In 2008, Keith Bradley wrote ‘[i]n classical art, figures who can be presumed to be slaves are ubiquitous, visible in almost any museum catalogue or handbook where they are often called “servants.” I recognise the difficulty in identifying them. But the conservatism of art historians is to be challenged and leaps of faith encouraged. Servants in antiquity much of the time were slaves, yet there is hardly any research that investigates art as a source of historical knowledge about them … the subject seems to me to be in its infancy’ (Journal of Canadian History 43: 477–500; at 489). Seen against this background, relatively little has changed in the more than ten years since Bradley's remarks appeared: ‘ein bislang noch wenig erforschtes Feld’ (1), as the editors of this volume note. The publication of A. Binsfeld and M. Ghetta's new collection thus marks a significant turning point in research on the visuality of enslaved (and freed) persons.
The volume originates from a workshop held in 2016 in Luxembourg, where one of the editors (Binsfeld) led a project on ‘Slavery in the Socio-economic Context of the Roman Provinces of Germania Inferior and Germania Superior and the Neighbouring Areas’. The project's Germanic orientation bears a strong imprint on the collection as a whole: eight of the twelve contributions are written in German, and many contributors address provincial material at multi-regional scales that provide useful foils to better-known monuments from Italy (e.g. c. thirty of the ninety-six black-and-white images depict works in German museums).
B's. ‘Introduction’ efficiently situates the volume's chapters within the context of previous work on the iconography and material culture of Greek and Roman slavery (though the evidence from Etruria is completely overlooked). In particular, B. notes the impossibility of formulating absolute criteria for visually identifying enslaved and freed persons, who can at best be categorised provisionally based on their depiction with one or more characteristic traits (see below). But even in the rare cases where scholars can identify their subjects as enslaved persons with confidence (e.g. together with an inscription), B. notes that it remains difficult to determine ‘to what extent the material sources provide us a picture of the real situation of slaves in Greek and Roman antiquity and to what extent we are more likely to receive insights into the respective society and its mentality’ (3).
This core methodological dilemma in the interpretation of the sources — as lived reality vs. (elite) social ideology — directly informs the four papers in the first section, ‘The Iconography of Slaves and Prisoners of War: General Aspects.’ This begins with L. Schumacher's ‘brief sketch’ of the key visual benchmarks for identifying slaves (e.g. physiognomy, hairstyle, dress, profession, placement, gestures, scale, ethnicity, etc.), summarising much of his own important work in this area. H. von Hesberg focuses on the qualities of beauty and specialisation that appear in a wide range of images of servants and argues that these images represent above all the idealised world envisioned by the slave owner, even if they may be tinged with aspects of reality. F. Luciani investigates the dress of Roman public slaves (servi publici), in a chapter which impressively pieces together a ‘mosaic’ of disparate literary, epigraphic, and iconographic sources. H. Huntzinger's contribution focuses on the iconography of captives and barbarians in late antiquity. He argues — curiously, to my mind — that since slavery is fundamentally characterised by captivity, scenes of captivity can inform us about the conceptualisation of slavery (contra H. von Hesberg, who elsewhere interpreted the image of captives as specifically referential to military conquest).
In the second section, ‘The Slave with Lamps, Lamps with Slaves’, M. Béraud looks at the figure of the lanternarius in Roman imperial imagery. There she seeks to understand images of hooded figures (cucullati) as not merely decorative accessories, but also — because of their putative connection to various protective figures (e.g. Telesphoros) — as amulets and companions for the dead. M. Grawehr's chapter is the most innovative in the volume. He first sketches the distinctive association made in art and literature between enslaved persons and lamps, then discusses how lamp imagery reflects the perspective and ideology of the slave-owner (e.g. the ‘beautiful slave’, who embodies his master's refinement), and concludes by attempting to recuperate the self-representation of enslaved persons by interpreting particular iconographic schemes (e.g. festivals, occupational portraits, donkeys) as evidence of their ‘subversive discourses’ (115) (cf. also R. Bielfeldt, Art History 41 (2018), 420–43, which is not cited in this volume).
In the third section, ‘The Function of Representations of Slaves and Servants in Funerary Art’, M. Ghetta looks at the representational language of military cavalrymen and their enslaved grooms (calones) on funerary reliefs (Reitergrab-steinen) from the two German provinces. H. Rose's chapter on manual labourers in scenes of transport and trade also focuses on material from the German provinces (e.g. on the famous Igel column) as well as Gallia Belgica. She interprets these scenes of ‘everyday life’ on stone monuments as enhancing their patrons’ ‘prestige’, but her analysis is troubled by our uncertainty over the status of the workforce depicted: are they enslaved or free? Did that not matter to these monuments’ patrons? G. Kremer provides a thorough survey of portrait stelai and grave banquet scenes (Totenmahlszenen) from the Donau provinces, in which — like H. Rose — she finds it difficult to isolate any clear social distinctions in the imagery. However, she rightly emphasises the necessity of discerning regional traditions and patterns rather than seeking to establish a uniform, empire-wide benchmark for interpreting the corpus as a whole.
In the fourth section, ‘The Slave at the Meal’, P. Ruggendorfer's chapter surveys the form and significance of the Classical and Hellenistic precedents of Roman scenes of the Totenmahl. P. Reinard's chapter provides an exhaustive study of the attendants (ministri) in Mahlszenen from the German provinces and Gallia Belgica in comparison with the literary sources. His observation that no Mahlszenen with servants were erected by or for slaves or liberti, with one exception (232), is of special interest. Finally, D. Vaucher treats images of servants at funerary banquets in early Christian funerary art, especially the catacombs in Rome, and wrestles with identifying them as slaves or as religious attendants.
The volume concludes with a list of abbreviations, multiple indices, contributor biographies and a list of illustrations, which appear at the back of the volume. The black-and-white images are mostly reproduced at a crisp resolution; however, the small scale of many, especially the funerary monuments, often does not show them to the best advantage, given their authors’ often highly detailed iconographic analyses.
Returning to Bradley's earlier remarks, the contributors to this volume rarely challenge ‘the conservatism of art historians’ or indulge in ‘leaps of faith’ (M. Grawehr's chapter being a notable exception). But this is not a criticism: for the editors of this volume have succeeded in assembling a cohesive and thought-provoking collection. Through their solid, scrupulous analyses of all the available evidence, they admirably bring together a highly diverse body of material and expand the geographic remit of work in this area beyond its customary focus on Rome. In this way, the volume's contents demonstrate that research on this rich and challenging corpus of imagery is no longer in its ‘infancy’ but has at last begun to come of age.
