Passage to Manhood offers a carefully researched and sobering assessment of the problems faced by one of the most marginalized and vulnerable segments of China's population, the Nuosu ethnic minority in rural Sichuan Province. Focusing on the intersection of post-socialist modernity, heroin use, and HIV/AIDS policies, Shao-hua Liu shows how young Nuosu men become caught up crime and drug use, and consequently infected with the HIV virus at very high rates through sharing needles. She then documents how international and national government initiatives have been largely ineffective in improving their situation. Stories of social marginalization and growing income disparities are commonplace in scholarship on rural-urban migration. However, this study is more alarming in that it portrays a group of stigmatized young people whose social and economic resources are so limited that they are almost completely unable to economically benefit from migration experiences. Indeed, the market reforms are shown to have greatly contributed both to personal patterns of criminality, drug addiction, and HIV risk, as well as to larger problems of community breakdown among the Nuosu.
As the title suggests, the central narrative of the book follows young Nuosu men from their isolated rural homes to Han-dominated city to experience modern life. Unlike most accounts of rural-urban migration in China, the economic motives of young men are not foregrounded in these stories. Rather, as Liu shows, these men are motivated by the desire for adventure, fun, and a taste of modernity. Most Nuosu men travel to cities in Sichuan, including Chengdu, with only minimal financial resources and a sketchy understanding of urban life. While some work in lawful jobs, mainly in construction, many subsist on theft, burglary, and drug dealing. Indeed, crime against Han people is constructed as a perfectly normal means of obtaining material resources among the Nuosu migrants. Consequently, a large number of Nuosu youth end up spending part of their youth in prison, or become victims of police abuse or violent altercations among the migrants themselves. While living in transient migrant settlements around the Chengdu train station, many young men become addicted to heroin. Death through violence, drug overdose, or AIDS is not an uncommon outcome of Nuosu migration to cities.
Although traveling away from home for adventure was traditionally a male activity, increasingly young women are making such trips. While men are more likely to engage in stealing in order make money, women are more likely to become involved in drug dealing. Some women take their own children or “borrow” children from poor families while engaging in drug deals, hoping that if they are caught by police they will be less likely, as mothers, to be incarcerated. Despite these insightful descriptions of young women's strategies, the biggest weakness of this ethnography, one acknowledged by the author herself, is the lack of data on women. Women were reluctant to talk with the educated, foreign, female anthropologist, and she was less able to collect data on women's social lives and attitudes. Moreover, because sexuality is such a taboo topic among the Nuosu in general, we learn very little about the sexual dimensions of young people's lives, including the implications for HIV transmission.
The second half of this book focuses on state programs to deal with the drug-related HIV crisis among the Nuosu. In chapter 4 we see that community-led efforts at controlling drug use have had some limited success, especially efforts that utilize Nuosu kinship structure. However, even these community-based efforts are ineffective in an increasingly individualistic society in which traditional social controls have weakened. In contrast with the partial success of community-based initiatives to control drug use, an international effort to combat HIV infection, called the China-UK project, is described as a near total failure. Chapter 5 outlines the reasons for the failure of this complex international project, which included economic and medical interventions into the crisis ranging from agricultural initiatives to needle exchanges and treatment programs. Corruption and bureaucratic incompetence comprised a large part of the failure at the management level, but a general disdain for the Nuosu minority culture among the Han-dominated state agents contributed as well. Not only did the China-UK project fail to provide a workable framework for diagnosing and treating HIV, but the anti-stigmatization efforts of the program inadvertently led to the increased stigmatization of HIV among Nuosu, who previously had not regarded HIV infection as a stigmatizing status. We thus learn how a globalized discourse of combating stigma can have nearly the opposite of its intended effects when programs are carried out with a systematic disregard for local cultural practices.
In sum, this is a clearly illustrated and well-argued account of the social construction of social problems of drug use and HIV in Southwest China and the unsuccessful attempts of various levels of state agencies to deal with these problems. Still, if the book has a weakness, it is that it reads as two studies collapsed into one. One is the study of youth and migration, which explains the practices of heroin use and related risks of HIV infection, but is also much more about the gendered migration and life strategies of young people. The second story is about the state's strategies for dealing with the twin drug and HIV crises, but is also much more about the political economy of medical practice in rural China. Still, I would not want to question the contributions of this particular volume. An advantage of reading these distinct narratives as one study is that those who are primarily interested in illness and drug dependency are able to get the whole picture of how both drug use and illness are structured by local cultural practices as well as by the activities of state agents.
