There exists a rapidly growing body of scholarship on the Kurdish movement in Turkey, and the author who ventures to add another book to this corpus is well advised to make clear what distinguishes it from the accumulated work of predecessors. Cengiz Gunes appears well aware of this and repeatedly states what he considers the unique contribution of his book: it is a discourse analysis of the ideological texts produced by the Kurdish movement during the past half century, from 1960 to 2010. For this purpose, he read a large amount of primary materials in Turkish (he does not list Kurdish-language sources), some of which are hard to find and most of which have not been systematically studied before. His analytical framework is also different from that of earlier studies. It is derived from the discourse theory of Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe, arguably the major body of post-Marxist theory in academia, and Gunes carried out the PhD research on which the book is based at the Department of Government of the University of Essex, the home base of this approach.
Gunes is especially interested in how Kurdish identity is discursively produced and focuses on major shifts in Kurdish ideological discourse. Until the early 1970s, the most articulate Kurdish activists emphasized the joint struggle of Kurdish and Turkish progressives against internal and external oppressors (“feudalism” and “imperialism,” respectively). From the early 1970s onward, and especially since the rise of the PKK (Partiya Karkeren Kurdistan, Workers’ Party of Kurdistan), the dominant Kurdish discourse became one of national liberation: Kurdistan was defined as a colony of Turkey (as well as of Iraq, Iran, and Syria) and the Kurds as a distinct, separate nation in need of liberation from its colonizers. A second major shift began in the 1990s and became especially conspicuous after Öcalan's imprisonment in Turkey in 1999: the PKK renounced the idea of an independent Kurdish state and redefined its objectives as democracy and equal rights for all Kurds and Turks. Most of the book consists of narrative accounts of the developments in the various phases of this process as reflected in the literature (and to some extent, the recorded songs) produced by the Kurdish movement.
Gunes's analysis of the available written source materials is one of the strengths of his book and constitutes a useful complement to those recent studies that do not take explicit account of such sources. (In his introduction, Gunes discusses especially the books by Ali Kemal Özcan, David Romano, and Nicole F. Watts, all of which he finds deficient in their analysis of the ideology of the Kurdish movement—although Özcan does in fact make extensive use of written PKK materials.) There is, however, a difficulty in Gunes's almost exclusive reliance on written sources, especially for the earlier period. Journals and books published in Turkey in the 1970s were subject to self-censorship and could at best partially reflect the ideological discussions carried on between the various factions of the left and Kurdish movements. Internal party documents of those years were (re)published much later in European exile, but in the absence of the original documents there is no way of knowing to what extent the published texts were adapted to later developments in ideology. Indeed, Gunes's quotations from early PKK texts resemble more the published material of the 1980s than the few clandestine PKK publications of the late 1970s that I have seen. He finds that among Kurdish organizations, only the PKK and the Özgürlük Yolu and Kawa groups had a “condensed” ideological discourse. It would have been useful if he had been able to complement his perusal of written materials with interviews with activists involved in the debates that were carried on during these years, because those debates—on the analysis of social forces and on strategy—were very lively. Thus, the DDKD (Devrimci Demokratik Kültür Dernekleri, Revolutionary Democratic Culture Associations), arguably the strongest movement in terms of numbers of followers during the 1970s, was the only Kurdish organization to conclude a formal alliance with a Turkish socialist party, at the time when most of the other organizations had given up on the Turkish left and shifted to a “national liberation” discourse. Gunes briefly mentions this short-lived alliance, but does not include the DDKD in his discourse analysis.
A related question in which Gunes professes an interest is how the PKK succeeded in establishing hegemony within the Kurdish movement. The question has been posed before, and most analysts have pointed to the PKK's excessive violence against all rivals and the final elimination of the latter in the wake of the 1980 military coup. Without denying the importance of this factor, Gunes is led by his analytical framework to look for specific aspects of the PKK's discourse, and so he points especially to its successful creation of myths—a myth of common origin in the Medes, those relating to the national festival of Newroz, and those of national resistance and martyrdom. None of these were inventions of the PKK. They were first developed by the Iraqi Kurdish movement and adopted by other movements in Turkey, though the PKK employed them far more systematically and successfully for purposes of mobilization.
Gunes's narrative of the subsequent phases of the Kurdish movement's development is largely based on PKK sources (along with a few journalistic works in Turkish) and therefore inevitably somewhat one-sided. One sorely misses the interviews with leading actors that could have provided important background information for understanding the sometimes oblique written materials. Aliza Marcus’ history of the PKK, based on interviews with (dissident) former leading members, also provides interesting insights on ideological developments but, though he refers to it a few times, Gunes does not engage with the substance of that book.
The second major shift, extensively discussed by Gunes, is in the PKK's discourse from separatism to a quest for a democratic solution within the framework of the existing Republic of Turkey—from a “logic of equivalence” to one of “difference,” in the terms adopted from Laclau. In accordance with Laclau's discourse theory, Gunes sees this shift as the consequence of a number of “dislocations” experienced by the PKK, worldview-shattering and identity-threatening events, among which he mentions notably the collapse of the Soviet Union, heavy military losses in the early 1990s, and the rise in Turkish nationalism (p. 125). There may have been other factors as well, but Öcalan's expulsion from Syria and his ultimate capture and imprisonment in Turkey were no doubt the most consequential “dislocation.” Öcalan's discourse changed dramatically after these events (although some of the changes were foreshadowed in his 1990s utterances). Citing the introduction to Öcalan's translated prison writings, Gunes informs us that in these recent texts Öcalan draws on various radical intellectual traditions—including the social ecology of libertarian socialist thinker Murray Bookchin, feminist political theory, leftist Foucauldians, and critical Marxists—for a vision of a decentralized and democratized Middle East. Gunes does not analyze these writings in detail, however, limiting himself to a few general observations. The final chapters of the book sketch organizational developments of the PKK since 1999 and narrate the history of the legal “pro-Kurdish” parties.
Although Gunes distances himself from essentialist views of (Kurdish) identity, emphasizing that identities are constructed through discourse, he pays scant attention to alternative discursive identity constructions with which Kurdish nationalists have had to contend. He mentions in passing the existence of Islamist discourses among Turkey's Kurds and the Hizbullah organization, as well as the existence of Alevi Kurds among whom Turkish leftist organizations have had a more lasting influence, but his discourse analysis remains limited to the PKK and the legal pro-Kurdish parties. As an analysis of the emergence and evolution of the PKK's ideology, this study provides some valid new insights. It will not, however, be able to replace the other recent studies that the author too summarily dismisses.
