Hans Hassell confronts and adds to two bodies of scholarly work in The Party’s Primary. First, he reviews the history of the direct primary election as a response to party boss control over the nominating process, demonstrating how generations of scholars have concluded that parties did indeed lose influence when they lost control of nominations to primary voters. After reviewing party role in legislative primaries for federal office from 2006 to 2014, he concludes that “the parties played a larger role in the nominating process than previously recognized and that the influence that parties have has a significant effect on the outcomes of the American democratic process” (p. 10).
Second, in exploring the role of parties in U.S. House and Senate nominations, Hassell also makes a significant contribution to party theory. Again, he carefully reviews the literature that has explored the role of party since the advent of direct primaries, noting the transition from those authors who discussed candidate-centered campaigns to those like John Aldrich, who explore the role of parties in servicing candidates for office. His careful discussion of the recent development in party theory—Marty Cohen and his coauthors’ (2008) The Party Decides’s conceptualization of party as a loose network of individuals and groups demanding certain policies—notes that these authors based their finding on the role that party elite, thus defined, played in presidential nominations. The contribution of Hassell’s book is to buttress that theory with findings from a decade of legislative nominations.
The analysis by Hassell is subtle, careful, and detailed. He argues that for parties to play a role in nominations, they must have resources that candidates value. Drawing on interviews conducted with party elites—donors, state and national officials, candidates, campaign managers, and consultants (both Republicans and Democrats) in 11 states plus the District of Columbia—Hassell notes that the party elite does provide resources that candidates need to win. These include access to experienced campaign staff, donors willing to follow the party lead, and media attention. His interviewees also note that the party elite, defined as the loose network of policy demanders, also has an ongoing interest in who wins legislative nominations.
Subsequently, Hassell shows that the party elite contributes to legislative primary results, rather than joining a bandwagon behind candidates who are winning in any case. He first makes this point by relying on interview data, but he buttresses it with an innovative quantitative analysis demonstrating party support for candidates and showing that the support contributed to, rather than reflected, candidate electoral strength.
The author’s methodological contribution is found in his development of a measure of party support from the loose network of individuals and groups comprising the party for individual candidates. He does this by counting the number of individuals and groups who support the party campaign committees (the Hill committees) and also contribute to various candidates in primaries. He demonstrates (in Chapter 3) that party support preceded and did not follow other measures of candidate strength. Nevertheless, the degree to which one is persuaded by Hassell’s argument is dependent on whether one accepts his operationalization of support from the network that constitutes the party.
After demonstrating that the causal arrow runs from party support to the candidates (rather than from strong candidates to party support), Hassell proceeds to look at the impact of party support in terms of clearing the field for supported candidates and supporting candidates who win nominations. Obviously, these links are critical to arguing that parties under this new definition retain influence over the nominating process. In all cases, his analysis shows statistically significant results—candidates’ paths to nomination are cleared by party support; party support leads to nomination. House and Senate experience varies to some extent, all explicable by contextual differences between House and Senate races.
In evaluating this work, one is led to question whether statistically significant results in the hypothesized directions are enough to support the claim of party influence. For instance, how often should the field be cleared for the supported candidate in order to show that parties retain their influence? And is clearing the field really the right variable to measure? Is that bar perhaps too high? What if the variable were clearing the field of viable candidates? Who cares if someone is on the ballot who does not raise any money and garners few votes?
Or, to look at the bottom line, Hassell shows that 80% of Senate candidates with party support win; 67% of House candidates win. Are those numbers high—and thus demonstrative of party influence—or are they low? What happens if all incumbents are removed from the analysis? Hassell controls for incumbency for some of his analyses—and he also controls for competitiveness of elections—but not for others. Can we draw a conclusion about party influence if much of that influence is demonstrated by supporting incumbents who win, most of whom win without serious opposition?
Seventy years ago, in Southern Politics (1949), V. O. Key told us about the influence of networks and about the importance of looking at the outliers, the exceptions. Hassell notes that Cohen and his colleagues (“Party Versus Faction in the Reformed Presidential Nominating System,” 2016, PS: Political Science and Politics, 49, 4) had to respond to the nomination of Donald Trump as an exception to their theory of the party deciding. Hassell, too, looked at 2016, to see if his theory held when applied in this case, and he concludes that it did. But what can we learn about the cases in which it does not apply? Who were the one-fifth of Senate nominees and one-third of House nominees who won despite not having party support? What do those nominations say about party influence on the nominating process? What about the Tea Party nominees in 2010 who beat party-supported candidates? What lessons about party influence can be learned from upsets like that of Joe Crowley by Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez in New York’s 2018 Democratic primary?
I raise these questions because Hassell does not. However, I raise them only as questions, not as fundamental criticisms of this work. The Party’s Primary asks many interesting and fundamental questions and answers them in a sophisticated way. In so doing, the book extends the analysis in The Party Decides in a manner that contributes significantly to our understanding of political parties and their role in the electoral process. This perceptive book will garner deserved attention from scholars in the years ahead.
