Ideologically motivated attempts to elucidate Shostakovich’s political views and to determine whether and how they may be coded into his compositions have come to characterize Western reception of the composer’s works since his death in 1975. Fuelled by the political oppositions of the cold war, Shostakovich’s posthumous reputation in the West has been largely shaped by two conflicting perspectives. These have positioned him on the one hand as a secret dissident, bent and broken under the unbearable strain of totalitarianism, made heroic through his veiled musical resistance to Communism; and on the other hand as a composer compromised by his capitulation to the regime – represented in an anachronistic musical style. Both perspectives surrender Shostakovich and his music to a crude oversimplification driven by vested political interests. Western listeners thus conditioned are primed to hear either the coded dissidence of a tragic victim of Communist brutality or the sinister submission of a ‘loyal son of the Communist Party’.Footnote 1 For those prepared to accept Shostakovich as a ‘tragic victim’, the publication of his purported memoirs in 1979, ‘as related to and edited by’ the author Solomon Volkov, presents a tantalizing conclusion: bitterly yet discreetly scornful of the Stalinist regime, Shostakovich was indeed a secret dissident and this dissidence was made tangible in his music. ‘You would have to be a complete oaf ’, in Volkov’s words, not to hear the forced rejoicing in the coda of Shostakovich’s Fifth Symphony, for example.Footnote 2 Volkov’s Testimony was, and remains, a divisive document, fuelling further debates about the composer’s life and works which centre on broader concerns regarding historical revisionism. While Testimony’s veracity has been authoritatively called into question, it has nevertheless been hugely influential on Shostakovich’s Western reception.Footnote 3 The so-called intellectual ‘Shostakovich Wars’ that it instigated have secured Shostakovich’s position in the West as one of the most contentious and deeply mythologized cultural figures of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. The stakes were admittedly high: within the context of cold war hostilities, would Shostakovich become absolved and his music cleansed of its uncomfortable Soviet connection through (purported) authorial intent? Or was it irrevocably ‘morally tainted’ by its association with Stalinism;Footnote 4 was the creative integrity of Shostakovich’s work doomed to be obscured under the rubric of ‘totalitarian art’? Both views have taken their hold over audiences in the West.
In an attempt to move beyond these reductive paradigms and invest nuance into our understanding of Shostakovich’s personal and political reality, recent research is geared towards familiarizing readers with Soviet power and demythologizing the intricate relationship between art and the state in Soviet Russia. Building on the invaluable research conducted within and outside Russia by leading Shostakovich scholars including Olga Digonskaya (the Chief Archivist of the Shostakovich Archive in Moscow), Manashir Yakubov, Marina Frolova-Walker, Elizabeth Wilson, Laurel Fay, Gerard McBurney and Pauline Fairclough, contemporary perspectives on the composer are guided by the understanding that Shostakovich ‘contains multitudes’.Footnote 5 This fundamental position resists the tendencies that have submitted the composer to ideologically motivated binaries that have produced and sustained trite generalizations about him and his times, seeking to distil from Shostakovich’s life the portrait of a dissident hero or a compromised sell-out. Here I highlight the contribution of the musicologist and cultural historian Pauline Fairclough’s new biography of the composer, published as part of Reaktion Books’ Critical Lives series, which consists of short, critical biographies aimed towards a general readership and relating to the lives and works of prominent cultural figures.
A succinct and accessible curation of the most recent research and significant critical perspectives on the composer, Fairclough’s biography is a major addition to the series, constituting a necessary antidote to pervasive Western discourses which condemn Shostakovich as a hapless victim of circumstance. In her focus on the composer’s resilience, his romantic relationships, loyal friendships and empowered civic role, Fairclough invests humanity and agency into the Shostakovich enigma. Viewed through the lens of the recent work within cold war studies and indebted to Laurel Fay’s authoritative and meticulously researched Shostakovich: A Life (see note 3), Fairclough’s biography carves a hopeful path forward for future studies on the composer’s life and works, and serves to demystify the ‘spectre of communism’Footnote 6 which has haunted the reception of Soviet music in the West.
Reflecting on the ‘Shostakovich Wars’ and the composer’s fraught Western reception, Fairclough’s biography highlights the necessity to steer the musicological discourse away from binary frameworks which have defined, for example, the political against the non-political in (to borrow from J. P. E. Harper-Scott’s work on musical modernism) a ‘mimesis of ideological binaries in whose confines the human subject “must” constitute itself ’.Footnote 7 Similarly constructed binaries also pit consonance against dissonance, tonalism against atonalism, Romanticism against modernism (and – emerging out of the influential Adornian discourses of the early twentieth-century – social utility), and popularity against aesthetic quality,Footnote 8 all of which operate within distinct geopolitical centres and peripheries, which themselves (re)produce problematic cultural hierarchies and reinforce canonic boundaries. It is, however, as Nicholas Mathew writes, untenable to speak of political music as though it were a genre ‘implicitly distinct from “non-political music”’, not least because it produces ‘conceptual problems that are hardly alleviated by distinguishing between overtly and covertly (or implicitly) political music’.Footnote 9 Similarly, attempts to divorce tonalism from atonalism and Romanticism from modernism and place them into non-interactive groups often reveal fraught attempts at periodization or a reliance on ideological positions. Indeed, these binary frameworks often reduce composers and their works to clichés. What emerges is the formation of asynchronous, insular music histories with narrow contextual frameworks which function to isolate, exoticize and ghettoize composers by casting them through the lens of discrete groups: political or non-political, nationalist or outsider, Romanticist or Modernist, or (to return to Shostakovich) faithful Soviet citizen or secret dissident.
While today Shostakovich scholarship has largely moved past what Richard Taruskin has called the ‘hermeneutic ventriloquism’Footnote 10 of the ‘Shostakovich Wars’, it remains difficult to untangle Shostakovich from debates regarding the political communication of his works. Shostakovich’s story is told through the history of the Soviet Union, viewed with hindsight as a failed experiment, and the Western comprehension of his works is still beholden to tensions of the cold war era. Resistant to the influential discourses of ‘diachronic historicism’ and ‘resonance’,Footnote 11 to theoretical perspectives on globalization and transnationalism manifested in the ‘global turn’Footnote 12 and to the growing body of work within ethnomusicology and postcolonial music studies which seeks out global connectivities and relativities, Shostakovich scholarship has persistently confined the composer to his ‘slice of time’, and his music continues to be largely defined by the political responses, both supportive and reactionary, which his temporality elicits. Referring back to the debates that constitute the ‘Shostakovich Wars’, and indeed more recent perceptions, it is often the case that our conjectures about Shostakovich have more to say about our own political climate and social landscape than they do about the composer himself. More broadly speaking, history, as Leo Treitler tells us, ‘not only depicts fragments of the past, but documents the present time of writing’.Footnote 13 Our reception of music and the way we respond to it, as James H. Johnson writes, is ‘shaped by dominant aesthetic and social expectations that are themselves historically structured’.Footnote 14 Discussing Shostakovich’s heavily debated Seventh Symphony, written during the siege of Leningrad, Jonathan Lewis writes:
Rather than ask whether the ‘invasion theme’ is an expression of the Nazi war-machine or an expression of the Stalinist regime, perhaps a better question to ask in the age of lost confidence is ‘do we interpret the theme as programmatically representing such and such?’ Even Richard Taruskin, who argues that the programmatic elements of the Seventh Symphony cannot be read out of the context of the immediate, overriding urgencies of the war, observes that if focus is taken away from what the author intended, ‘wartime listeners were just as justified in hearing a representation of Nazis, and we are justified now, if we are still interested in anti-Soviet revisionism, in hearing a representation of the Bolsheviks’.Footnote 15
So where do our Western interests presently lie, when considering Soviet music and in particular Shostakovich? In an era of apparently revived cold war tensions and rhetoric, the preoccupation continues to be how to reconcile Shostakovich’s music, unfailingly popular in the West, with the conditions in which it was created, primarily with Stalinism, which is persistently equated in the West, using the notion of ‘totalitarianism’, with Nazism.Footnote 16 This notion of totalitarianism has been brandished as an intellectual weapon and has been hugely effective in creating and fostering a dichotomy between, as Frolova-Walker writes, ‘the free and unfree’ worlds and their ‘free and unfree art’.Footnote 17 This limiting dual conception undermines the musical integrity of the work belonging to the so-called ‘unfree’ world, dismissing the genuine artistic creativity of its author. Indeed, the rubric of ‘totalitarian art’ often functions to bleach the work’s aesthetic value altogether. In many instances this renders Soviet composition as nothing more than an exercise in responding acceptably to tyranny, inviting casual listening or critical reception to consider (or rather to dismiss) it in such terms.
Soviet composers − Shostakovich primary among them − have thus traditionally occupied their own place in Western twentieth-century music scholarship. Excluded from conventional histories of musical development through inspiration and creative ingenuity, Soviet composers were instead often ‘trapped within narratives of oppression and resistance, collaboration and victimhood’.Footnote 18 In ‘An Inclusive History for a Divided World?’, Frolova-Walker maps out this exclusion and ghettoization, from ‘Robert Morgan’s Anthology of Twentieth-Century Music [which] doesn’t include a single example from Prokofiev or Shostakovich’ to Alex Ross’s The Rest Is Noise, where Shostakovich is confined to a chapter entitled ‘The Art of Fear: Music in Stalin’s Russia’ (the following chapter is entitled ‘Music for All: Music in FDR’s America’).Footnote 19 The current ‘guide’ to Shostakovich on the Classic FM website begins: ‘Was Dmitri Shostakovich a stunningly original composer whose music carries the scars of political intervention, or a devoted Soviet citizen who enshrined the glory of Mother Russia in his symphonies? Whichever way you look at it, there’s certainly no sitting on the fence.’Footnote 20
As Fairclough crucially points out, the vested interests in portraying Shostakovich this way, in literature and the media, are no longer purely political but also commercial. ‘The more the “tragic Shostakovich” image is stoked’, writes Fairclough, ‘the more marketable he is’ (p. 1). This ‘marketing strategy’ has indeed been undoubtedly effective in attracting new audiences to his music, which surely bodes well, considering young people’s waning exposure to classical music as a result of increasingly limited music education programmes in schools. However, we must be attuned to the theatrical misdirection taking place: comprehending Shostakovich in this limited way focuses our attention away from the complexity of the composer’s experiences and indeed from his music. To paraphrase Treitler, if we place too much emphasis on these extramusical connotations and allow them to represent what is interesting and significant about the music, to simulate its meaning and value, we risk, for example, distracting from and undermining the music as an autonomous aesthetic object − that is, the music itself.Footnote 21 Navigating the controversy and debates surrounding Shostakovich that have dominated Western discourse on Soviet music, often driven by post-Soviet revisionism or anti-Soviet Othering, Fairclough emphasizes the most crucial task facing musicologists today: negotiating the aesthetic with political and contextual factors in our evaluations of music’s creation, performance and reception without imposing interpretations skewed by hindsight or serving contemporary political agendas. This task is especially important with regard to the music written into the complex political history of the Soviet Union, which despite our ever-widening temporal distance, indeed continues to invoke impassioned political discussion and debate.
For anglophone readers, the most significant ‘shift of ground’ has been brought about, as Frolova-Walker writes, by Taruskin, since he ‘not only made a notable contribution to Shostakovich studies, but also previously managed to liberate nineteenth-century Russian composers from their historiographical ghetto of nationalism’.Footnote 22 More recent contributions that challenge the geographies of division engendered by persistent cold war politics and attitudes are manifested in research within the field of cold war studies. Although, when considering music, these studies have produced contentious, even contradictory conclusions, this growing body of research has interrogated the complex relationship between music and state institutions on both sides of the iron curtain. Challenging ideologies deeply entrenched in Western musicology and pervasive in popular thought, the research done in this field works to destabilize and revise binary understandings of the ‘free and unfree’ worlds and the music thereof.Footnote 23 In particular, this work has helped to nuance the narrative which traditionally presented Western modernism as the pinnacle of uninhibited creative and intellectual freedom of expression – the ideological antipode of the rigid and repressive strictures of Socialist Realism.
Taking account of the latest research in both English and Russian, Fairclough’s new biography of Shostakovich further distances us from these binary historiographies. Like Taruskin in On Russian Music,Footnote 24 Fairclough begins by contextualizing her Western perspective and acknowledging her own politicized introduction to Shostakovich’s music:
Like that of most music-lovers in the Western world, my introduction to Shostakovich was politicised right from the start: he was presented to me as a persecuted composer trapped in the frightening and repressive world of Soviet Russia. Even decades after the collapse of the Soviet Union, this is still how many of us ‘discover’ Shostakovich: as a ‘tragic victim’ (pp. 9−10).
From this point, she is quick to establish her critical position and distance herself from the pitfalls of viewing Shostakovich within the framework of the ‘tragic victim’ trope. In her interpretations, meaning is not ascribed to the music according to partisan political interests; her interpretations are instead guided by historical materials and it is Shostakovich’s own words which describe how his political circumstances influenced, and may be represented in, his music.
Though I have not been squeamish about interpreting Shostakovich’s music in places, I have no wish to insist on any particular reading: pieces of music are in any case rarely ‘about’ one single message or image. There are as many ways to hear this music as there are listeners, and my way is just one of those. I do not wish to ‘prove’ that Shostakovich had a particular set of political beliefs, since I can only guess at what these might have been. In placing interpretations on particular works, I have been guided by events around them and, where possible, by Shostakovich’s responses, either in letters or in the memories of people around him (p. 11).
In practice, Fairclough’s approach foregrounds primary resources, especially letters and interviews, which are fundamental in humanizing Shostakovich and portraying him as a self-aware, active participant in his historical circumstances, rather than as a passive recipient. This is crucial, especially when dealing with composers and works associated with Communism which, as Joanna Bullivant points out, has been ‘associated with the effacement of the individual, as witnessed by everything from the demand for total identity between the individual and the state, to the stipulation for composers to use national musical materials as a form of collective expression’.Footnote 25 Fairclough’s methodological approach thus locates her study within the growing body of work adopting microhistory as a route into a more intimate and ‘nuanced model of communist selfhood’,Footnote 26 and away from the tropes of the ‘maladapted’ Soviet ‘losers’.Footnote 27
Set against the familiar shifting political climate in which the regime defined and redefined the ‘rules of the game’, Shostakovich’s talent and compositional resilience,Footnote 28 rather than his oppression (which is not, however, underestimated), are at the centre of Fairclough’s depiction. In this vein, the titles of the six chapters illustrate Fairclough’s holistic portrait of Shostakovich: the first chapter addresses his consequential personal relationships throughout his early career (‘“She did not wait for me”’), the second acknowledges his vulnerability to Stalinist terror (‘On the Edge of the Whirlwind’) as a prelude to a closer look at his empowered civic role in ‘speaking for his countrymen’ in the third chapter (‘Civic Responsibility and Self-Assertion’). The subsequent chapters (‘Finding a Way Forward’, ‘The Inner Gaze’, ‘Final Years’), set in the post-Stalinist landscape, acknowledge his perseverance, and the accommodations and adjustments which he duly made to secure his safety and facilitate his late compositions. Without depreciating the incomprehensible trauma of the denunciations of 1937 and 1948 and the backdrop of the Great Purges, Fairclough emphasizes Shostakovich’s immensely difficult, yet remarkably successful, navigation of Soviet cultural politics.
One of Fairclough’s most crucial arguments is that, in the context of historical revisionism in which we (rightfully) dispute Shostakovich’s standing as a ‘loyal son of the Communist party’, we ‘too easily extrapolate […] that he would have preferred to have lived in the “free” West, where he could have composed the music he “really” wished to write; and that is nothing but a Western fantasy of breath-taking presumption’ (p. 10). As cultural life came increasingly under the influence of state apparatus during the interwar period in Soviet Russia, music was often radically political. Though often contradicted and confused, one of the tasks presented to musicians in the immediate aftermath of the Revolution was the demolition of bourgeois musical tradition and the creation of a fundamentally new and proletarian music. Many artists seized the challenge to construct a new innovative musical language with which to depict and promote their radical new milieu. Irreconcilable with the familiar trope of Shostakovich as a tragic victim, which we tend to cast back onto the composer’s professional beginnings, is the understanding that in this early post-revolutionary phase, ‘The personal hardships he and his family had suffered as a result of the Bolshevik takeover’, as Fairclough writes, ‘seem not to have affected his personal feelings toward the radical new social order he found himself living in. On the contrary, Shostakovich gave every indication of finding that new society an inspiring place to live and work’ (p. 29). The fact that there was a top-down, politically motivated instruction to spur artists to break with the past and create new, socialist art is not to say that the October Revolution was not a genuine source of creative inspiration for artists and indeed for the young Shostakovich. This understanding, sensitively asserted by Fairclough, counterpoints contemporary assumptions that the Soviet government was, from its inception, perceived as necessarily evil and deadly by the entirety of its citizens, and this is paramount on the mission to protect Soviet music from the ideological ghetto of ‘totalitarian art’. ‘Chronology is everything’ when looking back at this period of Russian history, such that the periods between approximately 1932 and 1935 and between 1936 and 1939 differed hugely in terms of the population’s experience of political terror and repression (p. 45).Footnote 29 Indeed, for Shostakovich as for many of his countrymen in 1934, as Fairclough tells us, ‘true inhumanity […] lay in the social structure of Tsarist Russia’ and it is worth reminding ourselves, as Fairclough does, what this pre-revolutionary social structure entailed:
Tsarist Russia, where even the abolition of serfdom in 1861 did not really emancipate the peasants […] where completely innocent citizens could be sent into ‘administrative exile’ in Siberia (a living death for many and a literal death for many more); where the vast structural and economic inequalities across the Russian Empire remained the lowest of low priorities for successive Tsars, and where exploitation, violence, early death and lack of basic care, education and rights were all considered absolutely normal (p. 32).
Towards the end of the 1930s, running parallel to policy shifts regarding industrialization and collectivization, Socialist Realism prevailed over modernism.Footnote 30 This signalled a transition from the pluralistic invention and ingenuity of the 1920s to the ‘great appropriation’ of Western classics,Footnote 31 the rehabilitation of imperial classics and the musical panegyrics of Stalinism.Footnote 32 Artists adapted to this shifting terrain, attempting to grasp and satisfy the rubric of Socialist Realism at their own risk. For music, a non-representational art, the prescriptions were difficult for composers to interpret. As he was the pre-eminent Soviet composer, the challenge of carving out what was acceptable − and, more crucially, what was not − fell largely upon Shostakovich’s shoulders. Navigating this shifting terrain was dangerous for artists, all too often fatal, and Shostakovich’s acute awareness of this, having witnessed numerous friends and colleagues being arrested and executed for non-existent crimes, prompted his pragmatism and instinct for self-preservation (p. 176). Shostakovich made the concessions and accommodations necessitated in order to survive Stalinism, and there is no reliable indication that he would have preferred to live and work in the ‘free’ West during this time. Indeed, Shostakovich took the ethical and civic duties imposed by Stalinism ‘very seriously’ and we might, as Fairclough suggests, even ‘say that he was sustained by them’ (p. 11).
Elaborating Taruskin’s portrait in Defining Russia Musically of Shostakovich as a civic composer,Footnote 33 Fairclough emphasizes that when discounting Shostakovich’s populist compositional style during Stalinism as ‘anachronistic’, we underestimate his genuine desire to speak to his countrymen and the seriousness with which he took on the responsibility, in the oeuvre of Socialist Realism, to serve his audiences: ‘Writing for a wide population was in Shostakovich’s DNA […] he wished to communicate through his music, and was pleased when audiences responded to it warmly’ (p. 10). This helps us to understand, as Fairclough notes, why Shostakovich did not return to the ‘more audacious language of the 1920s or ’30s, nor did he seek to copy innovations then in vogue in the West’ after the death of Stalin in 1953 (p. 108). These difficulties in reconciling his music with the political manoeuvring necessary to facilitate its composition epitomize our fraught (mis)understandings of Soviet society and the relationship between Soviet culture and state power. As a starting point we must (building on the work of Taruskin) dismantle the binary narratives of the cultural cold war which position the US and Western Europe against the Soviet Union in terms of their respective aesthetic ideologies. Political music – music designed to serve political goals or intended to inspire political thought across the broad masses – is not a uniquely Soviet phenomenon, nor is it one that necessarily voids cultural products of aesthetic quality. While, as Fairclough writes, ‘it is true that Shostakovich’s career was shaped by social forces that differed from those in capitalist democracies’, we cannot condemn him purely on this basis and conclude that Shostakovich therefore inevitably ‘watered down’ or otherwise compromised his ‘natural’ style (p. 11).
In her discussion of Shostakovich’s life and works throughout her biography, Fairclough focuses on the composer’s relationships (both friendly and romantic), highlighting that they were perhaps as influential on his compositional style as were his trying times. Without indulging in historical detail with a sensationalist or salacious appetite, Fairclough refers to Shostakovich’s newly discovered or previously unpublished correspondence with various love interests and his closest friends, Isaak Glikman and Ivan Sollertinsky, reflecting on the rejections, disappointments, conquests and compromises that marked his problematic romantic relationships. This correspondence reveals that he was often impulsive, indecisive and ‘emotionally vulnerable, easily led and prone to sudden and drastic romantic decisions’ (p. 33). If we are to understand his ‘multitudes’ and appreciate the depth and polysemy of his works, which were often invested with romantic messages, alongside and perhaps more prominently than political ones, this archival material is invaluable. With the prospect of the release of further romantic correspondence,Footnote 34 Fairclough’s measured approach to this sensitive data, in which she avoids exercising personal judgment and instead allows the narrative to be shaped by Shostakovich’s own words, should set the benchmark for future analysis.
While the Western comprehension of Shostakovich’s life and works has been fraught by problematic binarisms (political versus non-political, partisan versus ironic, timely versus anachronistic), we cannot strive to detach Shostakovich and his music from these political or aesthetic associations – to mute the interference of politics in his music, to disconnect and in so doing attempt to purify his life and legacy. I agree with Fairclough that Shostakovich ‘is at his most fascinating when heard as a true child of his time’.Footnote 35 Shostakovich emerged from a crucible of experimentation and creativity, genuinely inspired by the task of creating a new, inclusive Soviet art that reflected the spirit of the times and could communicate it to the people. With an unfaltering work ethic, even when set against unfathomable personal and political hardship, the young Shostakovich emerged in the Soviet Union as the pre-eminent composer, alongside Vladimir Tatlin and Kazimir Malevich in the visual arts, Vsevolod Meyerhold and Alexander Tairov in theatre, Vladimir Mayakovsky in poetry and Sergei Eisenstein and Dziga Vertov in film. Against a backdrop of cultural internationalism of the 1920s and early 1930s, Soviet Russia became established as a cultural superpower, rivalling its Western counterparts.Footnote 36 As the cultural landscape of the 1930s shifted to meet the new political requirements dictated by the Second World War, composers needed to respond to and reflect the concerns of the people, in a style that remained ‘socialist’ in content (still reflecting the ideological backbone of their social order) and ‘national’ in form (now having to respond to the new, nationalist demands of the ‘Great Patriotic War’).Footnote 37 Until his death, Shostakovich fulfilled this role. Our response cannot therefore strive to remove the political from Shostakovich, for this is precisely what made him and what, for better or for worse, continues to influence our interpretations of his life and work. The Seventh Symphony, for example, to cite one of Shostakovich’s most frequently performed and discussed works in the West, can perhaps be understood only as a sonic-experiential device of resistance and resilience − a Soviet intervention in our Western and logocentric histories of the Second World War. Removing this connotational meaning from the work would be to impoverish its aesthetic power and undermine the sheer grit, determination and sacrifice required by its composition and its momentous performance in besieged Leningrad in 1942. All subsequent performances carry forth this connotational baggage, and the work is ever richer and more meaningful as a result of it.
Without committing composers to fraught generic binaries, resolving the conceptual problems that arise through tendentious attempts to reveal authorial intent or personal political beliefs, we must aim to emphasize how music, its affective power and connotational meaning, for example, is multiple, changing and conditioned by various complex and even conflicting personal, social, cultural and historical factors. Above all, this establishes a framework through which we can appreciate composers’ nuanced mobility in between and across persistent binary musicological discourses. This can emerge from the rubble of the ‘Shostakovich Wars’ only through the growth of a scholarship that is primarily focused on investing agency into our portraits of composers embedded within complex political contexts and whose works resonate politically in a powerful way, spotlighting the variety and diversity of their human experience. It is within this scholarly tradition that I locate Fairclough’s biography of Shostakovich. While the biography’s length (192 pages) has its inevitable limitations, therein lies one of its primary strengths, as Fairclough brings her measured and sympathetic depiction of Shostakovich, infused with the fundamental argumentation of Taruskin and Fay, to the casual as well as the expert (anglophone) reader. Fairclough grapples with the complexity of Shostakovich’s various experiences and political and aesthetic positions and tackles head-on the frequent interaction of ‘conflicting priorities in his work’,Footnote 38 for which Shostakovich ‘seemed to divide himself into compartments’ (p. 175). While such an approach may initially seem uncontroversial, it is important to point out that, as has been the case with Shostakovich, binary premisses continue to construct a bulwark against serious and fair-minded critical analysis of composers and their works. Recent studies of Alan Bush, for example, and my ongoing research on the composer Nikos Skalkottas, confined within narratives of peripherality and political naivety, illustrate the ongoing presence and persistence of these notions.Footnote 39
Writing to the music theorist Boleslav Yavorsky in 1925, Shostakovich imagines what he would write to his teachers at the Moscow Conservatoire, from whom he won ‘far from clear-cut approval’ for his experimental First Symphony (p. 22): ‘And now give me my freedom. Let me listen to the voice which comes from inside me, and don’t force me to unquestioningly accept – what I hear you tell me. There shall be no musical servitude … Give me my freedom!’ Assisted by newly discovered or accessible primary resources, Fairclough carries on the work of Fay and Taruskin to undermine binary musical historiographies, defying cold war narratives of Shostakovich’s ‘musical servitude’ to any musical tutelage or indeed to a prescriptive regime. To continue this work, liberating the man and his music from these narratives in the West and investing in deeper understandings of his multitudes may, at last, grant Shostakovich his freedom.
