Rebels at the Bar is a collection of biographical sketches of eight of the first American women to become lawyers: Myra Bradwell, Lavinia Goodell, Belva Lockwood, Clara Shortridge Foltz, Mary Hall, Catharine Waugh McCulloch, Lelia Robinson, and Mary Greene. Jill Norgren frames the portraits with two introductory chapters on women's status and the legal profession in the mid-nineteenth century and a concluding chapter, “Law as a Woman's Enterprise,” which places the eight featured women in a larger context. The author ties portraits to one another by noting the subjects’ shared and contrasting experiences—for example, Lavinia Goodell in Wisconsin and Belva Lockwood in Washington, DC, both successfully lobbied legislatures for women's right to enter the legal profession (73), while Goodell's struggle to find a lawyer to train her contrasted with Mary Hall's good fortune in having a prominent Hartford lawyer who mentored her (137).
The featured women, born between 1831 and 1862, all began their entry into the legal profession between 1868 and 1880. They all had to challenge legal and social limits on their becoming lawyers. But within that common experience was great diversity. Although all were Christian and white,Footnote 1 they were in big cities (e.g., Boston, Washington, and Chicago) and small towns (e.g., Janesville, Wisconsin; and Seattle, Washington Territory). They were in the East, the Midwest, and the West. They studied law on their own, in law offices, and in law schools. They began their studies in their early twenties and in their late thirties. They were single, happily married, divorced, and widowed. They were childless, and they were mothers. They reveled in the battle of the courtroom, and they kept to backroom practice. They went into law from the suffrage movement or from personal interest. They represented criminal defendants, and they shied away from criminal law. They handled property conveyances, probates, and divorces. Some supported themselves with their law practices; others supplemented their legal fees with income from the lecture circuit or publishing.
The women profiled did not all have law practices. Myra Bradwell, the first woman profiled in the book, read the law with her husband and passed the Illinois bar exam but was denied admission. She challenged the denial in the United States Supreme Court, losing her case with a ringing endorsement of separate spheres ideology by Justice Joseph Bradley, who concurred in the judgment: “Man is, or should be, woman's protector and defender.… The harmony, not to say identity, of interest and views which belong, or should belong, to the family institution is repugnant to the idea of a woman adopting a distinct and independent career from that of her husband.”Footnote 2 While the case was on appeal, the Illinois legislature enacted a law enabling women to pursue almost any occupation (except the military and road construction). Although she had worked for this law, Bradwell “refused to reapply for bar admission,” asking the Illinois Supreme Court to admit her based on her first application. The court declined—until 1890 when, on its own motion, it admitted her.Footnote 3 Bradwell, a strong advocate for women's right to practice law and an influential legal publisher, was only a licensed lawyer the last few years of her life. Rebels at the Bar discusses her fight to become a lawyer but does not say anything about her eventual admission.
These women's efforts to become lawyers illustrate some cracks in the prevailing model of separate gender spheres. First is the inadequacy of excluding women from the profession as a way of protecting women in general. In making the argument that women should not be exposed to “all the nastiness of the world which finds its way into courts of justice,” a Wisconsin judge listed a range of problems such as “incest, rape, seduction, fornication, adultery, pregnancy, bastardy, . . . prostitution, lascivious cohabitation, abortion, infanticide, obscene publications, . . . divorce”Footnote 4 that lawyers must hear about—without any apparent recognition that, of course, women were already exposed to the evils as victims or participants. Protecting women from hearing about these social problems as attorneys did nothing to protect the many women actually harmed by them. Second is the pretense that a safe, secure domestic sphere will always be available to middle-class women. Several of the women profiled in this book turned to law to support themselves and their families—for instance, Clara Foltz, whose husband deserted her and their five children (106), and Mary Greene, who entered law school after her father died so that she could “handle her own and her mother's business affairs” (173).
Geographically dispersed as the women profiled were, it is striking how aware they were of one another's work. For example, when Belva Lockwood sought admission to a law school in Washington, DC, she knew about women who were attending classes at Union College (later Northwestern University) in Chicago and Washington University in St. Louis, one of whom she had met at the National Woman Suffrage Association convention (80). In 1886 a group of women who had attended the University of Michigan's law school began the Equity Club, a correspondence group for women lawyers, including a few of the lawyers that Norgren profiles.Footnote 5
The proverb cautions against judging a book by its cover, but of course we do expect covers to provide some good clues about their contents. In this case, the book designer chose a misleading image: a painting of Shakespeare's Portia, a girl who poses as a male lawyer. Every time I saw the book jacket, I found it jarring that a fictional Italian from the sixteenth century was representing nineteenth-century Americans. (The book does include many fine photographs of the women profiled, as well as two cartoons lampooning female lawyers.) The book's subtitle, The Fascinating, Forgotten Stories of America's First Women Lawyers, is hyperbole. These women's stories have not been forgotten, as witnessed by the author's rich notes and bibliography.Footnote 6 And the eight women featured were not the first American women to become lawyers,Footnote 7 although they were among the first and definitely in the first generation.Footnote 8 Their stories are worth sharing, and this book makes a valuable contribution to women's history, legal history, and the study of the professions and American society during the Progressive Era.
