dalit South Asian icon, Dr. B. R. Ambedkar (known as the architect of India’s constitution, among many other accomplishments) occasionally is vandalized (Kauntia Reference Kauntia2020).Footnote 11
Ironically, such contestation can be politically motivated, with the outcomes biased toward those whose version of events is covered in print media. In this light, during the edit-a-thon, students were encouraged to use their university-based privileged access to publish text that would chart a course of notability for their topic. Yet, some students experienced challenges to the notability of the subject of their pages.
Likewise, global publishing about and by women is severely behind that of men: significant information about women, their history, and their knowledge is still primarily oral or visual, not textual—if it has not been forgotten or never recorded at all. This underrepresentation of women is replicated in Wikipedia. On the English Wikipedia, only 18% of all biographies are of women; this percentage is as high as it is only because of the significant efforts of Wikipedian groups and individuals.Footnote 12
As noted previously, one way to establish notability is to be cross referenced in other pages of Wikipedia. Even if the cross reference goes to a page with no content, being mentioned on Wikipedia is part of what renders a person notable enough to have a page on Wikipedia. Thus, creating “red links”—that is, Wikipedia’s way of demonstrating articles that are not yet created—can be a way to signal the gaps and elisions of information.Footnote 13 These gaps and elisions are even more acute when confronting intersectionality or the multiple marginalizations of, for example, Black and Brown, Indigenous, and Global South–based women. To highlight this point, Sengupta described writing the page of a well-known feminist activist and philanthropist from Nigeria while attending a Wikipedia event in South Africa. Her initial article was nominated for deletion for both notability and reliability of sources (Kauntia Reference Kauntia2020; Kessenides and Chafkin Reference Kessenides and Chafkin2016). With the weighty support of a longtime Wikipedia editor (and former board chair of the Wikimedia Foundation)—who was sitting next to her at this event and who intervened on the talk page of the article to counter the intended deletion—the relevance of the article’s content and subject was affirmed. Ironically, the hierarchical status of well-established editors contributes to the democratization of the content of Wikipedia with similar interventions.
Both Dalit and women’s pages have been challenged as lacking the seemingly apolitical standard of the “neutral point of view.” An article is essentially an assemblage of facts, verified and made credible through secondary sources and references that support these facts. However, as discussed previously, the difference between fact and opinion sometimes can be the difference between who holds the power behind a “fact”—that is, whose knowledge is given the power of credibility. Oppressed communities rarely have the power of publishing on their side. This can lead to significant epistemic struggles around ongoing political events, sites, and issues. Administrators on Wikipedia, who have the power to manage pages beyond those of an ordinary editor, often are asked to mediate in these contestations. Who these administrators are, what their own politics might be, and how it might influence their decisions (even while maintaining seeming “neutrality”) are all issues at the heart of Wikipedia’s most contested pages.
Sometimes this results in making editing of a particular page equally constrained for everyone. For example, the article on Jerusalem and related articles on what Wikipedians call the “Arab-Israeli conflict” are restricted to a single edit every 24 hours by editors who have reasonably established accounts.Footnote 14 In summary, when the seemingly neutral standards of notability, secondary references, and neutral point of view are superimposed on a world in which power inequalities affect whose knowledge is published, these practices can serve to replicate those politics on the pages of Wikipedia, which masks hierarchical politics as democratic, exclusionary politics as inclusive, and elite perspectives as neutral.
When the seemingly neutral standards of notability, secondary references, and neutral point of view are superimposed on a world in which power inequalities affect whose knowledge is published, these practices can serve to replicate those politics on the pages of Wikipedia, which masks hierarchical politics as democratic, exclusionary politics as inclusive, and elite perspectives as neutral.
Although the assignment could not transform the underlying knowledge landscape of the world or Wikipedia’s rules of editing, students were made conscious of these forms of the politics of knowledge and experienced them when their pages were challenged or their edits were reversed. With this awareness, they found ways to challenge these politics in carrying out their assignment. We conclude this article by describing these achievements.
ASSIGNMENT “NUTS AND BOLTS”: SUBSTANTIVE AND CONCEPTUAL LEARNING THROUGH AN ASSIGNMENT
Knowledge of the ways that bias and seemingly neutral rules exacerbate a politics of privilege even within an open-source platform is an important complement to identifying its absences, gaps, ellipses, and misrepresentations. An open-source platform on which “all” can be editors, Wikipedia is a structure for even those on the access side of the digital divide to experience epistemic marginalization. By confronting these politics with the basic knowledge of how to edit Wikipedia and how to navigate its many policies and guidelines, students created their own experiential learning, guided by their curiosity and the limitations they confronted in making visible the people and ideas that were noteworthy to them.
Providing students with Wikipedia editing rules and a few examples of how they manifest in the public-facing pages of Wikipedia articles, as well as a few strategies that editors use to follow these rules while challenging inherent epistemic biases, created an opportunity for them to find and confront these biases. Drawing on the first part of the course, students were encouraged to look for absences, gaps, ellipses, and misrepresentations. Throughout their editing, they created hyperlinks in other pages to those that they were editing. When they had multiple pages that they wanted to create, they used red-links to signal the content gaps that they witnessed in Wikipedia that went beyond those that they could address in a one-semester course, thereby participating in the asynchronous possibilities for collaborative editing.
Drawing on the first part of the course, students were encouraged to look for absences, gaps, ellipses, and misrepresentations. Throughout their editing, they created hyperlinks in other pages to those that they were editing.
Throughout this assignment, students were able to observe and participate in epistemic struggles across a range of sites. Most obvious were the gaps. Many of the authors studied in the course did not have pages or had pages that had not been updated in several years. Challenging this problem had multiple pedagogical benefits, including students being motivated by the absence to read works well beyond the course-assigned works in order to make the entries more complete.
When students chose an author whose page was well developed (i.e., Angela DavisFootnote 15), they learned the epistemic power of creating cross-page links on Wikipedia. They sought out the topics that their authors were writing about and created links to them and to their work in the pages on those topics. By creating links to their article from other articles, they were able to support the claim of notability, thereby creating their own experience of the politics of knowledge.
In the undergraduate course, students studied many examples of feminists building solidarity networks in order to build support for their work while they did it. Similarly, the edit-a-thons for the class were planned for two courses—an undergraduate course on feminist theory and research and a graduate course on postcolonial and decolonial feminisms. Both courses address the politics of epistemology from different perspectives. They also reveal the import of difference as an essential part of solidarity, and solidarity as supported by networks that welcome diverse disciplinary and experiential knowledge. To provide an experience of solidarity across differences, the edit-a-thons were held with these groups together and open to the larger university community. Content that was not feminist was edited in feminist community.Footnote 16
As a matter of process, an edit-a-thon enables new editors to ask quick questions and support one another. Furthermore, the synchronicity of an edit-a-thon for two related courses fosters linking across sites, thereby enhancing the visibility of absences, gaps, ellipses, and misrepresentations and facilitating the documentation of the notability of pages, the credibility of references, and the editorial authority of student editors. None of our edit-a-thons generated backlash beyond challenges to notability; however, colleagues and students who are planning such events should inform themselves about these possibilities.Footnote 17
In summary, the pedagogical advantages of incorporating a Wikipedia edit-a-thon into a course supports experiential learning. Students witnessed for themselves a small subset of the absences, gaps, ellipses, and misrepresentations on Wikipedia. Invested in the presence of their chosen person, text, or topic on Wikipedia, they wanted others to know what they found important about their work. By working in an edit-a-thon format, the scope of the absences was more evident when each student described what was visible and invisible about their person or topic in the Wikipedia pages. Doing the work individually and together enabled them to understand conceptual ideas from the courses including epistemic oppression, intersectionality, and the digital divide not as abstractions but as concrete, observable, and lived experiences.
Supplementary Materials
To view supplementary material for this article, please visit APSA Educate at https://educate.apsanet.org/resource/12-13-2021/wikipedia-edit-a-thons-sites-of-struggle-resistance-and-responsibility.
