Rachel Bronson's Thicker than Oil: America's Uneasy Partnership with Saudi Arabia takes on an important subject matter, the history of the U.S.–Saudi relationship, and makes an important contribution to the literature. Bronson's book is thoroughly researched, with extensive citations to diplomatic accounts, autobiographies, government documents, and interesting interviews woven into a storyboard text that is likeable and enjoyable to read. The author sets out to demonstrate that the two countries had “overlapping strategic interests” that drove together “successive Saudi kings and American administrations” (p. 3). In the aftermath of the September 11 terrorist attacks on the United States and the uncomfortable fact that many of the perpetrators of that attack were Saudi nationals, it is a point well worth making. Saudi Arabia and the United States have been allies for many decades and have a complex and multilayered friendship—a friendship that has been interrupted more than once by periods of heightened tensions or outright geopolitical disagreements, not the least of which was the period of the oil embargo of 1973—which has survived and thrived despite such tensions.
It is against this background of long and complicated interaction that the United States and Saudi Arabia need to find a positive path forward, and it is by understanding whence the relationship came and why it has lasted so long that the two countries can best hammer out their future relations. In this regard, Bronson has picked an excellent time to look back and pursues an excellent premise—that the relationship between the United States and Saudi Arabia is about far more than a simple “oil for defense” arrangement.
The main thesis of Thicker than Oil is that a “critical, if often overlooked aspect of the U.S.–Saudi relationship, has been the shared interest in combating the Soviet Union” (p. 68). Bronson proves this point with gusto, relaying wonderful stories and hard evidence that Cold War concerns were a core aspect of the glue that bound the United States and Saudi Arabia together in spite of other competing interests and cultural differences. Bronson lays out many different ways the desert kingdom assisted with the containment of the Soviet Union, including its service as a religious bulwark against Soviet meddling in the region, the provision of its geographically valued air space to the Americans and denial of that air space to Soviets, and its important regional diplomatic and military role that was tapped in various ways over the decades to assist the U.S. policy of containment. The book is filled with countless and interesting anecdotes that support this thesis, including a tale of how it was the conservative Saudi king Faisal looked the other way when supplying the U.S. military with fuel for the war in Vietnam even while publicly and officially imposing an embargo on oil sales to the United States.
Students looking for examples of how the oil industry influenced international relations in an earlier period will also find valuable excerpts in Thicker than Oil as the book lays out excellent documented anecdotes of how American businessmen served in the capacity of unofficial diplomats on behalf of more than one U.S. administration. Bronson's historical account documents the backdoor role American oil company ARAMCO played as a channel to the Saudi ruling regime and provides insight into how unofficial diplomacy can sometimes succeed where direct efforts might have failed. It also shows the importance of such backdoor channels during periods of tensions between two governments.
My one criticism of Bronson's book is that she is so committed to demonstrating the importance and common interest in fighting Communism that she misses the opportunity to lay out a more nuanced history, including a host of social and political movements and other important economic interests that might have been as important to Saudi thinking—if not more important at certain junctures—as the Cold War. Bronson's Cold War focus makes for a coherent volume, but it also washes out some interesting analysis of religious, geopolitical, and economic trends that might have been equally important to consider in observing the history of U.S.–Saudi relations, especially for the period after 1980.
Sticking with her Cold War theme, Bronson writes, “After a decade of détente, a policy that Saudi Arabia never supported, King Fahd welcomed Reagan's determination to confront Soviet pressure more directly” (p. 168). Bronson spends an entire chapter recounting that Saudi Arabia contributed to anti-Soviet causes as far away as Nicaragua and Angola. However, Thicker than Oil downplays competing interpretations that Saudi Arabia might have seen the Cold War with a more mixed, less U.S.-centric perspective and ignores other important aspects of the U.S.–Saudi relationship at the time, not the least of which was the common concern about the activities of the new theocratic regime in Tehran.
This begs a question. By the 1980s, was Saudi Arabia pursuing anti-Communist adventures because it feared the party or because it wanted to maintain a close alliance with the United States for other reasons, including regional security and economic interests? Arab Communist movements might have threatened the stability of royal regimes in the Middle East in the 1950s and 1960s, but by 1980 those movements had lost ground in the region. Instead, Iran's early attempts to spread its revolution in the region became a major concern for the kingdom, which Bronson mentions briefly (pp. 146–47) but does not investigate as fully as this reader would have liked. In light of current Middle East politics, the Iranian question, it can be argued, was at least as important to the U.S.–Saudi alliance—post-1979—as the anti-Soviet piece of the puzzle. A more equal discussion of both factors would have been useful.
Bronson also glosses over some other crucial aspects of the U.S.–Saudi post-1980 relationship, including the kingdom's proactive interventions in the global oil market. A more thorough treatment of the recycling of Saudi petrodollars (for example, to Latin America, the U.S. arms industry, and the U.S. Treasury) could also have highlighted other interesting aspects of the U.S.–Saudi relationship.
Still, Bronson makes a thoughtful contribution to geopolitical analysis by bringing to light the influence that the Cold War had on the U.S.–Saudi alliance. By highlighting the function of this issue in the relationship, Thicker than Oil promotes a similarly thoughtful starting point to discuss what has changed in U.S.–Saudi bilateral relations and what remained the same. The end of the Cold War has dramatically changed the landscape for U.S. policy in the Middle East, a fact that needs to be clearly understood as we fashion new approaches. Bronson's book helps enlighten that discussion by bringing to life this history and letting us see more clearly how things were done in the past and how some very basic considerations have changed.
