This volume represents an ambitious effort to provide a comprehensive and up-to-date overview of minimum income protection provisions in Europe. A volume like this has been long overdue. Arguably not since the landmark study by Tony Eardley and others published over fifteen years ago (Eardley et al., Reference Eardley, Bradshaw, Gough and Whiteford1996) has there been an attempt this ambitious to map minimum income protection (MIP) in a large number of countries. It does not need adding, moreover, that a comprehensive volume on social safety nets could not have come at a better time. The economic crisis has pushed unemployment rates in many countries to levels not seen in a generation. Increasing numbers are finding themselves reliant on final safety net provisions for their economic survival. At the same time, minimum income protection is regaining significance at the EU social policy level. In May 2009, the European Parliament called on the Commission and the Member States ‘to guarantee the right to a minimum income irrespective of individuals’ chances in the labour market’ (European Parliament, 2009).
The book is not merely ambitious in its geographical span but also in its purported objectives. The authors claim to address three main questions: (a) what are the similarities and differences between MIP schemes in European countries, (b) how are these similarities and differences related to variations in overall social security systems and (c) what developments and trends can be observed for European MIP schemes?
The authors draw on a variety of data sources, including a self-compiled data base called ‘EuMin’. This data base contains institutional, quantitative and comparative indicators of MIP. The most important sources for ‘EuMin’ were statistics and legal documents available at the websites of national governments, statistical offices and the administrating bodies. Clearly, the validity here hinges on the quality and timeliness of the information presented on official websites, and on the correct interpretation of that information.
The volume does a very good job at achieving its first stated objective. A major part of the volume consists of sections on the individual countries covered in the book. This, in effect, is the volume's main feature and added value. These country analyses provide concise and clear descriptions of social safety nets in seventeen European countries. The main characteristics of the various schemes are described, including their historical development and legislative milestones. There is a contextualisation within the broader welfare state setting, especially with broader pension, unemployment and family provisions.
A volume this sweeping in scope and ambition has, of course, its limitations. The three authors have made an almost single handed attempt to accurately describe final safety provisions for each European country. Only for a handful of countries have they enlisted the help of national experts. This could have been helpful for the other countries in the book. Considering some national cases I know relatively well, I would argue that the authors could have captured some important nuances better.
The big question, however, is whether the volume manages to achieve its third objective: to capture the most significant recent developments and trends relating to MIP schemes. The volume certainly has added value if it comes to caseload trends over the past two decades. This is not to my knowledge available elsewhere. The volume also makes a very important addition in its focus on categorical differentiation in MIP schemes, an issue that so far has received relatively little attention in the literature. As for benefit level trends, here it needs to be said that there is more data available than the volume uses. As this volume is meant as a handbook, perhaps more attention could have been devoted to comparing and discuss benefit level trends across datasets and studies.
More fundamentally, perhaps it is the case that the most important trends are to be found on fronts that receive less attention in this volume. An increased emphasis on activation and the prevention of long-term dependence among social assistance recipients has become evident in many countries, certainly at the level of policy rhetoric. The question after reading this book largely remains to what extent this has been translated into changed policy realities. We still lack systematic comparisons of actual activation practices, in part because implementation aspects are so difficult to measure. We know that some countries have introduced earnings disregards for people dependent on social assistance or unemployment benefits who make a (partial) transition from complete benefit dependency to part-time work. People on targeted benefits have also become the focus of intensified monitoring, activation and sometimes sanctioning efforts in some countries. In addition, and simultaneously, a shift seems have taken place in places from cash support to more in-kind support, for example subsidised public transport, energy, medical care, education, etc. Minimum benefits have become more conditional upon behavioural requirements in some cases. Finally, the boundaries between income support systems for the non-employed and people in (part-time) work appear to becoming vaguer. For example, the French Revenu de Solidarité Active (RSA).
(RSA), introduced in 2009, is an integrated minimum income support provision for people out of work and for people in work. There can be no doubt that systematically capturing such trends is very hard for a single country, let alone for seventeen countries. While some of these issues are touched upon in the country sections, they do not feature very prominently in the comparative analyses. Perhaps somewhat more attention could have been given to these aspects. While this impressive volume fills a big gap and constitutes an absolutely essential reference source, an important research agenda remains.
