Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:52:54.323Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Dissecting coherent motions in extreme wall shear-stress events within adverse-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 June 2026

Leandro J.O. Silva
Affiliation:
Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, SP, 13083-860, Brazil
William R. Wolf*
Affiliation:
Universidade Estadual de Campinas, Campinas, SP, 13083-860, Brazil
*
Corresponding author: William R. Wolf, wolf@fem.unicamp.br

Abstract

Coherent motions associated with extreme wall shear-stress events are investigated for adverse-pressure-gradient turbulent boundary layers. The analyses are performed using wall-resolved large eddy simulations of a NACA0012 airfoil at angles of attack of $9$ and $12^{\circ}$ and Reynolds number $4\times 10^5$. The suction side exhibits attached TBLs which develop under progressively stronger APGs. A quadrant decomposition of Reynolds shear stress shows that sweeps and ejections dominate the momentum exchange between the mean and fluctuating fields, with the intensity of sweeps near the wall growing more rapidly with APG strength. Probability density functions of wall shear stress reveal a higher frequency of backflow events and an increased distribution symmetry with stronger APGs. Conditional statistics indicate that backflow events originate from inner-layer sweep motions that transport high-momentum fluid toward the wall, followed by ejections that drive local deceleration. In such cases, the intensity of ejections is modulated by the APG strength. In contrast, extreme positive events are primarily characterised by sweep motions. For both types of extreme events, inward and outward interactions become increasingly significant as the APG strengthens. The dynamics of the coherent turbulent structures and their interactions are examined using conditional flow field analyses. For extreme positive events, stronger APGs lead to shorter high-speed streaks, while the associated sweep motions generate spanwise velocities that increasingly influence the near-wall dynamics. In the case of backflows, stronger APGs shorten low-speed streaks and amplify high-speed structures associated with sweep motions, promoting spanwise alignment of vortical structures. Overall, APGs modify the structure and dynamics of extreme near-wall events by reshaping the balance and spatial organisation of sweep- and ejection-dominated motions.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Grid details and near-wall resolution in wall units for $9$ and $12^{\circ}$ AoA.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Simulation results presented for $9$ and $12^{\circ}$ angle of attack in the top and bottom rows, respectively. Iso-surfaces of $Q$-criterion coloured by the $U$ velocity component normalised by the free-stream velocity $U_\infty$ are presented in (a) and (c). Mean flow fields ($U/U_\infty$) are depicted in (b) and (d) using the same contour levels of the left column plots.

Figure 2

Figure 2.Evolution of the (a) Rotta–Clauser pressure-gradient parameter $\beta$ and (b) skin-friction coefficient $C_f$ along the airfoil chord.

Figure 3

Table 2.Properties of the TBLs at selected chordwise positions, including the pressure-gradient parameter $\beta$; the displacement, momentum and boundary-layer thicknesses ($\delta ^*$, $\theta$ and $\delta$); the Reynolds numbers based on displacement and momentum thicknesses ($\textit{Re}_{\delta ^*}$ and $\textit{Re}_\theta$); and the friction Reynolds number $\textit{Re}_\tau$. Boundary-layer integral parameters are normalised by the chord length.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Individual terms of the wall-tangential mean momentum equation at chordwise positions $x_c = (\textit {a,d})\,0.5$, (b,e) $0.7$ and (c,f) $0.9$. Solid lines denote the total contribution obtained by summation over the repeated index $j$ in (3.1), whereas dashed and dot-dashed lines represent the individual contributions from the $j=1$ and $j=2$ components, respectively. Top and bottom rows show results for AoA $9$ and $12^{\circ}$, respectively. All terms are non-dimensionalised by $u_\tau ^3/\nu$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Individual terms of the wall-normal mean momentum equation at chordwise positions (a,d) $x_c = 0.5$, (b,e) $0.7$ and (c,f) $0.9$. Solid lines denote the total contribution obtained by summation over the repeated index $j$ in (3.2), whereas dashed and dot-dashed lines represent the individual contributions from the $j=1$ and $j=2$ components, respectively. Top and bottom rows show results for AoA $9$ and $12^{\circ}$, respectively. All terms are non-dimensionalised by $u_\tau ^3/\nu$.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Decomposition of the wall-normal derivative of the Reynolds shear stress into quadrant contributions at chordwise positions (a,d) $x_c = 0.5$, (b,e) $0.7$ and (c,f) $0.9$. The top and bottom rows present results for $9$ and $12^{\circ}$ AoA, respectively. All quantities are non-dimensionalised by $u_\tau ^3/\nu$.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Probability density functions of the inner-scaled wall shear stress $\tau _w^+$ computed at chordwise positions $x=0.5$, $0.7$ and $0.9$ for (a) $9$ and (b) $12^{\circ}$ AoA, and (c) results of the wall shear-stress fluctuations normalised by their r.m.s. value $\tau '_w/\tau _{w_\textit{rms}}$. The vertical black dashed lines in (c) mark $\tau _w'/\tau _{w_{\textit{rms}}} = \pm 2$, which will serve as a threshold for identifying extreme positive and backflow events.

Figure 8

Table 3.Statistics of wall shear stress for different AoA and chordwise locations, with corresponding counts and percentages of extreme events. The mean, r.m.s. and skewness of $\tau _w$ are represented by $\langle \tau _w \rangle$, $ \tau _{w_\textit{rms}}$, and $S(\tau _w)$, respectively. The percentage of samples above or below the threshold $\tau _w' = \pm 2 \tau _{w_{\textit{rms}}}$ is given by $\% \textit{EP}_{{S}}$ and $\% \textit{BF}_{{S}}$. The parameters $N_{\textit{EP}}$ and $N_{\textit{BF}}$ represent the number of EP and BF realisations tracked in the temporal signals, as indicated by blue and red dots marked in figure 7. The percentages of EP and BF events are finally indicated by $\% \textit{EP}_{{E}}$ and $\% \textit{BF}_{{E}}$, respectively.

Figure 9

Figure 7.Examples of inner-scaled wall shear-stress signals over the full simulation duration, where (a) represents a probe at $x_c = 0.5$ for $9^{\circ}$ angle of attack and (b) represents a probe at $x_c = 0.9$ for $12^{\circ}$ angle of attack. Blue and red dots mark EP and extreme negative (BF) events, respectively, while the corresponding coloured lines represent the temporal windows of length $\Delta t_W = 0.202$ used to track their evolution.

Figure 10

Figure 8.Space–time correlations of BF events computed with the wall-tangential velocity fluctuation $u^1 = u_t$ displayed in the first and third columns, and with the wall-normal velocity fluctuation $u^2=u_n$ depicted in the second and fourth columns. Results for the $9^{\circ}$ angle of attack case are presented in the first two columns, while those for the $12^{\circ}$ case are presented in the last two columns. The correlations shown in the first, second and third rows represent results computed at $y^+=2.5$ for chordwise positions $x_c = 0.5$, $0.7$ and $0.9$, respectively.

Figure 11

Figure 9.Space–time correlations of EP events computed with the wall-tangential velocity fluctuation $(u^1 = u_t)$ displayed in the first and third columns, and with the wall-normal velocity fluctuation ($u^2=u_n$) depicted in the second and fourth columns. Results for the $9^{\circ}$ angle of attack case are presented in the first two columns, while those for the $12^{\circ}$ case are presented in the last two columns. The correlations shown in the first, second and third rows represent results computed at $y^+=2.5$ for chordwise positions $x_c = 0.5$, $0.7$ and $0.9$, respectively.

Figure 12

Figure 10.Temporal evolution of conditional statistics for BF events. (a,c) Conditional mean velocity profiles of the wall-tangential ($\widetilde {U}^1$, solid black line) and wall-normal ($\widetilde {U}^2$, dashed black line) components, compared with the corresponding total mean profiles (blue solid and dashed lines). (b,d) Conditional Reynolds shear-stress profiles ($\widetilde {u^1u^2}$, black), together with the quadrant decomposition contributions: outward interactions ($Q1$, green), ejections ($Q2$, blue), inward interactions ($Q3$, magenta) and sweeps ($Q4$, red). The total mean Reynolds shear stress is shown in grey. Results in figures (a,b) correspond to the chordwise position $x_c = 0.5$ of the $9^{\circ}$ angle of attack case, while figures (c,d) correspond to $x_c = 0.9$ for the $12^{\circ}$ case.

Figure 13

Figure 11.Temporal evolution of conditional statistics for EP events. (a,c) Conditional mean velocity profiles of the wall-tangential ($\widetilde {U}^1$, solid black line) and wall-normal ($\widetilde {U}^2$, dashed black line) components, compared with the corresponding total mean profiles (blue solid and dashed lines). (b,d) Conditional Reynolds shear-stress profiles ($\widetilde {u^1u^2}$, black), together with the quadrant decomposition contributions: outward interactions ($Q1$, green), ejections ($Q2$, blue), inward interactions ($Q3$, magenta) and sweeps ($Q4$, red). The total mean Reynolds shear stress is shown in grey. Results in figures (a,b) correspond to the chordwise position $x_c = 0.5$ of the $9^{\circ}$ angle of attack case, while figures (c,d) correspond to $x_c = 0.9$ for the $12^{\circ}$ case.

Figure 14

Figure 12.Schematic representation of vortical structures used for the definition of (a) BF and (b) EP events.

Figure 15

Table 4.Statistics of three-dimensional extreme wall shear-stress events, including the total number of events ($N_{{B}_{3D}}$, $N_{{P}_{3D}}$), and the number of events classified on the left ($N_{\textit{LB}}$,$N_{\textit{LP}}$) and right ($N_{\textit{RB}}$,$N_{\textit{RP}}$) sides. Subscripts B and P denote BF and EP events, respectively. The mean orientation angle $\phi _B$ of the structures generated during the BF event evolution is also reported.

Figure 16

Figure 13.Three-dimensional evolution of the conditionally averaged coherent structures associated with the BF event for the $12^{\circ}$ angle of attack case at chordwise position $x_c=0.9$. The first column shows a three-dimensional perspective, while the second column presents a top view of the event dynamics. Red and blue isosurfaces correspond to regions of tangential velocity fluctuations of $\widetilde {u}_t=0.02$ and $\widetilde {u}_t=-0.02$, respectively, highlighting a high-speed LSS approaching a low-speed streak. A vortex structure is visualised using a $Q$-criterion isosurface coloured in green. The third column shows a constant $z$ plane passing through the event centre, where the background contours represent the tangential velocity fluctuations $\widetilde {u}_t$ and the overlaid isolines denote the wall-normal velocity fluctuations $\widetilde {u}_n$. Movie 1 is provided as supplementary material showing the evolution of coherent structures and their interactions for this case.

Figure 17

Figure 14.Three-dimensional evolution of the conditionally averaged coherent structures associated with the BF event for the $9^{\circ}$ angle of attack case at chordwise position $x_c=0.5$. The first column shows a three-dimensional perspective, while the second column presents a top view of the event dynamics. Red and blue isosurfaces correspond to regions of tangential velocity fluctuations of $\widetilde {u}_t=0.035$ and $\widetilde {u}_t=-0.07$, respectively, highlighting a local sweep motion approaching a low-speed streak. A vortex structure is visualised using a $Q$-criterion isosurface coloured in green. The third column shows a constant $z$ plane passing through the event centre, where the background contours represent the tangential velocity fluctuations $\widetilde {u}_t$ and the overlaid isolines denote the wall-normal velocity fluctuations $\widetilde {u}_n$. Movie 2 is provided as supplementary material showing the evolution of coherent structures and their interactions for this case.

Figure 18

Figure 15.Histogram of the vortex orientation angle generated during BF events at chordwise positions $x_c =0.5$, $0.7$ and $0.9$. Results are shown for AoA of (a) $9^{\circ}$ and (b) $12^{\circ}$, respectively.

Figure 19

Figure 16.Three-dimensional evolution of the conditionally averaged coherent structures associated with the EP event for the $9^{\circ}$ angle of attack case at chordwise position $x_c=0.5$. The first column shows a three-dimensional perspective, while the second column presents a top view of the event dynamics. Red and blue isosurfaces correspond to regions of tangential velocity fluctuations of $\widetilde {u}_t=0.035$ and $\widetilde {u}_t=-0.035$, respectively, highlighting a high-speed streak flanked by low-speed streaks. A vortex structure is visualised using a $Q$-criterion isosurface coloured in green. The third column shows a $z^+-y^+$ plane passing through the event centre, where the background contours represent the tangential velocity fluctuations $\widetilde {u}_t$ and the overlaid isolines denote the wall-normal velocity fluctuations $\widetilde {u}_n$. Movie 3 is provided as supplementary material showing the evolution of coherent structures and their interactions for this case.

Figure 20

Figure 17.Three-dimensional evolution of the conditionally averaged coherent structures associated with the EP event for the $12^{\circ}$ angle of attack case at chordwise position $x_c=0.9$. The first column shows a three-dimensional perspective, while the second column presents a top view of the event dynamics. Red isosurfaces correspond to regions of tangential velocity fluctuations of $\widetilde {u}_t=0.08$, highlighting a short high-speed streak. Vortex structures are visualised using a $Q$-criterion isosurface coloured in green. The third column shows a constant $x$ plane passing through the event centre, where the background contours represent the tangential velocity fluctuations $u_t$ and the overlaid isolines denote the wall-normal velocity fluctuations $\widetilde {u}_n$. Movie 4 is provided as supplementary material showing the evolution of coherent structures and their interactions for this case.

Figure 21

Figure 18.Top view of coherent structures associated with BF events at $\Delta t_0 = 0.0$ for chordwise positions (a,d) $x_c = 0.5$, (b,e) $0.7$ and (c, f) $0.9$. The first three rows present the results for the $9^{\circ}$ angle of attack case, while the last three rows show the results for $12^{\circ}$. Red and blue isosurfaces correspond to regions of positive and negative tangential velocity fluctuations $\widetilde {u}_t$, respectively. Vortex structures are visualised by green isosurfaces using the $Q$-criterion.

Figure 22

Figure 19.Top view of coherent structures associated with EP events at $\Delta t_0 = 0.0$ for chordwise positions (a,d) $x_c = 0.5$, (b,e) $0.7$ and (c, f) $0.9$. The first three rows present the results for the $9^{\circ}$ angle of attack case, while the last three rows show the results for $12^{\circ}$. Red and blue isosurfaces correspond to regions of positive and negative tangential velocity fluctuations $\widetilde {u}_t$, respectively. Vortex structures are visualised by green isosurfaces using the $Q$-criterion.

Supplementary material: File

Silva and Wolf supplementary movie 1

Three-dimensional evolution of the conditionally averaged coherent structures associated with the backflow event for the 12 deg. angle of attack case at chordwise position x = 0.9.
Download Silva and Wolf supplementary movie 1(File)
File 3.3 MB
Supplementary material: File

Silva and Wolf supplementary movie 2

Three-dimensional evolution of the conditionally averaged coherent structures associated with the backflow event for the 9 deg. angle of attack case at chordwise position x = 0.5.
Download Silva and Wolf supplementary movie 2(File)
File 2.7 MB
Supplementary material: File

Silva and Wolf supplementary movie 3

Three-dimensional evolution of the conditionally averaged coherent structures associated with the extreme positive event for the 9 deg. angle of attack case at chordwise position x = 0.5.
Download Silva and Wolf supplementary movie 3(File)
File 3 MB
Supplementary material: File

Silva and Wolf supplementary movie 4

Three-dimensional evolution of the conditionally averaged coherent structures associated with the extreme positive event for the 12 deg. angle of attack case at chordwise position x = 0.9.
Download Silva and Wolf supplementary movie 4(File)
File 3 MB
Supplementary material: File

Silva and Wolf supplementary material

Silva and Wolf supplementary material
Download Silva and Wolf supplementary material(File)
File 4.9 MB