Natalie Crohn Schmitt's Performing Commedia dell'Arte, 1570–1630 focuses on performance techniques used in commedia dell'arte: improvisation, physical acting, and masks. Crohn Schmitt intentionally shapes the slim book to be user-friendly for theatre practitioners as well as students and scholars. The narrowed focus on the years 1570–1630, when commedia dell'arte was, arguably, at its height, allows Crohn Schmitt to make certain generalizations about the performance style, though it does not cover the important 1560s, when the first generation of female comici were especially active. Crohn Schmitt broaches the notoriously difficult subject of acting style through examples from the scenarios of the commedia dell'arte, principally those published by Flaminio Scala in 1611, a compilation that Crohn Schmitt already explored in her Befriending the Commedia dell'arte of Flaminio Scala: The Comic Scenarios (2014). In addition, she draws on the Locatelli and Corsini collections of scenarios, which are less frequently studied but that provide important information on the tragicomic and pastoral scenes that were also part of the comici's repertoire. The book is organized into four main chapters, following a brief introduction. The first three chapters focus on improvisation, acting style (dialect and voice use as well as gestures), and the incorporation of masks in performance. The final chapter, “Coda,” usefully focuses on contemporary commedia dell'arte.
In the first chapter, “Improvisation: Why, What, How,” Crohn Schmitt underscores the importance of improvisation in the context of the Renaissance, both as a demonstration of rhetorical skills and as an indication of the infinite inventiveness on the part of the actor (11). Improvisation allowed for the performance to appear not as a copy of an original, but as a living, authentic, if not completely spontaneous, creation. Improvisation always relied on an extensive process of preparation. Crohn Schmitt references commedia dell'arte scholars Robert Henke as well as Rosalind Kerr, who has shown how famous actors such as Isabella Andreini “intermixed” and “interpolated” parts of Petrarch's writing into seemingly devised verse so that the effect would reflect both inventiveness on the part of the performer and skillful application of erudition (12–13). The delivery would rely on sprezzatura, the Renaissance word for grace and effortlessness that would belie the amount of work that went into preparing the “improvisation.” A great effort on the part of actors was involved, and Crohn Schmitt's chapter focuses on the importance of memoria (memory) and rhetorical strategies of dividing up the material specified by Quintilian for the actors (14–15). Next, Crohn Schmitt addresses how the actors worked together to create an improvisation. Domenico Pietropaolo's ideas on improvisation as a stochastic composition could further enhance Schmitt's section, which does make useful reference to improvisation today by drawing examples from Chicago, home base of The Second City improvisational troupe and formerly the location of the iO Theater (18–19).
The second chapter, “Acting Styles: Dialects, Voice, Gesture,” has the largest scope, including a focus on voice, attention to the use of multiple dialects in performance, and a discussion of the use of the body in gestures. Crohn Schmitt gives much consideration to Quintilian's writing on voice and especially to the affective potential of voice to free emotions (29). Indeed, one of the book's strengths is Crohn Schmitt connecting the dots for readers between this ancient Roman rhetorician and the Renaissance acting style, even though she admits we cannot be firmly certain of the degree to which the comici were conversant with Quintilian's writing. As in all the chapters, Crohn Schmitt brings together recent scholarly work in her summation of approaches to the subject, the most important reference here being to the work of Emily Wilbourne on the ways commedia dell'arte aurally conditioned early modern audience to the emergence of opera (32). The final focus of the chapter is on discussions of gesture in performance. Turning again to Quintilian, a touchstone in this book, Crohn Schmitt explains that he “lays out general guidelines about the interrelationship between words, gesture, and voice, and between gestures” (40). Crohn Schmitt next applies Quintilian to Scala's scenarios and demonstrates, through close textual readings, how targeted gestures in these scenes evoked emotions such as anger, shock, and grief in order to create heightened performative displays (44–6). However, she is careful to nuance this point by arguing that the range of affective expressions, rather than merely create stereotypical characters and caricatures, could also reflect “real societal anxieties” through this range of acting styles (47). That was especially important for a period in which societal tensions between “fathers and sons; female lovers, wives, and widows and men; lovers; friends; citizens and servants; and with outsiders” were especially pronounced (47).
The third chapter, “The Uses of Masks,” attends to a neglected area: the masking specific to the pastorals and tragicomedies. For example, Crohn Schmitt considers characters such as shadows, oracles, and magicians, all of whom are rarely ever analyzed. Rather than stop there, Crohn Schmitt provides a “Coda” to the book, a chapter on “commedia dell'arte today” in which she counters the “myth that there is an unbroken line of commedia dell'arte continuing into the present day” (104). Nevertheless, although there may not be a direct line to historic commedia dell'arte, Crohn Schmitt animatedly discusses the ways in which commedia dell'arte's spirit is alive in the work of The Improvised Shakespeare Company (ISC) in Chicago.
Short and intentionally narrow in focus, Performing Commedia dell'Arte, 1570–1630 succeeds both in providing a foundation of Roman rhetorical writing for understanding commedia dell'arte performance and in culling together several recent scholarly works to focus on the wonderfully challenging subject of what performance was like in the golden age of commedia dell'arte.
