Recent years have seen intensifying interest in Roman letter-writing, including the appearance of several book-length studies on historical, literary, and social aspects of the epistolary genre. This book, which brings together themes from White's previous work, explores the Ciceronian correspondence as a representation of ‘the letter-writing habits of a particular Roman milieu’ (ix). Framed by the central question of what makes the Letters so different from other surviving ancient letter collections, W.'s wide-ranging discussion offers an enlightening glimpse into the practical and ideological considerations that shaped élite epistolary exchanges in the late Republic.
The book consists of six chapters distributed evenly between two parts. Part 1 focuses on the context of the Letters, and Part 2 on prominent themes in their content. Ch. 1 considers the short- and long-term purposes of letters in the light of logistical obstacles to delivery and the need for members of the élite to maintain social ties when face-to-face communication was impossible. The thorny issue of the editing of the Letters is the subject of ch. 2. Not everyone will agree with W.'s argument that the surviving corpus is a deliberate and final product of ancient editorial intervention, but his analysis contributes much to the debate by identifying seven quantifiable indications of editing. Next, ch. 3 examines the ‘Frames of the letter’: the written and unwritten cues which frame the discourse, from the significance of the choice of writing material to epistolary formulae and strategies for mediating the recipient's reaction to the letter. W. has been unable to take full account of Jon Hall's recent study Politeness and Politics in Cicero's Letters (2009) in his discussion of politeness, but his use of scholarship also cited by Hall yields a comparable analysis. Ch. 4 opens the second part of the book with an assessment of the letters as literature and a survey of allusions to contemporary literature contained in them. W.'s depiction of literature as a shared reference point among the educated élite is particularly interesting, not least because it adds a socio-political dimension to Cicero's frequent literary quotations. Epistolary advising is the subject of ch. 5, which draws attention to the social and moral aspects of giving and receiving advice by letter. This chapter also overlaps with Hall (ch. 3), but whereas Hall's focus is primarily linguistic, W. explores the relationship between advice and action, observing that ‘Cicero plunged into most activities of his career without consulting anybody’ (130) but did seek advice when his public image was at stake (131–2). Finally, ch. 6 examines the relationship between letter-writing and political leadership by way of a case study of the wartime letters from 44 to 43 b.c., which account for more than 20 per cent of the surviving correspondence. Although the analysis tends towards narration, it nevertheless shows clearly that letters helped Cicero to cultivate and exercise authority during this crisis. The book concludes with an Afterword in which W. reflects on the uniqueness of the Ciceronian correspondence and proposes directions for further research. Two appendices provide a statistical overview of the Letters (App. 1) and a catalogue of citations of the contemporary literature discussed in ch. 4 (App. 2); a bibliography and indexes of persons and passages are also included.
The engaging fluency of W.'s writing, breadth of material covered, and inclusion of lively, original English translations of all Latin quotations make this book an excellent companion — or even introduction — to the study of the Letters. The chapters of Part 1 provide a convenient overview of important, yet easily overlooked, external factors which influenced how the letters were written and preserved. It is an unfortunate consequence of the fullness of W.'s treatment of these issues (which fit comfortably into three chapters) that his selection of only three themes to represent the content of the Letters seems somewhat slight by comparison; but the respective focal points are apt, and themes addressed elsewhere are mentioned in the Preface (x–xi). Overall, W.'s arguments are well presented, though some flaws may be noted. His attempt to define a ‘typical’ Ciceronian letter in ch. 1 runs the risk of confusing readers who are unfamiliar with the correspondence, since the exemplar, Fam. 12.16, was written by Trebonius to Cicero and thus belongs to the small minority of surviving letters not written by Cicero. In ch. 4 the assessment of the literariness of the Letters is undermined by the conclusion that labels such as ‘literary letter’ obscure more than they clarify (98–9). The analysis of Cicero's leadership in ch. 6 contrasts with an earlier assertion that ‘I am concerned with what the letters do, not with the performance of their writers on any wider stage’ (89). This reviewer was disappointed by the tentative tone of the Afterword, where W. explains that he wrote the book with a reader like himself in mind (167) and states that, having completed this work, he is now ‘ready for a fresh reading of the correspondence’ (170). However, these minor criticisms should not detract from the value of W.'s achievement in bringing Cicero, his correspondents, and the culture of late Republican letter-writing to life.
