The political and social ramifications of identities have long been central to debates in the social sciences, and the essays collected in this volume by Rawi Abdelal et al. offer a stimulating range of approaches to these themes. The book provides guidance about approaching identity from a variety of perspectives: essays by the editors and a number of other distinguished authors explore identity in conceptual and theoretical terms, while also providing methodological and substantive suggestions for current and future survey-based, content- and discourse-analytic, ethnographic, and experimental research in this domain.
The first chapter, “Identity as a Variable,” is an abridged version of the editors' previously published article (Rawi Abdelal, Yoshiko Herrera, Alastair Iain Johnston, and Rose McDermott, “Identity as a Variable,” Perspectives on Politics 45 [December 2006]: 695–711). The authors develop a multidimensional conceptualization of identity as potentially involving four kinds of ideas: constitutive norms, or the criteria for in-group membership; social purposes, or the shared objectives of the in-group; relational comparisons, or the demarcation of in-group traits by reference to specific out-groups; and cognitive models, or specific understandings of how the world works, which are understood to be shared among in-group members (pp. 18–27). Each of these dimensions may be more or less contested by in-group members, depending on the identity group under study (pp. 27–29).
This framework for thinking about identity is not used in much detail by the subsequent chapters in the volume. Nonetheless, it provides a useful roadmap to the later empirical discussions. For the most part, those discussions focus on one or more aspects of the editors' broad concept of identity. With few exceptions, they also share a major weakness of that conception: its surprising inattention to affect as a component of identity. The aspects of identity that constitute the volume's focus do not include an emotional component; instead, they involve definitions, conceptual hierarchies, and causal models. The authors treat affectively loaded concepts such as identity salience or intensity as reducible to their affect-indifferent framework: such concepts “are recast more precisely within our framework for social identities using the concepts of content and contestation” (p. 30). This approach unfortunately obscures the possibility that emotional attachment to the in-group and its symbols functions as a motive force for the kinds of boundary maintenance and reference-group comparisons that are the essence of the editors' approach to identity. These limitations notwithstanding, the volume's conception of identity covers a great deal of ground and may be expected to spark much needed debate about how best to connect divergent theoretical accounts.
The eleven other essays in the volume collectively articulate a multimethod approach to research on identity. Indeed, Henry E. Brady and Cynthia S. Kaplan's chapter, substantially on ethnic identity in Estonia, explicitly argues for the value of well-designed and well-integrated multimethod research. They discuss using a combination of diverse methods to assess the content and salience of competing identity projects. In this essay, various methods contribute to a single descriptive and causal argument, reinforcing and deepening the findings from each separate method.
Donald A. Sylvan and Amanda K. Metskas's chapter offers a less unified view of multimethod research on identity, assessing tradeoffs involved in testing hypotheses about identity using one method at a time. Drawing on a variety of studies, mostly involving Palestinian and/or Israeli identity, the authors argue that methods have divergent sets of strengths and weaknesses. Unfortunately, the discussion misses what appears to be an important possible resolution of these tradeoffs: combining diverse methods in answering a single question, as in the Brady and Kaplan chapter.
Three somewhat divergent chapters, by Taeku Lee, Jack Citrin and David O. Sears, and Michael Dawson, address survey approaches to identity. Lee proposes a new method of measuring race by asking survey respondents to allocate ten “identity points” to a set of racial identity categories. Because this question format encourages respondents to think of racial identity as potentially multiple and partial, Lee argues that it better reflects contemporary theory regarding ethnic and racial identities. The new indicator finds a population proportion of multiracial identifiers that is “several magnitudes of order greater than the proportion … we find using categorical measures” (p. 130).
The chapter by Citrin and Sears offers a related notion of multiple identities and identity choice, discussing a survey measure in which individuals are allowed to choose between a purely national, a purely ethnic, and a hyphenated ethnic-national identity with reference to social and political affairs. Here, the emphasis is not on measurement properties, but rather on the relative degree of patriotism and assimilation into the American national identity of immigrants and people who adopt hyphenated political self-concepts. This is an intriguing and important issue, but one much less squarely focused on the book's central themes of conceptualizing, measuring, and designing research about identity than the earlier chapters.
The same could be said for Michael Dawson's chapter on black identity and the concept of linked fate in US public opinion. This chapter consists in part of a series of responses to critics of Dawson's earlier work on linked fate and in part of a set of regression analyses using survey measures of linked fate as variously as a key independent variable or as the dependent variables. While it is an engaging read, the chapter as a whole is only loosely linked to the book's general themes.
Kimberley A. Neuendorf and Paul D. Skalski provide an overview of quantitative approaches to content analysis in the context of research on social identities. They develop a typology of approaches that combines dimensions related to the procedure for content analysis and to data sources. They then provide brief anecdotes illustrating possible modes of application to identity research of the eight combinations that they regard as logically coherent. The next chapter, Robalyn Stone and Michael Young's discussion of using computers to build cognitive maps of individuals' causal and relational models connected with identity, is a far more targeted overview of similar themes. These two essays should provide ample motive for a number of identity researchers to familiarize themselves with human- and computer-based content analysis.
Kanchan Chandra's contribution to the volume argues for operationalizing constructivist understandings of identity, in which ethnic self-concepts may be multiple and latent unless politically mobilized, in cross-national research. In addition to offering a brief and cogent summary of the theory behind these understandings, this chapter provides an overview of the initial variables in Chandra's emergent constructivist cross-national dataset on ethnicity, CDEI.
Constructivist accounts of identity, but not cross-national quantitative analysis, are fundamental as well in Ted Hopf's chapter illustrating the role that societal constructivism may play in explaining state behavior in the international system. Hopf provides a general overview of his approach to measuring identity via the interpretive reading of texts, such as novels, in which identities are taken for granted rather than made the center of attention. He then argues that shifts in identity at the societal level can account for the Sino-Soviet split. This discourse-analytic approach to identity is helpfully complimented by Laura L. Adams's very hands-on and practical explanation of ethnographic approaches to identity (nicely illustrated by a précis of her research on national identity in Uzbekistan).
Rose McDermott's concluding chapter focuses on experimental research testing and elaborating on social identity theory. This engaging review of experimental findings, as well as a brief discussion of the pragmatics of experimental work on identity, should promote the expanded role of such research in social scientific thinking about identity more generally.
Taken as a whole, this volume is a stimulating invitation to engage in conceptually sophisticated, multimethod research on identity. Scholars familiar with the relevant literatures will find intriguing new contributions here, but the book also serves as a compelling introduction for those just approaching work on this central theme.
