In his 1995 book Isaiah Berlin, John Gray argued that Berlin had outlined a “distinctive, and highly original” conception of liberalism—a conception that repudiated one of the central assumptions of the liberal tradition.Footnote 1 Berlin stood apart from other liberals, in Gray's view, because he tried to rest liberalism on a new philosophical foundation: value pluralism. As Gray read it, there were two broad steps to Berlin's justification of liberalism: (1) if value pluralism is true, then none but liberal political institutions can be justified; (2) value pluralism is true.Footnote 2 Gray maintained, however, that this distinctive justification of liberalism, though it was “formidable and plausible,” was a failure. The problem, in his view, lay in the first step: Berlin failed to show that value pluralism could endow liberal institutions with “universal authority.” Gray held that value pluralism, properly understood, actually deprived liberalism of any such authority.
Since Gray's book was published, a great deal has been written about the relationship between value pluralism and liberalism, much of it focused on Berlin. Several philosophers—most recently, George Crowder and William Galston—have taken up Gray's challenge and tried to defend step (1) of the argument that Gray attributed to Berlin.Footnote 3 They tried to show that value pluralism does in fact entail liberalism. I will call this the entailment claim. I begin this essay by arguing that this claim is mistaken: value pluralism yields only indeterminate political conclusions; as Gray recognized, and as Berlin himself came to see, it does not entail liberal political institutions.
If Gray was right to reject the entailment claim, however, his reading of Berlin has contributed to several misunderstandings—both about Berlin's philosophy and about the relationship between value pluralism and liberalism—which have survived for the last fifteen years. First, there is very little evidence that Berlin endorsed the entailment claim in the first place. Gray and others rely heavily on the final section of “Two Concepts of Liberty,” in which Berlin makes mention of “pluralism, with the measure of ‘negative’ liberty that it entails.”Footnote 4 Berlin seldom repeated this claim; in fact, he later explicitly denied it—he certainly did not make it a centerpiece of his philosophy. Second and importantly, Berlin never set out to offer a foundational justification of liberalism. In fact, Berlin's philosophical corpus—from start to finish—suggests that he doubted that such justification was even possible.Footnote 5 In attributing foundational ambitions to Berlin, Gray, along with Crowder and Galston, among others, has helped turn him into a spokesman for a philosophical project that was not really his.Footnote 6 In doing so, they have made his philosophy seem weaker and less coherent than it is; they have also (mostly) neglected some of Berlin's most compelling insights about the relationship between value pluralism and liberalism.
In the second half of this essay, I argue that Berlin understood the relationship between value pluralism and liberalism in largely psychological terms. He believed that those who embraced value pluralism, along with a certain kind of empiricism about human values, would be more likely to affirm liberal institutions because they would be more likely to exhibit certain virtues—notably, empathy, imagination, and openness to other ways of life—that motivate tolerance.Footnote 7 I draw support for this reading largely from an essay titled “John Stuart Mill and the Ends of Life,” which, though it is rarely considered in this context, remains one of the few essays in which Berlin addresses the justification of liberalism directly and at length. In fact, I argue that Berlin's treatment of Mill supplies a key piece of evidence, both in vindicating the psychological reading of Berlin and in clarifying his view of liberalism's justification, for this is the only piece in which Berlin actually executes a value-pluralist defense of liberal institutions.
This is an essay, then, about the relationship between value pluralism, as Isaiah Berlin understood it, and liberalism. I begin by rejecting one view of this relationship; I then outline another, more plausible view and argue that it was in fact Berlin's.
The Idea of Value Pluralism
As George Crowder has argued, the idea of value pluralism combines four different propositions. The first is that human values are objective, not relative or subjective. For Berlin, the objectivity of value was linked to a teleology of the human person: human beings flourished, he thought, when they lived by some combination of these objective values; they failed to flourish to the extent that they ignored them.Footnote 8 This was true for all human beings, in all times and places. The second claim is that these objective values are plural: there are many of them, though their number is finite. Berlin never gave an exhaustive list; in fact, he never thought it possible to do so, because new objective values could always, in principle, be discovered. But he included such values as justice, compassion, courage, equality, honor, and negative and positive liberty, among others.
Third, these values conflict with one another in both personal and political life. We cannot, for instance, always be both just and compassionate—these values sometimes pull in different directions. Likewise, we cannot always pursue policies that advance both equality and (negative) liberty. In many concrete cases, these values will conflict, and we will have to choose between them. Fourth, objective values are incommensurable. This is the claim that makes value pluralism distinctive: values cannot be arranged neatly into a hierarchy of importance, so that every conflict between values could be arbitrated through appeal to some higher value. Nor is there even any “common denominator,” as Crowder puts it, in terms of which rival values can be measured. Berlin often expressed this fourth claim as a point about the limits of reason itself: “Rationality and calculation,” he writes, “can be applied only to means or subordinate ends, but never to ultimate ends.”Footnote 9 What he means here is not that conflicts between objective values must be settled without appeal to any reasons at all, but rather that there will often be no single, rationally correct solution.
Berlin gives countless examples, scattered through his many essays on the subject, of the conflict between incommensurable yet objective values. Sometimes he locates the conflict within a single individual's life, as in the example of the artist who must choose between his vocation and the well-being of his destitute family.Footnote 10 Sometimes the conflict shows up in the political dilemmas of a particular community, as in the example of the polity that recognizes that liberty “may have to be curtailed in order to make room for social welfare,” or vice versa.Footnote 11 But often, the conflict is between entire cultures, which represent “incompatible ideals of life.” Consider this example, drawn from his essay on Machiavelli:
One is the morality of the pagan world: its values are courage, vigour, fortitude in adversity, public achievement, order, discipline, happiness, strength, justice, above all assertion of one's proper claims and the knowledge and power needed to secure their satisfaction. … Against this moral universe (moral or ethical no less in Croce's terms than in the traditional sense, that is, embodying ultimate human ends however these are conceived) stands in the first and foremost place Christian morality. The ideals of Christianity are charity, mercy, sacrifice, love of God, forgiveness of enemies, contempt for the goods of this world, faith in the life hereafter, belief in the salvation of the individual soul as being of incomparable value.Footnote 12
For Berlin, as for Berlin's Machievelli, pagan and Christian ways of life alike had objective value, and neither was categorically superior to the other. To those who were in position to choose between them, there was no correct answer, no single, rationally privileged solution.
Berlin was careful to distinguish value pluralism from cultural relativism; he maintained that the values instantiated in pagan and Christian culture were objective values. But relativism was not the main target of his criticism; his target was what he called “monism.” Berlin believed that the Western philosophical tradition, from Plato onward, had been seduced by the possibility of discovering a single, rational hierarchy of human values—a moral or political utopia. “One assumption was common to all these views,” he writes, describing the whole arc of Western intellectual history from Plato through Christianity to the Enlightenment: they held that “it was, at any rate in principle, possible to draw some outline of the perfect society or the perfect man. … Problems of value were in principle soluble, and soluble with finality.”Footnote 13 Berlin was an adamant critic of monism throughout his career; he thought that it was an especially pernicious mistake, with important consequences for the modern world.
The ill effects of monism could be felt, he thought, in both personal and political life. In personal life, monism led to moral complacency and self-deception:
Happy are those who live under a discipline which they accept without question, who freely obey the orders of leaders, spiritual or temporal, whose word is fully accepted as unbreakable law; or those who have, by their own methods, arrived at clear and unshakeable convictions about what to do and what to be that brook no possible doubt. I can only say that those who rest on such comfortable beds of dogma are victims of forms of self-induced myopia, blinkers that make for contentment, but not for understanding of what it is to be human.Footnote 14
Such lines do not sit well with the image of Berlin as an enthusiastic multiculturalist. Berlin believed, as I will argue later, that human beings develop their distinctive faculties only in confronting and making difficult choices—choices between competing, incommensurable values. Monists are those who pretend that there are no such choices to make. Berlin thought that, in doing so, they not only misunderstand the human condition, but they also fail to develop the faculties that he—like John Stuart Mill—most admired.
But monism's most disastrous consequences, in Berlin's view, were political. Monism underwrote the forms of political utopianism that he most despised: fascism and totalitarian communism. “The possibility of a final solution—even if we forget the terrible sense that these words acquired in Hitler's day—turns out to be an illusion; and a very dangerous one,” writes Berlin. “For if one really believes that such a solution is possible, then surely no cost would be too high to obtain it.”Footnote 15 Monism lent support to political fanatics who terrorized their people in the name of distant utopias. Here lay Berlin's deepest objection to it. It is possible, as Berlin readily acknowledged, to be a monist without being a political fanatic. But he thought not only that many of the twentieth century's worst fanatics—the Stalins and Pol Pots—were monists, but also that their fanaticism drew strength from their monism.Footnote 16
Berlin's criticisms of political utopianism suggest one way of understanding the relationship between value pluralism and liberalism. Value pluralism was a philosophical weapon designed to attack utopianism; in doing so, it would help undermine the greatest twentieth-century enemy of liberalism. If there was no “final solution,” no single hierarchy of human values that could be used as a blueprint for the perfectly just or free or virtuous society, if instead there were many valuable but incommensurable alternatives, then the whole philosophical edifice that justified utopianism was false. Berlin often used value pluralism in precisely this negative way: he used it to locate the central ethical mistake that “more than any other, is responsible for the slaughter of individuals on the altars of the great historical ideals.”Footnote 17
But in order to believe, as Berlin did, that value pluralism could be an ally of political liberalism, he had to believe not only that it refuted utopianism, but also that it did not similarly refute liberalism itself. He had to believe—at least—that value pluralism and liberalism were mutually consistent. And here is where the controversy arises. As many of Berlin's critics have pointed out, the path that leads from value pluralism to liberalism is far from clear. To begin with, many of the seminal liberal thinkers—including John Locke, J. S. Mill, and Immanuel Kant—were themselves monists. So value pluralism stands as a challenge, not only to illiberal utopianism, but also to some of the most influential justifications of liberalism. Furthermore, value pluralism suggests—at first glance, anyway—that liberal values are but some among many legitimate human values, and that they cannot be given categorical priority over their illiberal rivals. The fact that Berlin never gave a systematic, analytical account of the relationship between value pluralism and liberalism only deepens the mystery.
Illiberal Pluralism
There is good evidence to suggest that Berlin himself came to reject the view that value pluralism entails liberalism. In 1997—the year he died—Berlin wrote, for instance, that “pluralism allows for all kinds of illiberalisms: suppressions of negative liberty.”Footnote 18 Still, a number of philosophers—notably Crowder and Galston—have continued to attribute the entailment claim to Berlin, and though they argue that Berlin's version of it was incomplete, they have tried to show that some version of the entailment claim is nonetheless correct.Footnote 19 I begin this section by outlining a coherent, value-pluralist justification of illiberal institutions; I then use this justification to show that both Crowder and Galston are mistaken.
If value pluralism is true, then any regime that tries to justify itself through appeal to the one true human good, or by arguing that it instantiates the one true hierarchy of human values, is illegitimate.Footnote 20 Its justification is false. Of course, as I suggested earlier, value pluralism invalidates illiberal and liberal monist regimes alike. It rules out Marxist totalitarianism, but is also rules out Kantian or utilitarian liberalism. It permits only regimes that justify themselves on pluralist grounds. And as Gray emphasized, there is no reason to suppose that all such regimes will be liberal:
It is true that value-pluralism undermines the universalist claims made by illiberal societies that are Marxist, utilitarian or positivist, Platonist, Christian or Muslim, at their foundations; but human history to date, and the human prospect for the likely future, abound with illiberal cultures that are particularistic, not universalistic, in the values they claim to embody. Authoritarian regimes sustained by Hindu, Shinto or Orthodox Jewish doctrine, or which seek simply to preserve a local way of life, make none of the universal claims that value-pluralism subverts.Footnote 21
The challenge for Galston and Crowder is to show that there is something incoherent in these kinds of justification; that is, in pluralist justifications of illiberal regimes.
To put the question more sharply, imagine two alternative societies. The first is a liberal society that tolerates a great deal of ethical and cultural diversity within its borders.Footnote 22 The second is an illiberal society that uses state coercion to encourage and enforce a certain particular way of life. Suppose that the rulers of this second society freely acknowledge that there are—or at least that there may be—many objectively valuable yet incommensurable ways of life. They acknowledge, in other words, that the way of life they enforce is but one of many objectively valuable possibilities.
To make this second society more concrete, suppose that its rulers justify their coercion as follows: They argue that many citizens of liberal, tolerant societies, if not most, live corrupt or degraded lives—that is, lives that (largely) fail to instantiate any objective values at all. The tolerant liberal state, they point out, is constrained to remain neutral between objectively valuable ways of life and corrupt, degraded ways of life. And because the temptations associated with ethical degradation are strong, corrupt ways of life often triumph over virtuous ones in open competition. They maintain, for instance, that hedonistic materialism is the style of life most likely to take root in diverse liberal societies, and that this way of life has no objective value. While they acknowledge that their own society may rule out many objectively valuable ways of life, they point out that it also forbids many of the most tempting forms of ethical corruption—including hedonistic materialism. The net result, they claim, is that their own citizens are far more likely to lead lives that are guided by values that are in fact objective.Footnote 23 They argue, in other words, that anyone interested in maximizing the ratio of objectively good to bad lives will choose against liberal society.Footnote 24
Patrick Devlin's famous defense of the criminalization of homosexuality in 1950s Britain can serve as an example of this sort of reasoning. Devlin argued, not that homosexuality was wrong, but rather than it threatened to rend the moral fabric that bound British life together. Such fabric was necessary, he thought, because absent a coherent set of ethical idealş taught and encouraged by law and culture, people would tend to lapse into degradation. We might paraphrase his argument as follows: the way of life Britain enforces may not be the only objectively good one available, but it is nonetheless important that the British government enforce it, for absent such enforcement, people tend to lead degraded, objectively valueless lives.Footnote 25 This perspective draws strength from a Burkean pessimism about the choices that individuals are likely to make absent strong and coherent ethical norms. And as long as the values enforced by the state are in fact objective values, this illiberal approach is wholly consistent with value pluralism. The challenge, in any case, for anyone who believes that value pluralism entails liberalism, is to show that there is something incoherent in this pluralist defense of illiberal repression. Neither Crowder nor Galston succeeds in doing so.
Crowder begins his argument with a point drawn from Bernard Williams: “If there are many competing values, then the greater the extent to which a society tends to be single-valued, the more genuine values it neglects or suppresses. More to this extent, must mean better.”Footnote 26 Crowder goes on to suggest that this argument proceeds in two steps. First, accepting value pluralism means endorsing all objective values “on an equal basis with one another.”Footnote 27 It is not enough simply to acknowledge the existence of plural, objective values; their very objectivity commands that we value them. Second, the best way to value the full range of human goods is to accommodate as many as possible, and the regime that best accomplishes this goal is a liberal one.Footnote 28 Crowder suggests, in effect, that governments ought to maximize the number of objective values that can be pursued within their borders.Footnote 29
It is an open question, as Crowder acknowledges, whether a world of liberal states will in fact tend to promote more ethical diversity than a world of illiberal states, or a world that includes both. But the deeper problem is that it is unclear why the proliferation of different objective values, as such, should matter at all. From the illiberal, pluralist point of view that I outlined earlier, such proliferation means very little if, for instance, these values survive only in small enclaves while the majority lapses into ethical degradation. Imagine, for example, a liberal consumer society that accommodates many different, objectively valuable ways of life, but in which most people simply ignore them. Crowder himself acknowledges that the ambition to maximize the number of objective values in existence seems like a “chiefly aesthetic” concern.Footnote 30 If value pluralism is to be an attractive view, there must be other ways of understanding its requirements.
In fact, Crowder himself rejects this strictly aesthetic interpretation. He concedes that maximization alone might not be desirable, because it might yield a society that pursues “too many different goods.”Footnote 31 A society that accommodates too many conflicting goods may actually make it harder, he concedes, for individuals to lead good lives. He quotes John Kekes's worry that lives can be “too scattered. Projects are begun and then discontinued, enthusiasms ebb and flow, the attractions of many possibilities are perceived but too few of them are realized.”Footnote 32 Crowder argues, therefore, that societies can legitimately restrict the number of values they accommodate in order to promote “balance or coherence” among them.Footnote 33 What matters here is not the sheer number of objective values in existence, but rather the extent to which human individuals are able to create good lives, lives that embody objective human values.
Crowder suggests that this principle of coherence could complement the principle of maximization. But as Patrick Neal has argued, it can just as easily be used to undermine maximization altogether.Footnote 34 It opens the door, in any case, for societies to argue that their central concern is not to maximize the number of values they accommodate, but to maximize the number of lives that are actually guided by objective, rather than false or corrupt, values. Whether or not repressive regimes can in fact achieve this goal more successfully than liberal regimes will depend on a number of things. It will depend, first, on how well, as an empirical matter, political repression can in fact discourage people from embracing corrupt values. It will also depend on which values turn out to be objective.Footnote 35 If hedonistic materialism, say, turns out to be an objectively valuable way of life, then liberal societies probably compare favorably to repressive, traditionalist societies. If not, they may not. The point here is that value pluralism alone does not compel societies to accommodate a broad range of values.
Crowder resists this conclusion with another argument drawn from John Kekes. For any individual to flourish, he suggests, that individual's life must instantiate a variety of values. “Good lives should have some scope for the appreciation of beauty, playfulness, and nonutilitarian relationships, as well as for tackling difficult projects that require hard work, discipline, and self-control. Lives involving single-minded concentration on a very narrow range of values will be impoverished.”Footnote 36 Crowder is right about this. But stated in these terms, his claim does not yield the conclusions he hopes for, because most illiberal societies are not so narrow as to exclude beauty, playfulness, or self-discipline. All societies allow some variety of values; the question is how much variety value pluralism compels them to allow. And again, there seems to me nothing in the idea of value pluralism that requires Crowder's principle of maximization.
Crowder develops several other, secondary strategies for deriving liberalism from value pluralism. I will mention one more here, which involves the idea of “reasonable disagreement.” If values are plural and incommensurable, then it will be quite reasonable for citizens to disagree about ethical questions. To his credit, Crowder recognizes that value pluralism in itself does not compel respect for all “reasonable” ethical doctrines—this is a Kantian, contractualist idea. Instead, Crowder argues that, as an empirical matter, reasonable disagreements can seldom be settled by force. Here Crowder relies on the Lockean premise that “attempts to compel agreement on matters that attract disagreement among reasonable people will be not only costly, but futile.”Footnote 37 He also cites Berlin's view that “drastic action” typically exacts a high cost in human suffering.Footnote 38 The problems with this line of argument are all too obvious: even if this were true as an empirical matter, it might compel heterogeneous societies to accommodate diversity, but it gives relatively homogenous, traditionalist societies no good reason to liberalize. At best, then, this line of argument gives us what Crowder would call “contextual,” not universal, support for liberal institutions.
Galston's strategy is somewhat more modest than Crowder's. In a 2004 article, he explicitly denies that he endorses the entailment claim.Footnote 39 Indeed, he suggests that there are two circumstances in which illiberal policies might be consistent with value pluralism. First, when there is perfect consensus around a certain way of life, the state does nothing wrong in enforcing that consensus. Second, when the only alternative to illiberal repression is violent conflict that threatens to undermine “basic decency,” then value pluralists can make their peace with such repression. Still, when neither of these circumstances obtains, he suggests that value pluralism does entail liberalism—or if not liberalism, a “space for individual and political choice … roughly congruent with the liberty that liberalism seeks to defend.”Footnote 40 Even this weakened version of the entailment claim, however, ultimately fails.
Galston begins by pointing out that value pluralism undermines any “restrictive state policies whose justification rests uneliminably on the assertion that there is … a uniquely valuable ordering [of human values].”Footnote 41 This much is true: as Gray acknowledges, value pluralism rules out monist justifications of liberal and illiberal regimes alike. But in order to gain traction against illiberal regimes that do not invoke monist justifications, Galston has to add another important step to the argument. “Because there is no single, uniquely rational ordering or combination of values,” he argues, “no one can provide a valid reason, binding on all individuals, for a particular ranking or combination.”Footnote 42 And absent such reasons, Galston thinks that it would be “unreasonable” for the state to impose any way of life on its citizens.Footnote 43 This last step is the crucial one, and Galston never succeeds in justifying it adequately.
“Taken seriously,” Galston argues, “value pluralism generates a principle of estoppal that denies the admissibility of the sorts of claims that the bearers of state power have used throughout human history to justify restrictions on individuals' ability to live in accordance with diverse but defensible conceptions of what gives life meaning and worth.”Footnote 44 This is a claim he repeats in a number of different books and articles, and yet there remains some ambiguity about it. In one article, he summarizes his “principle of estoppal” as follows: “no political or moral argument that denies the truth of value pluralism can stand.”Footnote 45 If this is all he means, then the principle has no traction against illiberal regimes that acknowledge the truth of value pluralism (such as the hypothetical regime I described above).Footnote 46 Let us call this the weak version of the principle. There is substantial evidence, however, that Galston in fact endorses a more ambitious version of the principle of estoppal—a version that does have traction even against illiberal regimes that affirm value pluralism. He suggests as much when he claims, for instance, that value pluralism “has important implications for politics,” namely, that states “may not seek to force their citizens into one-size-fits-all patterns of desirable human lives.”Footnote 47
How, then, can the principle of estoppal yield these stronger conclusions? The stronger version of the principle says that so long as a certain way of life is “rationally defensible,” citizens cannot reasonably be denied the opportunity to pursue it (unless the only alternative is violent chaos). And since value pluralism holds that many different ways of life are rationally defensible, value pluralism effectively constrains government from imposing any particular way of life on its citizens. The problem with this view is that it imports a strong presumption in favor of freedom—a presumption that finds no warrant in the idea of value pluralism itself. In fact, Galston acknowledges this presumption in his 2004 “Reply to Talisse”—he calls it “expressive liberty.” Expressive liberty, he says, “is a presumption in favor of individuals and groups leading their lives as they see fit … in accordance with their own understandings of what gives life meaning and value.”Footnote 48 With this added premise, Galston's position does indeed gain traction against the illiberal pluralist—in fact, this added premise is doing all the work.Footnote 49 But since this premise cannot be derived from value pluralism, illiberal pluralists can simply reject it.Footnote 50 They can reject it, for instance, for the reasons I outlined earlier: because they believe it leads to more wasted or degraded lives. Adding this extra premise does nothing, then, to reveal any incoherence in the illiberal pluralist justification that I outlined earlier. And if this is true, then Galston is not entitled to say that “while illiberal associations with full exit rights are consistent with value pluralism, illiberal polities that impose a way of life on some subset of their citizens are not.”Footnote 51
Robert Talisse has challenged Galston on similar grounds.Footnote 52 In response to Talisse, Galston invites readers to imagine a ruler who proposes to impose way of life “T” on citizens, and who justifies this by claiming that “T is preferable to (U, V, W, … n) for all citizens.”Footnote 53 To this, Galston thinks that citizens can simply respond that “they endorse (U, V, W, … n)” instead. And if value pluralism is true, then the ruler has no way of showing them conclusively that T is superior to these other ways of life. But this response does not get to the real issue: Galston never shows why states must justify restrictions of liberty in precisely this manner, by showing conclusively that the way of life they seek to impose is “preferable for all citizens” to any other alternatives. In fact, as I have already shown, there are other, more modest justificatory alternatives: illiberal states can claim, for instance, that their imposition of T gives citizens the best chance of living an objectively valuable life, while granting that T is no better than a host of other objective values or ways of life. I can see nothing in Galston's argument, short of his distinctly liberal idea of expressive freedom, that shows why such justifications should be ruled out.Footnote 54
Like Crowder, then, Galston fails to show that value pluralism either entails liberalism or even prohibits illiberal repression. Both do shed some light, however, on Berlin's own understanding of the relationship between liberalism and value pluralism. In a passage that Crowder later quotes, Galston writes,
A narrow society is one in which only a small fraction of inhabitants can live their lives in a manner consistent with their flourishing and satisfaction. The rest will be pinched and stunted to some considerable degree. … To the maximum extent possible in human affairs, liberal societies do avoid this kind of pinching.Footnote 55
This argument does not follow, as a matter of logical entailment, from value pluralism. Rather, it imports two additional assumptions: first, that individuals are not highly malleable, that any attempt to impose a certain way of life on them will “stunt” or “pinch” many of them; second, that what matters most, morally, is the well-being of individuals, and not the flourishing of anything so abstract as values or cultures or ways of life. These are among the familiar liberal insights that Berlin derives from John Stuart Mill.
Berlin, Mill, and the Moral Psychology of Tolerance
Berlin's essay on Mill stands out, partly because Berlin rarely wrote about fellow liberals. The thinkers who typically fascinated him—from Karl Marx to Johann Georg Hamann or Giambattista Vico—were either critics of liberalism or precursors to it. “John Stuart Mill and the Ends of Life” is an exception, all the more unusual because it addresses the philosophical justification of liberalism directly. In fact, Berlin not only explores Mill's justification of liberalism, he also seems to endorse it as the best available. “[Mill's] is still the clearest, most candid, persuasive, and moving exposition,” writes Berlin, “of the point of view of those who desire an open and tolerant society.”Footnote 56 It is puzzling that philosophers trying to reconstruct Berlin's own account of liberalism have paid this essay relatively little attention.
There are, admittedly, several reasons to be skeptical, at first glance, about the extent of Berlin's admiration for Mill. Berlin was most passionate in his condemnations of monism; Mill was a self-described monist. In fact, Gray and others often list Mill's liberalism as an example of the sort of monist doctrine that Berlin rejected.Footnote 57 Berlin is also thought to have celebrated a minimalist liberalism grounded in a principle of toleration; Mill, by contrast, is often read as a perfectionist who staked liberalism to a particular ideal of human flourishing—an ideal he called “individuality.”Footnote 58 How, then, could Berlin have endorsed Mill's version of liberalism so enthusiastically?
The answer begins with Berlin's unusual reading of Mill's moral philosophy. Berlin acknowledges that all utilitarians must, by definition, be monists. After all, utilitarians hold that conflicts between values can, in principle, always be resolved through appeal to the standard of utility; they also believe that utility can serve as a “common denominator” that can measure the costs and benefits of trade-offs between values. But Berlin doubts that Mill was in fact a utilitarian. He claims that Mill transformed Bentham's concept of utility into something distinctly pluralistic:
[happiness] is ‘complex and indefinite’ in Mill because he packs into it the many diverse (and, perhaps, not always compatible) ends which men in fact pursue for their own sake, and which Bentham had either ignored or falsely classified under the head of pleasure: love, hatred, desire for justice, for action, for freedom, for power, for beauty, for knowledge, for self-sacrifice. In J. S. Mill's writings happiness comes to mean something very like ‘realization of one's wishes,’ whatever they may be. This stretches its meaning to the point of vacuity.Footnote 59
As Berlin reads him, Mill remained a utilitarian in name, partly to appease his father, but his philosophy moved toward value pluralism. The parenthetical comment is especially telling: the goods that Mill subsumed under the heading “happiness” were not all compatible with one another—certainly not all the time. Choices had to be made, and Berlin thought that, notwithstanding his utilitarian rhetoric, Mill showed no way of arranging these goods—each valuable in itself—into a clear hierarchy.
Mill's alleged pluralism made him a much more attractive thinker to Berlin. Most important, for my purposes, is Berlin's belief that it strengthened Mill's defense of liberalism. This point comes into focus as Berlin begins to reconstruct Mill's defense of free expression. The opponents Mill took most seriously, writes Berlin, were those who believed that “if the true ends of life can be discovered, those who oppose these truths are spreading pernicious falsehood, and must be repressed.”Footnote 60 Mill's explicit response, as Berlin reads it, rests heavily on the claim that humans are fallible, and that those who have historically claimed the authority to impose life's true ends on others have often turned out to be mistaken. Christ and Socrates, Mill observes, were killed precisely because they were thought to be spreading pernicious falsehoods. He goes on to point out that European history is littered with examples of brutal repression, designed to protect dogmas that were later shown to be, if not entirely false, then radically incomplete.Footnote 61
It is clear, in these parts of Berlin's essay, how much he identified with Mill.Footnote 62 Both men were appalled by the moral and political consequences of repression justified through appeal to the “true ends of life,” perpetrated by those who had little doubt that they had discovered them. Both men spent their careers denouncing such repression. At the same time, it is clear that Berlin ultimately doubted the strength of Mill's (explicit) response to it. Mill's doctrine of fallibility, writes Berlin, rests ultimately on his empiricism, on his view that “no truths are—or could be—rationally established, except on evidence of observation.”Footnote 63 If this is true, in ethics just as surely as in scientific inquiry, then it follows that imposing a certain way of life on people will foreclose the possibility of new experiments in living, which might yet discover new (and superior) alternatives. Berlin believed that this was the heart of Mill's response to repressive monism: in its irrational self-assurance, it destroyed human possibilities that were as yet unimagined.
Berlin thought that this response was not strong enough, for it did not attack monism itself. And, crucially, he thought that Mill implicitly advanced another, more promising, line of argument:
[Mill's] argument is plausible only on the assumption which, whether he knew it or not, [he] all too obviously made, that human knowledge was in principle never complete, and always fallible; that there was no single, universally visible, truth; that each man, each nation, each civilization might take its own road towards it own goal, not necessarily harmonious with those of others…; that consequently the conviction, common to Aristotelians and a good many Christian scholastic and atheistical materialists alike, that there exists a basic knowable human nature, one and the same, at all times, in all places, in all men—a static, unchanging substance underneath the altering appearances, with permanent needs, dictated by a single, discoverable goal, or pattern of goals, the same for all mankind—is mistaken.Footnote 64
These lines, moving as they do from fallibilism to outright value pluralism, are more revealing of Berlin than of Mill—Mill himself would almost certainly have rejected them. But they help clarify Berlin's own view of the relationship between value pluralism on the one hand and the justification of liberalism on the other: Berlin introduces value pluralism as a way of improving and completing Mill's fallibilistic defense of liberal institutions.
To understand why Berlin thought that pluralism improved Mill's argument, it helps to turn briefly to some of his later writings. Berlin believed that there was a clear psychological connection between pluralism and liberalism:
If I am a pluralist, it means that I understand how people can come to accept these other values, whether because of their historical or geographical circumstances, or for whatever reason: the point is that I don't simply reject them as not mine and therefore nothing to me—as real relativism does—but I seek to understand what kind of world it is for those who don't share my beliefs, and how one can come to pursue values which are not mine.Footnote 65
Those who embrace this attitude, he goes on to say, are less likely to simply ignore or suppress other cultures or ways of life; these tendencies, he says, are “diminished by understanding itself.”Footnote 66 This passage moves much too quickly over difficult moral terrain, but it helps show the broad structure of Berlin's argument. It proceeds in two steps. First, Berlin thought that those who understood other values and ways of life with empathy and imagination would be more disposed to tolerate them. Second, Berlin saw monism as an impediment to such understanding; he thought that value pluralism, on the other hand, tended to encourage it.
The first step is evident in so many of Berlin's essays, including “John Stuart Mill and the Ends of Life”: Berlin thought that those who understood and appreciated other values and ways of life would be much less disposed to dismiss experimenters as cranks or sinners, or to use coercion to insulate existing values from new influences. He thought they would be more open to the exploration of new ethical possibilities, or of new combinations of old ones. Here he draws support from Mill. In On Liberty, Mill is amazed at the parochialism of his fellow Englishmen, who seem to ignore the fact that they are Christians only by accident of birth. “It never troubles him,” writes Mill of his countrymen, “that mere accident has decided which of these numerous [ethical and religious] worlds is the object of his reliance, and that the same causes which make him a Churchman in London, would have made him a Buddhist or a Confucian in Pekin.”Footnote 67 Mill thought that such parochialism encouraged intolerance; he wanted them to be more skeptical about their own inherited ways of life and more curious about others.
Mill's essay on Jeremy Bentham, which Berlin clearly admired, is also important here. Berlin cites it only in passing, but it seems to have shaped his view of Mill.Footnote 68 Mill criticizes Bentham for his inability (or unwillingness) to look charitably on traditions and ways of life that were alien to him. “The faculty by which one mind understands a mind different from itself, and throws itself into the feelings of that other mind,” writes Mill of Bentham, “was denied him by his deficiency of Imagination.”Footnote 69 For Mill, as for Berlin, Bentham's lack of imagination—and unwillingness to be charitable toward traditions that seemed to him irrational—helped explain his inability to identify with the diverse ends of human life, his willingness to reduce them all to simple, hedonistic measures. Time and again in “John Stuart Mill and the Ends of Life,” Berlin compares Mill favorably to Bentham. Mill possessed the ethical and philosophical temperament of the pluralist; Bentham did not.
Berlin believed that the desire to understand and empathize with different ways of life was a psychological prerequisite of genuine toleration.Footnote 70 Like Mill, he thought that repressive intolerance came naturally to human beings. “Men want to curtail the liberties of other men,” he writes, paraphrasing Mill.Footnote 71 Only a genuine, sympathetic curiosity about other ways of life could stand as a bulwark against this inveterate human tendency. This was one of the lessons that Berlin drew from Vico and Johann Gottfried Herder—two of the thinkers he most admired and to whom he devoted a great deal of his scholarly attention. Berlin presents the empathy and imagination that these men exemplified as “antidotes to Gibbon's or Hume's or Macaulay's blindness to medieval civilization, to Russell's dismissal of Byzantium, or Voltaire's antipathy to the Bible or Cromwell.”Footnote 72
The next step in Berlin's argument was to suggest that both monism and relativism tended to inhibit such curiosity. Relativism distanced other ways of life, to the point of making them ethically irrelevant: they might have relevance for those who embraced them, but not for anyone else. To outsiders, there were simply objects of idle curiosity.Footnote 73 Monism, on the other hand, raised the ethical stakes almost unbearably high: if there was only one true way of life, then most people lived in error or sin. Like everyone else, monists would have a hard time resisting the belief that their own way of life had to be right—or at least, mostly right. And if that was true, then those who rejected their way of life, including the experimenters whom Mill lauded in On Liberty, had to be wrong—or at least, mostly wrong. This conviction, in turn, would tend to shut down empathetic inquiry; other, alien ways of life would register as irrational or prejudiced and as threats to the true ends of life.
Berlin thought that this tendency could survive even Mill's fallibilism. Even if it is true, says Berlin, that ethical knowledge is always incomplete, there can be no guarantee that new experiments in living will not bring corruption and degradation rather than ethical improvement. Even if it is possible, in principle, that experiments in living will bring valuable new ethical discoveries, the most prudent path—from the monist point of view—might still be repression, to protect those ethical truths that have been discovered.Footnote 74 Mill was vulnerable to the charge—also advanced by Lord Devlin in the late 1950s—that he was simply too optimistic about the sorts of experiments that would likely occur in liberal societies. The new, experimental goods were as yet indistinct, whereas the harms that such experiments might cause were evident. Berlin thought, therefore, that those who conceded monism would too often lose the fight against repressive intolerance.
And so Berlin thought that Mill's fallibilistic defense of liberty “will not tell with those who believe that absolute truth is discoverable once and for all, whether by metaphysical or theological argument.”Footnote 75 Berlin was thinking not only of Mill's enemies—theocrats and philosophical intuitionists—but also of his own. He thought that repressive monism was “more powerful today perhaps than even in Mill's own century.”Footnote 76 The combination of monism and fallibilism—the one that Mill claimed to hold—was insufficient. It was unstable and tended to resolve itself into what Mill called the “illusion of infallibility”—the illusion that one's own way of life had to be the right one after all (or, at least, right enough to warrant protection from heresy and error).
And both men saw how easily this illusion would then underwrite political repression. This is one of the major themes of Berlin's corpus: if there is only one rationally defensible hierarchy of human values, and if this hierarchy can be known, then “why should any conduct be tolerated that is not authorized by appropriate experts?”Footnote 77 Like Mill, he thought that people who were confident that they knew the “true ends of life” would register dissent simply as heresy or evil that threatened the ethical life, or the very salvation, of the community.Footnote 78 When such people came to hold power in their hands, they would use it to enforce their own orthodoxies. The key difference between Berlin and Mill was this: Berlin thought that this psychological tendency inhered in monism itself, while Mill located it simply in dogmatic ethical certainty. But Berlin thought that he was simply following Mill's psychological insights to their own natural conclusions—conclusions of which Mill himself was not fully aware.
It is worth noting, as an aside, that Berlin did not think that liberal monists would escape the tendency to coerce and repress. He famously criticized the Enlightenment for its own form of universalistic moral hubris. In fact, he traced the origins of twentieth-century totalitarianism precisely to Enlightenment rationalism and to the colonial violence it justified.Footnote 79 In his view, pluralism would help inspire, not just any liberalism, but a more humane, more restrained liberalism that remained skeptical of the coercive projection of liberal norms across the world.
We come now to the final step in the argument, which is that value pluralism encourages precisely the kind of sympathetic curiosity about other ways of life that motivates genuine tolerance. Here is Berlin's key claim: the value pluralist can easily affirm the value of her own way of life while also acknowledging that other, incompatible cultures and ways of life contain objectively valuable human goods. After all, the pluralist must hold that many such goods exist in the human world and that not all of them are mutually consistent. Unlike the monist's, the value pluralist's affirmation of different cultures and ways of life does not threaten to impugn her own life or culture; she is therefore more likely to approach them openly and interpret them generously. Unlike the relativist, she has reason to be curious about them, because she glimpses in them the possibility of objective value, and with it real forms of human flourishing. “I don't simply reject [other values] as not mine and therefore nothing to me,” says Berlin, impersonating the pluralist point of view, “as real relativism does.”Footnote 80 Berlin therefore believed that pluralists would, by and large, find themselves disposed to respond to otherness with empathy and curiosity.
Put this way, however, his argument is not entirely convincing. It is certainly possible to imagine a pluralist who believes, for instance, that there are a limited number of objectively valuable ways of life, that they are all well known, and that all but these ways of life should be repressed. This kind of pluralist seems to have no more reason than the monist does to favor openness and tolerance. Missing from this version of pluralism is one of the key virtues that Mill celebrated—fallibilism, grounded in empiricism—and that Berlin admired.
I have argued elsewhere that empiricism is an important feature of Berlin's value pluralism.Footnote 81 He thought that objective values could never be known a priori; they could only be known through patient empirical inquiry into existing (or historical) cultures and ways of life. This is a second lesson that Berlin drew from Herder and Vico. History and anthropology were the disciplines through which we could learn the contours of human nature—that is, the range of the human potential for flourishing, and with it the objective values that conduced to such flourishing. “What we understand,” writes Bernard Williams of Berlin's historical approach to ethics, “is a truth about human nature as it has been revealed—revealed the only way in which it could have been revealed, historically.”Footnote 82 Berlin thought, furthermore, that any pluralist who took this empirical attitude toward human values would have to remain open, in principle, to the possibility that there were other objective values or ways of life to be discovered. The ethical history of the human species was ongoing. He also thought that the virtues needed to conduct historical and anthropological inquiry responsibly were precisely those that conduced to sympathetic curiosity toward others.Footnote 83 In humanistic inquiry, understanding simply cannot be achieved without the capacity to “enter into” the lives, motives, and feelings of others.Footnote 84
The pluralism that Berlin celebrated was something more, then, than the four propositions that I outlined earlier; it also included empiricism, properly understood, about values. And it was pluralism in this more inclusive sense that Berlin thought would encourage the epistemic virtues—imagination, empathy, openness—that he associated with tolerance and, by extension, liberal political commitments. Michael Walzer described this relationship perfectly:
I don't know anyone who believes in value pluralism who isn't a liberal, in sensibility as well as conviction. … You have to look at the world in a receptive and generous way to see a pluralism of Berlin's sort. … And you also have to look at the world in a skeptical way, since the adherents of each of the different values are likely to rank them very high on a scale designed just for that purpose. And receptivity, generosity, and skepticism are, if not liberal values, the qualities of mind that make it possible to accept liberal values (or better, that make it likely that liberal values will be accepted).Footnote 85
Mill was right, in Berlin's estimation, to list empiricism, as well as the fallibilism it underwrites, as psychological prerequisites of genuine toleration. But Berlin thought that value pluralism was important, too. Value pluralists could believe that their own way of life was objectively valuable without suspecting that other ways of life—even ways of life radically different from their own, guided by sharply different values—were therefore corrupt or sinful. To the value pluralist, the world presents itself is a less Manichean light. Those who embraced both a fallibilistic empiricism and value pluralism would find that liberal tolerance came more naturally to them.
One further piece of Berlin's story is relevant here. Berlin thought that all human beings (and all societies) were confronted with rationally underdetermined ethical choices. Since there was no single, rationally privileged way of life or hierarchy of political values, people had to choose. Only those who acknowledged the truth of value pluralism, moreover, and who were curious enough to understand something of the variety of objective alternatives, were in a position to make such choices deliberately. And these were precisely the people—including Herder, Vico, Maciavelli, and others—whom Berlin most admired. He admired them more than he admired the many cultures or ways of life that they observed.Footnote 86 This is an important fact about Berlin: he seldom praised cultural or ethical diversity as such. He thought that people who lived under the illusion that their own parochial way of life was the only valuable one led diminished lives, lives less free than they might have been. The moral psychology of tolerance, for Berlin, opens up into the practice of autonomous choice-making—and this deepened the psychological connection, in his mind, between pluralism and liberalism.Footnote 87
In “John Stuart Mill and the Ends of Life,” Berlin presents what seems to me a compelling account of the psychological relationship between an empirical, fallibilistic value pluralism and liberal tolerance. It is important, though, to recognize its limits. First, as I have just emphasized, it is an account of the psychology of value pluralism combined with a certain kind of empiricism, not of value pluralism alone. Second, though Berlin might have disagreed, the account applies to some forms of monism as well. It seems to me that one can reject the incommensurability thesis—as Mill did—and still find oneself inclined toward toleration in precisely the way Berlin hoped for. Mill, for one, thought that human goods were objective and diverse, and that they conflicted. And while he believed that the standard of utility could ideally be used to resolve these conflicts, he thought it was very difficult to apply faithfully and precisely; his fallibilism led him to believe, for instance, that governments—even utilitarian governments—would often do more harm than good when they tried to regulate citizens' lives. In other words, value pluralism, understood as encompassing the four claims I summarized earlier, is neither a sufficient nor a necessary element of the moral psychology of tolerance. Though Berlin might have doubted it, certain forms of monism—of which Mill's is but one example—encourage precisely the virtues that he associated with liberal tolerance. Berlin's assessments of monism were always far too dire.
I have argued that Berlin conceived of the relationship between value pluralism and liberalism in largely psychological terms. In a 2007 essay, “Value Pluralism and Liberalism,” Crowder considers this possibility, only to dismiss it rather quickly. He names two philosophers—Gray and Kekes—who embrace value pluralism without endorsing liberalism; “On the ‘psychological’ view of the liberalism-pluralism relation, what can liberals say to Gray and Kekes: that they are psychologically abnormal?”Footnote 88 Even if Crowder were invoking the more inclusive sense of value pluralism that I just outlined, it is surely uncharitable to understand Berlin as saying that everyone who embraces it will be liberal. Berlin is outlining a broad, psychological affinity, not a causal necessity.Footnote 89
Crowder's deeper complaint is that this affinity, even if it does exist, is not very interesting, for it can always be argued—as Gray and Kekes have—that value pluralists who are drawn to liberalism are simply “making a mistake.”Footnote 90 There is a fundamental disagreement here about what liberalism needs most. Berlin thought that the best we can do for liberalism is to encourage the habits of mind that will, by and large, incline us and others to embrace and defend it. If we can teach and exemplify the psychological prerequisites of liberal toleration, he thought, we can begin to create a better, more humane world. Crowder, like most liberal philosophers, is more preoccupied with outlining an airtight justification of liberalism. In my view, Berlin's project is the more important of the two.
Justifying Liberalism
I suggested, at the start of this essay, that those who mistakenly saddle Berlin with the ambition of offering a foundational justification of liberalism make his philosophy seem weak, if not actually incoherent. That said, Berlin was not entirely silent on the question of liberalism's justification. In fact, the rest of “John Stuart Mill and the Ends of Life” outlines two different justifications of liberalism.
The first is more modest, and it turns on two claims—one empirical and one normative—that I summarized earlier. Berlin is writing here about Mill and about the coercive imposition of a single value or way of life: “the imposition of any such construction upon a living society is bound, in his favorite words of warning, to dwarf, maim, cramp, wither the human faculties.”Footnote 91 For support, he quotes Mill's view that any such imposition is bound to “to maim by compression, like a Chinese lady's foot, every part of human nature which stands out prominently, and tends to make the person markedly dissimilar in outline to commonplace humanity.”Footnote 92 To force people into a single ethical mold is to maim them, to destroy some important part of their nature or personality, for people are not limitlessly malleable. This is the empirical claim. Its normative complement is that objective goods are not valuable for their own sake, but only because they provide avenues for human flourishing. There are many ways of making sense of the ideal of “human flourishing,” but for Berlin, as for Mill, it always had a subjective element: no human being whose life was scarred by deep and persistent suffering could be described as flourishing. Here, then, is the reason Berlin would have rejected the illiberal pluralism that I outlined earlier. If what matters most is human suffering, then the fact that illiberal pluralism might maximize the ratio of objectively good to bad lives is in itself no defense. If in fact—as Berlin and Mill both would have supposed—this maximization is purchased at the price of a great deal of suffering imposed on individuals who are prevented from pursuing the diverse goods that suit them, then illiberal pluralism is unjustifiable.
It is worth noticing the role that value pluralism plays in this first justification. The mere fact that human natures are diverse and not highly malleable, and that they suffer when forced into a particular mold, does not in itself compel liberal tolerance. To see why consider, for instance, the view of homosexuality that might be taken by a religious traditionalist. He might acknowledge that our sexual dispositions are diverse, and that imposing a certain sexual order—monogamous heterosexuality—causes substantial suffering to those whose natures do not fit this mold neatly. But he might say that such suffering, though is was indeed an evil, was justified by the fact that monogamous heterosexuality is among the “true ends of life.”Footnote 93 Mill's response to such arguments was fallibilism, which he thought would make us more hesitant to coerce others in the name of any particular conception of the human good. And as I argued earlier, Berlin doubted that fallibilism alone would make monists receptive to unfamiliar values and ways of life. He believed that pluralism, combined with a fallibilist empiricism, would prove a much stronger answer. If there were many objectively valuable yet incompatible ways of life, if new ones could always be discovered—and if the traditionalist therefore felt compelled to respond to homosexuality not as something radically alien and corrupt, but as part of a way of life that might (or might not) itself have objective value—then he would be less likely to want to repress it at the cost of substantial human suffering.
The first justification of liberalism, then, rests on the observation that human beings suffer when they are forced to live a way of life that does not suit them. The second is somewhat more controversial: “Mill believes in liberty, that is, the rigid limitation of the right to coerce, because he is sure that men cannot develop and flourish and become fully human unless they are left free from interference by other men within a certain minimum area of their lives, which he regards as—or wishes to make—inviolable.”Footnote 94 Berlin here draws attention to a central feature of Mill's ethics: there is embedded in Mill's defense of liberty a certain conception of human flourishing—flourishing through the exercise of choice (and choice not just among means to a prescribed end, but choice among ends). Berlin thought that though this was Mill's deepest commitment, it was ultimately an article of faith; he also calls it “the ultimate basis of political liberalism.”Footnote 95 Of course, as Gray emphasizes, no society deprives individuals of the opportunity to exercise meaningful choices. No society prescribes a single career, for instance, or a single way of spending one's leisure time. Choice is possible within all societies. Here is Berlin's response:
For [Mill] man differs from animals primarily neither as the possessor of reason, nor as an inventor of tools and methods, but as a being capable of choice, one who is most himself in choosing and not being chosen for; … with the corollary that the more various these fashions, the richer the lives of men become; the larger the field of interplay between individuals, the greater the opportunities of the new and the unexpected; the more numerous the possibilities for altering his own character in some fresh or unexplored direction, the more paths open before each individual, and the wider will be his freedom of action and thought.Footnote 96
At this point in the essay, the principle of maximization that Crowder endorses comes into view. If what matters is the cultivation of individuality, then individuals should have the opportunity to choose from a broad range of options. Illiberal societies deny individuals the range of examples and alternatives that are typically available in liberal societies. They therefore stymie the development of essential human faculties. Berlin is paraphrasing Mill in these passages, but it is clear that he approves of Mill's reasoning.
Again, it makes sense to ask: What work, exactly, is value pluralism doing in this argument? And again, the answer is that it serves as an important complement to fallibilism. It is certainly possible to value choice for its own sake as part of a monist ethical view. It is possible to hold, for instance, that there is one correct ethical way, but individuals must be allowed to come to it themselves, because choice making is valuable in itself. Most forms of Christianity, for instance, do contain this view. Moreover, virtually all monist strains of liberalism actually enshrine liberty as one of the highest public values, if not the highest value. Still, Berlin worried that even liberals monists might find themselves tempted to impose a certain understanding of the good life, often under the guise of liberty itself, on others.Footnote 97 Mill's fallibilism suggests one way of holding this temptation at bay: you never know; the ways of life that are being targeted for restriction might instantiate freedom in ways we do not fully understand, or they might instantiate other values at least as worthwhile as freedom, but whose importance we underestimate. I have already shown why Berlin doubted this argument's efficacy. He thought that it was ultimately more powerful to be able to say: There are in fact rival, incommensurable goods between which we are all destined to choose. We choose between them whether we know it or not. Better to do so deliberately, knowing something about our alternatives.Footnote 98 Better, in other words, to fashion lives for ourselves, and to design political institutions that protect and enable our power to do so.
At first blush, these two justifications of liberalism seem incompatible with value pluralism. After all, if Berlin is suggesting that suffering or autonomy is more important than other real values, or that either can be used to adjudicate between other conflicting values, then he seems to be embracing his own version of monism. It is important, in closing, to see why Berlin would have rejected this charge. Consider the following passage from a short reply to Crowder that Berlin and Bernard Williams coauthored in 1994:
It is true, as Crowder points out, that pluralists sometimes urge the particular importance, on their views, of some value such as variety or autonomy, which on other views may be less important, or perhaps not a value at all. Once again, there is no inconsistency between their doing this, and their accepting that this is one value among others. If they move to asserting the overriding importance of this value, as some liberals do, then they may begin to be in trouble with pluralism.Footnote 99
Berlin can urge the particular importance of human suffering, then, without claiming that it is irrational not to do so. The argument looks something like this: Yes, there are many objectively good yet incommensurable human values. When designing basic political institutions, however, in a world such as ours, I hold that certain values—notably the avoidance of suffering and the attainment of a minimal threshold of personal autonomy—should be given priority, at the cost of others. I acknowledge that others may disagree, and they are not irrational for doing so. They are not irrational, not simply because of what John Rawls called the “burdens of judgment,” but also because human values really are plural and incommensurable, and so human suffering has no rational priority over other goods. I will nonetheless press my case as persuasively as I know how, using all of the rhetorical tools that I can honestly use.Footnote 100
Berlin thought that very few people denied the moral importance of human suffering—it had a kind of empirical universality. And there points are in his essays where he gestures at a universal moral minimum that includes, as Amy Gutmann puts it, “not only protecting [some measure of] individual liberty, but also avoiding extreme forms of human suffering that are humanly inflicted, cruelty for short.”Footnote 101 But the moral status of this minimum is usually left ambiguous. And he sometimes explicitly denied that even these basic moral obligations could be universally binding. “To begin with,” he writes in a letter to Beata Polanowska-Sygulska, “we recognize ‘human rights’ and ‘crimes against humanity.’ As you know, I do not believe in a priori justification for these, or absolute values. Things would be easier if one did, but one must say what one believes—I should like to say in my case, knows—to be true.”Footnote 102 Berlin thought he could give reasons—powerful ones—why human suffering is morally important, should take moral priority. At the same time, he recognized that prioritizing suffering was not the only rational way of ordering political values. He was not, then, trying to endow liberal institutions, or even basic human rights, with “universal authority,” as Gray (and many other interpreters) have claimed he was. His philosophical ambitions were considerably more modest.
